Wikipedia World Wide Web: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol

Of the 111 citations in the Wikipedia article World Wide Web, 47 carry the sentence that cites them, 33 carry it in part, 16 do not carry it, 12 cannot be checked and 3 were not read, and the W3C page that the article cites three times defines the Internet by quoting Wikipedia, while the W3C copy of the proposal of March 1989 says that the only name Berners-Lee then had for the system was "Mesh".

Preamble: I audit the Wikipedia article World Wide Web footnote by footnote, opening the source that each footnote cites and reading it against the sentence that cites it. This page is the companion of Disagreement 98 in the standing index of the series, Disagreements of Published Claims | Network, Not Protocol, and the article lines cited on this page are the numbered lines of Exhibit A of Wikipedia World Wide Web: Disagreements | Network, Not Protocol. The method and the five grades are the same as on Wikipedia Robert Cailliau: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol.

Opinion Rules: You are visiting my record, and I am the subject matter expert on it. If you are a subject matter expert too, I want to hear from you: bring your document and I will answer it on the record. If you are not, you are welcome here to read and to learn. The documented-challenge terms of marknichols.com and the condition on opinion are stated at F40 of The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, and they govern this page.

Conditional on the Governing Definitions: Every finding on this page is conditional on the Governing Definitions D1 through D13 of marknichols.com, which are reproduced in full in the Definitions Addendum at the bottom of this page.

0.0 This section records the article this page audits, the method of the audit, and the grades it assigns.

0.1 The article audited on this page is World Wide Web of the English Wikipedia at revision 1383774564 of November 4, 2026. Wikipedia's revision history records that revision 1383774564 was saved by the account Grayfell and that it was the latest revision of the article on November 14, 2026, the day on which Mark Nichols supplied the text that Exhibit A of Disagreement 98 reproduces. This page matched the 111 footnote markers that Exhibit A prints in lines 1 through 396 and the 99 references of lines 398 through 496 against revision 1383774564, and they agree.

0.2 Revision 1383774564 carries 99 numbered footnotes in a single list, and the footnotes are cited 111 times. This page read the list of footnotes, the links of each footnote and the position of each citation in revision 1383774564 through Wikipedia's own public interface on November 14, 2026.

0.3 This page audited each footnote on November 14, 2026, by opening the source at the archived copy that the footnote names, or, where the footnote names none, at the link the footnote gives or the latest archived copy of that address, and the unit that grades it gives the date of the copy. Of the 99 footnotes, 81 were read in full or retrieved in full and read at the passages that bear on the sentence they support after a search of the whole text, 4 were read at the cited page or in part, 12 could not be read, and 2 were not read; the unit that grades each states which.

0.4 Each citation receives one of five grades. Supported means that the source carries the sentence in its own words. Partial means that the source carries part of the sentence and not the rest. Not supported means that the source was read and does not carry the sentence. Uncheckable means that the citation cannot be followed to a readable source. Unread means that the source was not read for this page, and the three citations so graded point to two books that the Internet Archive lends and does not show.

0.5 The sources are quoted on this page in short fragments, and the rest of what each source says is stated in the words of this page. The sentences of the article are quoted from Exhibit A of Disagreement 98. Where a site asked this page for a sign-in or stopped it at a check for automated visitors, this page stopped there and did not go around the check, and the unit says so. Three footnotes cite sites that this page does not open under the rules of its tools, and their units say so.

1.0 Each of the 99 footnotes of the article is graded at each sentence that cites it.

1.1 Footnote 1 and footnote 21 cite the same record of the CERN Document Server, "Software release of WWW into public domain". The live record answered with a check for automated visitors, and this page read the copy archived on February 17, 2022 that footnote 21 names. The record calls the item "The document that officially put the World Wide Web into the public domain on 30 April 1993". At line 18, where the infobox gives the license as public domain "(Since April 1993)", the citation of footnote 1 is graded Supported. At line 59, the record carries the public domain and the date and not the words royalty-free or the protocol, so the citation of footnote 21 is graded Partial.

1.2 Footnote 2 cites the MDN Web Docs glossary entry "World Wide Web", read in the copy archived on September 1, 2026, which says that the Web is "commonly referred to as WWW, W3, or the Web", and the citation at line 20 is graded Supported. The same entry says that "The Web is not the same as the Internet". Footnote 3 cites Edmund Wright, ed., The Desk Encyclopedia of World History (2006), page 312, with no link, and the citation at line 20 is graded Uncheckable.

1.3 Footnote 4 cites the W3C Help and FAQ page, read in the copy archived on July 9, 2015 that the footnote names. Under the question "What is the difference between the Web and the Internet?" the page answers "From the definition in the Wikipedia" and quotes a definition of the Internet as a system of computer networks using the Internet Protocol Suite, and it defines the Web as "an information space" whose first three specifications "defined URLs, HTTP, and HTML". At line 21, the page names HTTP among the first specifications and not the access to web resources according to its rules, so the citation is graded Partial. At line 36, the page says nothing of a primary tool or of billions of people, and at line 95 it names neither HTTPS nor application-level protocols nor transport protocols, so both citations are graded Not supported.

1.4 Three footnotes cite line 23 for the words "universal linked information system". Footnote 5, the HISTORY page "World Wide Web (WWW) launches in the public domain", read in the copy archived on February 6, 2025 that the footnote names, speaks of "an idea of linked information systems" and not of a universal one, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 6, the W3C copy of "Information Management: A Proposal", read in full in the copy archived on April 1, 2010 that the footnote names, concludes "We should work toward a universal linked information system", and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 7, Elizabeth Nix, "The World's First Web Site", HISTORY, read in full in the copy archived on August 19, 2023 that the footnote names, does not carry the words, and the citation is graded Not supported.

1.5 Footnote 6 is cited twice more. At line 52, the proposal's section "Non-Centralisation" says that a new system "must allow existing systems to be linked together without requiring any central control or coordination", and the citation is graded Supported. At line 53, the proposal is dated March 1989, and the W3C page that carries it says "the only name I had for it at this time was "Mesh"", where the line says that he submitted it "without giving the system a name", so the citation is graded Partial.

1.6 Four footnotes cite line 35, which calls the Web "the world's dominant information systems platform". Footnote 8, Michael Bleigh, "The Once And Future Web Platform", TechCrunch, May 16, 2014, read in the copy archived on December 5, 2021 that the footnote names, predicts that "the web is going to remain the dominant software platform for the foreseeable future", so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 9, the Pew Research Center's "World Wide Web Timeline" of March 11, 2014, read in full in the copy archived on July 29, 2015 that the footnote names, footnote 10, Caitlin Dewey, "36 Ways The Web Has Changed Us", The Washington Post, March 12, 2014, read in full in the copy archived on September 9, 2015 that the footnote names, and footnote 11, the home page of Internet Live Stats, read in the copy archived on July 2, 2015 that the footnote names, whose counters show "retrieving data", do not call the Web a dominant platform, and the three citations are graded Not supported. section 5.0 of Disagreement 98 answers the line.

1.7 Footnote 12 cites Joshua Quittner, "Network Designer Tim Berners-Lee", Time, March 29, 1999, read in full in the copy archived on October 16, 2007 to which the named copy redirects, the article that Wikipedia Tim Berners-Lee: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol reads at its unit 1.12. The article calls the Web "the work of one man" and places Berners-Lee at CERN, and it does not call him English, so the citation at line 39 is graded Partial. The article does not describe a decentralised system, and the citation at line 52 is graded Not supported. Footnote 13 cites Stephanie Sammartino McPherson, Tim Berners-Lee: Inventor of the World Wide Web (2009), at the Internet Archive item timbernerslee0000mcph, which the Internet Archive marks access-restricted for lending, so the citations at line 39 and line 52 are graded Unread.

1.8 Footnote 14 cites Dorian Rutter, From Diversity to Convergence: British Computer Networks and the Internet, 1970-1995, his thesis of 2005 at the University of Warwick, a PDF retrieved in full in the copy archived on November 8, 2022 and searched. Rutter writes that when Berners-Lee developed Enquire in 1980 "the ideas explored by Bush, Engelbart, and Nelson did not influence his work, as he was not aware of them", and that their work "would later confirm the legitimacy of his system". The thesis carries the later confirmation and not Nelson's model of 1965 with its hot spots, so the citation at line 43 is graded Partial. Footnote 15 cites Weaving the Web (1999), pages 5 and 6, at the Internet Archive item weavingweborigin00bern_0, which the Internet Archive marks access-restricted for lending, so the citation at line 43 is graded Unread. The reference itself quotes the book: "Unbeknownst to me at that early stage in my thinking, several people had hit upon similar concepts, which were never implemented."

1.9 Footnote 16 cites T. Berners-Lee, R. Cailliau, J.-F. Groff and B. Pollermann, "World-Wide Web: The Information Universe" (1992), at the PostScript copy archived on December 27, 2022 that the footnote names, whose text was extracted in full and searched. The article describes the aims, data model and protocols of the Web and does not say that the system should be decentralised or free of central control, so the citation at line 52 is graded Not supported.

1.10 Footnote 17 cites Berners-Lee's post "Re: Qualifiers on Hypertext links" of August 1991, read in full in the copy archived on December 7, 2021 that the footnote names. The post describes "a simple protocol (HTTP)" and addresses written "in WWW syntax", and it does not say that he defined the basic URL syntax or made HTML the primary document format, so the citation at line 55 is graded Partial.

1.11 Two footnotes cite line 58 for the 50 websites of the next two years. Footnote 18, Bob Hopgood, "History of the Web" at w3.org, retrieved in full in the copy archived on March 21, 2022 that the footnote names, says that "After nearly two years, having 50 web sites could be regarded as successful", and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 19, CERN's "A short history of the Web", read in full in the copy archived on April 17, 2022 that the footnote names, says that "By late 1993 there were over 500 known web servers" and gives no count of 50, so the citation is graded Not supported. The CERN page also says that "On 30 April 1993, CERN made the source code of WorldWideWeb available on a royalty-free basis".

1.12 Three footnotes cite line 59 for the release of 30 April 1993. Footnote 20, the British Council's "30 years of the web", read in the copy archived on October 24, 2026, says that Berners-Lee and others worked to ensure that CERN "would make the underlying code available on a royalty-free basis, forever" and that "This decision was announced in April 1993", and it gives no day and names no protocol, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 21 is graded at unit 1.1. Footnote 22, CERN's "Ten Years Public Domain for the Original Web Software", read in full in the copy archived on August 13, 2009 that the footnote names, quotes Berners-Lee that "CERN's decision to make the Web foundations and protocols available on a royalty free basis" was "crucial to the Web's existence" and gives the date 2003-04-30 and not the date of 1993, so the citation is graded Partial. section 2.0 of Disagreement 98 answers the line.

1.13 Footnote 23 cites Michael Calore in Wired of April 22, 2010, and footnote 28 cites Michael Calore in Wired of September 28, 2009. This page does not open wired.com or its archived copies under the rules of its tools, and the citations at line 60 and line 66 are graded Uncheckable. Footnote 24 cites Nick Couldry, Media, Society, World (2012), page 2, whose page image at Google Books was read in full. The page says that the World Wide Web was conceived by Berners-Lee in 1989, launched in 1991 and began to enter everyday use in 1993 and 1994, and it names neither Mosaic nor thousands of websites, so the citation at line 60 is graded Partial.

1.14 Two footnotes cite line 61 for Mosaic's inline images and forms processed by the HTTPd server. Footnote 25, Jay Hoffmann, "The Origin of the IMG Tag", read in the copy archived on February 13, 2022 that the footnote names, carries the inline images and not the forms or the server, and footnote 26, Roger Clarke, "The Birth of Web Commerce", read in the copy archived on February 15, 2022 that the footnote names, carries the forms of Mosaic 2.0 and the NCSA httpd and not the inline images, so both citations are graded Partial.

1.15 Footnote 27 cites Brian McCullough, "20 years on: Why Netscape's IPO was the big bang of the Internet era", read in full in the copy archived on February 12, 2022 that the footnote names, which dates the public offering to August 9, 1995 and speaks of "Netscape and the dot-com bubble era it ushered in", and the citation at line 64 is graded Supported. Footnote 29 cites Janet Daly, "World Wide Web Consortium Issues XHTML 1.0 as a Recommendation", January 26, 2000, read in the copy archived on June 20, 2021 that the footnote names, which describes XHTML 1.0 as HTML 4 rewritten "as an XML application" and gives no year of 1996 for XML and no recommendation to replace HTML, so the citation at line 67 is graded Partial.

1.16 Footnote 30 cites Ian Hickson, "WHAT open mailing list announcement", June 4, 2004, read in full in the copy archived on March 8, 2022 that the footnote names. It calls the group "a loose, unofficial, and open collaboration of Web browser manufacturers" writing for Safari, Mozilla and Opera, and it says nothing of a rejection of XHTML or of HTML5, so the citation at line 69 is graded Partial. Footnote 31 cites Stephen Shankland, "An epitaph for the Web standard, XHTML 2", CNET, July 9, 2009, read in the copy archived on February 16, 2022 that the footnote names, which reports that the charter of the XHTML 2 Working Group would not be renewed at the end of 2009, and the article concerns XHTML 2 and not XHTML, so the citation at line 70 is graded Partial. Footnote 32 cites the Memorandum of Understanding between W3C and WHATWG of May 28, 2019, read in the copy archived on May 29, 2019 that the footnote names, which says that "HTML and DOM shall be developed principally in the WHATWG", and the citation at line 71 is graded Supported.

1.17 Four footnotes cite line 72, which calls the Web central to the development of the Information Age and the primary tool billions of people use to interact on the Internet. Footnote 33, In Lee, ed., Electronic Commerce Management for Business Activities and Global Enterprises (2012), page 7, whose page image at Google Books was read in full, says that the Internet "did not experience real proliferation until the invention of the Web" and says nothing of the Information Age or of billions, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 34, Gina Misiroglu, American Countercultures (2015), page 398, whose page image was read in full, carries the entry "Internet" and not the Web as central or a primary tool, and the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 35, the Pew timeline that footnote 9 also cites, says that the Web "has touched the lives of billions of people" and quotes the phrase "buried treasures of the Information Age", so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 11 is graded Not supported at unit 1.6 and is graded Not supported here for the same reason.

1.18 Footnote 36 cites Christopher (Cal) Lee, "Where Have all the Gophers Gone?", April 23, 1999, read in full in the copy archived on November 3, 2026. Lee writes that Gopher was created in 1991 at the University of Minnesota and that "By April of 1994, the number of known Gopher servers had reached 6958", and the citation at line 77 is graded Supported. Lee names "institutional influence, publicity and open-systems participation" as his three factors and does not name a more rigid structure among them, so the citation at line 78 is graded Partial.

1.19 Footnote 37 cites Berners-Lee's W3C page "Frequently asked questions", read in full in the copy archived on August 2, 2009 that the footnote names, which says that the name "should be spelled as three separate words" and that "There are no hyphens", and the citation at line 80 is graded Supported. Footnote 48 cites the same page, which says that the first http address at the end of 1990 "was basically http://nxoc01.cern.ch/hypertext/WWW/TheProject.html" and does not say that the www prefix is required by no standard, so the citation at line 159 is graded Partial.

1.20 Footnote 38 cites Statista's page on the share of website traffic from mobile devices, read in the copy archived on November 11, 2026, whose visible text gives mobile devices 51.48 percent of global website traffic in the second quarter of 2026, down from 62.73 percent a year earlier, and whose series behind the paywall was not read, so the citation at line 82 is graded Partial. Footnote 39 cites Michael Castelluccio, "It's not your grandfather's Internet", Strategic Finance, October 1, 2010, read in the copy archived on March 5, 2016 that the footnote names, which describes applications drawing traffic away from the Web and does not discuss the www prefix, and the citation at line 82 is graded Not supported.

1.21 Footnote 40 cites Oxford Dictionaries' audible pronunciation of WWW, in the copy archived on May 25, 2014 that the footnote names, and footnote 42 cites Stephen Fry's Podgrams at Podcasts.com, in the copy archived on April 4, 2017 that the footnote names. Each page carries its pronunciation as audio, which this page did not hear, and the citations at line 83 and line 85 are graded Uncheckable. Footnote 41 cites Charlie Harvey, "How we pronounce WWW in English", August 18, 2015, read in the copy archived on November 19, 2022 that the footnote names, which says that "dub-dub-dub" is standard in New Zealand and Australia, and the citation at line 84 is graded Supported.

1.22 Footnote 43 cites Tom Simonite, "Help us find a better way to pronounce www", New Scientist, July 22, 2008, read in the copy archived on March 13, 2016 that the footnote names. The post quotes Douglas Adams word for word and does not name The Independent on Sunday or the year 1999, so the citation at line 86 is graded Partial. The post introduces its point about the length of www with the words "As noted in Wikipedia".

1.23 Footnote 44 cites Steve Muylle, Rudy Moenaert and Marc Despont, "A grounded theory of World Wide Web search behaviour" (1999). The DOI resolves to the publisher's page, which names the third author Marc Despontin and whose abstract, read in full, lists "exploratory surfing, window surfing, evolved surfing, bounded navigation and targeted navigation", and the citation at line 100 is graded Supported. Footnote 45 cites David Flanagan, JavaScript: The Definitive Guide, page 1, with no link, and the citation at line 131 is graded Uncheckable; the reference itself quotes the book on the triad of HTML, CSS and JavaScript.

1.24 Footnote 46 cites the HTML 4.0 Specification of December 18, 1997, section on conformance, read in the copy archived on July 5, 2015 that the footnote names, which says that "authors should use style sheets to achieve stylistic and formatting effects rather than HTML presentational attributes", and the citation at line 143 is graded Supported. Footnote 47 cites Tim Berners-Lee and Robert Cailliau, "WorldWideWeb: Proposal for a HyperText Project", dated 12 November 1990, read in full in the copy archived on May 2, 2015 that the footnote names. The proposal names WorldWideWeb and carries the date, and it is a proposal of two authors and not a publication on the Internet, so the citation at line 149 is graded Partial. section 6.0 of Disagreement 98 answers the line.

1.25 Footnote 49 cites P. Palazzi, "The Early Days of the WWW at CERN" (2011), at the soft-shake.ch conference page archived on July 23, 2012 that the footnote names, which lists the keynote by its title and carries no account of www.cern.ch or info.cern.ch, and the citation at line 160 is graded Not supported. Footnote 50 cites Dominic Fraser, "Why a domain's root can't be a CNAME", FreeCodeCamp, May 13, 2018, read in the copy archived on April 21, 2024 that the footnote names, and the citation at line 164 is graded Supported. Footnote 51 cites the mozillaZine thread "automatically adding www.___.com" of May 2003, read in the copy archived on June 27, 2009 that the footnote names, in which posters describe Firebird adding www and com and compare Lynx, and the citation at line 167 is graded Supported. Footnote 52 cites Mike Masnick, Techdirt, July 7, 2008, read in the copy archived on June 27, 2009 that the footnote names, which reports U.S. Patent No. 7,392,326 and that it is for data entry on mobile devices, and the citation at line 168 is graded Supported.

1.26 Footnote 53 cites Naomi Hamilton, "The A-Z of Programming Languages: JavaScript", Computerworld, July 31, 2008, an interview of six pages read in the copy archived on May 24, 2009 that the footnote names and pages 2 through 6 in the copies archived on February 5 and 6, 2010. The interview says that "Brendan Eich created JavaScript in 1995" at Netscape, and the citation at line 207 is graded Supported. It says that "ECMA-262 Edition 3 is the latest ECMAScript standard", and the citation at line 208 is graded Supported. Footnote 54 cites Seth Buntin, "jQuery Polling plugin", September 23, 2008, read in the copy archived on August 13, 2009 that the footnote names, and the citation at line 213 is graded Supported.

1.27 Footnote 55 cites the entry "website" of TheFreeDictionary, read in the copy archived on May 7, 2018 that the footnote names, which defines a website as "A set of interconnected webpages" generally on the same server and names neither multimedia content nor a common domain name, so the citation at line 217 is graded Partial. Footnote 56 cites Similarweb's "Top Browsers Market Share", read in the copy archived on February 17, 2025 that the footnote names, whose text gives Chrome 63.55 percent and names no other browser, so the citation at line 236 is graded Partial. Footnote 57 cites Patrick Killelea, Web performance tuning (2002), page 264, at a WorldCat record that carries no text of the book, and the citation at line 243 is graded Uncheckable.

1.28 Footnote 58 cites Robert Vamosi, "Gmail cookie stolen via Google Spreadsheets", CNET, April 14, 2008, read in the copy archived on December 9, 2013 that the footnote names, which says that obtaining one cookie could have compromised all Google services in a cross-site scripting attack, and the citation at line 268 is graded Supported. Footnote 59 cites the FAQ of WebCookies.org on the EU cookie directive, whose copy archived on October 11, 2017 that the footnote names carries the list of questions and not the answer, and the citation at line 269 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 60 cites the BBC report "New net rules set to make cookies crumble" of March 8, 2011, read in the copy archived on August 10, 2018 that the footnote names, which reports the European e-Privacy directive and no action of U.S. lawmakers, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 61 cites Edmund Lee, "Sen. Rockefeller: Get Ready for a Real Do-Not-Track Bill for Online Advertising", Adage.com, May 6, 2011, read in the copy archived on August 24, 2011 that the footnote names, and the citation at line 269 is graded Supported.

1.29 Footnote 62 cites Jann Horn, "Want to use my wifi?", read in the copy archived on January 4, 2018 that the footnote names, which recommends "to only use the browser in incognito mode" on insecure networks, and the citation at line 272 is graded Supported. Footnote 63 cites Jennimai Nguyen, Mashable, September 10, 2020, read in the copy archived on July 15, 2026, which says that Archie "was first released to the general public on Sept. 10, 1990" as an index of FTP sites, and the citation at line 282 is graded Supported.

1.30 Three footnotes cite line 285 for the terms deep web, invisible web and hidden web. Footnote 64 cites Nigel Hamilton, "The Mechanics of a Deep Net Metasearch Engine", whose IADIS record, read in the copy archived on May 31, 2023 that the footnote names, gives the year 2003 where the reference gives May 13, 2024, and whose abstract uses the term "Deep Net", so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 65 cites Jane Devine and Francine Egger-Sider (2004), whose DOI resolves to ScienceDirect, which refused the request, and the citation is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 66 cites Sriram Raghavan and Hector Garcia-Molina, "Crawling the Hidden Web" (2001), whose Stanford record, read in the copy archived on August 17, 2019 that the footnote names, describes content "hidden" behind search forms that crawlers ignore, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.31 Footnote 67 cites the entry "Surface web" of Computer Hope, read in full in the copy archived on May 5, 2020 that the footnote names, which defines the surface web as the portion of the Web "that may be indexed by popular search engines" and does not say that it is accessible to anyone, so the citation at line 286 is graded Partial. Footnote 68 cites Alex Wright in The New York Times of February 22, 2009, which this page does not open under the rules of its tools, and the citation at line 287 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 69 cites J. Madhavan and others, "Google's deep web crawl" (2008), with no link, and the citation at line 288 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 70 cites Sam Shedden in the Sunday Mail of June 8, 2014, whose excerpt at Questia, read in the copy archived on March 1, 2020 that the footnote names, describes the Deep Web as sites not indexed in search engines and does not mention HTTP forms, and the citation at line 288 is graded Not supported.

1.32 Footnote 71 cites Yuval Ben-Itzhak, CTO at Finjan, "Infosecurity 2008: New defence strategy in battle against e-crime", ComputerWeekly, April 18, 2008, read in the copy archived on June 4, 2008 that the footnote names. It says that cybercriminals use the web "for a wide range of illegitimate and malicious activities, including identity theft through keylogging, financial fraud, espionage, and intelligence gathering", and the citation at line 300 is graded Supported. It recommends "real-time code inspection technologies" that "analyse every piece of content regardless of its source", and the citation at line 310 is graded Supported.

1.33 Three footnotes cite line 301. Footnote 72, Steve Christey and Robert A. Martin, "Vulnerability Type Distributions in CVE", MITRE, read in the copy archived on March 17, 2013 that the footnote names, says that publicly reported web application vulnerabilities "have overtaken buffer overflows". Footnote 73, the executive summary of the Symantec Internet Security Threat Report XIII of April 2008, extracted in full from the PDF archived on June 25, 2008 that the footnote names, says that "the Web is now the primary conduit for attack activity" and counts 11,253 site-specific cross-site scripting vulnerabilities against 2,134 traditional ones. Footnote 74, the BBC report "Google searches web's dark side" of May 11, 2007, read in the copy archived on March 7, 2008 that the footnote names, says that "One in 10 web pages" that Google scrutinised contained malicious code. The three citations are graded Supported.

1.34 Footnote 75 cites the Sophos Security Threat Report for the first quarter of 2008, and the copy archived on December 31, 2013 that the footnote names is a documentation page of the Sophos site and not the report, so the citation at line 302 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 76 cites the Sophos Security threat report of July 2008, extracted from the PDF archived on December 31, 2013 that the footnote names, which gives as the "Biggest malware threat" the "SQL injection attack against websites", and the citation at line 303 is graded Supported.

1.35 Footnote 77 cites Jeremiah Grossman and others, Cross Site Scripting Attacks: XSS Exploits and Defense (2007), pages 68 and 69 and 127, in the PDF archived on November 15, 2024 that the footnote names, whose text was extracted in full and searched. The book's introduction calls JavaScript "an unknown harbinger of cross-site scripting", and page 127 says that XSS is not completely an issue of JavaScript; the citation at line 304 is graded Supported. Footnote 78 cites Tim O'Reilly, "What Is Web 2.0", September 30, 2005, pages 4 and 5, read in the copies of those pages archived on December 31, 2006, which describe the AJAX interface of Google Maps and say nothing of security, and the citation at line 304 is graded Not supported.

1.36 Footnote 79 cites Scott Berinato, "Software Vulnerability Disclosure: The Chilling Effect", CSO, January 1, 2007, page 7, read in the copy of page 7 archived on February 24, 2009, which reports that Jeremiah Grossman "claims XSS vulnerabilities can be found in 70 percent of websites", and the citation at line 305 is graded Supported. Footnote 80 cites FirstPost of February 20, 2013, read in the copy archived on December 21, 2014 that the footnote names, which reports that RSA, the Security Division of EMC, estimated "the global losses from Phishing at $1.5 Billion in 2012", and the citation at line 307 is graded Supported.

1.37 Footnote 81 cites Brian Prince, "McAfee Governance, Risk and Compliance Business Unit", eWEEK, April 2008. The copy archived on April 21, 2024 that the footnote names was refused by the Wayback Machine, and the live page, read in full, describes compliance reporting mandated by regulatory and industry standards and does not mention regulations after September 11, 2001, so the citation at line 310 is graded Partial. Footnote 82 cites Rob Preston, InformationWeek, April 12, 2008, read in the copy archived on April 14, 2008 that the footnote names, which urges security professionals to speak "the language of risk mitigation and business opportunity" so that they are less "considered a cost center", and footnote 83 cites Thomas Claburn, InformationWeek, February 6, 2007, read in the copy archived on February 7, 2009 that the footnote names, which describes the vision of RSA's Coviello as "ubiquitous, always-on digital rights management". Both citations at line 311 are graded Supported.

1.38 Footnote 84 cites Carolyn Duffy Marsan, "How the iPhone is killing the 'Net", Network World, April 9, 2008, five pages read in the copies archived on April 14, 2008 and October 18, 2008. The article reports that Jonathan Zittrain favors "community ethics and policing" in light of security breaches, "rather than locked down appliances", and the citation at line 312 is graded Supported. Footnote 85 cites danah boyd and Eszter Hargittai, "Facebook privacy settings: Who cares?", First Monday, July 2010, read in full at First Monday, which says that "the controls got more complex" and that users were confused about the settings, and the citation at line 334 is graded Supported.

1.39 Six footnotes cite the list of standards bodies at lines 344 through 350. Footnote 86, the W3C list of standards and drafts, read in the copy archived on July 15, 2018 that the footnote names, footnote 87, the IETF page of Requests for Comments, read in the copy archived on February 2, 2009 that the footnote names, footnote 89, Ecma's formal publications, read in the copy archived on December 27, 2017 that the footnote names, footnote 90, the Unicode Technical Reports, read in the copy archived on January 2, 2022 that the footnote names, and footnote 91, the IANA home page, read in the copy archived on February 24, 2011 that the footnote names, carry their bodies' publications, and the citations at line 344, line 346, line 348, line 349 and line 350 are graded Supported. Footnote 88 cites a search of the ISO site for "world wide web", whose copy archived on July 2, 2025 shows the search page and no results, and the citation at line 347 is graded Partial.

1.40 Footnote 92 cites Leslie Sikos, Web standards (2011), at the home page of the book's site archived on April 2, 2015 that the footnote names, which lists topics and carries no statement that web standards are evolving sets of specifications, and the citation at line 351 is graded Not supported.

1.41 Footnote 93 cites the W3C Web Accessibility Initiative home page, read in the copy archived on April 2, 2009 that the footnote names. The page quotes Berners-Lee, "The power of the Web is in its universality. Access by everyone regardless of disability is an essential aspect.", and the citation at line 362 is graded Supported. The page describes guidelines developed "through international collaboration", and the citation at line 364 is graded Supported. The page names ageing and not temporary disabilities such as a broken arm, so the citation at line 358 is graded Partial.

1.42 Footnote 94 cites the W3C business case overview, read in the copy archived on April 14, 2009 that the footnote names, which says that "it is essential that the Web be accessible in order to provide equal access and equal opportunity to people with disabilities", and the citation at line 360 is graded Supported. Footnote 95 cites the W3C page on legal and policy factors, read in the copy archived on April 5, 2009 that the footnote names, which says that "Some governments have laws that specifically require that certain types of Web sites are accessible", and the citation at line 363 is graded Supported. Footnote 96 cites the WCAG overview, read in the copy archived on April 1, 2009 that the footnote names, which names Web content developers and authoring tool developers as its audience and not international co-operation, so the citation at line 364 is graded Partial.

1.43 Footnote 97 cites the W3C Internationalization Activity, read in the copy archived on April 16, 2009 that the footnote names, which works "to make it possible to use Web technologies with different languages, scripts, and cultures", and the citation at line 367 is graded Supported. Footnote 98 cites Mark Davis, "Moving to Unicode 5.1", Google's blog, May 2008, read in the copy archived on May 21, 2009 that the footnote names, which says that "Just last December" Unicode became the most frequent encoding on web pages, overtaking ASCII and Western European encodings, and gives no starting year of 2004 or 2005 in its text, so the citation at line 368 is graded Partial. Footnote 99 cites the W3C press release of January 26, 2005, read in the copy archived on February 7, 2009 that the footnote names, which says that IRIs expand the allowed characters "from a subset of US-ASCII to the Universal Character Set", and the citation at line 370 is graded Supported.

2.0 The sources the article cites quote Wikipedia, give Berners-Lee a name for the system in March 1989, count the early servers differently, and describe the Web as an application of the Internet.

2.1 Two sources the article cites take their words from Wikipedia. The W3C Help and FAQ page at footnote 4, which the article cites at lines 21, 36 and 95, answers the question of the difference between the Web and the Internet "From the definition in the Wikipedia". The New Scientist post at footnote 43, cited at line 86, introduces its point with the words "As noted in Wikipedia".

2.2 At line 53, the article says that Berners-Lee submitted his proposal in March 1989 "without giving the system a name". The W3C page that carries the proposal at footnote 6 says that "the only name I had for it at this time was "Mesh"" and that he decided on "World Wide Web" when writing the code in 1990, and the HISTORY page at footnote 7 says that he tried "Mine of Information and Information Mesh" before settling on WorldWideWeb.

2.3 At line 58, the article counts 50 websites within two years. Bob Hopgood at footnote 18 carries 50 web sites after nearly two years and writes that in 1992 "The number of servers world-wide grew to 50", and CERN at footnote 19 counts "over 500 known web servers" by late 1993 and no 50.

2.4 At line 43, the article says that Ted Nelson's model confirmed the validity of Berners-Lee's concept when he became aware of it. Dorian Rutter at footnote 14 writes that Bush, Engelbart and Nelson did not influence Enquire of 1980 "as he was not aware of them", and the reference at footnote 15 quotes Weaving the Web: "several people had hit upon similar concepts, which were never implemented". Berners-Lee's FAQ, which this series reads at unit 1.18 of Wikipedia Tim Berners-Lee: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol, dates his reading of Ted Nelson's work to between March 1989 and September 1990.

2.5 Four sources the article cites describe the Web as an application of the Internet and not the Internet. The MDN glossary at footnote 2 says "The Web is not the same as the Internet: the Web is one of many applications built on top of the Internet." The W3C page at footnote 4 calls the Web "an information space". In Lee's book at footnote 33 calls the Web "a service provisioned through the Internet infrastructure". Nick Couldry at footnote 24 writes that the Internet became an everyday phenomenon through the World Wide Web protocols, which entered everyday use in 1993 and 1994. section 4.0 of Disagreement 98 and section 5.0 of Disagreement 98 answer lines 54, 89 and 35.

2.6 At line 59, the article says that CERN made "the Web protocol and code" available royalty-free on 30 April 1993. The CERN record at footnotes 1 and 21 speaks of the public domain, the British Council at footnote 20 of the underlying code and of an announcement in April 1993, and the CERN page at footnote 22 quotes Berners-Lee on the foundations and protocols. CERN's own history at footnote 19 says "the source code of WorldWideWeb". section 2.0 of Disagreement 98 reads CERN's statement of 30 April 1993.

2.7 At line 149, the article says that publication on the Internet created what Berners-Lee first called the WorldWideWeb on November 12, 1990. The document at footnote 47 is a proposal dated 12 November 1990 and signed by T. Berners-Lee and R. Cailliau. The Statista page at footnote 38, cited at line 82 for the growth of the mobile web, gives a share of mobile traffic that fell from 62.73 percent to 51.48 percent in the year to the second quarter of 2026.

3.0 Most lines of the article carry no footnote, and the sources of other footnotes bear on some of them.

3.1 Of the 396 lines of Exhibit A that precede the list of references, 80 lines carry footnotes: lines 18, 20, 21, 23, 35, 36, 39, 43, 52, 53, 55, 58 through 61, 64, 66, 67, 69 through 72, 77, 78, 80, 82 through 86, 95, 100, 131, 143, 149, 159, 160, 164, 167, 168, 207, 208, 213, 217, 236, 243, 268, 269, 272, 282, 285 through 288, 300 through 305, 307, 310 through 312, 334, 344, 346 through 351, 358, 360, 362 through 364, 367, 368 and 370. Every other line carries none, including the invention in 1989 and the opening to the public in 1993 at line 22, the working system and the name of the network at line 54, the release of 23 August 1991 at line 56, and the application layer protocol at line 89.

3.2 The W3C proposal page at footnote 6 dates the proposal to March 1989 and the name World Wide Web to the writing of the code in 1990, which bears on line 22 and line 54. The HISTORY page at footnote 7 dates the first website to August 6, 1991, which bears on line 56. The MDN glossary at footnote 2 calls the Web one of many applications of the Internet, which bears on line 89. section 1.0 of Disagreement 98, section 3.0 of Disagreement 98 and section 4.0 of Disagreement 98 answer lines 22, 56 and 54.

4.0 Of the 111 citations, 47 carry the sentence that cites them, 33 carry it in part, 16 do not carry it, 12 cannot be checked and 3 were not read.

4.1 The 47 citations graded Supported are footnote 1 at line 18, footnote 2 at line 20, footnote 6 at line 23, footnote 6 at line 52, footnote 18 at line 58, footnote 27 at line 64, footnote 32 at line 71, footnote 36 at line 77, footnote 37 at line 80, footnote 41 at line 84, footnote 44 at line 100, footnote 46 at line 143, footnote 50 at line 164, footnote 51 at line 167, footnote 52 at line 168, footnote 53 at line 207, footnote 53 at line 208, footnote 54 at line 213, footnote 58 at line 268, footnote 61 at line 269, footnote 62 at line 272, footnote 63 at line 282, footnote 66 at line 285, footnote 71 at line 300, footnote 72 at line 301, footnote 73 at line 301, footnote 74 at line 301, footnote 76 at line 303, footnote 77 at line 304, footnote 79 at line 305, footnote 80 at line 307, footnote 71 at line 310, footnote 82 at line 311, footnote 83 at line 311, footnote 84 at line 312, footnote 85 at line 334, footnote 86 at line 344, footnote 87 at line 346, footnote 89 at line 348, footnote 90 at line 349, footnote 91 at line 350, footnote 94 at line 360, footnote 93 at line 362, footnote 95 at line 363, footnote 93 at line 364, footnote 97 at line 367 and footnote 99 at line 370.

4.2 The 16 citations graded Not supported are footnote 7 at line 23, footnote 9 at line 35, footnote 10 at line 35, footnote 11 at line 35, footnote 4 at line 36, footnote 16 at line 52, footnote 12 at line 52, footnote 19 at line 58, footnote 34 at line 72, footnote 11 at line 72, footnote 39 at line 82, footnote 4 at line 95, footnote 49 at line 160, footnote 70 at line 288, footnote 78 at line 304 and footnote 92 at line 351.

4.3 The 12 citations graded Uncheckable are footnote 3 at line 20, footnote 23 at line 60, footnote 28 at line 66, footnote 40 at line 83, footnote 42 at line 85, footnote 45 at line 131, footnote 57 at line 243, footnote 59 at line 269, footnote 65 at line 285, footnote 68 at line 287, footnote 69 at line 288 and footnote 75 at line 302. The 3 citations graded Unread are footnote 13 at line 39, footnote 15 at line 43 and footnote 13 at line 52, whose copies at the Internet Archive are lending-only.

4.4 The 33 citations graded Partial are footnote 4 at line 21, footnote 5 at line 23, footnote 8 at line 35, footnote 12 at line 39, footnote 14 at line 43, footnote 6 at line 53, footnote 17 at line 55, footnote 20 at line 59, footnote 21 at line 59, footnote 22 at line 59, footnote 24 at line 60, footnote 25 at line 61, footnote 26 at line 61, footnote 29 at line 67, footnote 30 at line 69, footnote 31 at line 70, footnote 33 at line 72, footnote 35 at line 72, footnote 36 at line 78, footnote 38 at line 82, footnote 43 at line 86, footnote 47 at line 149, footnote 48 at line 159, footnote 55 at line 217, footnote 56 at line 236, footnote 60 at line 269, footnote 64 at line 285, footnote 67 at line 286, footnote 81 at line 310, footnote 88 at line 347, footnote 93 at line 358, footnote 96 at line 364 and footnote 98 at line 368, and units 1.1 through 1.43 state for each which part of the sentence its source carries.

5.0 The claims on this page are open to documented challenge on the standing terms of marknichols.com, and the terms are stated here in full.

5.1 The claims on this page are open to challenge on the same terms as every claim on marknichols.com. A challenger who holds that a claim on this page is wrong, or that the Internet is something other than the publicly joinable network of networks of the registry lineage defined at The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, states the competing claim or definition in one sentence, names the document that carries it and the document’s date, and sends both to mark@marknichols.com. A challenge submitted with its document is answered on this page, and a competing definition submitted with its document is added to this page as an exhibit with attribution to the person who submitted it; a challenge submitted without a document is an opinion and is heard as one.

5.2 The distinction the site’s definition rests on, that protocols enable interoperability and are not the Internet, is stated in the IETF’s own words, RFC 2026 and STD 1, in the Internet-Draft draft-mnichols-protocols-not-the-internet-01, posted by Mark Nichols to the IETF Datatracker on September 25, 2026 at https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-mnichols-protocols-not-the-internet/ and stated on this site at Protocols Are Not the Internet: The IETF Internet-Draft by Mark Nichols, so a challenger may also address the definition in the venue that publishes the protocol standards themselves. Any person who holds expertise in telecommunications and a competing claim or definition is invited to bring both, in writing, with the document.

6.0 The Definitions Addendum reproduces the Governing Definitions D1 through D13 of marknichols.com word for word, and every finding on this page is made under them.

6.1 Every finding on this page is made under the Governing Definitions of marknichols.com, D1 through D13, which are reproduced in this addendum word for word from The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking. A reader of this page either accepts these definitions or disputes them. A reader who disputes a definition states the competing definition in one sentence and names the dated document that carries it before opining on any finding of this page. A reader who opines on the findings without disputing a definition has read the findings under these definitions by default.

6.2 The definitions below are copied word for word from the section “These definitions are employed throughout marknichols.com” of The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, as that page read on November 13, 2026, and that page controls wherever a copy differs from it.

D1. The Internet (capital I). The publicly joinable network of networks of the registry lineage: the fabric whose addresses and autonomous system numbers were issued by the InterNIC and are maintained today by ARIN. A person joins it by purchasing access from any of competing commercial providers, for any lawful purpose, and a network joins it by obtaining addresses and an autonomous system number from the numbering registry and then interconnecting by agreement with any willing network, the way Digital Island joined under autonomous system AS6553, issued August 29, 1996 by the InterNIC, with the registration maintained today in ARIN’s registry. No owner grants admission, no written policy screens members or their purposes, and no government sponsorship is required, and that single property, open admission, is what separates the Internet from every gated network that existed before it. The capital-I Internet was born in 1991, when independently operated commercial networks of this lineage, PSINet, AlterNet under UUNET, and CERFnet, interconnected by their own agreement as the Commercial Internet eXchange (CIX), settlement-free and free of any purpose-screening policy, and it was born small: the gated research world stood beside it until April 30, 1995, upon the decommission of NSFNET folded into internetMCI, per orders of Congress. Neither the ARPANET intranet, which admitted members only by agency authorization, nor the NSFNET intranet, which admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education, met this definition on any day of either existence, so the capital I names an Internet network that is public, or it names nothing. Paragraphs D1.1 through D1.7 state why the ARPANET and the NSFNET are not in the lineage of the Internet, each on its document.

D1.1 A network stands in the lineage of the Internet only if it carried the trait that defines the Internet, and D1 names that trait as one property, open admission; a network that never carried open admission had no such trait to pass on, and the ARPANET and the NSFNET never carried it, so neither the ARPANET nor the NSFNET is the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet, and neither the ARPANET nor the NSFNET became the Internet.

D1.2 The ARPANET admitted members by its owner’s authorization from its procurement to its end: Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002, issued July 29, 1968 for the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense, states the network’s purpose as “making these advanced research computer systems available to users outside their own design circle,” a purpose among the owner’s research contractors, as F37 of this page records; admission ran through agency authorization, as D4 of this page records; and the ARPANET ran from 1969 to 1990, as F38 of this page records, so the ARPANET was an intranet under D2 on every day of its existence and never carried open admission.

D1.3 The NSFNET admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education, as D7 of this page records, and its backbone was terminated on April 30, 1995, when its regional networks passed principally to internetMCI and SprintLink, which, in the words of Merit Network, the operator of record, absorbed the NSFNET regionals as their customers, so the NSFNET’s member networks joined the Internet as customers on terms the NSFNET never offered, and the NSFNET itself ended and did not become the Internet.

D1.4 The trait that defines the Internet has a documented origin outside the gated networks: the release of March 25, 1991 by General Atomics, Performance Systems International, Inc., and UUNET Technologies, Inc., seated at F52 of this page, states that the three networks “are not subject to government mandated “acceptable use” restrictions on their traffic,” states that the agreement can be expanded “to include any commercial service which has no restrictions on traffic use,” and states that the exchange allows firms to communicate “without traversing the government restricted backbones, such as the NSFNET (National Science Foundation Network),” so the Internet was built by agreement among commercial networks to carry traffic around the gated backbone, and the Internet did not grow out of the gated backbone.

D1.5 The ARPANET, the NSFNET, and the Internet each performed internetworking under D3, and a shared function is not a shared lineage: RFC 2026, The Internet Standards Process, Revision 3, by Scott O. Bradner of Harvard University, published October 1996, states at its section 1.1 that “There are also many isolated interconnected networks, which are not connected to the global Internet but use the Internet Standards,” so a network that uses the same protocols as the Internet is a user of the same tools and is not thereby the Internet or its ancestor. A redwood and a palm are both called trees, and a redwood did not grow from a palm, and a palm cannot become a redwood; the gated internets of the ARPANET and the NSFNET and the capital-I Internet are both called internets, and the shared word names a shared function and not a shared tree. The shared word was applied to the gated networks in error, and this record documents the error by document and date: the Stanford University bronze dedicated July 28, 2005 casts the headline “BIRTH OF THE INTERNET” above an inscription that records protocol work, as Stanford University Is Petitioned to Retract the Headline of Its BIRTH OF THE INTERNET Plaque records; RFC 1208, A Glossary of Networking Terms, by Ole J. Jacobsen and Daniel C. Lynch of Interop, Inc., published March 1991 as a document that in its own words “does not specify an Internet standard,” calls the ARPANET the “grandfather” of today’s Internet with no document for the descent it asserts; and IEEE Milestone 94 of October 29, 2009 is titled “Birthplace of the Internet, 1969,” as F46.1 of this page records.

D1.6 The registry lineage named in D1 is a continuity of numbering administration, the assignment of network addresses and autonomous system numbers by the Network Information Center at SRI, then by the InterNIC, and today by ARIN, and the registry lineage is not a lineage of networks: the Network Information Center at SRI kept the Official Host Table of the ARPANET’s era, as D4 of this page records, and a number assigned by a registry admits no one to any network, so the continuity of the numbering places no gated network in the lineage of the Internet.

D1.7 On every page of marknichols.com, the ARPANET and the NSFNET are named earlier gated networks, networks that also performed internetworking, or intranets under D2, and no page of marknichols.com calls either network the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, the precursor, or the forerunner of the Internet, places either network in the lineage of the Internet, or states that either network became, evolved into, or grew into the Internet, under the ruling of Mark Nichols of November 7, 2026 that the ARPANET and the NSFNET belong to the history of internetworking and not to the lineage of the Internet, and that the Internet is a separate species.

D1.8 The plain statements of D1.1 through D1.7 are these. The ARPANET is not the Internet. The NSFNET is not the Internet. The ARPANET did not become the Internet. The NSFNET did not become the Internet. The ARPANET is not the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet. The NSFNET is not the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet. The ARPANET was an intranet, because the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense owned the ARPANET and admitted the ARPANET’s members by permission. The NSFNET was an intranet, because the NSFNET backbone admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education. The Internet admits anyone, and open admission is the one property that defines the Internet. Open admission came to the Internet from the commercial networks PSINet, AlterNet, and CERFnet at the Commercial Internet eXchange announced on March 25, 1991, and open admission did not come from the ARPANET or from the NSFNET. The ARPANET ended in 1990. The NSFNET backbone ended on April 30, 1995. The ARPANET, the NSFNET, and the Internet share the function of internetworking and share the word internet, and a shared function and a shared word are not a shared lineage. The Internet was born in 1991, and the Internet was not born from the ARPANET or from the NSFNET.

D2. intranet. A network, at any scale, in any geography, and under any protocol, whose members join by an owner’s permission. The word carries its own definition: intra means within, and an intranet is a network within a bounded and credentialed community, whether that community is one company’s offices or one government’s contractors spread across two continents. Scale does not convert an intranet into the Internet, geography does not, and protocol does not, because a gated network that adopts the optional protocols TCP/IP has changed its plumbing and not its admission policy; only open admission makes the Internet, and a research intranet is not the Internet. NSFNET and ARPANET are historical examples of intranets under this definition. Neither was the Internet, and neither became the Internet merely by being technically interconnected with other networks.

D3. internetworking. The technique of interconnecting distinct networks through gateways so that traffic originating on one can reach hosts on another. Internetworking among gated intranets was operating in production by 1975, when the gateway at University College London, developed and operated by Peter Kirstein’s group, of which Peter Higginson was a principal member, joined the ARPANET to the United Kingdom’s EPSS, an operation documented in the September 1975 paper of Peter L. Higginson and Andrew J. Hinchley, which recorded the working gateway while filing the Cerf and Kahn protocol as a future option rather than the operating method. Internetworking among gated intranets makes a lowercase internet, in the exact lowercase vocabulary of RFC 1983, and it never makes the capital-I Internet, because interconnecting two gated networks produces a larger gated system, not a public one. The credit for internetworking belongs to the engineers who built and operated the gateways; that credit does not extend to the birth of the Internet, which did not yet exist.

D4. ARPANET, also rendered DARPANET. The ARPA Network: one organization’s intranet, built, funded, owned, and access-controlled by the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense, later renamed DARPA, from its commissioning in 1969 until its decommissioning in 1990. Its very name is a possessive, the agency’s initials welded onto the agency’s property, and the network’s renamings followed the owner’s renamings, as only an owned network’s can. Admission was by the owner’s authorization for the owner’s purposes, the Official Host Table of the Network Information Center at SRI, the register of the era’s hosts that preceded the optional protocol DNS, listed 235 hosts in May 1982 and 562 hosts in August 1983, the two counts in RFC 1296 of January 1992 that bracket the 1983 protocol cutover, and no member of the public could join it, buy from it, or sell across it on any day of its twenty-one years. The owner stated the network’s purpose in its own procurement instrument before the network existed: Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002, issued July 29, 1968 by the Defense Supply Service-Washington of the Department of the Army for the Advanced Research Projects Agency under ARPA Order No. 1260, and signed by Thomas J. Scheblik, Deputy Director for Procurement, solicited the Interface Message Processors for the ARPA computer network, and its Statement of Work, Specifications of Interface Message Processors for the ARPA Computer Network, states that the Agency was forming the network “with the cooperation of its research contractors,” that the network’s potential lay in “making these advanced research computer systems available to users outside their own design circle,” and that the network itself was “a subject of study and experimentation,” while the Statement of Work’s nineteen pages and seven appendices contain no reference to war, to survivability, to attack, to command and control, or to any military mission. The design mission of the ARPANET was therefore resource sharing among the owner’s research contractors, stated by the owner in 1968, and the later recollections agree with the instrument: Charles Herzfeld, Director of ARPA from 1965 to 1967, stated that the ARPANET was not started to create a command and control system that would survive a nuclear attack; Vint Cerf recorded on the Internet Society’s internet-history list on September 1, 2009 that Larry Roberts confirmed the purpose of the ARPANET was resource sharing and that the nuclear resilience story came from Paul Baran’s earlier work; and the Internet Society’s own history, A Brief History of the Internet, calls that story a false rumor that arose from the unrelated RAND study. The wartime mission, command traffic surviving damaged links and destroyed nodes, belonged to the owner’s later internetting project, which Vint Cerf managed at DARPA and demonstrated by putting packet radios in Strategic Air Command aircraft, and the optional protocol TCP, specified in 1974 with military computer communication requirements as the stated primary focus of RFC 793 of September 1981, was designed for that mission and installed on this intranet by the owner’s directive in 1983. The ARPANET is not the Internet, and DARPANET is not the Internet: one organization’s intranet is not the publicly joinable network of networks. The ARPANET intranet was procured under Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002 of July 29, 1968, ran from 1969, and carried its traffic for fourteen years, under the Network Control Program, an optional protocol first specified in RFC 33 of February 1970, before TCP was added to it on January 1, 1983; a protocol added to a working network fourteen years after the network was procured is an add-on to that network, not its birth.

D5. Flag day, January 1, 1983. A scheduled protocol cutover, from NCP to TCP/IP, planned within the ARPANET community for years and executed on the owner’s own plant: an intranet’s internal maintenance event, touching no member of the public because no member of the public was on the network before the cutover or after it. The protocol installed that day was commissioned by the same owner to weld its own three networks together, the terrestrial ARPANET, its mobile packet radio network, and its satellite network, crossing dissimilar media under a single owner without ever crossing an owner, so that traffic could survive battlefield destruction. The Internet’s own standards registry graded TCP “Recommended” and never “Required,” in RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997, grades that bind only systems electing to implement the standard suite, and a protocol cutover on a gated intranet is not the birth of anything. The network the protocol was cut over onto had been procured on July 29, 1968 and running since 1969, fourteen years before that day, so the cutover added a protocol to an existing intranet and created no network.

D6. The Internet protocols, the optional protocols TCP and IP. Protocols are utilities whose messages the networks carry; they are not the networks, and they are not the Internet. Under these Governing Definitions, TCP and IP are optional protocols, and paragraphs D6.1 through D6.13 state the documents on which that definition rests and the judgment of Mark Nichols that completes it.

D6.1 The Internet’s own standards registry, issued first by the Internet Activities Board and later by the Internet Architecture Board, under the title IAB Official Protocol Standards and from RFC 1500 of August 1993 under the title Internet Official Protocol Standards, assigned a status to each listed protocol in twenty-two editions, from RFC 1083 of December 1988 through RFC 2400 of September 1998.

D6.2 Every one of those twenty-two editions lists TCP, the Transmission Control Protocol of RFC 793, at the status “Recommended”, printed “Rec” from RFC 1280 of March 1992 onward, and lists IP, the Internet Protocol of RFC 791, at the status “Required”, printed “Req” from RFC 1280 onward, and not one of the twenty-two editions lists TCP at the status “Required” in any of its tables.

D6.3 RFC 1200 of April 1991, issued by the Internet Activities Board with Jon Postel as editor, and RFC 2200 of June 1997, issued by the Internet Architecture Board with Jon Postel as editor, each define the status “Required” at section 4.2.1 in the words “A system must implement the required protocols”, define the status “Recommended” at section 4.2.2 in the words “A system should implement the recommended protocols”, and define the status “Elective” at section 4.2.3 in the words “A system may or may not implement an elective protocol”, so that by the registry’s own definitions TCP is a protocol that a system should implement and is not a protocol that a system must implement.

D6.4 RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997 each open by stating that the edition “describes the state of standardization of protocols used in the Internet” as determined by its board, and each states that “Few protocols are required to be implemented in all systems” because of the variety of possible systems, gateways, terminal servers, workstations and multi-user hosts among them.

D6.5 RFC 1122, Requirements for Internet Hosts -- Communication Layers, edited by Robert Braden for the Internet Engineering Task Force in October 1989 and listed at the status “Required” in RFC 2200 of June 1997, states at its section 1.1.3 that “To communicate using the Internet system, a host must implement the layered set of protocols comprising the Internet protocol suite” and, in the next sentence, that “A host typically must implement at least one protocol from each layer”, so RFC 1122 binds a host that has chosen to communicate using the Internet system, and RFC 1122 requires of that host at least one transport protocol, not TCP.

D6.6 RFC 1122 of October 1989 states at its section 1.1.3 that “There are two primary transport layer protocols at present”, naming TCP and UDP, and that “the set of official Internet transport protocols may be expanded in the future”, states at its section 4.2.1 that “TCP is used by those applications needing reliable, connection-oriented transport service”, and states at its section 4.1.1 that “UDP is used by applications that do not require the level of service of TCP”, so RFC 1122 itself assigns TCP by the needs of the application.

D6.7 RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997 each list, at section 6.3, Network-Specific Standard Protocols, the transmission of IP over each type of physical network, ARPANET, X.25, Ethernet, IEEE 802, FDDI and serial lines among them, at the status “Elective”, and each states that “it is elective to support any particular type of physical network” on which IP is transmitted.

D6.8 RFC 2500 of June 1999 prints no status for TCP or for IP, RFC 5000 of May 2008, the last edition of the registry, prints no status for TCP or for IP, and RFC 7100 of December 2013, written by Pete Resnick of Qualcomm Technologies, Inc., obsoletes RFC 5000 and requests that RFC 5000, and therefore STD 1, be moved to Historic status, so the last status that the Internet’s own standards registry ever assigned to TCP is “Recommended”, in RFC 2400 of September 1998.

D6.9 The IP that the registry listed at the status “Required” is version 4 of the Internet Protocol, RFC 791, and the Internet Engineering Task Force standardized a second and separate Internet Protocol, version 6, in RFC 8200 of July 2017, STD 86, by S. Deering and R. Hinden. RFC 6540 of April 2012, BCP 177, titled IPv6 Support Required for All IP-Capable Nodes and written by W. George of Time Warner Cable, C. Donley of CableLabs, C. Liljenstolpe of Big Switch Networks and L. Howard of Time Warner Cable, advises that “IPv6 support is no longer considered optional”, cautions that the term “IP” has become “a generic that can mean IPv4 + IPv6, IPv6-only, or IPv4-only, depending on context and application”, and states that new and updated IP networking implementations “must not require IPv4 for proper and complete function”, so the Internet Engineering Task Force itself used the word optional for an Internet Protocol until April 2012, and the IP version that the registry listed at the status “Required” is, under the Best Current Practice of April 2012, a version that no new or updated implementation may require.

D6.10 The suite’s own members prove reliability is a per-application choice, because the optional protocols UDP of RFC 768, RTP of RFC 1889 of January 1996, which RFC 3550 of July 2003 obsoletes, and QUIC of RFC 9000 all decline TCP’s services while each remains a protocol of the Internet standards track.

D6.11 TCP is an evolutionary option, not a permanent fixture: it replaced NCP on the owner’s intranet in the 1983 cutover, UDP stood beside it from 1980 for applications that declined its services, RTP went around it in 1996 for media that could not wait for retransmission, and QUIC, published in May 2021, is displacing it now by moving reliability into a new protocol carried inside UDP datagrams; the protocols rotate while the Internet persists, and a layer whose occupants rotate is by definition not the thing itself.

D6.12 It is the stated judgment of Mark Nichols that both are optional utilities: TCP optional on the registry’s own grade, and IP optional as a specific protocol, because the registry’s “Required” grade is conditional conformance language that binds only systems electing to implement the standard suite, the election being made before the grade applies, as the words “To communicate using the Internet system” of RFC 1122 and the word optional that RFC 6540 applies to IPv6 both record, and because what internetworking requires is the addressing function, the label that says where a packet should go, while IP is one implementation of that function and not the function itself.

D6.13 Hence the rebrand coinages stated at marknichols.com/internet-protocols/: TCP is better named ESFRP, the Endpoint Segment Failure Retry Protocol, and IP is better named ALP, the Address Label Protocol. The postmen are not the post office, and the protocols are not the Internet.

D7. NSFNET. The National Science Foundation’s backbone, 1986 to 1995: a federation of research intranets joined into a lowercase internet under a written Acceptable Use Policy that restricted carriage to research and education and barred commercial traffic. The dismantling is dated by the operator of record, Merit Network: the replacement architecture was awarded early in 1994, the very high speed Backbone Network Service to MCI and the Network Access Points to Sprint, MFS Datanet, and Bellcore representing Ameritech and PacBell; member networks began moving off in November 1994; the backbone was terminated on April 30, 1995; and the regional networks passed principally to the commercial carriers internetMCI and SprintLink, which, in Merit’s own words, absorbed the NSFNET regionals as their customers. The NSFNET is not the Internet: a backbone admission-screened under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education is a gated network, and a gated network is not the publicly joinable network of networks.

D8. The World Wide Web. An application design made by many persons inside and outside CERN, announced publicly on August 6, 1991, three programs of CERN's World Wide Web software, the line-mode client, the basic server and the library of common code, released into the public domain by CERN on April 30, 1993, with NCSA Mosaic released in 1993 putting a graphical browser in front of it. A free application is not an open network: until April 30, 1995, the Web’s principal carriage was the gated research intranets beneath it, research-only carriage under the written policy, and the calendar states the dependency exactly, because CERN's three programs of Web software went public on April 30, 1993, and the gated research fabric beneath most of its hosts was absorbed into the public Internet two years later to the day, on April 30, 1995. The name World Wide Web is a label for a large body of technology in the public domain, made by many persons and bodies inside and outside CERN, as F32.4 of this page states. The World Wide Web is not the Internet: the Web is an application using the Internet platform, and the application is not the platform.

D9. The birth of the Internet, and the absorption. The capital-I Internet was born in 1991, when PSINet, AlterNet under UUNET, and CERFnet, independently operated commercial networks of the registry lineage, established the Commercial Internet eXchange, a settlement-free router interconnection with open admission and no purpose-screening policy, as recorded in the Federal Communications Commission working paper The Digital Handshake by Michael Kende and as announced by the three networks’ operators themselves, General Atomics, Performance Systems International, Inc., and UUNET Technologies, Inc., in their release of March 25, 1991, which states that “The CIX agreement provides for all customers of AlterNet, CERFnet and PSINet to exchange Internet traffic directly, regardless of which network the customer obtains service from, and at no additional cost” and that the three “are not subject to government mandated “acceptable use” restrictions on their traffic,” the release being preserved as message 441 of the com-priv archive at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and seated at F52 of this page; the agreement’s own text and its execution date are still sought, and the ruling stands on the dated announcement, the year, the parties, and the terms until a dated earlier instrument of the same lineage is produced. April 30, 1995 is not the Internet’s birthday; it is the absorption: the day the last written admission policy over the general-purpose research backbone died with the NSFNET, the regional networks passed principally to internetMCI and SprintLink, and the populations that had lived behind the gate joined the Internet that had existed without them since 1991. Being born is not the same as being built, and the Modern Internet, publicly accessible, eCommerce native, media streaming native, and QoS native, was built from 1996 to 1997 on executed documents: the Telecommunications Act signed February 8, 1996, autonomous system AS6553 issued August 29, 1996 by the InterNIC, the $300,000 Cisco Systems agreement of November 1996 to host cisco.com on Digital Island’s Tier-0 network, and production service in the first quarter of 1997, with Cisco Systems, Stanford University, and Visa International as the first customers in sequence.

D10. The Modern Internet. The Internet changed from the legacy Internet to the Modern Internet on the day its internetworking changed from best effort to deterministic, and that day is November 1, 1996, the Effective Date of the Cisco Systems Remote Data Services Agreement, signed for Digital Island, Inc. by Mark Nichols, Director, Global Networks, on November 7, 1996 and for Cisco Systems, Inc. by Hervé Goguely, Director, Global Service Management, on November 8, 1996, under which Cisco Systems became the first customer to buy a contractually guaranteed global service, a network segment exclusively its own with secure transaction services and sub-300 milliseconds round trip, on the architecture Mark Nichols hand-drew in June 1996, redrew as DIGITAL ISLAND DRAFT.1 in July 1996 and DRAFT.2 in October 1996, and registered as AS6553, issued to Digital Island, Inc. on August 29, 1996. An evolution, not a synonym. The capital-I Internet born in 1991 and made general-purpose by the absorption of April 30, 1995 was public but bare: a network anyone could join, and nothing commerce-grade could yet depend on, because open admission supplies members and does not supply performance. The Modern Internet is what that public network evolved into when global commerce was engineered onto it: the enabling of the globalization of eCommerce, of streaming media, and of Quality of Service under signed and enforceable terms, built on Digital Island’s Tier-0 network under autonomous system AS6553 with contractually enforced sub-300-millisecond round-trip performance across major markets, carrying the Merchant Transport product category coined in September 1996, on the architecture designed by Mark Nichols as co-founder and chief architect, the record standing at marknichols.com/architect-of-the-modern-internet/, marknichols.com/merchant-transport/, and marknichols.com/tier-0/. The evolution is dated by the executed record and by the customers who ran on AS6553 in sequence: Cisco Systems in November 1996, Stanford University in 1997, Visa International in the second quarter of 1997, E*TRADE under its global data distribution agreement with Digital Island dated August 1, 1997, as Digital Island’s S-1 records it, Charles Schwab in 1998, and MasterCard in March 1999; Telefónica Data formed a global IP alliance with Digital Island on April 26, 1999, Sun Microsystems and Inktomi invested in Digital Island in December 1999, Microsoft, Intel, and Compaq invested in Digital Island in June 2000, and CERNET, the China Education and Research Network, peered with Digital Island under the contract signed in Beijing on February 25, 1998 and was never a customer. The Modern Internet is therefore dated 1996 to 1997 in executed documents, and the word modern means publicly accessible, commerce-grade, streaming-capable, and QoS-governed, none of which the newborn network possessed.

D11. Usage. On every page of this site, Internet with a capital I means the publicly joinable network of the registry lineage born in 1991 and nothing else; internet in lowercase means any interconnection of networks, including gated ones; gated systems are named what they were, research intranets, whatever their date; and any page, headline, plaque, or biography that assigns the birth of the Internet to 1969, 1974, or 1983 is measured against these definitions and fails, because on each of those dates every network in the claim admitted its members by permission, and any account that assigns the birth to April 30, 1995 is measured against these definitions and fails as well, because on that date the Internet already existed and what died was the gate beside it. And on every page of this site, “Required” as a registry grade appears only in quotation marks with its condition stated in the same sentence, that it binds only systems electing to implement the standard suite, except within D6 of this page, where D6.12 states that condition once for every quotation of the registry in D6.1 through D6.11; this site’s own prose never calls any Internet protocol required, because at the level of Internet membership there are no required protocols, only elected ones, and an unconditional “required” applied to an Internet protocol is the registry’s conditional conformance label promoted into a membership law that no document states.

D11.1 Definitions govern meaning. Documents govern facts. Findings govern conclusions.

D12. Contemporary primary-source documents control over retrospective accounts, institutional narratives, biographies, media summaries, machine-generated responses, and personal recollections.

D13. Any finding in this record may be amended upon production of contemporaneous documentary evidence demonstrating a materially earlier, later, or contrary fact.