Wikipedia History of the Internet: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol

Of the 358 citations in the Wikipedia article History of the Internet, 81 carry the sentence that cites them, 189 carry it in part, 34 do not carry it and 54 cannot be checked, and of the three sources that the article cites for its statement that international connections to the National Science Foundation Network (NSFNET), the emergence of the Domain Name System and the adoption of the optional protocols Transmission Control Protocol and Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) marked the beginnings of the Internet, two carry a part of the statement and the third, an essay of Ian Peter, carries none of it and quotes Bob Taylor, "The ARPAnet was not an internet. An internet is a connection between two or more computer networks.", the hearing that the article cites for the controversy that it says the Scientific and Advanced-Technology Act of 1992 caused was held on March 12, 1992, seven months before that Act was signed into law on October 23, 1992, and the 588 exabytes of mobile data traffic that the article gives for 2020 stand in neither of the two copies of the page of the company Ericsson that it cites and are twelve times the 49 exabytes per month that the page gives for the end of that year.

Preamble: I audit the Wikipedia article History of the Internet footnote by footnote, opening the source that each footnote cites and reading it against the sentence that cites it. This page is the companion of Disagreement 3 in the standing index of the series, Disagreements of Published Claims | Network, Not Protocol, and the sentences cited on this page are the numbered sentences of the Wikipedia source text that section 13.1 of Wikipedia Defines the History of the Internet: Disagreements | Network, Not Protocol prints, which this page calls Exhibit 13.1 of Disagreement 3. The method and the five grades are the same as on Wikipedia Robert Cailliau: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol, and units 0.4 and 0.5 of this page state the rules that this page adds for words that the article prints in quotation marks, for two or three footnotes that share one sentence, for a cited page that was read in another copy than the one that the footnote names, for the captions, which Exhibit 13.1 does not print, for footnotes that give no page or no address, and for the printing of quotations.

Opinion Rules: You are visiting my record, and I am the subject matter expert on it. If you are a subject matter expert too, I want to hear from you: bring your document and I will answer it on the record. If you are not, you are welcome here to read and to learn. The documented-challenge terms of marknichols.com and the condition on opinion are stated at F40 of The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, and they govern this page.

Conditional on the Governing Definitions: Every finding on this page is conditional on the Governing Definitions D1 through D13 of marknichols.com, which are reproduced in full in the Definitions Addendum at the bottom of this page.

0.0 This section records the article this page audits, the method of the audit, and the grades it assigns.

0.1 The article audited on this page is History of the Internet of the English Wikipedia, page 13692 of that site, in revision 1370792739, the revision whose body sentences section 13.1 of Disagreement 3 prints and numbers. Wikipedia's revision history, read through Wikipedia's own public interface on November 15, 2026, records that revision as saved at 03:16 UTC on August 23, 2026 by the account Sickerboi, with no edit summary and at a size of 211,485 bytes. The history records eight later revisions as of November 15, 2026, saved between November 1, 2026 and November 11, 2026: four by the account GreenC bot, whose edit summaries speak of moving or rescuing links, one by the account 110521sgl, two by the account Popcornfud, and one by the account Extraordinary Writ, which at 06:34 UTC on November 11, 2026 moved the article from the title History of the Internet to the same title with the word Internet written without the capital, at the request of the account Popcornfud and with a reference to the style guideline that Wikipedia abbreviates as MOS:INTERNET. The latest revision when this page read the history was revision 1385000264, saved at 09:02 UTC on November 11, 2026 by the account Popcornfud. This page audits revision 1370792739, the revision that Disagreement 3 examines, and it did not read the later revisions against it.

0.2 Revision 1370792739 carries 315 numbered footnotes in one list, and every one of them is cited. The footnotes are cited 358 times. Twenty-nine footnotes are cited more than once: footnotes 2, 3, 14, 29, 61, 80, 89, 91, 95, 96, 107, 109, 115, 117, 129, 142, 189, 206, 219, 225, 236 and 299 are each cited twice, footnotes 49, 56 and 207 three times, footnotes 39 and 209 four times, footnote 230 five times and footnote 23 six times, and the two citations of footnote 115 stand in one sentence, sentence 167. This page read the list of footnotes, the links of each footnote and the position of each marker in revision 1370792739 through Wikipedia's own public interface, and it matched every citation to its sentence in Exhibit 13.1. Of the 551 sentences of Exhibit 13.1, 225 carry at least one citation, and those 225 sentences carry 352 of the 358 citations. The other six citations stand in five captions, which Exhibit 13.1 leaves out under its own heading, where it says that it excludes captions that are purely image labels: the caption of a figure of the message block of Paul Baran, the captions of three maps of Internet users and of broadband subscriptions, and the caption of a chart of the number of Internet hosts. This page grades the six citations as it grades the others, in units 1.226 through 1.230. The article itself tags sentence 140, sentence 232 and sentence 346 with the words citation needed, a name in sentence 232 with the words clarification needed, the citation of footnote 199 at sentence 335 with the words non-primary source needed, and sentence 372 with the words needs update; it tags footnote 146 with the question user-generated source; and it sets over its section on net neutrality a notice, dated April 2015, that the examples and perspectives of the section may not represent a worldwide view of the subject, and over its subsection on file hosting services a notice, dated October 2024, that the section relies excessively on references to primary sources.

0.3 This page audited the footnotes on November 15, 2026. It opened each source at the archived copy that the footnote names, or, where the footnote names none, at the archived copy of the address of the footnote that is nearest to the retrieval date that the footnote gives, and the unit that grades the footnote gives the date of the copy that was read. Where a footnote cites a book, this page read the cited pages from their images in the preview of Google Books, by optical character recognition, or, where the footnote cites no page, searched the book there and read the pages that the search returned; where the preview shows no page of the book, or does not show the cited page, the unit says so. The encyclopedia at footnote 49 and the article at footnote 56 were read in the public text of the scans that those footnotes link at the Internet Archive. Where the cited source is a long file, as the report of 190 pages of a hearing of the House of Representatives at footnote 175 and the order of 400 pages of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) at footnote 278 are, this page retrieved the file in full, extracted its text, searched it and read the passages that the unit names. Where the cited file holds page images and no text, as the paper of the RAND Corporation at footnote 25, the notes of a meeting at footnote 82 and the three magazine pages at footnote 194 do, this page read the images by optical character recognition and checked the words that it quotes against the images. Where the cited paper or article stands behind a sign-in or a paywall of its publisher, this page read the abstract, the summary or the opening that the page of the publisher shows, and the unit says so; where the author or a repository posts the text of such a paper, this page read that text, and the unit names the copy. Where a footnote gives no address, this page looked for the page or the file that the footnote names by a web search for its title, and the unit says what was found: so at footnotes 199, 299, 300, 301, 306, 307 and 309. Where the cited address stopped this page at a check for automated visitors and a web search found the text at another address, as at footnotes 310 and 312, this page read that copy, and the unit names it. The page of the trade association CTIA that footnote 301 names was read on the live site of the association on November 15, 2026, because the copies of that page in the Wayback Machine hold no text. Of the 315 footnotes, 215 were read in full, or retrieved in full and searched; 56 were read in part, at the cited pages of a book, at an abstract, at a summary, at a preview or at the opening of an article; and 44 could not be read. The unit that grades each footnote states which of the three applies.

0.4 Each citation receives one of five grades. Supported means that the source carries the sentence in its own words. Partial means that the source carries part of the sentence and not the rest. Not supported means that the source was read and does not carry the sentence. Uncheckable means that the citation cannot be followed to a readable source. Unread means that the source was not read for this page, and no citation of this article is graded Unread. A citation is graded against the sentence or the clause that it follows: where a marker stands inside a sentence, as at sentence 104, sentence 303 and sentence 517, the citation is graded against the words before the marker, and the unit says where the marker stands. A fuller name for a thing that the source identifies does not make a grade Partial, and a date, a figure, a person, an attribution or a description that the source does not carry does. Where a footnote cites pages of a book or a part of a source and that part was read, the citation is graded on that part, and where another part of the same source carries the statement, the unit says so, as at sentence 281. Where only the abstract of a source, a summary, a preview or the opening of it could be read, the citation is graded Supported when that part itself carries the sentence, Partial when it carries some of the things that the sentence states and not others, and Uncheckable when it carries none, and the unit states what the part carries. Where a source is older than the fact that the sentence reports, or speaks of that fact as a thing to come, the source cannot carry the fact, and the citation is graded Partial when the source carries the rest of the sentence or the plan and Not supported when it carries nothing of the sentence; a source that this page could not open at all stays Uncheckable. Where the cited page presents a recording, this page read the text of the page and did not play the recording. Six further rules apply on this page. First, where the article prints words in quotation marks and the cited source does not print those words, the citation is graded no higher than Partial. Second, where two or three footnotes stand together at one sentence and each source carries a part of the sentence that another does not, each citation is graded Partial, and the unit says that the footnotes together carry the sentence, as at sentence 97, sentence 362 and sentence 386. Third, where a footnote names an archived copy of a page, the citation is graded on that copy; where the named copy is incomplete, as at footnote 63, this page read a later copy, and where a later copy of the page differs from the named copy, as at footnote 216, the unit gives both. Fourth, the six citations in the five captions are graded against the caption as the revision prints it. Fifth, where a footnote cites a book without a page, the citation is graded on the pages that the search of the book returned and on the page that the link of the footnote opens, and the unit names those pages. Sixth, where a footnote gives no address and this page found the source by a web search, the citation is graded on the page or the file that was found, and the unit says that the footnote does not give the address.

0.5 The sources are quoted on this page in short fragments, and the rest of what each source says is stated in the words of this page. The sentences of the article are for the most part restated in the words of this page, with words of the article in quotation marks where a unit turns on them, and their text stands in Exhibit 13.1 of Disagreement 3. A quotation that itself contains straight quotation marks is printed between curly quotation marks, so that the marks of the source stay as the source prints them. Where the text of a page image or of a search result divides a word at the end of a line or sets a space before a mark of punctuation, the quotation prints the word whole and without the space. The quotations are chosen so that the word Internet stands in them with the capital, with one exception, the two sentences of Bob Taylor that the subtitle of this page and units 1.2 and 2.1 quote, in which the word without the capital is the point of the quotation; a title that prints the word without the capital is described and not quoted. The page of the company Dropbox at footnote 296 was read in a copy in traditional Chinese, and unit 1.206 quotes it in Chinese with a rendering into English that is this page's. Where a site asked this page for a sign-in or a payment, or stopped it at a check for automated visitors, this page stopped there and did not go around the barrier, and the unit says so. Thirty-one footnotes cite articles of publishers whose sites this page does not open under the rules of its tools, in the original or in an archived copy: footnotes 12, 61, 251, 252, 253, 254, 255, 256, 257, 258, 260, 262, 263, 267, 269, 270, 271, 273, 276, 277, 281 and 293 cite The New York Times, footnotes 33, 259 and 268 cite Wired, footnotes 202, 203, 242 and 243 cite The Wall Street Journal, and footnotes 93 and 110 cite The Economist, and their 32 citations are graded Uncheckable for that reason. The page that footnote 220 cites on the site of the Internet Hall of Fame presents itself in its own text as an article of Wired; this page does not read the texts of those publishers in copies on other sites, and the citation of footnote 220 at sentence 381 is graded Uncheckable for the same reason.

1.0 Each of the 315 footnotes of the article is graded at each sentence that cites it.

1.1 Sentence 2 says that the Internet protocol suite, the optional protocols that the sentence calls the set of rules used to communicate between networks and devices on the Internet, arose from research and development in the United States and involved international collaboration, particularly with researchers in the United Kingdom and France. Footnote 1 cites page 3 of Janet Abbate, Inventing the Internet (MIT Press), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, in the volume that the footnote links, by optical character recognition; the footnote dates the book 1999 and the volume data of Google Books date it July 24, 2000. The source reads: "he drew on the ideas of network experimenters in the United States and in the United Kingdom" and "Cerf and Kahn also enlisted the help of computer experts from England, France, and the United States when they decided to expand the ARPANET into a system of interconnected networks that would become known as the Internet." The page carries the collaboration with England and France and names no protocol and no protocol suite. The quotation printed in the footnote reads "computer scientists" where the page reads "computer experts" and drops the second "in" of "in the United States and in the United Kingdom". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "Tim Berners-Lee took advantage of the Internet’s unique capabilities to invent an application that he called the World Wide Web." and "The history of the Internet is not, therefore, a story of a few heroic inventors". The citation of footnote 1 at sentence 2 is graded Partial. Footnote 2 cites the press release of the Computer History Museum, SRI International and BBN Technologies dated October 27, 2009, on the site of SRI International, copy archived March 29, 2019 (named), read in full. The source reads: "By the early1970s, researchers in France, the UK, and the U.S. began developing ways of connecting networks to each other, a process known as internetworking." and "By 1983, the ARPANET and other networks had switched over to the internetworking protocols still used today and the Internet was rapidly growing." The release does not use the name Internet Protocol Suite. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the release bears in its title the words "Precursor to Today's Internet", calls the first transmission one between two nodes of "the ARPANET, a key precursor to the Internet", quotes Marc Weber, founding curator of the Internet History Program of the museum, on "the project that led to the Internet", describes internetworking as "leading to the Internet on which the World Wide Web and email run today", and says that SRI International "ran the Domain Name System until 1991". The citation of footnote 2 at sentence 2 is graded Supported. Footnote 3 cites Vinton Cerf, as told to Bernard Aboba, "How the Internet Came to Be", copyright 1993, copy archived September 26, 2017 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the passages on the International Network Working Group, on the Stanford seminars and on the implementations read. The source reads: "We began doing concurrent implementations at Stanford, BBN, and University College London. So effort at developing the Internet protocols was international from the beginning.", "Gerard Lelann was visiting from IRIA and the Cyclades/Cigale project" and "Louis Pouzin who led the Cyclades/Cigale packet network research program". The citation of footnote 3 at sentence 2 is graded Supported.

1.2 Sentence 22 says that international connections to the National Science Foundation Network (NSFNET), the emergence of architecture such as the Domain Name System, and the adoption of the optional protocols Transmission Control Protocol and Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) on existing networks in the United States and around the world marked the beginnings of the Internet. Footnote 4 cites the blog post "The Untold Internet" of the Internet Hall of Fame, dated October 19, 2015, signed "Internet Hall of Fame Editorial Staff", copy archived March 21, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date April 3, 2020; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "many of the milestones that led to the development of the modern Internet are already familiar to many of us: the genesis of the ARPANET, the implementation of the standard network protocol TCP/IP, the growth of LANs (Large Area Networks), the invention of DNS (the Domain Name System), and the adoption of American legislation that funded U.S. Internet expansion". The source carries TCP/IP and the Domain Name System as milestones that led to the modern Internet. The source names neither the NSFNET nor international connections, and does not say that the three things of the sentence marked the beginnings of the Internet. The post expands LANs as "Large Area Networks". The citation of footnote 4 at sentence 22 is graded Partial. Footnote 5 cites RTFM LLP (Reid Technical Facilities Management LLP), "Study into UK IPv4 and IPv6 allocations", a study for Ofcom of 46 pages, file at the cited address in the copy archived March 6, 2023 (the latest copy of the address in the Wayback Machine returns a page not found; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the section on the history of address allocation read. The source reads: "The US National Science Foundation set up a national IP-based backbone network, NSFnet, so that its grant-holders could be interconnected to supercomputer centres, universities and various national/regional academic/research networks, including ARPAnet. That resulting network of networks was the beginning of today’s Internet." The source carries the NSFNET as the beginning. The source says nothing of international connections to it, of the emergence of the Domain Name System or of the adoption of TCP/IP on networks around the world as marks of the beginning. The glossary of the study calls the Advanced Research Projects Agency Network (ARPANET) "Forerunner of the Internet created by ARPA". The citation of footnote 5 at sentence 22 is graded Partial. Footnote 6 cites Ian Peter, "So, who really did invent the Internet?", page headed "Origins of the Internet" of nethistory.info, copy archived September 3, 2011 (named), retrieved in full and searched; opening, the findings on each theory and the conclusions read. The essay sets out five theories of the origin of the Internet (packet switching, TCP/IP, telephone company activities, applications, Xerox PARC) and concludes "There are a number of valid claims to origins of the Internet." and "Neither Arpanet nor TCP/IP is present in all valid theories." The essay never names the NSFNET or the Domain Name System (searched: NSF, Domain Name, DNS: no occurrence). Of TCP/IP the essay says "TCP/IP was not even added to Arpanet officially until 1983". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the essay quotes Bob Taylor, "The ARPAnet was not an internet. An internet is a connection between two or more computer networks.", and says "What defines the Internet is the capacity to connect networks of different types. It therefore follows that Arpanet as a single network could hardly be described as an Internet". The citation of footnote 6 at sentence 22 is graded Not supported.

1.3 Sentence 23 says that commercial Internet service providers (ISPs) emerged in 1989 in the United States and Australia. Footnote 7 cites Roger Clarke, "Origins and Nature of the Internet in Australia", version of 29 January 2004, copy archived February 9, 2021 (named), retrieved in full and searched; section 5.2, to which the link of the footnote points, and the passage on commercial access in the United States read. Of Australia the page says "DIALix claims to have been offering services commercially in Perth as early as 1989" and that Pegasus Networks "offered public dialup access to the Internet in Australia, commencing in June 1989". Of the United States the page says "In the U.S.A., the pilot connection of commercial services to the Internet began in 1989, although in a tightly controlled manner." and, quoting Kahin 1995, “"Commercial Internet access was first offered by PSI and AlterNet beginning in early 1990"”. The source dates commercial Internet access in the United States to early 1990, not 1989. The citation of footnote 7 at sentence 23 is graded Partial.

1.4 Sentence 24 says that limited private connections to parts of the Internet by officially commercial entities emerged in several American cities by late 1989 and 1990. Footnote 8 cites the essay "The First ISP", signed Spike, on indra.com, which says it was published in the magazine ;login: of the USENIX Association, copy archived March 5, 2016 (named), read in full. The essay is the account of one company, Software Tool & Die of Brookline near Boston: "On a fine Boston (OK, Brookline) day early in November 1989, our first customer logged on and The World was born." (a service of electronic mail and of Usenet news by the optional protocol Unix-to-Unix Copy, UUCP). Of its connection of 1990 through Alternet the essay says "We could get to the parts of the Internet that were connected to Alternet and a few other networks that were privately interconnected with them (they call it peering in the modern era), but not the bulk of it." The source names no other city where such connections emerged (The Well in San Francisco and Portal are named as earlier sellers of access). Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words “if you weren't an institute of higher learning or a defense contractor, you couldn't be on the "Internet."” and "So that's how on August 13, 1992, I was running the very first official ISP." The footnote gives August 13, 1992 as the date of the page, which is the date the essay gives for that event. The citation of footnote 8 at sentence 24 is graded Partial.

1.5 Sentence 26 credits research at the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) in Switzerland by the British computer scientist Tim Berners-Lee in 1989 and 1990 with the World Wide Web application design, which the sentence describes as linking hypertext documents into an information system accessible from any node on the network. Footnote 9 cites page 2 of Nick Couldry, Media, Society, World: Social Theory and Digital Media Practice (Polity, 2012), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, in the volume that the footnote links, by optical character recognition. The source reads: "World Wide Web protocols that link hypertext documents into a working system that were conceived first by Tim Berners-Lee in 1989, launched in 1991, but only began to enter everyday use in 1993–4". The page names neither CERN nor Switzerland, does not call Tim Berners-Lee British or a computer scientist, gives no research of 1989 to 1990, and says nothing of access from any node. What the sentence calls an information system the page calls "protocols". The citation of footnote 9 at sentence 26 is graded Partial.

1.6 Sentence 29 says that increasing amounts of data are transmitted at higher and higher speeds over fiber-optic networks operating at 1 gigabit per second, 10 gigabits per second and 800 gigabits per second by 2019. Footnote 10 cites Patrick Nelson, "Data center fiber to jump to 800 gigabits in 2019", Network World, copy archived March 30, 2019 (nearest to the date of the article, March 20, 2019; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "networking company Ciena says it will start deliveries of an 800 gigabit-per-second, single wavelength light throughput system in Q3 2019", "data center connects that can now be using 100 or 200 gigabits or less" and "systems running at 10 gigabits per second just cannot keep up with this kind of rapid scalability". The article reports an announced product to be delivered from the third quarter of 2019, not networks operating at 800 gigabits per second, and it does not mention 1 gigabit per second. The citation of footnote 10 at sentence 29 is graded Partial.

1.7 Sentence 30 says that the takeover of the global communication landscape by the Internet was rapid in historical terms: that the Internet communicated 1 percent of the information flowing through two-way telecommunications networks in 1993, 51 percent by 2000 and more than 97 percent by 2007. Footnote 11 cites Martin Hilbert and Priscila López, "The World's Technological Capacity to Store, Communicate, and Compute Information", Science 332 (6025); page of the journal reached through the identifier of the footnote, copy archived September 23, 2025: the abstract and the list of references read; the page offers the article after a sign-in (registration), where this page stopped. The abstract reads "The world’s capacity for bidirectional telecommunication grew at 28% per year" and "Telecommunication has been dominated by digital technologies since 1990 (99.9% in digital format in 2007)". The abstract gives no share of the Internet in telecommunicated information for 1993, 2000 or 2007. The citation of footnote 11 at sentence 30 is graded Uncheckable.

1.8 Sentence 32 says that the future of the global network may be shaped by regional differences. Footnote 12 cites The Editorial Board, "There May Soon Be Three Internets. America's Won't Necessarily Be the Best.", October 15, 2018, an editorial of The New York Times. The rules of the tools of this page close the site of that publisher and copies of its articles, and the source was not opened. The citation of footnote 12 at sentence 32 is graded Uncheckable.

1.9 Sentence 46 says that Christopher Strachey, who became the first Professor of Computation of Oxford University, filed a patent application in the United Kingdom for time-sharing in February 1959. Footnote 13 cites J. A. N. Lee, "Computer Pioneers: Christopher Strachey", page of the History Committee of the IEEE Computer Society, copy archived February 1, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date January 23, 2020; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the passages on time-sharing and on Oxford read. The source reads: "Strachey filed a patent application for time-sharing in February 1959." The page records "Programming Research Group, Oxford University, 1966-1975" and nowhere calls Strachey a professor or the first Professor of Computation of Oxford University (searched: professor). The words of the sentence on the professorship stand on the page of the book that footnote 16 cites at the next sentence. The citation of footnote 13 at sentence 46 is graded Partial. Footnote 14 cites Encyclopaedia Britannica, article Computer, section "Time-sharing and minicomputers", copy archived October 5, 2023 (nearest to the retrieval date July 23, 2023; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the subsection on time-sharing read. The source reads: "In 1959 Christopher Strachey in the United Kingdom and John McCarthy in the United States independently described something they called time-sharing." The article carries no patent application, no February and no professorship at Oxford. The citation of footnote 14 at sentence 46 is graded Partial.

1.10 Sentence 47 says that in June 1959 Christopher Strachey gave a paper, "Time Sharing in Large Fast Computers", at the UNESCO Information Processing Conference in Paris, where he passed the concept on to J. C. R. Licklider. Footnote 15 cites F. J. Corbató and others, The Compatible Time-Sharing System: A Programmer's Guide (The M.I.T. Press, 1963), file of 104 page images at the cited address, copy archived April 7, 2026 (the latest copy of the address returns a refusal; the footnote names no archive); the first 16 pages of the file read by optical character recognition, the rest not read. The preface reads at page vi: "Shortly after the first paper on time-shared computers, by C. Strachey at the June 1959 UNESCO Information Processing Conference, H. M. Teager and J. McCarthy at MIT delivered an unpublished paper". The source carries the paper, the month and the conference. The source gives neither the title of the paper nor Paris, and does not name Licklider. The citation of footnote 15 at sentence 47 is graded Partial. Footnote 16 cites page 13 of James Gillies and Robert Cailliau, How the Web was Born (Oxford University Press, 2000), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books (volume pIH-JijUNS0C, found by the ISBN of the footnote; the copy at archive.org that the list of sources links is a lending copy that asks for a sign-in), by optical character recognition. The source reads: "Licklider had first heard about time-sharing from ‘a young Britisher’ at a UNESCO-sponsored International Conference on Information Processing in Paris in 1959. The ‘young Britisher’ would probably have been Christopher Strachey, who went on to become Oxford University’s first Professor of Computation." (line breaks rejoined). The book says probably. It gives neither the month nor the title of the paper. It adds "It is difficult to say, however, whether Strachey really invented the idea." The citation of footnote 16 at sentence 47 is graded Partial.

1.11 Sentence 48 says that J. C. R. Licklider, a vice president at Bolt Beranek and Newman, Inc. (BBN), promoted the idea of time-sharing as an alternative to batch processing. Footnote 14 cites the same source as at sentence 46, read in the same copy. The source reads: "computer pioneer J.C.R. Licklider at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) began to promote the idea of interactive computing as an alternative to batch processing". The page places Licklider at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and does not name Bolt Beranek and Newman or a vice presidency. What it has him promote is "interactive computing". The citation of footnote 14 at sentence 48 is graded Partial.

1.12 Sentence 50 says that other multi-user mainframe systems developed, such as PLATO at the University of Illinois Chicago. Footnote 17 cites John McCarthy, "Reminiscences on the Theory of Time-Sharing", dated 1983, with a letter of Christopher Strachey, page of John McCarthy's site at Stanford, copy archived November 5, 2019 (nearest to the retrieval date January 23, 2020; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; opening and the letter read. The page never names PLATO or the University of Illinois (searched: PLATO, Illinois, mainframe, multi-user: no occurrence). The words that the footnote quotes are in the letter of Strachey: "`time-sharing' as a phrase was much in the air. It was, however, generally used in my sense rather than in John McCarthy's sense of a CTSS-like object." The letter is signed "C. Strachey Professor of Computation University of Oxford". The citation of footnote 17 at sentence 50 is graded Not supported.

1.13 Sentence 52 says that J. C. R. Licklider, while working at BBN, proposed a computer network in his paper of March 1960, Man-Computer Symbiosis. Footnote 18 cites J. C. R. Licklider, "Man-Computer Symbiosis", IRE Transactions on Human Factors in Electronics, volume HFE-1, pages 4-11, March 1960, transcription on a site of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, copy archived November 3, 2005 (named), retrieved in full and searched; summary and the passage on the thinking center read. The source reads: "The picture readily enlarges itself into a network of such centers, connected to one another by wide-band communication lines and to individual users by leased-wire services." and "volume HFE-1, pages 4-11, March 1960". The transcription does not give the employer of the author and never names Bolt Beranek and Newman (searched: Bolt, BBN, Beranek). The citation of footnote 18 at sentence 52 is graded Partial.

1.14 Sentence 54 says that in August 1962 J. C. R. Licklider and Welden Clark published the paper "On-Line Man-Computer Communication", where the marker stands, and, after the marker, that the paper was one of the first descriptions of a networked future. Footnote 19 cites J. C. R. Licklider and Welden E. Clark, "On-Line Man-Computer Communication", scan of pages 113 to 128 of the proceedings, file of 16 pages, copy archived October 31, 2014 (named), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; first page read. The source reads: "ON-LINE MAN-COMPUTER COMMUNICATION J. C. R. Licklider and Welden E. Clark Bolt Beranek and Newman, Inc." The scan prints no date of publication, so August 1962 is not carried (the footnote itself labels the proceedings Spring). The word network does not occur in the paper (searched), and the words of the sentence after the marker, on one of the first descriptions of a networked future, follow the page that footnote 21 cites. The citation of footnote 19 at sentence 54 is graded Partial.

1.15 Sentence 57 says that J. C. R. Licklider began by writing memos in 1963 that described a distributed network to the staff of the Information Processing Techniques Office (IPTO), whom he called "Members and Affiliates of the Intergalactic Computer Network". Footnote 20 cites J. C. R. Licklider, memorandum of April 23, 1963, as published on KurzweilAI.net on December 11, 2001, copy archived January 23, 2013 (nearest to the retrieval date January 26, 2013; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the introduction of the site and the opening of the memorandum read. The source reads: "ADVANCED RESEARCH PROJECTS AGENCY Washington 25, D.C. April 23, 1963 MEMORANDUM FOR: Members and Affiliates of the Intergalactic Computer Network" and "Consider the situation in which several different centers are netted together". The source is one memorandum, where the sentence has memos. The addressees are not called staff of the office, the office is named "The ARPA Command & Control Research office", and the word distributed is used only of the distribution of the memorandum. The wording of the sentence follows the page that footnote 21 cites. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the introduction of KurzweilAI says "ultimately, this vision would lead to ARPANet, the precursor of the Internet in use today". The citation of footnote 20 at sentence 57 is graded Partial.

1.16 Sentence 59 says that J. C. R. Licklider later returned to lead the IPTO in 1973 for two years. Footnote 21 cites "J.C.R. Licklider and the Universal Network", page of Living Internet, copy archived October 17, 2019 (named), read in full. The source reads: "In 1973, he returned again to lead the IPTO for two years." The same page carries the wording of sentences 54 and 57: “Licklider and Welden Clark elaborated on these ideas in the the paper "On-Line Man Computer Communication", one of the first conceptions of the future Internet.” and “He started by writing a series of memos to the other members of the office describing the benefits of creation of a global, distributed network, addressing some memos to "Members and Affiliates of the Intergalactic Computer Network".” Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "inspired his successors to realize his dream by inventing the ARPANET, which led to the Internet". The citation of footnote 21 at sentence 59 is graded Supported.

1.17 Sentence 65 says that the systems of sentences 63 and 64, of which it names SAGE and SBRE, still required rigid routing structures that were prone to a single point of failure. Footnote 24 cites pages 51 to 55 of Byung-Keun Kim, Internationalizing the Internet: The Co-evolution of Influence and Technology (Edward Elgar, 2005), read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books, in the volume that the footnote links, by optical character recognition. Page 51 reads "One of the earliest computer communication systems was SAGE (Semi-Automatic Ground Environment), a computer and radar-based air defence system of the 1950s." Page 52 reads "a centralized network has aggregating nodes and thus is vulnerable to military attack". The pages do not name SABRE, do not speak of rigid routing structures, and do not say of SAGE that it was prone to a single point of failure. The article prints SBRE for SABRE. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: page 52 reads "Packet switching was independently invented by two computer scientists, Paul Baran of the Rand Corporation in the USA and Donald W. Davies of the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in the UK". Page 55 reads "Packet switching technology was not invented and developed by a heroic individual or visionary entrepreneur." The citation of footnote 24 at sentence 65 is graded Partial.

1.18 Sentence 67 says that in the early 1960s Paul Baran of the RAND Corporation produced a study of survivable networks for the military of the United States in the event of nuclear war. Footnote 25 cites Paul Baran, "Reliable Digital Communications Systems Using Unreliable Network Repeater Nodes", RAND paper P-1995, May 27, 1960, file of 30 page images at the cited address, copy archived October 20, 2012 (nearest to the retrieval date July 25, 2012; the footnote names no archive), read by optical character recognition and searched; title page, summary, acknowledgment and introduction read. The summary describes a communications network "that utilizes a moderate degree of redundancy to provide high immunity from the deleterious effects of damage of relay centers". The introduction speaks of "The cloud-of-doom attitude that nuclear war spells the end of the earth". The paper says it is "directed toward the communications systems designer" and does not say that the study was made for the military of the United States (searched: military, Air Force: no occurrence in the text as read). The citation of footnote 25 at sentence 67 is graded Partial. Footnote 26 cites "Paul Baran and the Origins of the Internet", page of the RAND Corporation, last modified December 23, 2011, copy archived July 16, 2012 (nearest to the retrieval date July 25, 2012; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "US authorities considered ways to communicate in the aftermath of a nuclear attack.", "Paul Baran, a researcher at RAND, offered a solution" and "neither the long-distance telephone plant, nor the basic military command and control network would survive a nuclear attack". The page also carries the wording of sentences 68 and 71: “Baran also developed the concept of dividing information into "message blocks" before sending them out across the network.” and “A British man named Donald Davies independently devised a very similar system, but he called the message blocks "packets," a term that was eventually adopted instead of Baran's message blocks.” Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "This effort would eventually become the foundation for the World Wide Web." and “In 1989, the ARPANET moniker was retired in favor the "Internet,"” and the heading "Forerunner of the Internet". The citation of footnote 26 at sentence 67 is graded Supported.

1.19 Sentence 68 says that information would be transmitted across a "distributed" network, divided into what Paul Baran called "message blocks". Footnote 27 cites James Pelkey, The History of Computer Communications, section 6.1 "The Communications Subnet: BBN 1969", copy archived May 11, 2026 (the latest copy of the address returns a page not found; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the passage in which Robert Kahn speaks of Paul Baran read. The section speaks of Baran through one recollection of Robert Kahn, on routing and on what moved Baran. It has neither the words message block nor a distributed network (searched: message block: no occurrence). What it carries of Baran belongs to sentence 69, where the same section is cited as footnote 31. The citation of footnote 27 at sentence 68 is graded Not supported. Footnote 28 cites Derek Barber, "The Origins of Packet Switching", in Resurrection, the bulletin of the Computer Conservation Society, issue 5, Spring 1993, page of the whole issue, copy archived September 12, 2017 (nearest to the retrieval date September 6, 2017; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the talk of Derek Barber read at the passage on the Rand paper. The source reads: "There had been a paper written by someone from the Rand Corporation which, in a sense, foreshadowed packet switching in a way for speech networks and voice networks but nobody knew anything about it and certainly it didn't enter into our thinking at all." The talk has no message blocks and no distributed network (searched). The quotation in the footnote puts the name Paul Baran in brackets where the talk says "someone". The citation of footnote 28 at sentence 68 is graded Not supported. Footnote 29 cites M. Mitchell Waldrop, The Dream Machine (Stripe Press, 2018), preview of Google Books, in the volume that the footnote links: the preview has no page at the page mark of the link, and an in-book search for the words that the footnote quotes returned nothing; four pages of the account of the Gatlinburg symposium of October 1967 were read from their images by optical character recognition (the pages before and after the one that the preview withholds), and the search snippets of the volume. The pages read say that Scantlebury told Roberts of the work of an American who had "invented the packet network independently" and that Roberts dug out "Baran’s final network design, which had been circulated as a RAND report in August 1964". They carry neither a distributed network nor message blocks. The page that would follow, where the account of the report continues, is not shown by the preview. The citation of footnote 29 at sentence 68 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 30 cites "On packet switching", page of nethistory.info recording an exchange of electronic mail of April 2009 among Ian Peter, Vint Cerf, Robert Kahn and Roger Scantlebury, copy archived January 8, 2024 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), read in full. Vint Cerf writes: "Paul's principal conceptual ideas related to packetization (message blocks) and hot-potato routing". The source carries the message blocks. The word distributed does not occur on the page. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: Robert Kahn writes: "Then there was the plan to interconnect multiple heterogeneous packet networks (and their attached computers cum protocols) which demonstrated the concept of Internetting and led to today's Internet. But, then again, thats an entirely different story." The citation of footnote 30 at sentence 68 is graded Partial.

1.20 Sentence 69 says that the design of Paul Baran was intended for high-speed digital communication of voice messages using low-cost hardware, and that it was not implemented. Footnote 29 cites the same pages of the preview as at sentence 68. The pages read say nothing of voice, of low-cost hardware or of whether the design of Baran was built. The words that the footnote quotes, on digital voice communications, were not found by the in-book search and would stand on a page that the preview does not show. The citation of footnote 29 at sentence 69 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 31 cites the same section of James Pelkey as footnote 27, same copy. Robert Kahn says: "I also think Paul was motivated almost entirely by voice considerations. If you look at what he wrote, he was talking about switches that were low-cost electronics." The source carries voice and low-cost electronics. The source says nothing of high speed and does not say that the design was not implemented ("he had not really laid a clear template for what it was"). The citation of footnote 31 at sentence 69 is graded Partial. Footnote 32 cites Leonard Kleinrock, "Principles and Lessons in Packet Communications", Proceedings of the IEEE 66 (11), November 1978, pages 1320 to 1329, read in the copy that the author posts on his site at the University of California, Los Angeles (file of 10 pages, copy archived May 13, 2026; the footnote links only identifiers, and the page of the publisher shows the abstract), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; section III read at the passage on Baran. The source reads: "In the early 1960's Paul Baran had described some of the properties of data networks in a series of Rand Corporation papers" and "did not concentrate on the need for resource sharing in its form as we now understand it". The paper says nothing of voice, of low-cost hardware or of whether the design was implemented. The words that the footnote quotes are in the paper and concern routing, survivability and the absence of a software switch. The citation of footnote 32 at sentence 69 is graded Not supported. Footnote 33 cites Cade Metz, "What Do the H-Bomb and the Internet Have in Common? Paul Baran", September 3, 2012, an article of Wired. The rules of the tools of this page close the site of that publisher and copies of its articles, and the source was not opened. The citation of footnote 33 at sentence 69 is graded Uncheckable.

1.21 Sentence 71 says that, beginning in 1965, Donald Davies, at the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in the United Kingdom, independently developed a similar proposal of the concept, designed for high-speed data communication in computer networks, which he called packet switching, the term that would ultimately be adopted. Footnote 34 cites David M. Yates, Turing's Legacy: A History of Computing at the National Physical Laboratory 1945-1995 (1997): Google Books shows no pages of the volume that the footnote links; the snippets that its in-book search returns for pages 127 to 132 were read (the footnote cites pages 132 to 134). Page 127 reads "1965, Donald Davies saw that existing telecommunication systems, which had evolved to meet quite different demands, would need to be supplemented by new services". Page 129 reads "Davies was not aware of it, the principle of packet-switching had been put forward independently in 1964 in an outline design for a military communication network by Paul Baran of the RAND Corporation". Page 130 reads "term packet in the technical sense". The snippets carry 1965, the independence and the term. They do not show high-speed data communication or the adoption of the term. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: page 129 reads "Baran's ideas were not put into practice." The citation of footnote 34 at sentence 71 is graded Partial. Footnote 35 cites page 201 of Tony Hey and Gyuri Pápay, The Computing Universe: A Journey through a Revolution (Cambridge University Press), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, in the volume that the footnote links, by optical character recognition. The source reads: "Meanwhile, back in the United Kingdom, Davies and his colleagues set about building a small, packet-switching network at NPL." and "Despite the similarity of their ideas, Davies always gave credit to Baran as being the first to publish the idea of packet switching". The page carries the work of Davies at the laboratory and the likeness to the idea of Baran. It gives no 1965, does not say that Davies named packet switching, and does not say that the term was adopted. The citation of footnote 35 at sentence 71 is graded Partial. Footnote 36 cites page 102 of Gareth Ffowc Roberts, For the Recorde: A History of Welsh Mathematical Greats (University of Wales Press, 2022), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, at the page to which the link of the footnote points (the footnote names no page), by optical character recognition. The source reads: "That insight was provided by Donald Davies, who established the principles that today enable computers to communicate easily and speedily with each other". The page names neither 1965 nor the National Physical Laboratory, and does not print the words packet switching. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page credits Davies with the principles of the "computer networks that together form the ‘Internet’". The citation of footnote 36 at sentence 71 is graded Partial. Footnote 37 cites Ed Smith, Chris Miller and Jim Norton, "Packet Switching: The first steps on the road to the information society", file of 25 pages of the National Physical Laboratory, copy archived September 16, 2024 (the latest copy of the address returns a page not found; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; abstract, introduction and the passages on Baran and Davies read. The source reads: "packet switching, as illustrated in figure 1, which was independently devised by Paul Baran in the USA and Donald Davies in the UK", "Davies, a computer scientist at the UK’s National Physical Laboratory (NPL), was interested in interactive time -sharing systems, which were limited by inadequate data communications.", "This technique, which he called packet switching" and "Following public presentation of his ideas, in late 1965 and early 1966, Davies became aware of Baran’s work". The paper says the planners of the ARPANET took up "Davies’ term packet switching". The citation of footnote 37 at sentence 71 is graded Supported.

1.22 Sentence 74 says that packet switching is a distinct concept to message switching. Footnote 38 cites Scott Ruthfield, "The Internet's History and Development: From Wartime Tool to the Fish-Cam", Crossroads 2.1, September 1995, copy archived October 18, 2007 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the passages on packet switching read. The article describes packet switching ("IMPs would use a technology called packet-switching, which split large sections of data into small parts called packets") and never mentions message switching or circuit switching (searched: no occurrence). The citation of footnote 38 at sentence 74 is graded Not supported.

1.23 Sentence 75 says that, following discussions with J. C. R. Licklider in 1965, Donald Davies became interested in data communications for computer networks. Footnote 39 cites Lawrence G. Roberts, "The Evolution of Packet Switching", Proceedings of the IEEE 66 (11), November 1978, pages 1307 to 1313, file of 7 pages at the cited address (copy archived July 14, 2026; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted by column and searched; the sections ARPA I, National Physical Laboratory and ARPA II read. The source reads: "the discussions and interest Licklider spawned had an important motivating impact on the initiators of the two first actual network projects: Donald Davies and me" (line breaks rejoined). It also reads: "Evidently Donald Davies of the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in the United Kingdom had been seized by the same conviction, partially as a result of a seminar he sponsored in autumn 1965, which I attended with many M.I.T. Project MAC people." The source carries the interest of Davies, the influence of Licklider and a seminar of autumn 1965. The source does not say that Davies had discussions with Licklider in 1965. The citation of footnote 39 at sentence 75 is graded Partial. Footnote 40 cites Lawrence G. Roberts, "The ARPANET & Computer Networks", page dated May 1995 on packet.cc, copy archived March 24, 2016 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the opening and the passages on Davies read. The source reads: "One year later, in 1965, a second important meeting took place at MIT. Donald Davies from the National Physical Laboratory in the U.K. was at MIT to give a seminar on time sharing. Licklider, Davies, and I discussed networking and the inadequacy of data communication facilities for both time sharing and networking." The paper of 1978 of the same author (footnote 39) has the seminar of autumn 1965 as one that Davies sponsored. The citation of footnote 40 at sentence 75 is graded Supported.

1.24 Sentence 76 says that later in 1965, at the NPL, Donald Davies designed and proposed a national commercial data network based on packet switching. Footnote 41 cites Chris Edmondson-Yurkanan, "SIGCOMM's archaeological journey into networking's past", Communications of the ACM 50 (5), May 2007, pages 63 to 68, file of the article at the ACM Digital Library (5 pages, copy archived November 11, 2024; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the passage on the drafts of Davies read. The source reads: "he included four drafts written between 1965–1966 describing usage, costs, and design details of his packet-switched network. In his first draft dated Nov. 10, 1965 [5], Davies forecast today’s “killer app” for his new communication service" and "“unauthorised access [to business data] via a national network”". Reference 5 of the article reads "Davies, D.W. Remote On-line Data Processing and its Communication Needs. National Physical Laboratory (Nov. 10, 1965)". The source reads: "Unfortunately, Davies’ design received minimal funding." The citation of footnote 41 at sentence 76 is graded Supported.

1.25 Sentence 77 says that in the following year Donald Davies described the use of "switching nodes" to act as routers in a digital communication network. Footnote 42 cites D. W. Davies, "Proposal for a Digital Communication Network", National Physical Laboratory, June 1966, file at the cited address (copy archived October 16, 2026; the same file, byte for byte, as the one retrieved for an earlier audit of this series), text extracted and searched; introduction and the overall description of the proposed implementation read. The source reads: "there is a central system consisting of nodes marked N connected by links. This system is responsible for carrying the messages through the network and directing them along the right path." The proposal speaks of nodes and of node computers. The words switching nodes, which the sentence prints in quotation marks, do not occur in it (searched), nor does the word router. The words that the footnote quotes are in the proposal: "Computer developments in the distant future might result in one type of network being able to carry speech and digital messages efficiently." The citation of footnote 42 at sentence 77 is graded Partial. Footnote 43 cites the same page as footnote 40, same copy. The source reads: “Then in June 1966, Davies wrote a second internal paper, "Proposal for a Digital Communication Network" In which he coined the word packet,- a small sub part of the message the user wants to send, and also introduced the concept of an "Interface computer" to sit between the user equipment and the packet network.” The source carries the paper of 1966. The source says nothing of switching nodes that act as routers. The citation of footnote 43 at sentence 77 is graded Partial.

1.26 Sentence 78 says that the proposal was not taken up nationally, but that Donald Davies produced a design for a local network to serve the needs of the NPL and to prove the feasibility of packet switching using high-speed data transmission. Footnote 44 cites page 29 of K. G. Coffman and A. M. Odlyzko, "Growth of the Internet", in Optical Fiber Telecommunications IV-B, edited by Ivan Kaminow and Tingye Li (2002), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, at the page to which the link of the footnote points (the footnote names no page), by optical character recognition. The source reads: "the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in England deployed an experimental network called the NPL Network that made use of packet switching. It utilized 768 Kb/s lines." The source carries the network and its line speed. The source says nothing of a proposal that was not taken up nationally or of the purposes of the local network. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: of the four-node ARPANET of 1969, "a case can be made that this was when the Internet was born". The citation of footnote 44 at sentence 78 is graded Partial. Footnote 45 cites page 260 of Technological Innovation and Economic Performance, edited by Benn Steil, David G. Victor and Richard R. Nelson (Princeton University Press, 2002), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, at the page to which the link of the footnote points (the footnote names no page), by optical character recognition; the page ends a chapter and begins "Appendix A: An Internet Timeline (adapted from Hobbes’ Internet Timeline by Robert H. Zakon)". The source reads: "Donald Davies, NPL: Proposal for the Development of a National Communications Service for On-line Data Processing, first NPL network plan." and "National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in Middlesex, England develops NPL Data Network using 768 kbps lines." The source carries the proposal and the network with its line speed. The source says nothing of the proposal not being taken up or of the purposes of the local network. The citation of footnote 45 at sentence 78 is graded Partial.

1.27 Sentence 79 says that, to deal with permutations of packets and with losses of datagrams, Donald Davies assumed that "all users of the network will provide themselves with some kind of error control", where the marker stands, and, after the marker, that he thus invented what came to be known as the end-to-end principle. Footnote 46 cites D. W. Davies, K. A. Bartlett, R. A. Scantlebury and P. T. Wilkinson, "A Digital Communication Network for Computers Giving Rapid Response at Remote Terminals" (1967), file at the cited address (copy archived November 14, 2020, nearest to the retrieval date September 15, 2020; the same file, byte for byte, as the one retrieved for an earlier audit of this series), text extracted and searched; the passage that carries the quoted words read. The source reads: "A computer failure in a node would probably destroy the few packets that are stored there." and "It is thought that all users of the network will provide themselves with some kind of error control and that without difficulty this could be made to show up a missing packet. Because of this, loss of packets, if it is sufficiently rare, can be tolerated." The quoted words are in the paper. The paper says them of the packets lost when the computer of a node fails, not of packets that arrive out of order or of losses between a fast source and a slow destination. The paper has four authors. The citation of footnote 46 at sentence 79 is graded Partial.

1.28 Sentence 80 says that in 1967 Donald Davies and his team were the first to use the term protocol in a modern data-commutation context. Footnote 47 cites John Naughton, A Brief History of the Future (Orion, 2015): Google Books shows no pages of the volume that the footnote links, and its in-book search returned nothing, and the source was not read. The article that footnote 56 cites says that a memorandum of Scantlebury and Bartlett of April 1967 "contains what appears to be the first occurrence in print of the term protocol in a data communications context". The citation of footnote 47 at sentence 80 is graded Uncheckable.

1.29 Sentence 81 says that in 1968, where the first marker stands, Donald Davies began building the Mark I packet-switched network to meet the needs of his multidisciplinary laboratory and to prove the technology under operational conditions. Footnote 48 cites R. A. Scantlebury and P. T. Wilkinson, "The National Physical Laboratory Data Communication Network", transcription on rogerdmoore.ca, copy archived October 20, 2013 (named), retrieved in full and searched; introduction read. The source reads: "Its construction, started in 1968, formed part of the research program of the Division of Computer Science". The citation of footnote 48 at sentence 81 is graded Supported. Footnote 49 cites the entry "Packet Switching", signed Roger Scantlebury, pages 573 and 574 of the Encyclopedia of 20th-Century Technology, edited by Colin Hempstead and William Worthington (Routledge, 2005), in the full text of the copy at archive.org that the footnote links (text of the whole volume retrieved and searched; the entry read in full). The source reads: "During 1968 and 1969, development work proceeded in both U.S. and the U.K." and "At the same time, a campus network was built by the NPL team to meet the laboratory's local data processing needs." The source carries the building of the network for the needs of the laboratory. The source does not name it Mark I and does not give the purpose of proving the technology under operational conditions. The citation of footnote 49 at sentence 81 is graded Partial. Footnote 50 cites Mark Ward, "Celebrating 40 years of the net", BBC News, October 29, 2009, copy archived November 1, 2009 (nearest to the date of the article; the footnote names no archive), read in full. Roger Scantlebury says: “"When we first started we were just going to build something to show it would work, but fairly quickly Donald realised that in order for it to have any impact it needed to be a proper working system, and we actually built the network which went live at the start of 1970,"”. The source carries the building of the network to show that it would work. The source does not name it Mark I, gives no 1968 and says nothing of the needs of the laboratory. It dates the start of service to the start of 1970, where sentence 83 says early 1969. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the article says that the Arpanet became the Internet in the 1970s and calls the change "largely cosmetic". The citation of footnote 50 at sentence 81 is graded Partial.

1.30 Sentence 82 says that the development of the network was described at a conference of 1968. Footnote 51 cites the same file as footnote 37, in the copy archived August 9, 2024 of the address of this footnote (the two addresses return the same file, byte for byte), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched. The source reads: "Its development was described at a 1968 conference, two years before similar progress on ARPANET, the precursor to the Internet, was demonstrated". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "the precursor to the Internet". The same passage says "This prototype network was built between 1966 and 1969, providing internal services using 768 K bps channels and was operational by 1970". The citation of footnote 51 at sentence 82 is graded Supported. Footnote 52 cites "The accelerator of the modern age", BBC News, August 5, 2008, copy archived July 1, 2009 (nearest to the retrieval date May 19, 2009; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: “On 5 August 1968 Dr Davies gave the first public presentation of work he had been doing on a method of moving data around computer networks called "packet switching".” The source carries a public presentation of 1968 on packet switching. The source does not call the occasion a conference and does not say that the development of the network was described there. The citation of footnote 52 at sentence 82 is graded Partial.

1.31 Sentence 83 makes three statements, each followed by markers: that elements of the network became operational in early 1969, that this was the first implementation of packet switching, and that the NPL network was the first to use high-speed links. Footnote 49 cites the same source as at sentence 81, read in the same copy. The source reads: "Elements of the pilot NPL network first operated in 1969". The source carries the year. The entry does not say early in 1969. The citation of footnote 49 at sentence 83 is graded Partial. Footnote 53 cites David Rayner, Derek Barber, Roger Scantlebury and Peter Wilkinson, "NPL, Packet Switching and the Internet", page of the symposium of the Institution of Analysts and Programmers of 2001, copy archived August 7, 2003 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the passage on the first network read. The source reads: "The system first went 'live' early in 1969, and exhibited a sustained capacity of around 200 packets per second." The citation of footnote 53 at sentence 83 is graded Supported. Footnote 54 cites John S. Quarterman and Josiah C. Hoskins, "Notable Computer Networks", Communications of the ACM 29 (10), October 1986, pages 932 to 971: the scan of the article at the ACM Digital Library, to which the identifier of the footnote leads, retrieved for an earlier audit of this series (40 page images without text), read by optical character recognition and searched; the section History read. The source reads: "The first packet-switching network was implemented at the National Physical Laboratories in the United Kingdom. It was quickly followed by the ARPANET in 1969". The citation of footnote 54 at sentence 83 is graded Supported. Footnote 55 cites the page of the podcast Computer Freaks of Inc. magazine at the cited address, copy archived June 10, 2023 (nearest to the date of the footnote, June 22, 2023; the footnote names no archive): the text of the page read in full; the recording of the episode, to which the footnote points at 35 minutes 55 seconds, was not played, and no copy of the page of the episode was found in the Wayback Machine. The text of the page announces the podcast and lists the people interviewed. It says nothing of a first implementation of packet switching. Of Donald Davies it says “Welsh physicist who came up with the word "packet" in "packet switching."” Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page calls the Arpanet one of the earliest versions of the Internet. The citation of footnote 55 at sentence 83 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 56 cites Martin Campbell-Kelly, "Data Communications at the National Physical Laboratory (1965-1975)", Annals of the History of Computing 9 (3/4), pages 221 to 247: the full text of the scan at archive.org that the footnote links, retrieved in full (51,573 characters of text made from the scan by optical character recognition) and searched; abstract and the passages on the Mark I and Mark II networks read. The article has "the arrangements to secure reliable transmission of packets of data over the high-speed lines" and studies with lines of 1.5 megabits per second. It does not say that the network was the first to use high-speed links (searched: first, high-speed, megabit). Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the abstract says "the NPL Data Communications Network, which first became operational in 1970", where the sentence says early 1969. The citation of footnote 56 at sentence 83 is graded Partial.

1.32 Sentence 84 says that many other packet switching networks built in the 1970s were similar "in nearly all respects" to the original design of Donald Davies of 1965. Footnote 39 cites the same file as at sentence 75. The source reads: "In nearly all respects, Davies’ original proposal, developed in late 1965, was similar to the actual networks being built today." (line breaks rejoined; the paper is of November 1978). The citation of footnote 39 at sentence 84 is graded Supported.

1.33 Sentence 85 says that the Mark II version of the network, which operated from 1973, used a layered protocol architecture. Footnote 56 cites the same source as at sentence 83, read in the same copy. The article says that "it was only in the Mark II network" that a network architecture which it calls explicitly layered emerged. For the year the article has "The group of three, Scantlebury, Bartlett, and Wilkinson, were to be the project principals until it was completed in 1973." It does not say in so many words from when the Mark II network operated. The citation of footnote 56 at sentence 85 is graded Supported.

1.34 Sentence 86 says that in 1977 there were roughly 30 computers, 30 peripherals and 100 visual display unit (VDU) terminals, all able to interact through the NPL network. Footnote 57 cites page 275 of Alan Turing's Electronic Brain, edited by B. Jack Copeland (Oxford University Press, 2012), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books and checked by eye; the link of the footnote points to page 349 of the volume, the first page of another chapter, which was read too and says nothing of the network. The source reads: "When I retired in 1977 there were roughly 30 computers, 30 exotic peripherals, and 100 VDU terminals all able to interact through the NPL network." The speaker is the author of the chapter "Applications of the Pilot ACE and the DEUCE", whose name is not on the page. The citation of footnote 57 at sentence 86 is graded Supported.

1.35 Sentence 87 says that the team of the NPL carried out simulation work on wide-area packet networks, including datagrams and congestion, and research into internetworking and secure communications. Footnote 49 cites the same source as at sentence 81, read in the same copy. The source reads: "Simulation work on packet networks was also undertaken by the NPL group." The source carries the simulation work. The source says nothing of datagrams, of congestion, of research into internetworking or of secure communications. The citation of footnote 49 at sentence 87 is graded Partial. Footnote 58 cites Peter Nicholas Clarke, "Packet and Circuit-Switched Data Networks", doctoral thesis, Imperial College of Science and Technology, 1982, file of 502 pages, in the copy archived August 3, 2022 that footnote 81 names (the latest copy of the address returns a page not found), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; section 2.3.1 read. The source reads: "As well as the packet switched network actually built at NPL for communication between their local computing facilities, some simulation experiments have been performed on larger networks.", "The work was carried out to investigate networks of a size capable of providing data communications facilities to most of the U.K." and "Experiments were then carried out using a method of flow control devised by Davies [70] called 'isarithmic' flow control." The source carries the simulation of wide-area networks and the control of flow. The source says nothing of research into internetworking or of secure communications. The citation of footnote 58 at sentence 87 is graded Partial. Footnote 59 cites James Pelkey, section 6.3 "CYCLADES Network and Louis Pouzin 1971 - 1972", copy archived June 17, 2021 (named), read in full. Louis Pouzin: “"The inspiration for datagrams had two sources. One was Donald Davies' studies. He had done some simulation of datagram networks, although he had not built any, and it looked technically viable.” The source carries the simulation of datagram networks. The source says nothing of congestion, of research into internetworking or of secure communications. The citation of footnote 59 at sentence 87 is graded Partial.

1.36 Sentence 88 says that the network was replaced in 1986. Footnote 56 cites the same source as at sentence 83, read in the same copy. The source reads: "until its replacement by a new network in 1985/86". The citation of footnote 56 at sentence 88 is graded Supported.

1.37 Sentence 90 says that Robert Taylor intended to realize the ideas of J. C. R. Licklider of an interconnected networking system. Footnote 60 cites pages 39 and 40 of Katie Hafner and Matthew Lyon, Where Wizards Stay Up Late (Simon and Schuster, paperback of 1998, the ISBN of the footnote), read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition; the preview does not show page 41, of which the snippets of the in-book search were read. Page 40 reads "Taylor became the third director of IPTO", inheriting, the page says, the responsibility for the community and much of the vision that Licklider had established. The snippet of page 41 reads "Taylor found himself rolling around an idea Lick had discussed with him several times but never actually acted on. Now that it was his watch, Taylor decided to act." The citation of footnote 60 at sentence 90 is graded Supported.

1.38 Sentence 91 says that, as part of the role of the IPTO, three network terminals had been installed: one for System Development Corporation in Santa Monica, one for Project Genie at the University of California, Berkeley, and one for the Compatible Time-Sharing System project at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Footnote 61 cites John Markoff, "An Internet Pioneer Ponders the Next Revolution", The New York Times, December 20, 1999: the footnote links the site of The New York Times and an archived copy of it, and neither is open to the tools of this page, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 61 at sentence 91 is graded Uncheckable.

1.39 Sentence 93 is a quotation that the article sets under sentence 92 as the words of Robert Taylor: that he had three different sets of user commands for the three terminals, and that there ought to be one terminal that goes anywhere, an idea that the quotation calls the ARPAnet. Footnote 61 cites the same article of The New York Times, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 61 at sentence 93 is graded Uncheckable.

1.40 Sentence 95 says that Larry Roberts and Thomas Merrill had been researching computer time-sharing over wide area networks (WANs). Footnote 62 cites Thomas Marill and Lawrence G. Roberts, "Toward a Cooperative Network of Time-Shared Computers", transcription on packet.cc, copy archived April 1, 2002 (named), read in full. The source reads: "work is proceeding on an experimental network between the TX-2 computer at Lincoln Laboratory and the Q-32 computer at System Development Corporation". The paper places the two computers in Lexington, Massachusetts and in Santa Monica, California. The paper prints the name of its first author as Thomas Marill, where the sentence has Merrill and the footnote Marrill, and the page dates the paper November 1966, where the footnote has October 1966. The paper does not use the words wide area network. The citation of footnote 62 at sentence 95 is graded Supported.

1.41 Sentence 97 says that at the first Symposium on Operating Systems Principles of the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM), in October 1967, Larry Roberts presented a proposal for the "ARPA net", based on the idea of Wesley Clark to use Interface Message Processors (IMPs) to create a message switching network. Footnote 63 cites Gil Press, "A Very Short History Of The Internet And The Web", Forbes, January 2, 2015: the copy that the footnote names, archived January 9, 2015, shows the first of the twelve pages into which the site then divided the article, with the entries of 1728 to July 1945; the copy archived December 20, 2019, which holds the whole article on one page, was retrieved in full and searched, and its entries of 1967 were read. The three markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The entry of October 1967 reads "At the first ACM Symposium on Operating Systems Principles, Larry Roberts presents" a paper "in which he describes the architecture of the “ARPA net”", and the entry of early 1967 has Wesley Clark suggest to Roberts "that the network be managed by identical small computers, each attached to a host computer", which Roberts named Interface Message Processors. The source carries the symposium, the month, the proposal and the idea of Wesley Clark. The words message switching are not in the article: they stand in the paper of footnote 65, and the three footnotes together carry the line. The citation of footnote 63 at sentence 97 is graded Partial. Footnote 64 cites "SRI Project 5890-1; Networking (Reports on Meetings)", transcription of papers of Douglas Engelbart on the site of Stanford University, copy archived February 2, 2020 (named), read in full: three reports of E. B. Shapiro of Stanford Research Institute, on the meeting of October 9 and 10, 1967, on a meeting with Western Union, and on the meeting of May 18, 1967. Of the meeting of May 18, 1967 at the Pentagon, chaired by L. Roberts, the report says: "W. Clark's message switching proposal (appended to Taylor's letter of April 24, 1967 to Engelbart)were reviewed" and "The notion of a communication processor to couple a CPU to the network was viewed as a reasonable approach." The report of the meeting of October 9 and 10, 1967 lists "interface message processor (IMP) specifications" among the topics. The source carries a message switching proposal of W. Clark and the processor. The source says nothing of the symposium of October 1967 or of a proposal that Roberts presented there. The citation of footnote 64 at sentence 97 is graded Partial. Footnote 65 cites Lawrence G. Roberts, "Multiple Computer Networks and Intercomputer Communication", file of 6 pages at the cited address (copy archived October 10, 2026; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full; the text of its 3 pages of print rebuilt from the positions of the letters of the file and read in full; pages 4 to 6 are figures. The paper has a section headed ARPA Net and a section headed Interface Message Processor: "a small computer, an interface message processor (IMP), would be located with each main computer to handle a communications interface" and "Thus the set of IMP's, plus the telephone lines and data sets would constitute a message switching network". The source carries the proposal and the words that the footnote quotes. The file does not name the symposium or its date, and it does not name Wesley Clark as the source of the idea: it cites W. A. Clark once, for macromodular computer systems. The citation of footnote 65 at sentence 97 is graded Partial.

1.42 Sentence 100 says that Larry Roberts raised the proposed communications speed from 2.4 kilobits per second to 50 kilobits per second and sought input from Paul Baran. Footnote 66 cites pages 37 to 39 and 57 to 59 of Janet Abbate, Inventing the Internet (MIT Press, 2000), read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition; the footnote prints the name of the author as Jane. Page 38 reads "Roberts decided to increase the bandwidth of the links in his proposed network from 9.6 to 56 kilobits per second." Page 39 reads "In 1967, Roberts recruited Baran to advise the ARPANET planning group on distributed communications and packet switching." The source carries the increase and the advice of Baran. The figures of the book, from 9.6 to 56 kilobits per second, are not the figures of the sentence, from 2.4 to 50. The citation of footnote 66 at sentence 100 is graded Partial. Footnote 67 cites A History of the ARPANET: The First Decade, Bolt Beranek and Newman Inc., Report No. 4799, April 1, 1981, file of 183 pages at the address of the Defense Technical Information Center (copy archived December 1, 2012, named), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the cited page, page 53 of the file, printed page III-11, read, and pages III-14 to III-17 read. The cited page is the section "The NPL Data Network", which says that the design of that network "bears a resemblance to the network proposed by Paul Baran at RAND, and to the ARPANET". It says nothing of line speeds or of advice from Baran. Five pages on, at printed page III-16, the report has the two figures of the sentence: "It was decided that 50 Kb communications lines would be used because of the vastly improved response time which could be obtained with these lines as opposed to the previously proposed 2.4 Kb lines." The citation of footnote 67 at sentence 100 is graded Not supported.

1.43 Sentence 102 says that the "IMP guys", led by Frank Heart and Bob Kahn, developed the routing, the flow control, the software design and the network control. Footnote 39 cites the same file as at sentence 75. The source reads: "such as routing, flow control, software design, and network control were developed by a BBN team consisting of Frank Heart, Robert Kahn" (the sentence goes on to name three more men; line breaks rejoined). The source carries the four things developed and a team of five named men of Bolt Beranek and Newman. The words IMP guys, which the sentence prints in quotation marks, are not in the paper, and the paper does not say that Frank Heart and Robert Kahn led the team. The citation of footnote 39 at sentence 102 is graded Partial. Footnote 68 cites page 344 of The Froehlich/Kent Encyclopedia of Telecommunications, volume 1 (1990), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The page belongs to an article headed "ARPANET, the Defense Data Network, and Internet". It treats the NPL Data Network, the Information Processing Techniques Office and the meeting of early 1967 at which the group concluded that a small interface computer should stand between each computer and the telephone line. It names neither Frank Heart nor Robert Kahn and says nothing of routing, flow control, software design or network control as the work of a team. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 99 the page says "the NPL Data Network effort appears to have had little fundamental impact on the design of ARPANET". The citation of footnote 68 at sentence 102 is graded Not supported.

1.44 Sentence 104 introduces a quotation with the statement that Leonard Kleinrock spoke of the actions of the graduate and undergraduate students who worked with the IMPs, and it carries two groups of markers: footnotes 69 and 70 after the words "Kleinrock said", and footnotes 71 and 72 after the quotation, in which the letters L and O are typed and seen at the other end and the system crashes at the letter G. Footnote 69 cites Scott Nover, report of the BBC of October 29, 2024, whose title opens with the words "We were just trying to get it to work", copy archived April 30, 2025 (nearest to the retrieval date April 26, 2025; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The report is an interview with Charley Kline and Bill Duvall: "Kline, a 21-year-old graduate student at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), and Duvall, a 29-year-old systems programmer at Stanford Research Institute (SRI)". Charley Kline says: "I typed the letter G. Bill told me his system had crashed, and he would call me back." The source carries the actions of one graduate student. The report does not name Leonard Kleinrock and quotes nothing that he said. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the title calls the failure the one that started the Internet, a caption says that Charley Kline was the first to send a message over the Internet, and another caption calls the Interface Message Processor the first router of the Internet. The citation of footnote 69 at sentence 104 is graded Partial. Footnote 70 cites Jonathan Strickland, "How ARPANET Works", HowStuffWorks, December 28, 2007: the page "ARPANET Computers" at the cited address, copy archived January 12, 2008 (named), read in full. The source reads: "On the first attempt, the system crashed before UCLA could send a complete command to the Stanford computer." The page says nothing of students and does not name Leonard Kleinrock. It says "Each site had its own team of engineers". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page gives the line as "a 50 kilobyte per second (kbps) phone line" and calls the computer of Stanford Research Institute the Stanford computer. The citation of footnote 70 at sentence 104 is graded Not supported. Footnote 71 cites Leo Beranek, "Roots of the Internet: A Personal History", Massachusetts Historical Review 2 (2000), pages 55 to 75: the footnote links only JSTOR, which answered with a check for automated visitors, where this page stopped; the full text of the article was read in the copy of the History Cooperative, archived May 6, 2006 (49,449 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the opening and the passages on the first message read). The article of Leo Beranek tells the first message in its own words and without the quotation: “Charlie Kline, an undergraduate at UCLA, announced to another student at Stanford by telephone, "I'm going to type an L."” and “When Kline transmitted the "G" Stanford's computer crashed.” The source carries the event. None of the words that the sentence quotes is in the article of Leo Beranek, which does not give them to Leonard Kleinrock. The same article dates the event "ON OCTOBER 3, 1969" and says the two computers then spoke "over the Internet for the first time". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentences 69 and 100, note 15 of the same article reads “Frank Heart has since stated that "we were unable to use any of the work of Kleinrock or Baran in the design of the ARPANET. We had to develop the operating features of the ARPANET ourselves."” The citation of footnote 71 at sentence 104 is graded Partial. Footnote 72 cites Gregory R. Gromov, "Roads and Crossroads of the Internet History", netvalley.com, copy archived January 3, 2021 (the latest copy of the address is a check for automated visitors; the footnote names no archive), 29,130 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the passage on the first message read. The source reads: “"We set up a telephone connection between us and the guys at SRI...," Kleinrock ... said in an interview: "We typed the L and we asked on the phone, "Do you see the L?" "Yes, we see the L," came the response.” The page ends the passage “"Then we typed the G, and the system crashed"... Yet a revolution had begun"...” and gives as its source "Sacramento Bee, May 1, 1996, p.D1". The sentence of the Wikipedia article reproduces the passage of the cited page with its omission marks. The citation of footnote 72 at sentence 104 is graded Supported.

1.45 Sentence 105 says that in 1969 Robert Taylor helped fund ALOHAnet, a system designed by Professor Norman Abramson and others at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa that transmitted data by radio between seven computers on four islands of Hawaii. Footnote 73 cites page 220 of Katie Hafner and Matthew Lyon, Where Wizards Stay Up Late (paperback of 1998), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The source reads: "In 1969, before Bob Taylor had left ARPA, he set up funding for a fixed-site radio network to be built at the University of Hawaii. It was designed by a professor named Norm Abramson and several colleagues. They constructed a simple system using radios to broadcast data back and forth among seven computers stationed over four islands. Abramson called it ALOHA." (line breaks rejoined). The citation of footnote 73 at sentence 105 is graded Supported.

1.46 Sentence 106 says that by December 1969 a three-node network was connected by adding an IBM 360/75 computer of the Culler-Fried Interactive Mathematics Center at the University of California, Santa Barbara, followed by the fourth node, a DEC PDP-10 computer of the Graphics Department of the University of Utah. Footnote 74 cites pages 154 to 156 of Katie Hafner and Matthew Lyon, Where Wizards Stay Up Late (paperback of 1998), read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. Page 154 reads "IMP Number Three was installed at UC Santa Barbara on November 1." Page 155 reads "Fourth was Utah.", and the page adds that it was by then December. The source carries the third and the fourth sites and the month of December. The pages name none of the computers, operating systems, center or department of the sentence. The citation of footnote 74 at sentence 106 is graded Partial. Footnote 75 cites "ARPANET, Internet", Living Internet, copy archived May 20, 2026 (the copy of June 10, 2026, nearest to the retrieval date June 12, 2026, is a refusal page; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "The Culler-Fried Interactive Mathematics centre at the University of California at Santa Barbara was the third site added to the ARPANET, running on an IBM 360/75 computer using the OS/MVT operating system. The fourth ARPANET site was added in December 1969 at the University of Utah Graphics Department, running on a DEC PDP-10 computer using the Tenex operating system." The sentence of the article follows these two sentences of the page. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page calls the ARPANET "the “Eve” network of what has evolved into the Internet we know and love today", says that the ARPANET and with it the Internet was born on August 30, 1969, and says "By the middle of the 80’s there were ARPANET gateways to external networks across North America, Europe, and in Australia, and the Internet was global in scope." The citation of footnote 75 at sentence 106 is graded Supported.

1.47 Sentence 108 says that Steve Crocker, working with Jon Postel and others, where the marker stands, initiated and managed the Request for Comments (RFC) process, which the sentence says is still used today for proposing and distributing contributions. Footnote 76 cites A. McKenzie and S. Crocker, RFC 6529, "Host/Host Protocol for the ARPA Network", April 2012, page of the RFC Editor, copy archived November 15, 2025 (the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the introduction read. The marker stands after the words Working with Jon Postel and others, and the citation is graded against them: “The first official document defining the protocol was issued by Crocker on August 3, 1970 as "Host-Host Protocol Document No. 1" (see citation in RFC 65), which was based on RFC 54 by Crocker, Postel, Newkirk, and Kraley.” The document also has "the Network Working Group, chaired by Steve Crocker, a graduate student at UCLA", which is the statement of sentence 107. It says nothing of who began or managed the series of Requests for Comments. The citation of footnote 76 at sentence 108 is graded Supported.

1.48 Sentence 115 says that Paul Baran had faced the same rejection as Larry Roberts and thus failed to convince the military to construct a packet switching network. Footnote 77 cites Lawrence G. Roberts, "The ARPANET and Computer Networks", in A History of Personal Workstations (ACM Press, 1988), pages 141 to 172: the file of the chapter at the ACM Digital Library, to which the identifier of the footnote leads (32 pages, copy archived January 11, 2025; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the section on the reception of packet switching read. The source reads: "Paul Baran reported the same reaction to his papers when he presented them; this reaction was the major reason his proposals never moved the military." The three sentences before it in the chapter are the statements of sentences 112, 113 and 114 of the article: "communications professionals reacted with considerable anger and hostility". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 100, the chapter has the two line speeds of that sentence, "(50 Kilobit/sec vs. 2.4 Kilobit/sec)". The citation of footnote 77 at sentence 115 is graded Supported. Footnote 78 cites Lawrence G. Roberts, "The ARPANET and Computer Networks", Proceedings of the ACM Conference on the History of Personal Workstations (1986), pages 51 to 58: the file of the paper at the ACM Digital Library, to which the identifier of the footnote leads (8 pages, copy archived March 8, 2024; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched. The source reads: "Paul Baran reported the same reaction to his papers when he presented them; this reaction was the major reason his proposals never moved the military." (the letters of the file are spaced; the words are given here without the spacing). The paper of 1986 has the same passage as the chapter of 1988 that footnote 77 cites. The citation of footnote 78 at sentence 115 is graded Supported.

1.49 Sentence 117 says that connections of the ARPANET were made in 1973 to Norway (NORSAR), where the first marker stands, by a satellite link at the Tanum Earth Station in Sweden, and to the research group of Peter Kirstein at University College London, which provided a gateway to British academic networks, the first international heterogeneous resource sharing network. Footnote 79 cites "NORSAR and the Internet", page of NORSAR: the archive that the footnote names, a copy at Wikiwix of June 7, 2009, returned an empty frame; the page was read in full in the copy of the Wayback Machine of May 19, 2009 of the original address. The marker stands after the words to Norway (NORSAR), and the citation is graded against the connection of 1973 to Norway: "As the first ARPANET connection outside the United States, NORSAR's TIP was installed in June 1973." The page has the station of Tanum for the year 1970: "selected data from the NORSAR seismic array were transmitted to the Seismic Data Analysis Center (SDAC) in Virginia via the Nordic satellite station in Tanum, Sweden". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page says of the ARPANET that it "is the predeseccor to what is now commonly known as the Internet" (spelling of the page). The citation of footnote 79 at sentence 117 is graded Supported. Footnote 80 cites Peter T. Kirstein, "Early experiences with the Arpanet and Internet in the United Kingdom", IEEE Annals of the History of Computing 21 (1), 1999, pages 38 to 44: the footnote links only identifiers, and the page of the publisher did not load in the Wayback Machine; this page read in full the text of the paper that the author posted on the site of University College London, "Early experiences with the ARPANET and Internet in the UK" (copy archived July 20, 2022, 29,259 characters), which may differ in wording from the printed paper. The citation is graded against the words after the marker of footnote 79: "Everything proceeded normally, and the TIP was duly shipped in July 1973." The source reads: "By this time the British Academic network was slowly emerging. Between 1973 and 1985 we kept our facilities in step with the emerging British network. Any user of that network could get physical access to the US ARPANET". The source carries the connection of University College London in 1973 and the access of the users of the British academic network. The text names neither Tanum nor Sweden, and of the line to NORSAR it says "this channel went by Satellite to the UK; in London it was connected onto to a cable to Kjeller". The words first international heterogenous resource sharing network are not in it (searched: heterogen, resource, first). Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: of the gateways of the Atlantic Packet Satellite Network (SATNET) the text says "This was the first Internet installation", and of a test of late 1974 between Stanford and University College London it says “the first test anywhere of the protocol suite now called the "Internet suite", which has made possible the current development of the Internet”. The citation of footnote 80 at sentence 117 is graded Partial.

1.50 Sentence 118 says that throughout the 1970s Leonard Kleinrock developed the mathematical theory to model and measure the performance of packet-switching technology, building on his earlier work on the application of queueing theory to message switching systems. Footnote 81 cites the same file as at sentence 87; section 2.2 read. The source reads: "Many of the theoretical studies of the performance and design of the ARPA Network were developments of earlier work by Kleinrock, and the extensions to this by Meister, Miiller and Rudin. Although these works concerned message switching networks, they were the basis for a lot of the ARPA network investigations and will be discussed first." and "Kleinrock [62] extended the theoretical approaches of [56] to the early ARPA network." The thesis goes on to measurements of 1973 by Kleinrock and Naylor and to a model of 1979 by Kleinrock and Kermani. The years in square brackets in the quotation of the footnote are not in the thesis. The citation of footnote 81 at sentence 118 is graded Supported. Footnote 82 cites J. Postel, the notes of the Internet meeting of January 25 and 26, 1979, Internet Experiment Note (IEN) 76, dated February 7, 1979, file of 19 page images at the address of the RFC Editor (copy archived March 3, 2022, nearest to the retrieval date February 9, 2022; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, read by optical character recognition and searched; the report of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) on page 5 read. The notes say that the work of UCLA is "primarily theoretical research on throughput and delay analysis" and that L. Kleinrock heads it. The source carries theoretical research on performance under Kleinrock in January 1979. The source says nothing of the 1970s as a whole, of packet switching by name, of queueing theory or of earlier work on message switching. The citation of footnote 82 at sentence 118 is graded Partial. Footnote 83 cites Donald Watts Davies and others, Computer Networks and Their Protocols (Wiley, 1979): the copy at archive.org that the footnote links is open to borrowers only and its text is not public; Google Books shows no pages of the book; the snippets that its in-book search returned for pages 83, 87 and 88 were read. The snippets of page 87 read "In mathematical modelling use is made of the theories of queueing processes and of flows in networks" and "heartening in Kleinrock's work to see the good correspondence achieved between the results of analytic methods and those of simulation". The snippets carry the use of queueing theory and the analytic work of Kleinrock in connection with the network of the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA). They say nothing of the 1970s as a period or of earlier work on message switching. The citation of footnote 83 at sentence 118 is graded Partial.

1.51 Sentence 119 says that by 1981 the number of hosts of the ARPANET had grown to 213. Footnote 84 cites August E. Grant and Jennifer H. Meadows (editors), Communication Technology Update and Fundamentals, 11th edition (Focal Press, 2008): the link of the footnote opens an unnumbered page of the electronic edition in Google Books, which the preview does not show; the in-book search for the words 213 hosts returned nothing; the snippet of printed page 289 and the images of printed pages 30, 268 and 271 were read; printed pages 269 and 270 are not shown. The snippet of printed page 289 speaks of new technologies and their costs and says nothing of hosts. The index of the book lists the ARPANET at pages 30 and 269, and page 269 is not shown. No page that could be read carries a count of hosts for 1981. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: page 30 reads "The Internet began in the 1960s with ARPANET". The same source also carries the following: page 271 reads "By the early 1990s, the physical and virtual structure of the Internet was in place." The citation of footnote 84 at sentence 119 is graded Uncheckable.

1.52 Sentence 121 says that CYCLADES was a French research network designed and directed by Louis Pouzin. Footnote 85 cites Andrew L. Russell and Valérie Schafer, "In the Shadow of ARPANET and Internet: Louis Pouzin and the Cyclades Network in the 1970s", Technology and Culture 55 (4), 2014, pages 880 to 907: JSTOR answered with a check for automated visitors, where this page stopped; the page of the article at Project MUSE is a refusal page in the Wayback Machine; no other copy was found in the Wayback Machine, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 85 at sentence 121 is graded Uncheckable.

1.53 Sentence 122 says that in 1972 Louis Pouzin began implementing his ideas to build on the work of Donald Davies and to explore alternatives to the early design of the ARPANET. Footnote 86 cites the same page as footnote 59, same copy. The source reads: "After the meeting, Pouzin returned to his task of designing a simpler packet switching network than Arpanet. In the process, he spent time studying the NPL network". The meeting is that of June 1972. The source reads: "The inspiration for datagrams had two sources. One was Donald Davies' studies." The page speaks of designing in 1972 and says "Pouzin hoped to have CYCLADES working by the end of 1973." The citation of footnote 86 at sentence 122 is graded Supported. Footnote 87 cites "A Technical History of CYCLADES", THINK Protocols team, Computer Science Department, University of Texas at Austin, copy archived September 1, 2013 (named), read in full. The source reads: "The end result was the development in 1972 of the Cyclades network." The source carries the year and a network set against the ARPANET. The page names neither Louis Pouzin nor Donald Davies. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page asks "why is the ARPANET generally recognized as the parent of the modern Internet" and says "The ARPANET would borrow from this technology when it developed the TCP-IP in 1974." The citation of footnote 87 at sentence 122 is graded Partial.

1.54 Sentence 123 says that the goal of Louis Pouzin was to enable internetworking, which he called a "catenet". Footnote 88 cites L. Pouzin, "A Proposal for Interconnecting Packet Switching Networks", Proceedings of EUROCOMP, Brunel University, May 1974, pages 1023 to 1036: the footnote gives no address and no identifier, and a web search found no copy of the paper, and the source was not read. RFC 675, which footnote 92 cites, lists the paper as “L. Pouzin, "A proposal for interconnecting packet switching networks, INWG Note #60, March 1974 [also submitted to EUROCOMP 74].” The citation of footnote 88 at sentence 123 is graded Uncheckable.

1.55 Sentence 124 says that CYCLADES was the first network to implement the end-to-end principle by making the hosts, rather than the network itself, responsible for the reliable delivery of data, using unreliable datagrams. Footnote 89 cites page 31 of Lelia Green, The Internet: An Introduction to New Media (Berg, 2010): the footnote links only the record of the book at WorldCat; the page was read from its image in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The source reads: "host computers were responsible for checking the data transmitted had been safely received" and "Cyclades’s end-to-end protocol greatly simplified the packet switching operations of the network". The source carries the responsibility of the hosts and the end-to-end protocol. The page does not say that the network was the first to do so and does not use the word datagram. The page begins in the middle of a sentence, and page 30 was not read. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "Intrigued by Pouzin’s success with Cyclades they looked carefully at the French system." The citation of footnote 89 at sentence 124 is graded Partial. Footnote 90 cites Richard Bennett, "Designed for Change: End-to-End Arguments, Internet Innovation, and the Net Neutrality Debate", Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, September 2009, file of 54 pages at the cited address (copy archived September 12, 2017, nearest to the retrieval date September 11, 2017; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; pages 7 to 11 read. Page 9 reads "The first end-to-end research network was CYCLADES, designed by Louis Pouzin at IRIA in France with the support of BBN’s Dave Walden and Alex McKenzie and deployed beginning in 1972." and "CYCLADES employed a connectionless, unreliable datagram service at the network layer, adding reliability in the path between one end system and the other through a virtual circuit transport protocol implemented in host computers, as TCP would." Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: page 31 of the report says, of the network and not of the protocol, "the most important reason TCP/IP won the protocol wars had less to do with design than with material reality: unlike CYCLADES, XNS, DECNet, and OSI, TCP/IP had a far-reaching network infrastructure". The same source also carries the following: the same page says "In 1991, they formed the Commercial Internet Exchange (CIX) and connected with each other without settlement fees or payments to ANS." The citation of footnote 90 at sentence 124 is graded Supported.

1.56 Sentence 125 says that concepts implemented in CYCLADES influenced the initial proposal of the optional protocol Transmission Control Program, where the first two markers stand, and were reflected in the later TCP/IP architecture. Footnote 91 cites Vinton G. Cerf and Robert E. Kahn, "A Protocol for Packet Network Intercommunication", IEEE Transactions on Communications 22 (5), May 1974: the footnote links only identifiers; the paper was read in the copy on the site of Princeton University, 13 page images marked as reprinted from the journal, read in full by optical character recognition for an earlier audit of this series and searched again. The marker stands with that of footnote 92 after the words on the initial proposal, and the citation is graded against them: "A window strategy, similar to that used by the French CYCLADES system (voie virtuelle transmission mode [8]) and the ARPANET very distant HOST connection [18]), is proposed here". The acknowledgment thanks "D. Davies and L. Pouzin who constructively commented on the fragmentation and accounting issues". The references list two papers on the CYCLADES network. The citation of footnote 91 at sentence 125 is graded Supported. Footnote 92 cites Vinton Cerf, Yogen Dalal and Carl Sunshine, RFC 675, "Specification of Internet Transmission Control Program", December 1974, page of the RFC Editor with the text of the document, copy archived November 12, 2026 (the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the introduction and the references read. The source reads: "In the early phases of the design work, R. Metcalfe, A. McKenzie, H. Zimmerman, G. LeLann, and M. Elie were most helpful in explicating the various issues to be resolved." The source carries the help of five named men in the early design work. The document does not say there to which network any of them belonged and does not say that concepts of the CYCLADES network shaped the design. Its references list two papers of L. Pouzin on that network, and its table of addresses gives the network an address. The citation of footnote 92 at sentence 125 is graded Partial. Footnote 93 cites The Economist, article of November 30, 2013 on the man whom its title calls the fifth man of the Internet: the site of The Economist is closed to the tools of this page, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 93 at sentence 125 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 94 cites page 125 of Janet Abbate, Inventing the Internet (MIT Press, 2000), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The marker stands with that of footnote 93 after the words on the later architecture, and the citation is graded against them: "the Cyclades group “had a lot to do with the early discussions of what the [host protocol] would look like.”" A member of the Cyclades team, the page says, worked in the laboratory of Vinton Cerf at Stanford and there took part directly in the design of the internetworking system of ARPA. The source carries the part of the Cyclades group in the early discussions and in the design. The page does not say that concepts of the network are reflected in the later architecture of TCP/IP. The citation of footnote 94 at sentence 125 is graded Partial.

1.57 Sentence 126 says that, based on international research initiatives, particularly the contributions of Rémi Després, packet switching network standards were developed by the CCITT, "which is now the International Telegraph and Telephone Consultative Committee (ITU-T)", in the form of the optional protocol X.25 and related standards. Footnote 95 cites Tony Rybczynski, "Commercialization of packet switching (1975-1985): A Canadian perspective", IEEE Communications Magazine 47 (12), 2009, pages 26 to 31: the article stands behind the sign-in of IEEE Xplore; the summary on the page of the publisher was read, in the copy archived April 22, 2025 (the footnote names no archive). The summary, written by the editor of the column, says "This effort required the rapid development of an international standard, X.25." It carries the development of the standard. It names neither Rémi Després nor the CCITT. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "helping lay the groundwork for the Internet". The citation of footnote 95 at sentence 126 is graded Partial. Footnote 96 cites the article that the footnote lists under the name of Mischa Schwartz, "X.25 Virtual Circuits - TRANSPAC IN France - Pre-Internet Data Networking", IEEE Communications Magazine 48 (11), 2010, pages 40 to 46: the article stands behind the sign-in of IEEE Xplore; the summary on the page of the publisher was read, in the copy archived December 26, 2025 (the footnote names no archive). The summary says "The following article, by Remi Despres, is the second on the history of X.25 systems to appear in this column" and that "it focuses on the major contributions of French engineers to the development of packet switching as well as to X.25 standardization". It carries contributions of French engineers to the standard, in an article written by Rémi Després himself. It does not name the CCITT. The summary is the introduction of the editor of the column, under whose name the footnote lists the article. The citation of footnote 96 at sentence 126 is graded Partial.

1.58 Sentence 128 says that the initial standard of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) on X.25 was approved in March 1976. Footnote 97 cites the page of the International Telecommunication Union at the cited address, headed "Short History of Study Group 17", copy archived July 17, 2009 (nearest to the retrieval date June 5, 2009; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "with the first edition of the famous X.25 Recommendation approved in 1976". The source carries the year. The page does not give the month of March: its table of plenary assemblies dates the assembly of the Orange Book, the Sixth Plenary Assembly of the CCITT, "27 September – 8 October 1976". The citation of footnote 97 at sentence 128 is graded Partial.

1.59 Sentence 129 says that existing networks, such as Telenet in the United States, adopted X.25, as did new public data networks, such as DATAPAC in Canada and TRANSPAC in France. Footnote 95 cites the same source as at sentence 126, read in the same copy. The summary says "The Canadian Datapac network, in particular, was the first network to fully implement the X.25 suite." The source carries DATAPAC and the spread of the standard to "multiple data networks in many countries". It names neither Telenet nor TRANSPAC. The citation of footnote 95 at sentence 129 is graded Partial. Footnote 96 cites the same source as at sentence 126, read in the same copy. The title names TRANSPAC in France under the heading of X.25, and the summary says "early commercial packet switching networks in the United States, such as Tymnet and Telenet, also adopted the virtual circuit paradigm". The source carries TRANSPAC, and of Telenet the adoption of virtual circuits. It does not say that Telenet adopted X.25, and it does not name DATAPAC except as the subject of the earlier article. The citation of footnote 96 at sentence 129 is graded Partial.

1.60 Sentence 133 says that by the 1990s the international packet-switched network of sentences 131 and 132 provided a worldwide networking infrastructure. Footnote 98 cites "Events in British Telecomms History", sigtel.com, copy archived April 5, 2003 (named), 45,666 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the entries on packet switching read. The page carries the statements of the two sentences before this one, which stand without a citation, and not this sentence: under 1977, "The first international switched data network service was offered. Western Union International and Tymenet collaborated with the British Post Office in a trial service. In 1978 the service went live. Links to Canada, Spain, Hong Kong and Australia were added by 1981." It says nothing of the 1990s or of a worldwide infrastructure (searched: worldwide, infrastructure, 1990). The citation of footnote 98 at sentence 133 is graded Not supported.

1.61 Sentence 134 says that X.25 was supplemented by the optional protocol X.75, which enabled internetworking between the national networks of the postal, telegraph and telephone administrations (PTT) of Europe and commercial networks in North America. Footnote 99 cites pages 2 and 9 of Howard Davies and Beatrice Bressan (editors), A History of International Research Networking (Wiley, 2010), read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. Page 2 reads "all the European PTTs rapidly established plans for national packet switched services and for interworking between them" and "The transit arrangements between the national PTTs then gradually became operational, offering communication on a European scale." The source carries the interworking of the national networks of Europe on the basis of X.25. Neither page names X.75, and neither speaks of commercial networks in North America. The citation of footnote 99 at sentence 134 is graded Partial. Footnote 100 cites Nadeem Ikram, "Internet Protocols and a Partial Implementation of CCITT X.75", thesis, University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa, 1985: the page of ProQuest at the cited address, copy archived December 1, 2024 (the copy of March 9, 2026 is a refusal page; the footnote names no archive), shows the title, the author, the university and the year and no text of the thesis; the records at WorldCat were not opened. The title names the Recommendation X.75 of the CCITT. Nothing else of the sentence stands on the page, and the words that the footnote quotes from page 2 of the thesis could not be read. The citation of footnote 100 at sentence 134 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 101 cites Mehmet S. Unsoy and Theresa A. Shanahan, "X.75 Internetworking of Datapac and Telenet", ACM SIGCOMM Computer Communication Review 11 (4), 1981, pages 232 to 239: the file of the paper at the ACM Digital Library, to which the identifier of the footnote leads (8 pages, copy archived April 15, 2024; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted by column and searched; abstract, introduction and section 2 read. The source reads: "To accomplish the interconnection of Public Data Networks, X.75 was defined in 1978 based upon Recommendation X.25." (the letters of the file are spaced; the words are given here without the spacing). The paper is about the interface between Telenet in the United States and Datapac in Canada. The source carries X.75 as the standard for the interconnection of public packet switching data networks. It says nothing of the networks of the postal and telephone administrations of Europe (searched: Europe, PTT). The citation of footnote 101 at sentence 134 is graded Partial.

1.62 Sentence 139 says that other major dial-in networks were America Online (AOL) and Prodigy, which also provided communications, content and entertainment features. Footnote 102 cites page 148 of The Unpredictable Certainty: White Papers (National Academies Press, 1998), in the paper "Service Provider Interoperability and the National Information Infrastructure", read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books, at the page to which the link of the footnote points (the footnote names no page), by optical character recognition. The source reads: "These X.25 networks have recently found new life as the access vehicle of choice for consumer information services, such as America Online, owing to their deployed dial-up facilities." The source carries America Online as a consumer information service reached by dial-up. The page does not name Prodigy and says nothing of communications, content and entertainment features. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 133 the source says "The emergence of public data networks based on the X.25 protocol suite through the 1980s created a global infrastructure for data transport." The same source also carries the following: on the matter of sentence 134 the source says "competing service providers have been reluctant to deploy X.75 connections". The same source also carries the following: of the plant the source says "the Internet has long been based on the connection of devices that implement the Internet protocols (i.e., IP routers) with private lines". The citation of footnote 102 at sentence 139 is graded Partial.

1.63 Sentence 147 says that by 1981 the number of UUCP hosts had grown to 550, and that it nearly doubled to 940 in 1984. Footnote 103 cites Ian Lance Taylor, "UUCP Internals Frequently Asked Questions", faqs.org, copy archived May 19, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), 77,473 characters, retrieved in full and searched. The article describes the UUCP protocols and their internals. It gives no count of UUCP hosts for any year, and none of the figures 550 and 940 and neither of the years 1981 and 1984 occurs in it (searched: 550, 940, 1981, 1984, host). The citation of footnote 103 at sentence 147 is graded Not supported.

1.64 Sentence 151 says that Louis Pouzin initiated the CYCLADES project in 1972, where the first marker stands, building on the work of Donald Davies and the ARPANET. Footnote 104 cites Louis Pouzin, "Presentation and major design aspects of the CYCLADES computer network", Proceedings of the Third Data Communications Symposium (1973), pages 80 to 87: the file of the paper at the ACM Digital Library, to which the identifier of the footnote leads (8 pages, copy archived April 6, 2025; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted by column and searched; summary, introduction, planning and acknowledgments read. The marker stands after the year 1972, and the citation is graded against the start of the project: "The Cyclades project was launched on the beginning of 1972." The paper is by Louis Pouzin and presents the project as his own. It also carries the clause that follows the marker: "Our work stemmed mainly from earlier research accomplished at NPL and within the ARPA community." The citation of footnote 104 at sentence 151 is graded Supported. Footnote 105 cites James Pelkey, section 8.3 "CYCLADES Network and Louis Pouzin 1971 - 1972", copy archived July 15, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), 49,596 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the section read. The citation is graded against the words after the marker of footnote 104: "After the meeting, Pouzin returned to his task of designing a simpler packet switching network than Arpanet. In the process, he spent time studying the NPL network". Louis Pouzin says: "The inspiration for datagrams had two sources. One was Donald Davies’ studies." The text of the section is that of the page that footnotes 59 and 86 cite. The citation of footnote 105 at sentence 151 is graded Supported.

1.65 Sentence 152 says that an International Network Working Group formed in 1972 and that its active members included Vint Cerf of Stanford University, Alex McKenzie of BBN, Donald Davies and Roger Scantlebury of the NPL, and Louis Pouzin and Hubert Zimmermann of the Institut de Recherche d'Informatique et d'Automatique (IRIA). Footnote 106 cites Alexander McKenzie, "INWG and the Conception of the Internet: An Eyewitness Account", IEEE Annals of the History of Computing 33 (1), 2011, pages 66 to 71: the footnote links only identifiers, and the page of the publisher shows the abstract; this page read in full the text of the article that the author posted on his own site, marked as published in the journal and carrying corrections that he added later (copy archived December 2, 2020, 29,137 characters). The source reads: "On 24 October, these designers met to form what they called the International Packet Network Working Group (INWG)". The month is October 1972. The note on those present lists "V. Cerf (Stanford University, US)", "D. Davies (NPL, UK)", "A. McKenzie (BBN, US)" and "L. Pouzin (IRIA, F)". The text has Roger Scantlebury "representing NPL and EIN" and Hubert Zimmermann among the "members of the Cyclades project", which it places at IRIA. The citation of footnote 106 at sentence 152 is graded Supported. Footnote 107 cites Andrew L. Russell, "OSI: The Internet That Wasn't", IEEE Spectrum, July 30, 2013 (the footnote gives the issue of August 2013), copy archived August 24, 2021 (the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "An early attempt began in 1972, with the formation of the International Network Working Group (INWG). Vint Cerf was its first chairman; other active members included Alex McKenzie in the United States, Donald Davies and Roger Scantlebury in England, and Louis Pouzin and Hubert Zimmermann in France." The sentence of the Wikipedia article follows this sentence and puts an institution where the source has a country. The source carries the group, the year and the six men. The cited article names the National Physical Laboratory for Davies and Stanford for Cerf at other places of its text, and it names neither BBN nor IRIA (searched: BBN, Bolt, IRIA). The citation of footnote 107 at sentence 152 is graded Partial. Footnote 108 cites Vinton Cerf, as told to Bernard Aboba, "How the Internet Came to Be", copy of the text on netvalley.com, archived December 21, 2021 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), 30,906 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the passage on the conference of October 1972 read. The source reads: "At the conference we formed the International Network Working Group or INWG." The conference is that of October 1972. Among those who convened there the text names "Donald Davies from the UK, National Physical Laboratory" and Louis Pouzin of IRIA, and it says "Roger Scantlebury from NPL with Donald Davies may also have been in attendance. Alex McKenzie from BBN almost certainly was there." The source carries the group, the year, Cerf, Davies and Pouzin, and two of the men as probably present. It does not name Hubert Zimmermann (searched), and it places Cerf at Stanford from November 1972, the month after the conference. The citation of footnote 108 at sentence 152 is graded Partial.

1.66 Sentence 157 says that the hosts became responsible for reliability, instead of the network, as in the ARPANET. Footnote 2 cites the same source as at sentence 2, read in the same copy. The release says nothing of which party is responsible for reliability, the network or the hosts. The words reliability and host do not occur in it (it has "reliably connecting different kinds of computers to each other", of the ARPANET). The citation of footnote 2 at sentence 157 is graded Not supported. Footnote 109 cites Ronda Hauben, "The Internet: On its International Origins and Collaborative Vision", Amateur Computerist 12 (2), 2004, text file at the cited address, copy archived January 6, 2009 (the copy nearest to the retrieval date May 29, 2009; the footnote names no archive), 123,111 characters, retrieved in full and searched. The article says nothing of reliability passing from the network to the hosts (searched: reliab, responsib, host, end-to-end, datagram). Of the French network it says that its researchers "contributed the important concept of the datagram as a means of transporting data". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the abstract reads "The mythology surrounding the origins of the Internet is that it began in 1969 in the U.S. That is the date marking the origins of the ARPANET (a U.S. packet switching network), but not the birth of the Internet." The citation of footnote 109 at sentence 157 is graded Not supported.

1.67 Sentence 158 says that Vint Cerf and Bob Kahn published their ideas in May 1974, where the first marker stands, and that the ideas incorporated concepts implemented by Louis Pouzin and Hubert Zimmermann in the CYCLADES network. Footnote 91 cites the same copy as at sentence 125. The marker stands after the words in May 1974, and the citation is graded against the publication: the copy is marked "Reprinted, with permission, from IEEE Trans on Comms, Vol Com-22, No 5 May 1974", and the authors are Vinton G. Cerf and Robert E. Kahn. The citation of footnote 91 at sentence 158 is graded Supported. Footnote 89 cites the same page as at sentence 124. The citation is graded against the words after the marker of footnote 91: "Intrigued by Pouzin’s success with Cyclades they looked carefully at the French system." and "The idea was to adopt several principles from Cyclades and invert the ARPANET model to minimise international differences." The source carries the taking of principles from the network of Louis Pouzin into the paper of May 1974. The page does not name Hubert Zimmermann. The citation of footnote 89 at sentence 158 is graded Partial. Footnote 110 cites The Economist, the article that footnote 93 cites, here with the date December 13, 2013: the site of The Economist is closed to the tools of this page, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 110 at sentence 158 is graded Uncheckable.

1.68 Sentence 159 says that the specification of the resulting protocol, the Transmission Control Program, was published as RFC 675 by the Network Working Group in December 1974. Footnote 111 cites Vinton Cerf, Yogen Dalal and Carl Sunshine, RFC 675, December 1974: the cited address forwards to the page of the RFC Editor, which carries the text of the document, copy archived November 6, 2026 (the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the head of the document read. The head of the document reads "Network Working Group", "Request for Comments: 675", "December 1974" and "SPECIFICATION OF INTERNET TRANSMISSION CONTROL PROGRAM". The footnote gives the title with the word Protocol where the document has Program. The citation of footnote 111 at sentence 159 is graded Supported.

1.69 Sentence 164 says that testing began in 1975 through concurrent implementations at Stanford, BBN and University College London (UCL). Footnote 3 cites the same source as at sentence 2, read in the same copy. The source reads: "the first specification of the TCP protocol was published as an Internet Experiment Note in December 1974. We began doing concurrent implementations at Stanford, BBN, and University College London." The account gives no year for the start of the implementations and does not print 1975 there (the next sentence begins "In July 1975, the ARPANET was transferred"). The citation of footnote 3 at sentence 164 is graded Partial.

1.70 Sentence 166 says that on November 22, 1977 a three network demonstration was conducted including the ARPANET, the Packet Radio Van of SRI on the Packet Radio Network and the Atlantic Packet Satellite Network (SATNET), including a node at UCL. Footnote 112 cites "Computer History Museum and Web History Center Celebrate 30th Anniversary of Internet Milestone", press release of the Computer History Museum, November 1, 2007, copy archived November 11, 2007 (the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "The key event occurred on November 22, when data flowed seamlessly from the van to a gateway at SRI in Menlo Park, Calif. and eventually to a host at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles via London, England, across three types of networks: packet radio, satellite, and the ARPANET." The source carries the date, the three networks and the van of SRI. The release has the path run by way of London and does not name University College London. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the release calls the transmission "widely regarded as the first true Internet connection", and it says that, while many people trace the origins of the Internet to the ARPANET of the late 1960s, the word means the joining of different types of individual networks, a kind of internetworking that made its formal debut with the transmission across three networks on November 22, 1977. The citation of footnote 112 at sentence 166 is graded Partial. Footnote 113 cites Erica Ogg, "'Internet van' helped drive evolution of the Web", CNET News, November 8, 2007, copy archived April 8, 2012 (the footnote names no archive), read in full. The article says that the first transmission by the Transmission Control Protocol between three separate networks, the Arpanet, packet radio and satellite, was made possible by the van that SRI International built: "It was driven for the first time on November 22, 1977." The source carries the date, the three networks and the van. The article has the data go to England among other places and does not name University College London. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the article calls the event "the very first true Internet connection". The citation of footnote 113 at sentence 166 is graded Partial.

1.71 Sentence 167 makes two statements, each followed by a group of markers: first, that the software was redesigned as a modular protocol stack using full-duplex channels and that between 1976 and 1977 Yogen Dalal, John Shoch and Robert Metcalfe, among others, proposed separating the routing and transmission control functions of the Transmission Control Program into two discrete layers; second, that this led to the splitting of the Transmission Control Program into the Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and the Internet Protocol (IP) in version 3 in 1978. Footnote 114 cites Georgios Panzaris, "Machines and romances: the technical and narrative construction of networked computing as a general-purpose platform, 1960-1995" (Stanford University, 2008), page 128: Google Books shows no pages of the volume; the snippets that its in-book search returned for page 128 were read. The citation is graded against the words before the marker, up to the two discrete layers. The snippets of page 128 read "researchers at Xerox PARC, including ARPANET pioneers Robert Metcalfe and Yogen Dalal, shared the basic contours" and "Dalal, shared the basic contours of their research with colleagues at TCP and Internet working group meetings in 1976 and 1977, suggesting the possible benefits of separating TCPs routing and transmission control functions into two". The snippets carry the suggestion, the two years, Robert Metcalfe and Yogen Dalal. They do not name John Shoch and say nothing of a redesign as a modular stack with full-duplex channels. The citation of footnote 114 at sentence 167 is graded Partial. Footnote 115 cites James L. Pelkey, "Yogen Dalal", page of the interview summaries of his history, copy archived September 5, 2019 (named), read in full. This first citation is graded against the words before the first group of markers: "In 1977 Dalal went to work at Xerox PARC". The source reads: "Dalal and colleagues John Shoch and David Boggs realized the coming importance of local area networking" and "they did what they could to convince Cerf and his team of the need for both a datagram and a session protocol". The source carries the year 1977, Yogen Dalal and John Shoch and the case for two protocols. The page names David Boggs, not Robert Metcalfe, as the third man, and it says nothing of the year 1976 or of a modular stack with full-duplex channels. The first citation of footnote 115 at sentence 167 is graded Partial. Footnote 116 cites "On the design of TCP/IP", nethistory.info, an exchange of electronic mail among Vint Cerf, Bob Frankston and David Reed, copy archived June 19, 2024 (the copy of December 6, 2025, nearest to the retrieval date December 5, 2025, is a check for automated visitors; the footnote names no archive), read in full. David Reed writes: "John Schoch, Danny Cohen and I each presented arguments to that effect, from different points of view." and "we 3 (sitting next to each other) agreed to push for splitting the TCP packet into two layers, the routing header and the end-to-end stream payload". The source carries the proposal of two layers and John Shoch, whose name the page spells Schoch. The page gives no year for the meeting at Marina del Rey, names Danny Cohen and David Reed where the sentence names Yogen Dalal and Robert Metcalfe, and says nothing of a modular stack with full-duplex channels. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: David Reed writes "we were designing the Internet protocols as *overlays* to interconnect existing networks with heterogeneous designs". The citation of footnote 116 at sentence 167 is graded Partial. Footnote 115 stands at the sentence a second time, with the same source. This second citation is graded against the words after the first group of markers, on the splitting in version 3 in 1978: "This led eventually to the splitting of TCP into TCP and IP protocols." The source carries the splitting as the outcome. The page gives neither the version number nor the year 1978. The second citation of footnote 115 at sentence 167 is graded Partial. Footnote 117 cites "BGP Reports", bgp.potaroo.net, copy archived December 23, 2012 (nearest to the retrieval date January 9, 2013; the footnote names no archive): an index page of 377 characters of text, read in full. The page is a table of links to reports on the routing table of the optional protocol Border Gateway Protocol (BGP), with the numbers of routes seen at two points. It says nothing of the Transmission Control Program, of a version 3 or of the year 1978. The citation of footnote 117 at sentence 167 is graded Not supported.

1.72 Sentence 169 says that TCP/IP was installed on SATNET in 1982 and on the ARPANET in January 1983, after the Department of Defense (DoD) made it standard for all military computer networking. Footnote 118 cites "TCP/IP Internet Protocol", Living Internet, copy archived July 26, 2020 (named), read in full. The source reads: "The full switchover to TCP/IP was performed on January 1, 1983, without too many problems" and "In 1984, the US Department of Defense made TCP/IP the standard for all military computer networking". The source carries the change of the ARPANET in January 1983 and the standard of the Department of Defense, in the words of the sentence. The page dates the standard to 1984, the year after the change and not before it, and it does not say that the protocols were installed on SATNET in 1982: it has SATNET in tests of 1975 and of November 1977. The citation of footnote 118 at sentence 169 is graded Partial. Footnote 119 cites Jon Postel, RFC 801, "NCP/TCP Transition Plan", November 1981: the cited address forwards to the page of the RFC Editor, which carries the text of the document, copy archived October 27, 2026 (the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the introduction and the general plan read. The document is a plan of November 1981 and is older than the events of the sentence: "The goal is to make a complete switch over from the NCP to IP/TCP by 1 January 1983." Of the Department of Defense it says that it has adopted the two protocols "as DoD wide standards for all DoD packet networks". The source carries the standard, before the change, and the date as a goal. It cannot carry the change itself, and it says nothing of an installation on SATNET in 1982. The citation of footnote 119 at sentence 169 is graded Partial.

1.73 Sentence 171 says that the networking model was also referred to as the Department of Defense (DoD) model or the model of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA). Footnote 120 cites Charles M. Kozierok, The TCP/IP Guide, "TCP/IP Architecture and the TCP/IP Model", page 1 of 3 at the cited address, copy archived February 16, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date February 11, 2020; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "This model goes by different names, including the TCP/IP model, the DARPA model (after the agency that was largely responsible for developing TCP/IP) and the DOD model (after the United States Department of Defense, the “D” in “DARPA”)." The citation of footnote 120 at sentence 171 is graded Supported.

1.74 Sentence 172 says that Vint Cerf credits several of his graduate students with important work on the design and testing. Footnote 121 cites "Excerpts from an Oral History Interview with Vinton Cerf", interviewer Judy O'Neill, April 24, 1990, page of the National Museum of American History, copy archived September 23, 2019 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), 67,093 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the passage on the students at Stanford read. In the article the marker stands at the end of the sentence, after a pointer in brackets to a list of pioneers. The source reads: "I had a whole team of graduate students, some of whose names are now fairly familiar in the industry." Of Richard Karp the interview says "He wrote the first TCP in BCPL on the PDP 11/20 at Stanford." Of Yogen Dalal, whose first name the page spells Yogan, the interview says that he "was deeply involved in the design of the TCP". The source carries the credit to graduate students for the design and for the first implementation. The interview does not speak of testing by the students (searched: test). The citation of footnote 121 at sentence 172 is graded Partial.

1.75 Sentence 179 says that the networks based on the ARPANET were government funded and therefore restricted to noncommercial uses such as research, and that unrelated commercial use was strictly forbidden. Footnote 122 cites ARPANET Information Brochure, NIC 50003, December 1985, published for the Defense Communications Agency, file of 59 page images with a text layer at the address of the Defense Technical Information Center (copy archived February 28, 2025; the latest copy of the address is a refusal page; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the section on policies read. The source reads: "The network is not available for use by the general public". The brochure says that users "must not use the network for private gain or for commercial purposes, such as advertising or recruiting". The brochure also says that legitimate users must be engaged in the business or research of the United States government. It states the rule for the ARPANET itself, as of December 1985, and does not speak of other networks based on it. The citation of footnote 122 at sentence 179 is graded Supported.

1.76 Sentence 192 says that the Computer Science Network (CSNET) played a central role in popularizing the Internet outside the ARPANET. Footnote 23 cites "CSNET, Computer Science Network", Living Internet, copy archived February 3, 2026 (a copy of October 2026 is a refusal page; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: "CSNET played a central role in popularizing the Internet outside the ARPANET". The sentence of the article is this sentence of the page, word for word and without quotation marks. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page says that CSNET "helped introduce what was fast becoming the Internet to universities around the world" and calls its history "yet another example of TCP/IP‘s inexorable drive to spread". The citation of footnote 23 at sentence 192 is graded Supported.

1.77 Sentence 194 says that the NSFNET also provided support for the creation of regional research and education networks in the United States and for the connection of university and college campus networks to the regional networks. Footnote 123 cites David Roessner and others, "The Role of NSF's Support of Engineering in Enabling Technological Innovation", part IV, "The Internet", SRI International, 1997, copy archived December 19, 2008 (named), 28,306 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the passages on the regional networks read. The source reads: "the backbone administered by NSF, the regional networks funded either by NSF or by other institutions, and campus networks funded by the universities they served". The source carries the support of some regional networks by the National Science Foundation and the three tiers. The page does not say that the NSFNET supported the connection of campus networks to the regional networks: it has the universities pay for the campus networks. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: of the plant, the page lists "the physical communication links (satellites, microwave links, copper and fiber optic cables)" among the technologies of the Internet and then sets them aside: "these latter technologies are not intrinsic to the Internet (defined as a system of interlinked, packet-switched, distributed networks)". The citation of footnote 123 at sentence 194 is graded Partial.

1.78 Sentence 200 says that when the NSFNET was decommissioned in 1995, its optical networking backbones were handed off to several commercial Internet service providers, including MCI, PSI Net and Sprint. Footnote 124 cites Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), "Internet Traffic Exchange: Developments and Policy", OECD Digital Economy Papers No. 34, a file of 76 pages reached from the page of the publisher to which the identifier of the footnote leads (copy of the page archived November 29, 2025, copy of the file archived December 6, 2025; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the five pages that name the NSFNET and every passage that names MCI, PSINet or Sprint read. The source reads: "In 1995 NSFNET was retired and US backbone traffic was routed via interconnected commercial networks." A later page dates the retirement to May 1995. The source carries the end of the NSFNET in 1995 and the passage of the backbone traffic of the United States to commercial networks. The paper does not say that the backbones of the NSFNET were handed to anyone: it has the traffic routed through commercial networks that were interconnected. The word optical does not occur in its 76 pages, and it names MCI, PSINet and Sprint among the backbone providers of the United States of 1997 and 1998, in its account of peering and in a table, and nowhere as receivers of the backbone. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: of the time of the NSFNET the paper says that "the Internet was still considered a private network because it was restricted to a defined group of users". The citation of footnote 124 at sentence 200 is graded Partial.

1.79 Sentence 201 says that, as a result, when the handoff was complete, Sprint and its Network Access Points in Washington DC began to carry Internet traffic, and that by 1996 Sprint was the largest carrier of Internet traffic in the world. Footnote 125 cites "Sprint Boosts Fiber-Optic Network Capacity 1,600 Percent", press release dated Kansas City, June 11, 1996, on the site of Ciena Corporation, copy archived November 27, 2022 (nearest to the retrieval date December 20, 2022; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The closing description of the company in the release says that Sprint is "the world's largest carrier of Internet traffic". The source carries that description for June 1996, in the words of the company itself. The release is about wavelength division multiplexing equipment on the fiber network of Sprint and says nothing of the NSFNET, of a handoff or of Network Access Points in Washington. The citation of footnote 125 at sentence 201 is graded Partial.

1.80 Sentence 203 says that the term, which the sentence prints without the capital, was reflected in the first RFC published on the TCP protocol, RFC 675, Internet Transmission Control Program, of December 1974, as a short form of internetworking, when the two terms were used interchangeably; the marker stands after the number of the RFC. Footnote 126 cites Vinton Cerf, Yogen Dalal and Carl Sunshine, RFC 675, December 1974, page of the RFC Editor, copy archived March 1, 2020 (the copy that the Wayback Machine returned for the retrieval date May 28, 2009; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the head and the introduction read. The marker stands inside the brackets, after the number of the document, and the citation is graded against the use of the term in it: the title is "SPECIFICATION OF INTERNET TRANSMISSION CONTROL PROGRAM", and the introduction begins "This document describes the functions to be performed by the internetwork Transmission Control Program [TCP]". The document has the short word in its title and the long word in its text. The citation of footnote 126 at sentence 203 is graded Supported.

1.81 Sentence 205 says that in the period when the ARPANET was connected to the newly formed NSFNET project, in the late 1980s, the term was used as the name of the network, Internet, being the large and global TCP/IP network. Footnote 127 cites Andrew S. Tanenbaum, Computer Networks (Prentice Hall, 1996): the footnote names no page; the copy at archive.org that it links is open to borrowers only and its text is not public, and Google Books shows no pages of the edition, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 127 at sentence 205 is graded Uncheckable.

1.82 Sentence 207 says that the expense and delay of laying new fiber led providers to test an alternative for expanding the bandwidth of fiber that had been pioneered in the late 1970s by Optelecom, and it prints in quotation marks a description of the alternative as interactions between light and matter, such as lasers and optical devices used for optical amplification and wave mixing. Footnote 128 cites Bahaa E. A. Saleh and Malvin Carl Teich, Fundamentals of Photonics (Wiley, 2019): the footnote gives no address; pages xxii, xxiii and xxiv of the front matter were read from their images in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition, and the book was searched there. Page xxii, the page that the footnote cites, ends an earlier preface with thanks and photo credits and says nothing of the sentence. The words that the sentence prints in quotation marks are a reworking of a sentence on page xxiii, in the preface to the first edition, which defines a term and is not about any company: "The term quantum electronics is used in connection with devices and systems that rely principally on the interaction of light with matter (lasers and nonlinear optical devices used for optical amplification and wave mixing serve as examples)." The in-book search finds the name Optelecom nowhere in the book, and the pages read say nothing of providers, of the laying of fiber or of the late 1970s. The citation of footnote 128 at sentence 207 is graded Not supported.

1.83 Sentence 209 says that Bell Labs deployed a 4-channel wave division multiplexing (WDM) system in 1995. Footnote 129 cites Peter J. Winzer, David T. Neilson and Andrew R. Chraplyvy, "Fiber-optic transmission and networking: the previous 20 and the next 20 years", Optics Express 26 (18), 2018: the footnote links only identifiers, and the page of the publisher to which they lead is a check for automated visitors; the full text was read at the earlier address of the publisher, in the copy archived May 23, 2021 (523,782 characters with the references, retrieved in full and searched; section 2.2.5 read). The source reads: "The first commercial terrestrial WDM systems (8 wavelengths at 2.5 Gb/s on a 200-GHz grid) were deployed in the AT&T network in 1995". The source carries a first deployment of wavelength division multiplexing in 1995. The paper has eight wavelengths, not four channels, and it names the network of AT&T, not Bell Labs, as the place (searched: 4-channel, four channels, four wavelengths). The citation of footnote 129 at sentence 209 is graded Partial.

1.84 Sentence 210 says that, to develop a dense WDM system of mass capacity, Optelecom and its former head of Light Systems Research, David R. Huber, formed a new venture, Ciena Corp., which deployed the first dense WDM system in the world on the fiber network of Sprint in June 1996. Footnote 129 cites the same source as at sentence 209, read in the same copy. The source reads: "In 1996 Ciena announced its first WDM product, comprising 16 wavelengths carrying 2.5 Gb/s per wavelength". The source carries Ciena and the year 1996. The paper names neither Optelecom nor David R. Huber nor Sprint (searched), gives no month, and does not call the product the first dense system in the world: it gives the first commercial systems to the network of AT&T in 1995. The press release that footnote 125 cites, of June 11, 1996, is the source among those of the Wikipedia article that has Ciena, Sprint and June 1996. The citation of footnote 129 at sentence 210 is graded Partial.

1.85 Sentence 211 says that this was referred to as the real start of optical networking. Footnote 130 cites Milorad Cvijetic and Ivan Djordjevic, Advanced Optical Communication Systems and Networks (Artech House, 2013): the footnote gives no page and no address; pages 11 and 12 were read from their images in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition, and the book was searched there. Page 12 reads "The introduction of WDM signaled a real start to optical networking, since each wavelength within the WDM spectrum could eventually follow its distinct path or the lightpath." The source carries the phrase, said of the introduction of wavelength division multiplexing in general. The book does not say it of the system of Ciena on the network of Sprint in June 1996: the in-book search finds the name Ciena nowhere in it. The citation of footnote 130 at sentence 211 is graded Partial.

1.86 Sentence 216 says that some gateway services went beyond simple mail peering, such as allowing access to sites of the optional protocol File Transfer Protocol (FTP) by UUCP or by mail. Footnote 131 cites two lists of Internet access providers of the Network Service Center of the National Science Foundation (NSF), dated September 25, 1992 and October 16, 1992, in one text file, copy archived January 12, 2002 (named), read in full. The file lists providers by name, place and type of service, among them "EMAIL HOSTS WITH GATEWAYS TO THE INTERNET". It does not say that any gateway gave access to File Transfer Protocol sites by way of UUCP or of mail. Its key to the types of service has "IP - Dialup IP including TELNET, FTP and possibly other services". The citation of footnote 131 at sentence 216 is graded Not supported.

1.87 Sentence 220 says that in 1994 Classless Inter-Domain Routing (CIDR) was introduced to support better conservation of address space, which allowed the use of route aggregation to decrease the size of routing tables. Footnote 132 cites RFC 1871, November 1995, page of the RFC Editor, copy archived August 18, 2019 (the copy that the Wayback Machine returned for the retrieval date May 28, 2009; the footnote names no archive), read in full; RFC 1817, page of the RFC Editor, copy archived January 1, 2026, read in full. The document with the number that the footnote cites is not on routing: it is an addendum to RFC 1602 by J. Postel, headed "Variance Procedure", a memo on the procedures of the Internet Engineering Task Force. The title that the footnote gives, CIDR and Classful Routing, is not its title, and the words CIDR, classless, routing and address do not occur in it in the sense of the sentence. That title belongs to RFC 1817 of August 1995, by Y. Rekhter, whose two pages speak of Classless Inter-Domain Routing (CIDR) as already deployed in the Internet and name neither the year 1994 nor the aggregation of routes. The citation of footnote 132 at sentence 220 is graded Not supported.

1.88 Sentence 221 says that the MOS transistor underpinned the rapid growth of telecommunication bandwidth over the second half of the 20th century. Footnote 133 cites R. P. Jindal, "From millibits to terabits per second and beyond - over 60 years of innovation", 2nd International Workshop on Electron Devices and Semiconductor Technology (2009): the page of the paper at IEEE Xplore did not load in the Wayback Machine; the first address of the footnote is a page of IEEE for an invited talk of the same author under nearly the same title, held February 14, 2019, whose abstract was read in the copy archived August 15, 2026. The abstract of the talk reads "This meteoric increase in bandwidth has been made possible by three key developments over the last 60 years." The first is the transistor of 1947, "followed by the demonstration of the MOS Field-Effect-Transistor by Kahng and Atalla in 1960", the second is information theory and the third is the laser. The source carries the MOS transistor as part of one of three developments behind the growth of bandwidth. It does not give the growth to the MOS transistor alone. The citation of footnote 133 at sentence 221 is graded Partial.

1.89 Sentence 227 says that Gordon Gould coined the term LASER, Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation, for this technology. Footnote 134 cites page 212 of Nick Taylor, Laser: The Inventor, the Nobel Laureate, and the Thirty-Year Patent War (2000), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The page treats the issue of United States Patent No. 4,053,845 to Gordon Gould in 1977 and the reaction of the makers of lasers. It says nothing of the coining of the word laser. The book that footnote 137 cites has the coining: at a conference of June 1959 "Gould presented a paper “The LASER: Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation” in which for the first time the name laser was publically used". The citation of footnote 134 at sentence 227 is graded Not supported.

1.90 Sentence 228 says that, using the light amplification method of Gordon Gould, patented as "Optically Pumped Laser Amplifier", where the first marker stands, Theodore Maiman made the first working laser on May 16, 1960. Footnote 135 cites United States patent 4,053,845: the address of the footnote at Espacenet returned an error page; the patent was read on the page of Google Patents, copy archived April 17, 2025 (167,162 characters, retrieved in full and searched; the head of the record read). The marker stands after the brackets, and the citation is graded against the patent and its title: the record has the title "Optically pumped laser amplifiers", the inventor Gordon Gould, the filing date August 16, 1974 and the publication date October 11, 1977. The patent does not name Theodore Maiman (searched). The citation of footnote 135 at sentence 228 is graded Supported. Footnote 136 cites Charles H. Townes, "The first laser", in A Century of Nature, edited by Laura Garwin and Tim Lincoln (University of Chicago Press), which the footnote dates 2010: the footnote gives no address; the first page of the essay was read from its image in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition (the contents of the book list the essay at page 105), and the book was searched there. The citation is graded against the words after the marker of footnote 135: "Theodore Maiman made the first laser operate on 16 May 1960 at the Hughes Research Laboratory in California". The in-book search finds the name Gould nowhere in the book. The citation of footnote 136 at sentence 228 is graded Supported.

1.91 Sentence 229 says that Gordon Gould co-founded Optelecom in 1973 to commercialize his inventions in optical fiber telecommunications, where the marker stands, and, after the marker, that Corning Glass was then producing the first commercial fiber optic cable in small quantities. Footnote 137 cites Mario Bertolotti, Masers and Lasers: An Historical Approach, second edition (CRC Press, 2015): the footnote gives no address; the passage was found by the in-book search of Google Books and read from the images of two pages of the electronic edition, which carry no printed page numbers, by optical character recognition. The marker stands after the word telecommunications, and the citation is graded against the founding: Gould was a professor at the Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute "until 1973, when he left to found Optelecom, Inc. of Gaithersburg, Maryland, an early manufacturer of fiber-optic data links". The source carries the founding, the year and the field of the company. The book has him found the company, not found it with others, and does not say that he founded it to commercialize inventions of his own. The citation of footnote 137 at sentence 229 is graded Partial.

1.92 Sentence 230 says that Optelecom configured its own fiber lasers and optical amplifiers into the first commercial optical communication systems, which it delivered to Chevron and to "the US Army Missile Defense". Footnote 138 cites pages 225 and 226 of Nick Taylor, Laser (2000), read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. Page 226 reads "Optelecom got a contract from Chevron to develop an oil well logging cable." The company did work for the Army under contracts that "were monitored by the Army Missile Command". The source carries Chevron as a customer, for a cable of three optical fibers, and work for the Army. The pages say nothing of fiber lasers or optical amplifiers of the company, and they do not call the cable the first commercial optical communication system. Page 225 is on the law of reexamination of patents. The citation of footnote 138 at sentence 230 is graded Partial.

1.93 Sentence 231 says that three years later, in 1977, GTE deployed the first optical telephone system in Long Beach, California. Footnote 139 cites page 46 of Sachidananda Kangovi, Peering Carrier Ethernet Networks (2016), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The source reads: "In 1977, GTE installed a test fiber-optic cable system in Long Beach, California." The source carries GTE, the year and the place. The page calls the system a test system and does not call it the first optical telephone system. The citation of footnote 139 at sentence 231 is graded Partial.

1.94 Sentence 233 says that in 1982 Norway, for which the sentence names NORSAR and the Norwegian Defence Research Establishment (NDRE), and the research group of Peter Kirstein at University College London (UCL) left the ARPANET and reconnected through SATNET using TCP/IP. Footnote 109 cites the same file as at sentence 157; the passages on SATNET read. The article quotes Paal Spilling on the lines of the ARPANET to Kjeller and London: "This was the situation as far as I can remember until say mid 1982." Then the sites "could start interconnecting their local networks to SATNET via Gateways at Kjeller and UCL", and "It was therefore a push to move away from ARPANET and over on SATNET." The article adds "But Spilling does not have a direct reference to when the ARPANET link to Kjeller/London was decommissioned." and "Kirstein remembers that it was in 1981 that UCL used SATNET." The source carries the move of the Norwegian Defence Research Establishment and of University College London from the ARPANET to SATNET. The year 1982 stands in it as a recollection, beside 1981 for University College London, and it does not name NORSAR in the move. The citation of footnote 109 at sentence 233 is graded Partial. Footnote 140 cites Robert Cole and Robert Braden, "Routing and Access Control in UK to US Services", IEN 190, July 9, 1981, text file at the address of the RFC Editor, copy archived April 17, 2026 (the footnote names no archive), 20,967 characters, retrieved in full and searched; sections 1 to 3 read. The note is of July 1981 and is older than the year of the sentence: "The removal of the TIP at UCL, and the consequent change to TCP-based service from UCL to the DARPA Catenet, present some interesting problems in routing and access control." It allows the users authorised by the Ministry of Defence "to use SATNET as a path for their traffic into the ARPANET" and sends the others by the public networks. The source carries the change at University College London as a thing to come. It says nothing of Norway. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 134, the note says of those public networks "These networks all use X.25, and are joined by X.75 gateways". The citation of footnote 140 at sentence 233 is graded Partial.

1.95 Sentence 234 says that 40 British research groups were using the link of UCL to the ARPANET in 1975, where the first marker stands, and that by 1984 there was a user population of about 150 people on both sides of the Atlantic. Footnote 80 cites the same text as at sentence 117. The marker stands after the year 1975, and the citation is graded against the first clause: "The 1975 SRC annual report pointed to the link as a sign of its far-sighted funding; there were already some 40 British academic research groups using the link." The citation of footnote 80 at sentence 234 is graded Supported. Footnote 141 cites P. T. Kirstein, "The University College London International Computer Communications Interconnection Service", internal working paper, December 1984, file of 19 page images at the address of University College London (copy archived March 22, 2026; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, read by optical character recognition and searched. The citation is graded against the words after the marker of footnote 80: "On average some 10 queries are dealt with each working day from a user population of approximately 150 people, on both sides of the Atlantic." The first page says that the paper will be presented at a conference in Karlsruhe on March 13 to 15, 1985. The citation of footnote 141 at sentence 234 is graded Supported.

1.96 Sentence 237 says that there was considerable resistance in Europe towards more widespread use of TCP/IP, and that the TCP/IP intranets of CERN remained isolated from the Internet until 1989, when a transatlantic connection to Cornell University was established. Footnote 142 cites François Fluckiger, "The European Researchers' Network", English text of an article in La Recherche 328, February 2000, file at the cited address (copy archived September 29, 2018, named), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched. The source reads: "A second front in the technology conflict has been open in Europe since 1986. This time the OSI and Internet protocols are in opposition." and "In February 1990 the first transatlantic Internet link with a transfer rate of l.5 million bits per second, entered into service between CERN and Cornell University on the east coast of the United States." The source carries the opposition in Europe and the link between CERN and Cornell University. The article dates the link to February 1990, where the sentence has 1989, and it says nothing of networks of CERN that stood apart from the Internet until then. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: of 1991 the article says "85% of the international bandwidth installed for the Internet in Europe terminates in the Computer Centre building 513 of CERN", and it calls the World Wide Web application design "this Internet application". The citation of footnote 142 at sentence 237 is graded Partial. Footnote 143 cites "How the Web Got its 'Lingua Franca'", Internet Hall of Fame, July 2, 2014, copy archived March 21, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date April 3, 2020; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "But not everyone in the fractured computer networking community was convinced of TCP/IP's viability.", "Between 1984 and 1989, Segal encouraged CERN, one of the world's largest and most influential research centers, to accept TCP/IP" and "CERN's main Network Group finally went public with TCP/IP in 1989". The source carries doubt about the protocols, their use inside CERN from 1984 and the year 1989. The page does not speak of resistance in Europe as such, and it names neither Cornell University nor a transatlantic connection. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page says that the World Wide Web application design became a global phenomenon "thanks to its being built on TCP/IP". The citation of footnote 143 at sentence 237 is graded Partial. Footnote 144 cites "The Internet - From Modest Beginnings", page of the history of the National Science Foundation, copy archived October 7, 2016 (named), read in full. The page treats the ARPANET and CSNET in the United States. It names neither CERN nor Cornell University, and it says nothing of Europe, of resistance to the protocols or of the year 1989. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the words "CSNET was responsible for the first Internet gateways between the United States and many countries in Europe and Asia." The citation of footnote 144 at sentence 237 is graded Not supported.

1.97 Sentence 240 says that, soon after the first international connection of CSNET of 1984, connections were established to computer science departments in Canada, France and Germany. Footnote 23 cites the same page as at sentence 192. The source reads: "In February, 1984, Israel became the first international node on the CSNET, soon followed by Korea, Australia, Canada, France, Germany, and Japan." The page says of CSNET that it gave connectivity to the departments of computer science and engineering of universities. The citation of footnote 23 at sentence 240 is graded Supported.

1.98 Sentence 241 says that in 1988 the first international connections to the NSFNET were established by the Institut national de recherche en informatique et en automatique (INRIA) of France, where the first two markers stand, and by Piet Beertema at the Centrum Wiskunde & Informatica (CWI) in the Netherlands. Footnote 145 cites Valérie Schafer and Benjamin G. Thierry, "From the Minitel to the Internet", in The Routledge Companion to Global Internet Histories (2017), pages 77 to 89: the page of the electronic edition that the link of the footnote opens, and two further pages of the chapter that the in-book search of Google Books found, were read from their images by optical character recognition; the summary on the page of the publisher was read in the copy archived November 30, 2025. The marker stands with that of footnote 146 after the name of INRIA, and the citation is graded against the connection of 1988 by INRIA: "Later, in 1988, INRIA’s Christian Huitema used his relationships with US researchers to obtain a direct liaison with Wisconsin". The source carries the year, INRIA and a direct link to the United States. The pages read do not name the NSFNET and do not call the link the first international connection to it. The page that the link opens is on the Minitel and says nothing of the sentence. The citation of footnote 145 at sentence 241 is graded Partial. Footnote 146 cites Menjanirina Andrianarisoa, a brief history of the Internet posted on March 2, 2012 on the weblog Technology Trend, which the article itself tags as a user-generated source, copy archived March 27, 2014 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: “It took until July 28, 1988, that the France is connected to the NSFnet, a transatlantic link established by the team "networks" of INRIA Sophia Antipolis.” The source carries the year, INRIA and the NSFNET. The post does not call the link the first international connection to the NSFNET. The citation of footnote 146 at sentence 241 is graded Partial. Footnote 147 cites "CWI History: details", page of the Centrum Wiskunde & Informatica, copy archived December 15, 2019 (nearest to the retrieval date February 9, 2020; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The citation is graded against the words after the markers of footnotes 145 and 146: "CWI established the first connection between Europe and the Internet on November 17, 1988. The institute was the first non-American organization to gain access to the American science network NSFnet". The page names "CWI's network manager Piet Beertema and his colleagues". The page gives the first place to CWI alone, with a date in November 1988, where the post of footnote 146 dates the link of INRIA to July 28, 1988. The citation of footnote 147 at sentence 241 is graded Supported.

1.99 Sentence 245 says that the connection of NORDUnet to the NSFNET was in place soon after, providing open access for university students in Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden. Footnote 148 cites Kaarina Lehtisalo, The History of NORDUnet (NORDUnet, 2005), file of 79 pages at the cited address (copy archived March 4, 2016, named), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the chapter on the building of the network read. After the worm of November 1988 the network "got the Internet routing via a satellite link to the John von Neumann Center at Princeton, New Jersey". The book calls the network "the first international research network to get a connection to the Internet and to thus give university students open access to the network". The source reads: "No European country had an Internet connection that could be used freely by university students." The book speaks of the Nordic countries and tells the connection of Iceland in a section of its own. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 241, the book says that INRIA "was also connected" to the NSFNET and still gives the first place among international research networks to NORDUnet. The citation of footnote 148 at sentence 245 is graded Supported.

1.100 Sentence 246 says that in January 1989 CERN opened its first external TCP/IP connections. Footnote 149 cites Ben Segal, "A Short History of Internet Protocols at CERN", April 1995: the identifier of the footnote did not resolve in the Wayback Machine; the text was read on the page of the author at CERN, copy archived June 8, 2023 (19,372 characters), read in full. The source reads: “A year later, CERN opened its first external connections to the Internet after a "big bang" in January 1989 to change all IP addresses to official ones.” In the text the month of January 1989 is the month of the change of addresses, and the connections open after it. The citation of footnote 149 at sentence 246 is graded Supported.

1.101 Sentence 250 says that in 1991 the Joint Academic Network (JANET) adopted the Internet Protocol on the existing network. Footnote 150 cites FLAGSHIP, newsletter of the Central Computing Department of the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, issue 12, January 1991, copy archived February 13, 2020 (named), read in full; the article headed IP by Paul Bryant read. The source reads: "A group has recently been set up to advise the JNT on this problem and they have now reported and recommended some use of IP across the JANET X.25 network." The source carries, for January 1991, a recommendation of some use of the Internet Protocol across the X.25 network of JANET. The issue does not report the adoption. The citation of footnote 150 at sentence 250 is graded Partial. Footnote 151 cites FLAGSHIP, issue 16, September 1991, copy archived February 13, 2020 (named), read in full; the article on the pilot of the JANET IP Service read. The source reads: "An operational pilot (called Shoestring) for the planned JANET IP Service (JIPS) has been underway since March 1991." The service is to use "JANET's X.25 service to encapsulate and deliver IP traffic". The source carries, for 1991, a pilot of the Internet Protocol on the existing network. In September 1991 the issue speaks of the service itself as planned and still to be launched. The citation of footnote 151 at sentence 250 is graded Partial.

1.102 Sentence 251 says that in the same year Dai Davies introduced Internet technology into the pan-European national research and education network (NREN), EuropaNet, which the sentence says was built on the X.25 protocol. Footnote 152 cites "Dai Davies", page of the Internet Hall of Fame, copy archived August 2, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: "In 1991 Davies introduced Internet technology into the pan-European backbone, EuropaNet, which was originally planned as an X.25 network." The sentence of the article follows this sentence. The page says that the network was originally planned as an X.25 network, where the article says that it was built on the X.25 protocol. The citation of footnote 152 at sentence 251 is graded Partial. Footnote 153 cites "Protocol Wars", Internet Hall of Fame, January 16, 2015, copy archived January 9, 2023 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: "In 1991 Dai Davies introduced Internet technology into the pan-European backbone, EuropaNet, which was originally planned as an X.25 network." This is the same sentence as on the page of footnote 152, with the same difference from the article. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 253, the post has the words of that sentence, on engineers, organizations and nations who became polarized over which protocol "would result in the best and most robust networks", and footnote 153 is not cited there. The citation of footnote 153 at sentence 251 is graded Partial.

1.103 Sentence 252 says that the European Academic and Research Network (EARN) and the Réseaux Associés pour la Recherche Européenne (RARE) adopted IP around the same time, and that the European Internet backbone EBONE became operational in 1992. Footnote 142 cites the same file as at sentence 237. Of RARE the article says that on February 1, 1990 it adopted a resolution that "recognizes the TCP/IP family of protocols as an open multivendor suite". Of Ebone the article says "The network starts up at the end of 1991 with 14 member organizations. In the autumn of 1992 ten other members join the Ebone consortium". The source carries the turn of RARE and the backbone Ebone. The article dates the resolution to February 1990 and the start of Ebone to the end of 1991, where the sentence has 1992, and it does not say that EARN adopted the Internet Protocol: it has the head of EARN propose to replace the transport infrastructure of EARN by one of the standards of Open Systems Interconnection (OSI). The citation of footnote 142 at sentence 252 is graded Partial.

1.104 Sentence 253 says that, for a period in the late 1980s and early 1990s, engineers, organizations and nations were polarized over the issue of which standard, the OSI model or the Internet protocol suite, would result in the best and most robust computer networks. Footnote 107 cites the same page as at sentence 152. The source reads: "The two camps became bitter rivals.", "By the mid-1980s the worldwide adoption of OSI appeared inevitable." and "By the late 1980s, frustration with OSI’s slow development had reached a boiling point." The article names telephone companies, regulators, national governments, standards agencies and researchers among the parties. The citation of footnote 107 at sentence 253 is graded Supported. Footnote 154 cites Andrew L. Russell, "'Rough Consensus and Running Code' and the Internet-OSI Standards War", IEEE Annals of the History of Computing 28 (3), 2006, pages 48 to 61: the footnote links only identifiers; the article was read in the copy on a site of Duke University, archived November 17, 2019, a file of 14 pages retrieved in full for an earlier audit of this series, text extracted by column and searched again. The source reads: "A spirited rivalry between respective advocates of OSI and TCP/IP networks emerged as they fought for jurisdiction over standards for computer internetworks." and "During the 1980s and early 1990s, OSI enjoyed widespread support from national governments, particularly in Western Europe, North America, and the Far East." The citation of footnote 154 at sentence 253 is graded Supported. Footnote 155 cites pages 106 and 107 of Howard Davies and Beatrice Bressan (editors), A History of International Research Networking (Wiley, 2010), the section "The Protocol Wars", read from the images of the pages in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The source reads: "The protocol wars were undeclared and no peace treaty was ever signed, so it is hard to say when they started or ended." and "By 1985 the only question was: which standard?" The source carries wars over the choice of standard among vendors, administrations, governments and researchers. The two pages run from 1978 to 1985 and do not place the dispute in the late 1980s and early 1990s. The section goes on after page 107, which was not read. The citation of footnote 155 at sentence 253 is graded Partial.

1.105 Sentence 254 says that Japan, which had built the UUCP-based network JUNET in 1984, connected to CSNET, where the marker stands, and, after the marker, that Japan connected later to the NSFNET in 1989, marking the spread of the Internet to Asia. Footnote 23 cites the same page as at sentence 192. The marker stands after the words connected to CSNET, and the citation is graded against the words before it: the page lists Japan among the countries that soon followed Israel as international nodes of CSNET from 1984. The source carries the connection of Japan to CSNET. The page names neither JUNET nor UUCP and gives no year for a Japanese network. The citation of footnote 23 at sentence 254 is graded Partial.

1.106 Sentence 256 says that the System Development Network (SDN) of South Korea was connected to the rest of the world in August 1983 using UUCP, was connected to CSNET in December 1984, where the first marker stands, and was formally connected to the NSFNET in 1990. Footnote 23 cites the same page as at sentence 192. The marker stands after the words on December 1984, and the citation is graded against the connection to CSNET: the page lists Korea first among the countries that soon followed Israel, which joined in February 1984. The source carries the connection of Korea to CSNET. The page gives no month and no year for it and does not name the SDN. The citation of footnote 23 at sentence 256 is graded Partial. Footnote 156 cites Kilnam Chon, Hyunje Park, Kyungran Kang and Youngeum Lee, "A Brief History of the Internet in Korea", file at the cited address (copy archived December 7, 2025; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched. The citation is graded against the words after the marker of footnote 23, on the formal connection of 1990: "SDN was connected to CSNET in December 1984, and this connection was utilized as a forum for exchange of technology until SDN was formally connected to the U.S. Internet in 1990." The source carries the formal connection and the year. The paper says the U.S. Internet, not the NSFNET, and tells of a line of March 1990 from the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST) to the University of Hawaii. The two earlier clauses of the sentence, on August 1983 and December 1984, follow this paper. The citation of footnote 156 at sentence 256 is graded Partial. Footnote 157 cites "A Brief History of the Internet in Korea (2005)", page of the Korea Internet History Project, copy archived September 27, 2016 (nearest to the retrieval date May 30, 2016; the footnote names no archive), 25,700 characters, retrieved in full and searched. The page has the text of the paper that footnote 156 cites: "until SDN was formally connected to the U.S. Internet in 1990". The source carries the formal connection and the year. It says the U.S. Internet, not the NSFNET. The citation of footnote 157 at sentence 256 is graded Partial. Footnote 158 cites page 55 of Past, Present and Future of Research in the Information Society, edited by Wesley Shrum and others (Springer, 2007), read from the image of the page in the preview of Google Books by optical character recognition. The page tells the start of the network on May 15, 1982 and its links by UUCP from 1983. It says nothing of a formal connection in 1990 or of the NSFNET. It carries what sentence 255 and the first clause of this sentence state. The citation of footnote 158 at sentence 256 is graded Not supported.

1.107 Sentence 257 says that in Australia ad hoc networking to ARPA and between Australian universities formed in the late 1980s, based on various technologies such as X.25 and UUCPNet, and by way of a CSNET. Footnote 23 cites the same page as at sentence 192. The page lists Australia among the countries that soon followed Israel as international nodes of CSNET. The source carries a connection of Australia by way of CSNET. The page says nothing of ad hoc networking among Australian universities, of the late 1980s, of X.25 or of UUCPNet. The citation of footnote 23 at sentence 257 is graded Partial.

1.108 Sentence 261 says that New Zealand adopted the Coloured Book protocols of the United Kingdom as an interim standard and established its first international IP connection to the United States in 1989. Footnote 159 cites "History of University of Waikato", page of the University of Waikato, copy archived August 1, 2020 (named), read in full. The source reads: "In 1989 (with a little help from NASA) we connected New Zealand to the Internet". The source carries the connection of New Zealand in 1989. The page says nothing of the Coloured Book protocols or of an interim standard. The citation of footnote 159 at sentence 261 is graded Partial.

1.109 Sentence 264 says that at the beginning of the 1990s African countries relied upon the International Packet Switched Service (IPSS) of X.25 and upon UUCP links by modems of 2400 baud for international and internetwork computer communications. Footnote 163 cites "Africa Internet History: Highlights", Internet Society, file of 46 pages at the cited address (copy archived October 25, 2026; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; page 18 read. The source reads: "At the beginning of the 1990s, African countries relied upon X.25 IPSS and 2400 baud modem UUCP links for international and internetwork computer communications." The sentence of the article is this sentence of the file, word for word and without quotation marks. The citation of footnote 163 at sentence 264 is graded Supported.

1.110 Sentence 272 says that, as with other Internet regions, there is an operational forum, the Internet Community of Operational Networking Specialists. Footnote 164 cites the home page of the Internet Community of Operational Networking Specialists (ICONS) on the site of the African Network Information Center (AFRINIC), copy archived May 9, 2007 (named), read in full. The page describes itself as "A site to share network operation experience and knowledge, and promote events happening in the Internet operators community." Its description spells the name out as "ICONS - Internet Community of Online Networking Specialists". The source carries a forum of network operators under that abbreviation. The page has the word Online where the sentence has Operational, and it does not compare the region with other regions. The citation of footnote 164 at sentence 272 is graded Partial.

1.111 Sentence 275 says that undersea cable development is slower for East Africa, and that the original joint effort between the New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD) and the East Africa Submarine System (Eassy) has broken off and may become two efforts. Footnote 165 cites "Nepad, Eassy partnership ends in divorce", cited to the South African Financial Times at an address of the site fmtech.co.za: the copy that the footnote names, archived April 23, 2012, is a parking page that offers the name of the site for sale, and the copy archived August 14, 2011 is a parking page of the same service; the earliest record that the Wayback Machine holds of the address, of June 6, 2010, is a forwarding to another address, of which the Wayback Machine holds no copy. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 165 at sentence 275 is graded Uncheckable.

1.112 Sentence 277 says that the Asia Pacific Network Information Centre (APNIC) sponsors an operational forum, the Asia-Pacific Regional Internet Conference on Operational Technologies (APRICOT). Footnote 166 cites the home page of APRICOT, copy archived June 9, 2009 (nearest to the retrieval date May 28, 2009; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The page lists the yearly meetings from "APRICOT 1996: January 1996, Singapore" to those planned for 2013. The source carries the conference. The page does not spell out the name, and it does not say that APNIC sponsors the conference: it names APNIC as the host of the site ICONS and sends enquiries to a secretariat of its own. The citation of footnote 166 at sentence 277 is graded Partial.

1.113 Sentence 278 says that in South Korea the very high speed digital subscriber line (VDSL), a last mile technology developed in the 1990s by NextLevel Communications, connected corporate and consumer copper-based telephone lines to the Internet. Footnote 167 cites the opening of a release of Business Wire of September 11, 2000, on a page of WorldNews, copy archived December 20, 2022 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive): the page shows the headline and the first sentence and sends the reader elsewhere for the rest, which was not read. The release says that Next Level Communications "today announced that Hansol Electronics, a leading electronics distributor in Seoul, South Korea, has placed its initial", where the page breaks off. The headline has a purchase order for DSL equipment in South Korea. The source carries the company and an order from South Korea in September 2000. The part read does not name VDSL, does not say that the company developed it in the 1990s and says nothing of the lines of businesses and consumers. The citation of footnote 167 at sentence 278 is graded Partial.

1.114 Sentence 281 says that China went on to implement its own digital divide by implementing a country-wide content filter. Footnote 168 cites IDG News Service, "China celebrates 10 years of being connected to the Internet", on the site of PC World in Australia, dated May 17, 2004, an article in six pages: the copy that the footnote names, archived October 21, 2008, is the second page, which holds the part headed "A brief history of the Internet in China", the title that the footnote gives, and it was read in full; the print version of the whole article, archived June 9, 2008, was read in full, and the five other pages, archived June 14, 2008 and October 5, 2008, were retrieved. The cited part is a timeline that runs from 1986 to September 20, 1994, signed Martyn Williams. It carries the sentence before, sentence 280, which has no footnote ("May 17, 1994 - The IHEP link is opened to full Internet connectivity"), and it says nothing of a filter, of censorship or of a digital divide. Another part of the article, on its third page, headed "Finding freedom behind China's Great Firewall", speaks of "Chinese government attempts to block access to some Web sites and censor discussion groups" and says that official confirmation that such efforts exist is absent. The words digital divide and country-wide occur in none of the six parts, and the one mention of content filtering is of the filtering of messages by Chinese Web sites that an investigation of Reporters Without Borders of 2003 reported. The citation of footnote 168 at sentence 281 is graded Not supported.

1.115 Sentence 283 says that Singapore developed TECHNET in 1990, and that Thailand gained a global Internet connection between Chulalongkorn University and UUNET in 1992. Footnote 169 cites "Internet History in Asia", page of a session of the 16th APAN Meetings in Busan, copy archived February 1, 2006 (named), read in full. The abstract on Thailand reads "The first international IP connection came alive in 1992 between Chulalongkorn University and UUNET". The abstract on Singapore has the establishment of TECHNET in 1990. The citation of footnote 169 at sentence 283 is graded Supported.

1.116 Sentence 291 says that in 1989 MCI Mail became the first commercial email provider to get an experimental gateway to the Internet. Footnote 171 cites "Meet Mr. Internet: Vint Cerf", IEEE Spectrum, published April 30, 2023, copy archived May 3, 2023 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the passages on MCI Mail read. The profile tells that Vinton Cerf asked the Federal Networking Council for leave to run an experiment that would connect MCI Mail to the backbone of the NSFNET, and goes on: "He got the okay, and CNRI announced the project in June 1989." Its next sentence has all the other commercial electronic mail services ask at once for the same leave and receive it. The source carries the year, MCI Mail, the experiment and the first place. The profile dates the announcement of the project, not the working connection, to June 1989, and it does not use the word gateway of this connection. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the profile says that the use of the networks funded by the National Science Foundation and by other agencies was restricted to researchers and academics, "with commercial activity, businesses, and the general public banned". The citation of footnote 171 at sentence 291 is graded Supported.

1.117 Sentence 292 says that the first commercial dialup ISP in the United States was The World, which opened in 1989. Footnote 172 cites the home page of The World, copy archived May 31, 2009 (nearest to the retrieval date May 28, 2009; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "We were the first public dialup Internet Service Provider (ISP)." The source carries The World and the first place among dialup providers. The page says public where the sentence says commercial, it names no year of opening, and it does not limit the claim to the United States. It says that The World is operated by Software Tool & Die and has its headquarters in Boston, Massachusetts. The citation of footnote 172 at sentence 292 is graded Partial.

1.118 Sentence 293 says that in 1992 the Congress of the United States passed the Scientific and Advanced-Technology Act, 42 U.S.C. § 1862(g), which allowed the National Science Foundation (NSF) to support access by the research and education communities to computer networks that were not used exclusively for research and education purposes, thus permitting the NSFNET to interconnect with commercial networks. Footnote 173 cites United States General Accounting Office, Office of the General Counsel, letter of July 7, 2000 on the subject "Department of Commerce: Relationship with the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers" (GAO/OGC-00-33R), file of 45 pages, copy archived June 15, 2009 (named), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; pages 6 and 36 read. Note 6 on the cited page 6 reads "In 1992, the Congress allowed commercial activity on the NSF’s network, one of the networks that became the Internet and permitted NSFNET to interconnect with commercial networks.", followed by the citation "Scientific and Advanced-Technology Act of 1992, 42 U.S.C. § 1862(g)." The source carries the year, the Congress, the Act with its place in the United States Code and the interconnection with commercial networks. A search of the file for the words research and education finds no statement of the clause on the access of the research and education communities to networks not used for research and education alone, which stands in the review cited by footnote 174. The file prints the name General Accounting Office where the footnote has Government Accountability Office. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: page 36 says "In 1992, NSF was authorized to allow commercial activity on the Internet." and goes on "This paved the way for today’s Internet." The citation of footnote 173 at sentence 293 is graded Partial. Footnote 174 cites Office of Inspector General of the National Science Foundation, "Review of NSFNET", March 23, 1993, with the response of the Foundation of April 19, 1993, text file at the cited address (copy archived December 22, 2024; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the sections on commercial use and on the Acceptable Use Policy and the response to Recommendation 5 read. The review says "The Scientific and Advanced Technology Act of 1992, introduced by Congressman Boucher and signed into law on 23 October 1992, subtly modified NSF's authority to support computer networks that are not limited to research and education." It prints the new subsection (g), which authorizes the Foundation to "foster and support access by the research and education communities" to computer networks "which may be used substantially for purposes in addition to research and education in the sciences and engineering", on a condition that the sentence of the article leaves out, namely that the additional uses tend to increase the capabilities of the networks to support research and education. Its note 73 gives "42 U.S.C. 1862(g)". The source carries the year, the Act, its place in the United States Code and the clause on access. A search of the file for the words interconnect and commercial networks finds no statement that the Act permitted the NSFNET to interconnect with commercial networks, which stands in the letter cited by footnote 173. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: against the word thus of the sentence, the review prints a message of the Foundation to Merit of May 24, 1991, seventeen months before the Act was signed, which begins "NSF agrees that ANS may move commercial traffic in both directions across the NSF sponsored Backbone gateways". The footnote makes a statement of its own, that the Foundation never felt it could do away with its Acceptable Use Policy, and the response to Recommendation 5 reads "NSF agrees with this recommendation and will continue to maintain an acceptable use policy." The review calls the amended law the NSF Act, where the footnote calls it the appropriations act. The citation of footnote 174 at sentence 293 is graded Partial.

1.119 Sentence 294 says that this caused controversy within the research and education community, who were concerned that commercial use of the network might lead to an Internet that was less responsive to their needs, and within the community of commercial network providers, who felt that government subsidies were giving an unfair advantage to some organizations. Footnote 175 cites Management of NSFNET, hearing before the Subcommittee on Science of the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology of the House of Representatives, March 12, 1992, printed report of 190 pages in the file of the ERIC database, ED350986 (copy of the record archived June 9, 2025, copy of the file archived March 15, 2026; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date): the file was retrieved in full and its text searched, and the opening statements, the passages that the searches returned and the two markups of the bill H.R. 5344 that the report prints were read. The chairman of the subcommittee, Rick Boucher, opens by saying that policy decisions on the operation of the NSFNET reverberate among the communities of users and providers, an effect that "is evident in the aftermath of the decision to allow the mixing of research and education traffic with commercial traffic on the NSFNET backbone", and he asks whether the policies of the National Science Foundation provide a level playing field for the providers and keep the network responsive to the needs of the users. William L. Schrader, President and CEO of Performance Systems International, Inc., asks Congress to direct the Foundation to "remove the unfair advantages ANS has acquired". A. Nico Habermann, Assistant Director of the Foundation for Computer and Information Science and Engineering, says that "the user community is very much concerned about the potential balkanization of the networking infrastructure". The source carries the complaint of the commercial providers and concerns of the users. The hearing of March 12, 1992 stands seven months before the Act of sentence 293, which the review cited by footnote 174 has signed into law on October 23, 1992, and it ties the dispute to the management of the backbone by the Foundation, not to the Act. The report prints the bill H.R. 5344 of 1992, which adds to section 3 of the National Science Foundation Act of 1950 (42 U.S.C. 1862) a subsection (g), the subsection that sentence 293 cites, and it records that Rick Boucher, who offered the bill, said on June 4, 1992 that the users, the providers and the Foundation "all recommended the policy change which is enabled by this amendment", and that George E. Brown, Jr., chairman of the committee, called the bill on June 10, 1992 "a relatively short and relatively non-controversial piece of legislation". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: Douglas E. Van Houweling, Member of the Board of Directors of Merit Network, Inc. and Vice Provost for Information Technology of the University of Michigan, testified that the commercial traffic carried on the backbone was "in the neighborhood of just 1 or 2 percent", and William L. Schrader testified: "There are other commercial providers with nationwide backbones." The citation of footnote 175 at sentence 294 is graded Partial.

1.120 Sentence 299 says that the final restrictions on carrying commercial traffic ended on April 30, 1995, when the NSF ended its sponsorship of the NSFNET Backbone Service. Footnote 176 cites Susan R. Harris and Elise Gerich, "Retiring the NSFNET Backbone Service: Chronicling the End of an Era", reprinted from ConneXions, volume 10, number 4, April 1996, on the site of Merit, copy archived January 1, 2016 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the opening and the passages on the final shutdown read. The source reads: "April 30, 1996, marks the one-year anniversary of the final dismantling of the venerable NSFNET Backbone Service." The cited article prints the notice of termination, which names midnight of April 30, 1995 for each of 19 locations. The source carries the date and the end of the NSFNET Backbone Service. A search of the cited article for the words restrict, acceptable and commercial traffic finds no statement on restrictions on commercial traffic or on their end. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the cited article says that the National Science Foundation "inherited the responsibility for nurturing the U.S. Internet from the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA)" and that the NSFNET program "laid the foundation of the U.S. Internet". The citation of footnote 176 at sentence 299 is graded Partial. Footnote 177 cites Walt Howe, "A Brief History of the Internet", page of walthowe.com that gives April 20, 2025 as the date of its last update, copy archived November 1, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the passages on commercial use read. The source reads: "All pretenses of limitations on commercial use disappeared in May 1995 when the National Science Foundation ended its sponsorship of the Internet backbone, and all traffic relied on commercial networks." The source carries the end of the limits on commercial use and the end of the sponsorship of the Foundation. The page dates both to May 1995, where the sentence has April 30, 1995, and it says the Internet backbone, where the sentence says the NSFNET Backbone Service. The second half of the sentence of the Wikipedia article follows the wording of the page of Walt Howe. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page says of the early 1990s, when independent commercial networks began to grow, "It then became possible to route traffic across the country from one commercial site to another without passing through the government funded NSFNet Internet backbone." The citation of footnote 177 at sentence 299 is graded Partial.

1.121 Sentence 301 says that the NSF also sponsored the very high speed Backbone Network Service (vBNS), which continued to provide support for the supercomputing centers and for research and education in the United States. Footnote 178 cites National Science Foundation, program solicitation NSF 93-52 of May 6, 1993, for a Network Access Point Manager, a Routing Arbiter, Regional Network Providers and a Very High Speed Backbone Network Services Provider for NSFNET and the NREN Program, text file, copy archived March 5, 2016 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the opening and the passages on the very high speed Backbone Network Service read. The solicitation invites proposals for the service: "The vBNS will continue this tradition and will provide for: high speed interconnection of NSF Supercomputing Centers (SCCs)". The source carries the plan of the Foundation for the service, the supercomputing centers and the research and education community. A solicitation of May 6, 1993 speaks of the service as a thing to come, and it cannot carry that the Foundation sponsored the service or that the service continued to provide support. The citation of footnote 178 at sentence 301 is graded Partial.

1.122 Sentence 302 says that an event held on January 11, 1994, The Superhighway Summit at Royce Hall of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), was, in words that the sentence prints in quotation marks, the first public conference bringing together all of the major industry, government and academic leaders in the field, and that it also began the national dialogue about the Information Superhighway and its implications. Footnote 179 cites "UCLA Center for Communication Policy", a section of a longer document on the site digitalcenter.org, copy archived May 26, 2009 (named), read in full. The Center writes of a conference that it co-hosted: "In January, 1994, the Center for Communication Policy co-hosted the Information Superhighway Summit with the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences." The source reads: "Not only was this the first public conference bringing together all of the major industry, government and academic leaders in the field, but also began the national dialogue about the Information Superhighway and its implications." The source carries the conference, its month and year and the description. The page does not give the day, January 11, and it does not name Royce Hall. The words that the article prints in quotation marks leave out the words ", but" of the page. The description is the description that the Center gives of its own conference. The citation of footnote 179 at sentence 302 is graded Partial.

1.123 Sentence 303 credits the invention of the World Wide Web application design to Tim Berners-Lee at CERN, as an application on the Internet, where the first marker stands, and says that it brought many social and commercial uses to what was, at the time, a network of networks for academic and research institutions. Footnote 180 cites James Tobin, Great Projects, Simon and Schuster, the edition of June 12, 2012 in the preview of Google Books: the footnote names no page, and its link opens a page of the index, on which the entry for the subject of the sentence points to pages 291 to 300; the book was searched there for the name Berners-Lee, and the pages that Google Books labels PT328, PT329, PT336 and PT337 were read from their images. The marker stands after the words as an application on the Internet, and the citation is graded against the clause before it: "Then, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, Tim Berners-Lee, an English computer scientist, invented a method of using the Internet". The source reads: "He named his method the World Wide Web". The next page places him at CERN. The source carries the clause in the words of the book, which has Tim Berners-Lee invent, at CERN, a method of using the Internet and name it the World Wide Web. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the same page says "The Internet was, and still is, a big network of smaller computer networks, a bunch of boxes connected to each other by wires." The citation of footnote 180 at sentence 303 is graded Supported. Footnote 181 cites Electronic Commerce Management for Business Activities and Global Enterprises: Competitive Advantages, IGI Global, 2012, which Google Books lists under the name Lee, In, in the preview of Google Books: the footnote names no page, and its link opens page 7; pages 7 and 8 were read from their images. The marker stands with that of footnote 182 at the end of the sentence, and the two citations are graded against the words after the marker of footnote 180. The sentence that runs from page 7 to page 8 begins "In 1990, Tim Berners-Lee and a team at CERN invented the World Wide Web and" and ends "transformed an academic telecommunication network into a worldwide open communication system". Page 7 reads "The Internet did not experience real proliferation until the invention of the Web, a service provisioned through the Internet infrastructure." The source carries an academic network before the World Wide Web application design and its opening to the world after it. The two pages do not speak of social and commercial uses, of research institutions or of a network of networks. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: page 7 reads "For the next decade, NSFNET would be the core of the US Internet, until its privatization and ultimate retirement in 1995." The citation of footnote 181 at sentence 303 is graded Partial. Footnote 182 cites American Countercultures, an encyclopedia that the footnote lists under Gina Misiroglu, Routledge, 2015, in the preview of Google Books: the footnote names no page, and its link opens page 398; the entry Internet was read on pages 398 and 399 from their images, and the entry goes on after page 399. The source reads: "ARPANET enabled communication between computers at government research agencies and universities holding defense contracts." The entry says that it was with the World Wide Web application design, in the 1990s, that the Internet became available and accessible to a larger segment of society, and that at the end of the 1990s "businesses, industries, and individuals took advantage of the power of the Internet by establishing Web sites for conducting business". The source carries the clause in the words of the entry: a network between research agencies and universities, to which the World Wide Web application design brought the public and business. The citation of footnote 182 at sentence 303 is graded Supported.

1.124 Sentence 304 says that the World Wide Web application design opened to the public in 1991 and began to enter general use in 1993 and 1994, when websites for everyday use started to become available. Footnote 183 cites Nick Couldry, Media, Society, World: Social Theory and Digital Media Practice, Polity, 2012, in the preview of Google Books; the cited page 2 was read from its image. The page speaks of "the World Wide Web protocols that link hypertext documents into a working system that were conceived first by Tim Berners-Lee in 1989, launched in 1991, but only began to enter everyday use in 1993–4". The source carries the year 1991 and the entry into everyday use in 1993 and 1994. The page says launched, where the sentence says opened to the public, and it does not say that websites for everyday use started to become available in 1993 and 1994. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the same page calls the Internet a network of networks, and it quotes Clay Shirky to the effect that the Internet is only a set of agreements about how to move data between two points. The citation of footnote 183 at sentence 304 is graded Partial.

1.125 Sentence 312 says that typical design elements of the websites of the era that it calls "Web 1.0" included, where the first marker stands, a list of seven things: static pages instead of dynamic HyperText Markup Language (HTML), where the second marker stands; content served from filesystems instead of relational databases; pages built using Server Side Includes or the Common Gateway Interface (CGI) instead of a web application written in a dynamic programming language; structures of the era of HTML 3.2 such as frames and tables to create page layouts; online guestbooks; overuse of buttons in the Graphics Interchange Format (GIF) and of similar small graphics promoting particular items, where the third marker stands; and HTML forms sent by email. Footnote 184 cites Ganesh Viswanathan, Punit Dutt Mathur and Pradeep Yammiyavar, "From Web 1.0 to Web 2.0 and beyond: Reviewing usability heuristic criteria taking music sites as case studies", page of the paper at Academia: the copies archived June 6, 2019 and March 10, 2021 show no text of the paper; the copy archived October 12, 2026 prints the text of the paper of 10 pages, which was retrieved in full and searched, and section 2.2 was read (the footnote names no archive). The marker stands after the word included, and the citation is graded against the opening of the list: section 2.2 of the paper, headed Features of Web 1.0, says that typical web design "elements of that initial phase of Web 1.0 can be listed" and lists six of them. The source carries the opening. Of the seven items of the list of the article, the paper has "Static pages instead of dynamic user content", the use of framesets, online guest books, "GIF buttons, typically 88x31 pixels in size" and "HTML forms sent via email." It does not list content served from filesystems, pages built with Server Side Includes or the Common Gateway Interface (CGI), or tables for page layouts. The citation of footnote 184 at sentence 312 is graded Supported. Footnote 185 cites Jonathan Strickland, "Is there a Web 1.0?", HowStuffWorks, January 28, 2008, an article in four pages, copies archived February 10, 2008 (the first and second pages) and February 11, 2008 (the third and fourth); the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date; all four pages read in full. The marker stands inside the list, after its first item. The second page, headed "Web 1.0 Defined", lists among the strategies that it has Tim O'Reilly count as the philosophy of Web 1.0: "Web 1.0 sites are static." The source carries static pages. The cited article sets against them a blog or an account that its owner can update often, and the words dynamic HTML are on none of the four pages. The citation of footnote 185 at sentence 312 is graded Partial. Footnote 186 cites "Web 1.0 Revisited", page of Complexify.com, copy archived February 16, 2006 (named), read in full. The marker stands after the item on buttons, and the citation is graded against that item. The page is one person's collection of buttons: "My collection of silly 88x31 buttons.", with the count "(133 strong and growing...)", under the line "Welcome back to Web 1.0". An editor's note calls it "a 2006 resurrection of a long-dead web page". The source carries buttons of that size on a page of that era, as a specimen, and the title of the page calls the buttons too many. The page does not say that such buttons were typical of the websites of the era or that they promoted particular items. The citation of footnote 186 at sentence 312 is graded Partial.

1.126 Sentence 313 says that support for server side scripting was rare on shared servers, so that the usual feedback mechanism was by email, using mailto forms and the email program of the user. Footnote 187 cites "The Right Size of Software", a section of chapter 13, Complexity, of a book on the site catb.org, copy archived October 24, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The section is about the size of programs and about frameworks. Its one sentence that touches the subject of the sentence of the article reads "The paradigmatic example in the 1990s was the way that the mailto: URL induced the growth of huge mail clients embedded in Web browsers." The section says nothing of server side scripting, of shared servers, of a feedback mechanism or of forms. The citation of footnote 187 at sentence 313 is graded Not supported.

1.127 Sentence 316 says that the history of the World Wide Web application design up to around 2004 was retrospectively named and described by some as "Web 1.0". Footnote 188 cites Nathan Jurgenson and George Ritzer, "The Internet, Web 2.0, and Beyond", chapter 33 of The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Sociology: the page of the publisher to which the identifier of the footnote leads, copy archived February 10, 2023 (the footnote names no archive), shows the title, the authors and the titles of the sections of the chapter and not its text; for the addresses of the file of the chapter the Wayback Machine answered that it holds no copy. The part read carries nothing of the sentence. The page says "First published: 16 December 2011", where the footnote dates the chapter February 2, 2012. The citation of footnote 188 at sentence 316 is graded Uncheckable.

1.128 Sentence 317 says that in the final stage of the exhaustion of the addresses of Internet Protocol version 4 (IPv4), the last IPv4 address block was assigned in January 2011 at the level of the regional Internet registries. Footnote 189 cites Internet Society, "State of IPv6 Deployment 2017", copy archived April 6, 2018 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the summary, the history and the conclusion read. The source reads: "The Internet Assigned Number Authority (IANA) ran out of IPv4 address space in January 2011, and the RIR for the Asia Pacific region, APNIC, ran out in April, two months later." The source carries the month and the year in which the address space of version 4 of the Internet Protocol (IPv4) ran out at the central authority. The report does not speak of a last address block or of a final stage, and it places January 2011 at that authority and not at the regional Internet registries, which by the report have each run out since, the registry of the Asia Pacific region first, in April. The citation of footnote 189 at sentence 317 is graded Partial.

1.129 Sentence 318 says that IPv4 uses 32-bit addresses, which limits the address space to 2 to the power of 32 addresses, that is, 4,294,967,296 addresses. Footnote 117 cites the same page as at sentence 167. The page is a table of links to reports on the routing table of the Border Gateway Protocol. It says nothing of the length of an address or of the number of addresses. The page cited by footnote 190 at sentence 319 does carry the statement, without the figure of ten digits: "IPv4 uses a 32-bit address scheme allowing for a total of 2^32 addresses (just over 4 billion addresses)." The citation of footnote 117 at sentence 318 is graded Not supported.

1.130 Sentence 319 says that IPv4 is in the process of replacement by Internet Protocol version 6 (IPv6), its successor, which uses 128-bit addresses and provides 2 to the power of 128 addresses, where the marker stands, and, after the marker, it prints that number in 39 digits and calls it a vastly increased address space. Footnote 190 cites Vangie Beal, "What is The Difference Between IPv6 and IPv4?", Webopedia, copy archived January 31, 2011 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the body read; the copy is dated on its face January 27, 2011, where the footnote has January 27, 2010. The marker stands after the abbreviation i.e., and the citation is graded against the words before it: "IPv6 is the successor to Internet Protocol Version 4 (IPv4)." The page says that the new version was reviewed in the standards committees of the Internet Engineering Task Force "to replace the current version of IPv4", and that its addresses are of 128 bits. The source carries the succession, the replacement and the length of the address. The page does not give the number of addresses as a power of two, and a search of it for the digits 340 finds no figure such as the one that follows the marker. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 320, the page says "IPv6 will coexist with the older IPv4 for some time." The citation of footnote 190 at sentence 319 is graded Partial.

1.131 Sentence 320 says that the shift to IPv6 is expected to take a long time to complete. Footnote 189 cites the same page as at sentence 317. A search of the report for the words expect, complete, transition and long time finds no statement that the shift is expected to take a long time to complete. The report uses the words long time once, of the past: "IPv6 has been a project in development or test for a long time, but is now a present reality." It calls it a common myth that the progress of deployment is stalled, and it reports the expectation of the IPv4 Market Group that the count of users of version 6 will exceed 50% of the world in 2019. The citation of footnote 189 at sentence 320 is graded Not supported.

1.132 Sentence 332 says that the term Web 2.0 first appeared in an article of January 1999 called "Fragmented Future", written by Darcy DiNucci, a consultant on electronic information design, and, after the four markers, it prints a quotation from that article. Footnote 191 cites Paul Graham, "Web 2.0", essay dated November 2005 on paulgraham.com, copy archived August 12, 2006 (nearest to the retrieval date August 2, 2006; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched. The four markers stand before the quotation, and each citation is graded against the statement that the term first appeared in the article of January 1999 by Darcy DiNucci. A search of the essay for DiNucci, 1999 and Fragmented finds nothing. The essay dates the author's own first hearing of the term to 2004, in the words that the footnote itself quotes: “I first heard the phrase "Web 2.0" in the name of the Web 2.0 conference in 2004.” The citation of footnote 191 at sentence 332 is graded Not supported. Footnote 192 cites Tim O'Reilly, "What Is Web 2.0", September 30, 2005, an article in five pages: the first page, which is the page at the cited address, copy archived August 10, 2006 (nearest to the retrieval date August 6, 2006; the footnote names no archive), read in full; the four later pages, copies archived August 13, 2006, retrieved in full and searched. A search of the five pages for DiNucci, 1999 and Fragmented finds nothing. The first page gives the term another origin: “The concept of "Web 2.0" began with a conference brainstorming session between O'Reilly and MediaLive International.” The citation of footnote 192 at sentence 332 is graded Not supported. Footnote 193 cites Jonathan Strickland, "How Web 2.0 Works", HowStuffWorks, December 28, 2007, an article in six pages: the first page, which is the page at the cited address, copy archived February 17, 2015 (nearest to the retrieval date February 28, 2015; the footnote names no archive), read in full; the five later pages, copies archived February 25, 2015, February 26, 2015 and March 7, 2015, retrieved in full and searched. A search of the six pages for DiNucci, 1999 and Fragmented finds nothing. The first page gives the term another origin, a brainstorming session of 2004 between O'Reilly Media and MediaLive International: "During this brainstorming session, O'Reilly Media publisher Dale Dougherty coined the phrase Web 2.0 to describe the new Web environment that emerged after the crash." The citation of footnote 193 at sentence 332 is graded Not supported. Footnote 194 cites Darcy DiNucci, "Fragmented Future", a file of three page images at the cited address (copy archived July 26, 2026; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date): pages 32, 221 and 222 of the magazine Print, read in full by optical character recognition and against the images; the second page of the file stands upside down and was turned for reading. The article of Darcy DiNucci prints the passage that the Wikipedia article quotes after the markers, from the words on the Web we know now to "are beginning to appear, and we are just starting to see how that embryo might develop." and on to the list of devices. The source carries an article of Darcy DiNucci that uses the term Web 2.0 and prints the passage. The three pages print no month and no year, and they carry no note on the author, so that neither January 1999 nor the description of her as a consultant on electronic information design stands in the file, and an article cannot itself carry that it was the first appearance of a term. The quotation in the Wikipedia article passes from the words might develop to the words The Web will be understood without a mark of omission, where the magazine begins a new paragraph and prints four sentences between them, and it ends with the words microwave oven, where the magazine prints "and maybe even your microwave (automatically finding" cooking times for products, without the word oven. A graphic in the scan covers the first letters of two lines of the passage, where the quotation has the words screenfuls and Web. The citation of footnote 194 at sentence 332 is graded Partial.

1.133 Sentence 333 says that the term resurfaced during the years 2002 to 2004, where the four markers stand, and, after the markers, that it gained prominence in late 2004 following presentations by Tim O'Reilly and Dale Dougherty at the first Web 2.0 Conference. Footnote 195 cites Kingsley Idehen, "RSS: INJAN (It's not just about news)", entry of a weblog on the site of OpenLink Software, copy archived November 28, 2009 (named), read in full. The four markers stand after the years 2002 to 2004, which the sentence prints as a range, and each citation is graded against the statement that the term resurfaced in those years. The entry uses the term: "(I refer to this as Web 2.0.)". The page dates the entry August 21, 2003 and gives June 22, 2006 as the date of its modification. The source carries one use of the term under a date of 2003. The entry does not say that the term resurfaced, it does not name an earlier use, and it is not of 2002 or of 2004. The citation of footnote 195 at sentence 333 is graded Partial. Footnote 196 cites Kingsley Idehen, "Jeff Bezos Comments about Web Services", entry of the same weblog, copy archived March 7, 2012 (named), read in full. The entry uses the term: "the final stages of the Web 2.0 inflection". The page dates the entry September 25, 2003 and gives June 22, 2006 as the date of its modification. The source carries one use of the term under a date of 2003. The entry does not say that the term resurfaced, and it does not name an earlier use. The citation of footnote 196 at sentence 333 is graded Partial. Footnote 197 cites Eric Knorr, "The Year of Web Services", CIO, issue of December 15, 2003 and January 1, 2004, page 90, in Google Books, read in full from the image of the page. The column ends on the term, which it gives as the term of a named man: "what Scott Dietzen, CTO of BEA Systems, calls the Web 2.0". The source carries one use of the term in December 2003. The column does not say that the term resurfaced, and it does not name an earlier use. The citation of footnote 197 at sentence 333 is graded Partial. Footnote 198 cites John Robb's Weblog, page of the entries of Saturday, August 16, 2003, copy archived September 18, 2003 (named), read in full. The source reads: "WEB 2.0 (Personal Broadcast Networks) is starting to get some traction." The entry ends "Note: I changed the name of this post to Web 2.0 to make it more understandable." The source carries one use of the term in August 2003, in a copy archived in the month after. The entry does not say that the term resurfaced, and it does not name an earlier use. The four sources of the clause bear dates from August 16, 2003 to the issue of December 15, 2003 and January 1, 2004, and none of them is of 2002. The citation of footnote 198 at sentence 333 is graded Partial.

1.134 Sentence 335 says that the unique aspect of this migration, as John Battelle and Tim O'Reilly argued, is that "customers are building your business for you"; the article tags the footnote with the words non-primary source needed. Footnote 199 cites a talk, the opening welcome of Tim O'Reilly and John Battelle in San Francisco on October 5, 2004, and gives no address; one web search for the quoted words on November 15, 2026 returned no transcript and no recording of the talk. The source could not be read. The article itself tags the citation with the words non-primary source needed. None of the source files retrieved for this page prints the quoted words. The citation of footnote 199 at sentence 335 is graded Uncheckable.

1.135 Sentence 339 says that examples of Web 2.0 include social networking services, blogs, wikis, folksonomies, video sharing sites, hosted services, Web applications and mashups. Footnote 200 cites Tim O'Reilly, "Web 2.0: Compact Definition?", O'Reilly Radar, October 1, 2005, with the 45 comments of readers under it, copy archived July 14, 2008 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the post read in full. The post is one definition in one sentence, which begins "Web 2.0 is the network as platform, spanning all connected devices". It gives no examples, and none of the eight examples of the sentence of the article stands in the post. In the comments under the post, which readers wrote, the words mashups, blogging and web applications occur in passing. The citation of footnote 200 at sentence 339 is graded Not supported.

1.136 Sentence 340 says that Terry Flew, in the third edition of New Media, described what he believed to characterize the differences between Web 1.0 and Web 2.0, and it prints his description as a quotation on the move from personal websites to blogs, from publishing to participation, and from content management systems to links based on tagging. Footnote 201 cites Terry Flew, New Media: An Introduction, third edition, Oxford University Press, 2008, page 19: the footnote gives no address, and the record of the edition in Google Books shows no pages. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 201 at sentence 340 is graded Uncheckable.

1.137 Sentence 344 says that the packets into which voice is converted are collected and converted back to analog voice. Footnote 202 cites The Wall Street Journal, article of October 11, 1999: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 202 at sentence 344 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 203 cites The Wall Street Journal, article of May 27, 2003: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 203 at sentence 344 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 204 cites "Packet Softswitches – The Next Generation", page of telephoneworld.org, copy archived June 19, 2024 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "The packets would be collected and converted back to analog voice." The sentence of the article and the sentence before it, sentence 343, are two consecutive sentences of the page of telephoneworld.org, nearly word for word and without quotation marks. The citation of footnote 204 at sentence 344 is graded Supported.

1.138 Sentence 352 says that media consumption statistics show that over half of the media consumption of those aged 18 to 34 was by smartphone. Footnote 205 cites Yanitsa Boyadzhieva, "Media consumption on mobile skyrockets in the US", Mobile World Live, February 12, 2020, copy archived December 7, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date November 1, 2020; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The report gives a figure of the company Nielsen for the third quarter of 2019: "53 per cent of time spent consuming media content by US consumers aged between 18 years and 34 years-old was on a mobile phone or a tablet". The source carries more than half and the ages 18 to 34. The figure is for a mobile phone or a tablet, where the sentence says a smartphone, and it is a figure for the United States in one quarter, where the sentence names no country and no period. The citation of footnote 205 at sentence 352 is graded Partial.

1.139 Sentence 353 says that in the transition to Web 2.0 in the mid-2000s a number of research groups emerged that aimed to improve the existing infrastructure of the Internet. Footnote 206 cites Britt Paris, "Finding time in a future Internet", First Monday, volume 23, number 8, August 6, 2018, copy archived July 20, 2019 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the section on the project Named Data Networking read. The source reads: "As the Internet moved from Web 1.0 to 2.0, the future Internet design (FIND) projects were the first generation of future Internet projects funded by the NSF in 2006." The source carries the move to Web 2.0, the year and projects for a future Internet. The paper speaks of projects that the National Science Foundation funded, where the sentence speaks of research groups that emerged. The citation of footnote 206 at sentence 353 is graded Supported.

1.140 Sentence 354 says that these future Internet groups coalesced around the idea that the current Internet and its legacy protocols were inadequate to support the exponential increase in traffic and the integration of mobile technologies. Footnote 207 cites Hasan Tuncer, Sumita Mishra and Nirmala Shenoy, "A survey of identity and handoff management approaches for the future Internet", Computer Communications 36 (1), December 1, 2012: the preview page of the publisher, copy archived April 18, 2024 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), which shows the abstract, the opening of the introduction, the openings of the sections and the list of references; the preview was read in full, and the article behind the purchase notice was not read. The introduction says: "Despite these changes, the Internet continues to operate based on the legacy principles and protocols." It says that the inclusion of mobile devices and applications has affected performance, scalability and quality of service, and it names the initiatives of the United States, the European Union, Asia and Japan as supporting solutions "to overcome the challenges encountered by the current Internet Architecture". The source carries the legacy protocols, the mobile devices and the common aim of the initiatives. The preview speaks of an unprecedented growth and of the number of devices and networks, where the sentence speaks of an exponential increase in traffic. The citation of footnote 207 at sentence 354 is graded Partial.

1.141 Sentence 355 says that a number of experimental networking schemes and protocols were developed, seeking either to build upon the existing Internet in an evolutionary approach or to supplant it entirely in a clean-slate approach. Footnote 208 cites Lutz Heuser, "Is Europe Leading the Way to the Future Internet?", IEEE Internet Computing 14 (5), September 2010: the record of the article at IEEE Xplore, copy archived April 30, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), whose text shows the title and whose description gives the opening of the abstract; the article was not read. The description of the record begins "In this article, we briefly review US and European approaches to addressing the future Internet's core infrastructure problems." The part read speaks of two approaches, of the United States and of Europe, and carries nothing of experimental schemes and protocols, of an evolutionary approach or of a clean-slate approach. The citation of footnote 208 at sentence 355 is graded Uncheckable.

1.142 Sentence 356 says that these schemes varied in scope but usually prioritized enhanced support for mobile networking, cloud computing, content delivery and user privacy. Footnote 209 cites Nick McKeown and Jennifer Rexford, "How the U.S. National Science Foundation Enabled Software-Defined Networking", Communications of the ACM, posted October 24, 2025, copy archived October 24, 2025 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the opening, the passages on the programs of the Foundation and the conclusion read. The article says of the designs of the programs Future Internet Design and Future Internet Architecture: "The resulting ideas were bold and exciting, including better support for mobility, content delivery, user privacy, secure cloud computing, and more." The source carries the four aims of the sentence, with mobility where the sentence has mobile networking and secure cloud computing where the sentence has cloud computing. The citation of footnote 209 at sentence 356 is graded Supported.

1.143 Sentence 357 says that the most prominent of these future Internet groups included the Future Internet Design (FIND) of the NSF, established in 2006, and its successor, the Future Internet Architecture (FIA), established in 2010. Footnote 210 cites Katharine Gammon, "Networking: Four ways to reinvent the Internet", Nature 463, pages 602 to 604, published online February 3, 2010: the footnote links only an identifier; the text of the feature on the news pages of Nature, copy archived August 1, 2013, retrieved in full and searched; the opening read. The source reads: "Since 2006, for example, the Future Internet Design (FIND) programme run by the US National Science Foundation (NSF) has funded researchers trying to develop wholesale redesigns of the Internet." The source carries the first program, the Foundation and the year 2006. A feature of February 3, 2010 does not name the Future Internet Architecture and cannot carry that it was established in 2010, and it introduces the program with the words for example, not as the most prominent. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the feature spells out TCP/IP as "Transfer Control Protocol/Internet Protocol". The citation of footnote 210 at sentence 357 is graded Partial. Footnote 209 cites the same article as at sentence 356. The source reads: "In 2007, NSF started the FIND program to support new Internet architectures that could be prototyped and evaluated on the GENI test bed." and "The FIND program and its successor Future Internet Architecture (FIA) in 2010 expanded the community". The source carries the two programs, the succession and the year 2010. The article dates the start of the first program to 2007, where the sentence has 2006, the year that the feature cited by footnote 210 and the paper cited by footnote 206 give. The article does not call the two programs the most prominent. The citation of footnote 209 at sentence 357 is graded Partial.

1.144 Sentence 358 says that, following the lead of the NSF, the National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT) of Japan established the AKARI Project in 2006, and the European Union established the Evolved Internet Future for European Leadership (EIFFEL) in 2008. Footnote 207 cites the same preview page as at sentence 354. The preview names, beside the two programs of the National Science Foundation, "the European Union’s sixth and seventh framework [3] programs, the Asia consortium [4], and New Generation Networks [5] in Japan". The source carries programs of Japan and of the European Union beside those of the Foundation. The preview does not name the AKARI Project, the National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT) or the project EIFFEL, it gives no year for any of them, and it does not say that they followed the lead of the Foundation. The citation of footnote 207 at sentence 358 is graded Partial. Footnote 209 cites the same article as at sentence 356. The source reads: "As momentum for clean-slate networking research grew in the U.S., the rest of the world followed suit, such as the EU Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE) program." The source carries that the rest of the world followed the United States, with a program of the European Union as the example. A search of the article for AKARI, EIFFEL, NICT and Japan finds nothing. The citation of footnote 209 at sentence 358 is graded Partial.

1.145 Sentence 360 says that each of these testbeds facilitated the large-scale validation of their networking schemes and protocols. Footnote 207 cites the same preview page as at sentence 354. The source reads: "The Global Environment for Network Innovations (GENI) [6] in the United States and the Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE) [7] in Europe provide large-scale experimental network infrastructure for validation of new protocols and schemes." The source carries the statement for two of the three testbeds that sentence 359 names, and the sentence of the article follows the wording of this sentence. The preview does not name the third, JGN2plus. The citation of footnote 207 at sentence 360 is graded Partial.

1.146 Sentence 361 says that the few tangible results of the future Internet initiatives of the NSF include the increased use of software-defined networking and the proposal for named data networking. Footnote 209 cites the same article as at sentence 356. The article is an account of what the funding of the Foundation did for software-defined networking, and it says that the two programs "fostered many clean-slate network designs with prototypes and real-world evaluation, many leveraged SDN and improved its foundations". The source carries software-defined networking as a result. A search of the article for named data and NDN finds nothing, and the article does not call the results few: its conclusion begins "The investments NSF made in SDN over the past two decades have paid huge dividends." The citation of footnote 209 at sentence 361 is graded Partial. Footnote 206 cites the same paper as at sentence 353. The paper is a study of an application built for Named Data Networking, which it calls "a NSF-funded Future Internet Architecture (FIA) project that is currently underway". The source carries Named Data Networking as a project of the initiatives of the Foundation. A search of the paper for software-defined and SDN finds nothing, and the paper does not speak of few tangible results. The citation of footnote 206 at sentence 361 is graded Partial.

1.147 Sentence 362 says that the Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE) of the European Union and the Global Environment for Network Innovations (GENI) of the NSF, which it names by their initials, dissolved in 2022 and 2023 respectively. Footnote 211 cites the home page of Fed4FIRE+, copy archived April 9, 2026 (nearest to the retrieval date April 6, 2026; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence, and each source carries one half of it. The source reads: "Fed4FIRE+ reached its finish line in June 2022 after more than 5 years of operation." The source carries the end, in 2022, of one project, which the page calls a project under the programme Horizon 2020 of the European Union and the successor of the project Fed4FIRE. The page does not say that the initiative Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE) dissolved, and it says nothing of GENI. The citation of footnote 211 at sentence 362 is graded Partial. Footnote 212 cites "GENI to FABRIC Transition", page of geni.net, copy archived April 14, 2026 (the footnote gives the retrieval date March 14, 2025 and names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "the GENI research network shut down its operations on August 1, 2023". The source carries the end of GENI in 2023. The page says nothing of FIRE. The two footnotes together carry the two years, the first of them for the project Fed4FIRE+. The citation of footnote 212 at sentence 362 is graded Partial.

1.148 Sentence 363 says that the first Internet link into low Earth orbit was established on January 22, 2010, when the astronaut T. J. Creamer posted the first unassisted update to his Twitter account from the International Space Station, marking the extension of the Internet into space. Footnote 213 cites the tweet of the account Astro_TJ, copy of the page of Twitter archived November 8, 2013 (named), read in full. The page dates the tweet "12:13 AM - 22 Jan 10" under the name TJ Creamer. The tweet says "We r now LIVE tweeting from the International Space Station" and calls itself "the 1st live tweet from Space!" The source carries the astronaut, the date and a first live tweet from the station. The tweet does not speak of an Internet link into low Earth orbit, of an unassisted update or of an extension of the Internet into space. The words first unassisted update are the words of the advisory of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) that footnote 214 cites at sentence 366. The citation of footnote 213 at sentence 363 is graded Partial.

1.149 Sentence 366 says that, to browse websites, astronauts can use a laptop computer of the station to control a desktop computer on Earth, and that they can talk to their families and friends on Earth using "Voice over IP" equipment. Footnote 214 cites NASA, media advisory M10-012, "NASA Extends the World Wide Web Out Into Space", dated on its face January 22, 2010, where the footnote has January 24, 2010, copy archived December 13, 2010 (named), read in full. The source reads: "The crew will view the desktop of the ground computer using an onboard laptop and interact remotely with their keyboard touchpad." The advisory says that the crew will continue to have "official e-mail, Internet Protocol telephone and limited videoconferencing capabilities". The source carries the laptop that controls a computer on the ground and the telephone. The advisory does not name families and friends: it speaks of direct private communications that ease the isolation of the crew. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 363, the advisory says that T.J. Creamer "posted the first unassisted update to his Twitter account". The citation of footnote 214 at sentence 366 is graded Partial.

1.150 Sentence 371 says that the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) conducted in November 2008 the first field test of what the sentence says the agency calls a deep space Internet, three words that the sentence prints in quotation marks. Footnote 215 cites NASA, release 08-298, "NASA Successfully Tests First Deep Space Internet", dated on its face November 18, 2008, where the footnote has November 19, 2008, copy archived November 24, 2010 (named), read in full. The source reads: "NASA has successfully tested the first deep space communications network modeled on the Internet." The source carries a first test and, in the title of the release, the three words that the article prints in quotation marks. The release does not date the test to November: "Engineers began a month-long series of DTN demonstrations in October." Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the release says that the method differs from the suite of the Transmission Control Protocol and the Internet Protocol (TCP/IP), "which Cerf co-designed". The citation of footnote 215 at sentence 371 is graded Partial.

1.151 Sentence 372 says that testing of communications based on delay-tolerant networking (DTN), now termed disruption-tolerant networking, between the International Space Station and Earth has been ongoing since March 2009 and was scheduled to continue until March 2014; the article tags the sentence with the words needs update. Footnote 216 cites NASA, fact sheet "Disruption Tolerant Networking for Space Operations (DTN)": the copy that the footnote names, archived July 29, 2012, which bears the date 07.25.12, read in full; the next copy in the list of copies of the Wayback Machine, archived November 8, 2012, which bears the date 11.01.12, read in full; the footnote dates the page July 31, 2012 and gives August 26, 2012 as its retrieval date. The named copy says that two units on board the station "will serve as communications test computers that transmit messages between ISS and ground Mission Control Centers" and gives the duration of the investigation as "March 2009 - October 2013". The later copy gives "March 2009 - March 2014". The source carries the testing between the station and the ground and its start in March 2009. The end that the sentence states, March 2014, is not in the copy that the footnote names, which has October 2013, and stands in the later version of the page. The citation of footnote 216 at sentence 372 is graded Partial.

1.152 Sentence 374 says that, according to a statement of February 2011 by Vint Cerf of Google, the so-called "bundle protocols" have been uploaded to the spacecraft of the EPOXI mission of NASA, which is in orbit around the Sun, and that communication with Earth has been tested at a distance of approximately 80 light seconds. Footnote 217 cites Julie Bort, "Cerf: 2011 will be proving point for 'InterPlanetary Internet'", Network World, February 18, 2011, the first of the two pages of the interview, which is the page at the cited address, copy archived May 24, 2012 (named), read in full; the second page was not read. Vinton Cerf, whom the page introduces as Chief Internet Evangelist for Google, says of the spacecraft EPOXI: "We've uploaded the InterPlanetary protocols to that spacecraft and we've done testing of them at approximately 80 light seconds." He says that the spacecraft "is still in orbit around the sun". The interview uses the words Bundle Protocols of the protocols that run on board the International Space Station. The citation of footnote 217 at sentence 374 is graded Supported.

1.153 Sentence 376 says that each constituent network chooses the technologies and protocols that it deploys from the technical standards that are developed by the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF). Footnote 218 cites RFC 1958, "Architectural Principles of the Internet", B. Carpenter, editor, Internet Architecture Board, June 1996, on the page of the RFC Editor, copy archived October 4, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; sections 1 and 2 read. A search of the RFC for the words Engineering Task Force, constituent, autonomous, each network and deploy finds no statement that each network chooses what it deploys from standards developed by the Internet Engineering Task Force, whose name stands only in the footer of the page. The RFC states principles for the design of protocols. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: section 2.4 carries the statement of the uncited sentence 375: "nobody owns the Internet, there is no centralized control, and nobody can turn it off". Section 2.1 says that in the belief of the community "the goal is connectivity, the tool is the Internet Protocol, and the intelligence is end to end rather than hidden in the network". The citation of footnote 218 at sentence 376 is graded Not supported.

1.154 Sentence 378 says that, for managing the parameters that must be common throughout the network, the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) oversees the allocation and assignment of various technical identifiers. Footnote 219 cites RFC 1174, "IAB Recommended Policy on Distributing Internet Identifier Assignment and IAB Recommended Policy Change to Internet Connected Status", V. Cerf, August 1990, on the page of the RFC Editor, copy archived November 11, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; sections 1 and 2 read. The source reads: "Throughout its entire history, the Internet system has employed a central Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) for the allocation and assignment of various numeric identifiers needed for the operation of the Internet." The sentence of the article follows the wording of this sentence, with technical identifiers for numeric identifiers. The uncited sentence 380 follows the three sentences that come next in the RFC, on the Information Sciences Institute, on the delegation of the numeric identifiers and on the Network Information Center at SRI International. The citation of footnote 219 at sentence 378 is graded Supported.

1.155 Sentence 381 says that Jonathan Postel of the Information Sciences Institute (ISI) managed the IANA, served as RFC Editor and performed other key roles until his death in 1998. Footnote 220 cites a page of the site of the Internet Hall of Fame, which the footnote lists under the Internet Society with the date October 15, 2012 (copy archived January 8, 2023; the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date): the page presents itself in its own text as an article of Wired, the site of that publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and this page does not read the texts of that publisher in copies on other sites. The source was not read for a grade. The citation of footnote 220 at sentence 381 is graded Uncheckable.

1.156 Sentence 384 says that a technical solution came in the form of the Domain Name System, created by Paul Mockapetris of ISI in 1983. Footnote 221 cites Elizabeth Feinler, "Host Tables, Top Level Domain Names and the Origin of Dot Com": the footnote gives the head of a proof of the article in the IEEE Annals of the History of Computing, page 74, and no address; this page read a draft of the article, dated March 28, 2010, posted on the site bortzmeyer.org (copy archived February 8, 2026), retrieved in full and searched, which may differ in wording from the printed article. The draft says that the domain naming system that was ultimately adopted "was developed by Paul Mockapetris", who worked in the group of Jon Postel at the Information Sciences Institute, and that "the draft DNS was published in November 1983 as two final RFCs". The source carries the system, the man, the institute and the year. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the draft says of the years of the changeover, 1984 to 1988, "The Internet was not yet commercial. This did not happen until after 1990". The citation of footnote 221 at sentence 384 is graded Supported.

1.157 Sentence 385 says that the Network Information Center of the Defense Data Network (DDN-NIC) at SRI handled all registration services, including the top-level domains (TLDs) .mil, .gov, .edu, .org, .net, .com and .us, the administration of the root nameservers and the assignment of Internet numbers, under a contract of the United States Department of Defense. Footnote 219 cites the same RFC as at sentence 378. The RFC names the registry: "a single Internet Registry (IR) was designated: the Defense Data Net Network Information Center (DDN-NIC) at SRI International". It has the registry assign network and autonomous system numbers and maintain the list of the root servers of the Domain Name System. The source carries the center at SRI International, the number assignments and the root servers. A search of the RFC for Department of Defense, contract, top-level and the names of the domains finds nothing: the RFC does not list the top-level domains and does not name a contract. The citation of footnote 219 at sentence 385 is graded Partial.

1.158 Sentence 386 says that in 1991 the Defense Information Systems Agency (DISA) awarded the administration and maintenance of the DDN-NIC, managed by SRI up to that point, to Government Systems, Inc., which subcontracted it to the small private-sector company Network Solutions, Inc. Footnote 222 cites RFC 1261, "Transition of NIC Services", S. Williamson and L. Nobile of Network Solutions, September 1991, copy archived December 5, 2025 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source reads: "The transition of the Network Information Center from SRI International in Menlo Park, CA, to Government Systems Inc. in Chantilly, VA, is officially scheduled for 1 October 1991." The RFC names the Defense Information System Agency beside the company. The source carries the year, the transition from SRI International to Government Systems and the agency. The RFC does not speak of an award or of a subcontract: Network Solutions stands in it only as the organization of its two authors. The citation of footnote 222 at sentence 386 is graded Partial. Footnote 223 cites Thomas v. Network Solutions, Inc., memorandum opinion of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia of April 6, 1998, Civ. No. 97-2412, copy archived December 22, 2008 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the cited section I.A read. The source reads: "In 1991, NSI won a subcontract to a procurement contract that Government Services, Inc. (GSI) had been awarded by the Defense Information Services Agency." The source carries the year, the award to the one company and the subcontract to Network Solutions. The opinion says nothing of SRI, and it calls Network Solutions a private company, not a small one. It names the company Government Services and the agency the Defense Information Services Agency, where the RFC cited by footnote 222 has Government Systems and the Defense Information System Agency. The two footnotes together carry the sentence but for the word small. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the same section says that with the Act of 1992 the National Science Foundation "received an expanded mandate to support development of the Internet and to facilitate its use", and section I.B says that the Internet "is the outgrowth of a system known as ARPANET, a network that the military created in 1959". The citation of footnote 223 at sentence 386 is graded Partial.

1.159 Sentence 388 says that in October 1992 the IETF published RFC 1366, where the marker stands, and, after the marker, that the RFC described the "growth of the Internet and its increasing globalization" and set out the basis for an evolution of the IP registry process, based on a regionally distributed registry model. Footnote 224 cites RFC 1366, "Guidelines for Management of IP Address Space", E. Gerich of Merit, October 1992, copy archived October 14, 2025 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the abstract and the first two sections read. The marker stands after the number of the RFC, and the citation is graded against the clause before it. The RFC is dated October 1992. The source carries the month, the year and the document. The RFC does not name the Internet Engineering Task Force as its publisher: its head names the Network Working Group and Merit, and its abstract says that it was reviewed by the Federal Engineering Task Force on behalf of the Federal Networking Council, by the co-chairs of the International Engineering Planning Group and by the Reseaux IP Europeens (RIPE). The words that follow the marker in quotation marks stand in the introduction: "With the growth of the Internet and its increasing globalization". The sentence of the article, with the sentence before it and the two sentences after it, is a run of four consecutive sentences of the journal article that footnote 225 cites at sentences 392 and 396, nearly word for word and without quotation marks. The citation of footnote 224 at sentence 388 is graded Partial.

1.160 Sentence 392 says that the second regional Internet registry (RIR), APNIC, was established in Tokyo in 1993 as a pilot project of the Asia Pacific Networking Group. Footnote 225 cites Daniel Karrenberg, Gerard Ross, Paul Wilson and Leslie Nobile, "Development of the Regional Internet Registry System", The Internet Protocol Journal, volume 4, number 4, December 2001, on the site of Cisco, copy archived January 1, 2016 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the sections on the emergence of the registries read. The source reads: "Asia Pacific Network Information Centre (APNIC), the second RIR, was established in Tokyo in 1993, as a pilot project of APCCIRN". The journal adds that this committee is now the Asia Pacific Networking Group, the name that the sentence uses. The sentence of the article is this sentence of the journal with the name changed, and the sentence before it, sentence 391, follows the statement of the journal that the first registry "was fully operational in May 1992". The citation of footnote 225 at sentence 392 is graded Supported.

1.161 Sentence 395 says that registration services would be provided by Network Solutions, directory and database services by AT&T, and information services by General Atomics. Footnote 226 cites the release of the National Science Foundation of January 5, 1993, "NSF Network Information Services Awards", forwarded on that day to a mailing list of RIPE by Daniel Karrenberg, copy archived November 30, 2025 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: "Network Solutions will provide registration services, AT&T will provide directory and database services, and General Atomics will provide information services." The release also bears on the uncited sentence 394: it has a solicitation of the spring of 1992, three organizations competitively selected to receive cooperative agreements, and the name INTERNIC for the three awards together. The citation of footnote 226 at sentence 395 is graded Supported.

1.162 Sentence 396 says that over time, after consultation with the IANA, the IETF, the RIPE Network Coordination Centre (RIPE NCC), APNIC and the Federal Networking Council (FNC), the decision was made to separate the management of domain names from the management of IP numbers. Footnote 225 cites the same article as at sentence 392. The source reads: "Over time, after lengthy consultation with the IANA, the IETF, RIPE NCC, APNIC, the NSF, and the Federal Networking Council (FNC), a further consensus was reached in the general Internet community to separate the management of domain names from the management of IP numbers." The sentence of the article is this sentence with the word lengthy and the National Science Foundation left out, and with a decision in the place of a consensus of the general Internet community. The two sentences that follow it in the article, sentences 397 and 398, follow the next two sentences of the journal. The citation of footnote 225 at sentence 396 is graded Supported.

1.163 Sentence 398 says that, as a result, the American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) was established in December 1997 as an independent, not-for-profit corporation by direction of the NSF, and became the third regional Internet registry. Footnote 227 cites National Science Foundation, press release 97-046 of June 24, 1997, "Internet Moves Toward Privatization", copy archived September 23, 2008 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: "The NSF has approved a plan from Network Solutions, Inc. (NSI) which establishes the American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN)." The source carries the registry, a non-profit organization and the part of the Foundation, and it says that the registry is patterned after the registration activities of Europe and of Asia. A release of June 24, 1997 speaks of the change as a thing to come, "expected to be fully implemented before March 1998", and cannot carry an establishment in December 1997. The release has the Foundation approve a plan of Network Solutions, where the sentence says by direction of the Foundation. The opening of the sentence, with the month and the word independent, follows the journal article cited by footnote 225. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the release quotes George Strawn, director of the Networking and Communications Research and Infrastructure division of the Foundation: "The Internet is no longer in its infancy. It is growing up into a commercially based, self-regulating entity." The citation of footnote 227 at sentence 398 is graded Partial.

1.164 Sentence 400 says that, as these tasks involved technical coordination for two principal Internet name spaces created by the IETF, the names of the Domain Name System (DNS) and IP addresses, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) also signed a memorandum of understanding with the Internet Architecture Board (IAB) to define the technical work to be carried out by the IANA. Footnote 228 cites RFC 2860, "Memorandum of Understanding Concerning the Technical Work of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority", B. Carpenter, F. Baker and M. Roberts, June 2000, on the page of the RFC Editor, copy archived November 11, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The RFC records the text of a memorandum "signed on March 1, 2000 between the IETF and ICANN". Its first article says that its intent is "to define the technical work to be carried out by the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority", words that the sentence of the article repeats. The source carries the memorandum, the corporation and the purpose. The memorandum is an agreement with the Internet Engineering Task Force, not with the Internet Architecture Board, whose chair signs under the words approved by. Nor does the memorandum rest on the name spaces of domain names and addresses, as the sentence has it: article 4.3 names the assignment of domain names and of blocks of addresses as two spaces with policy issues and says "These policy issues are outside the scope of this MOU." The citation of footnote 228 at sentence 400 is graded Partial.

1.165 Sentence 401 says that the management of Internet address space remained with the regional Internet registries, which collectively were defined as a supporting organization within the structure of ICANN. Footnote 229 cites Bylaws of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), as amended March 16, 2012, copy archived April 13, 2012 (nearest to the retrieval date April 10, 2012; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; article VIII read. Article VIII says: "The ASO shall be the entity established by the Memorandum of Understanding entered on 21 October 2004 between ICANN and the Number Resource Organization (NRO), an organization of the existing regional Internet registries (RIRs)." The source carries a supporting organization of the registries within the structure of the corporation. The bylaws do not say that the management of the address space remained with the registries: they give the Address Supporting Organization the task to "advise the Board with respect to policy issues relating to the operation, assignment, and management of Internet addresses". The citation of footnote 229 at sentence 401 is graded Partial.

1.166 Sentence 407 says that the standardization efforts of the working groups are often adopted by the Internet community, but that the IETF does not control or patrol the Internet. Footnote 230 cites P. Hoffman and S. Harris, "The Tao of IETF: A Novice's Guide to the Internet Engineering Task Force", the version on the site of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), which is dated June 2006 in its head and says that it is based on a draft that will become an RFC, copy archived September 24, 2006 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; section 3 read. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source reads: "The IETF makes standards that are often adopted by Internet users, but it does not control, or even patrol, the Internet." The sentence of the article follows this sentence. The citation of footnote 230 at sentence 407 is graded Supported. Footnote 231 cites RFC 3935, "A Mission Statement for the IETF", H. Alvestrand, October 2004, copy archived March 1, 2020 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the mission statement read. The source reads: "The mission of the IETF is to produce high quality, relevant technical and engineering documents that influence the way people design, use, and manage the Internet". The RFC says that "when the IETF is not responsible for a protocol or function, it does not attempt to exert control over it". The source carries documents that are meant to influence and a limit that the Task Force sets to its own control. The RFC does not say that the standards are often adopted, and it does not say that the Task Force does not control or patrol the Internet. The citation of footnote 231 at sentence 407 is graded Partial.

1.167 Sentence 416 says that the number of attendees of the meetings of the IETF from outside the United States is typically about 50 percent, even at meetings held in the United States. Footnote 230 cites the same page as at sentence 407. The source reads: "About one in three IETF meetings are now held in Europe or Asia". The same sentence gives the share of the attendees from outside the United States as "about 50%, even at meetings held in the US". Sentences 415 and 416 of the article are the two halves of this one sentence of the page. The citation of footnote 230 at sentence 416 is graded Supported.

1.168 Sentence 420 says that the IETF works closely with and under the supervision of the Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG), where the first marker stands, and of the IAB. Footnote 232 cites RFC 3710, "An IESG Charter", H. Alvestrand, February 2004, copy archived August 17, 2019 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; section 1 read. The marker stands after the name of the group, and the citation is graded against the words before it. The source reads: "The Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG) is the group responsible for the direct operation of the IETF and for ensuring the quality of work produced by the IETF." The citation of footnote 232 at sentence 420 is graded Supported. Footnote 233 cites RFC 2850, "Charter of the Internet Architecture Board (IAB)", B. Carpenter, editor, May 2000, copy archived August 24, 2019 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; sections 1 and 2 read. The citation is graded against the last words of the sentence, on the Board. The charter gives the Board the oversight of the architecture and of the standards process: "The IAB provides oversight of the process used to create Internet Standards". The charter calls the Board a committee of the Task Force: "The IAB is chartered both as a committee of the IETF and as an advisory body of the Internet Society." The citation of footnote 233 at sentence 420 is graded Supported.

1.169 Sentence 421 says that the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF) and the Internet Research Steering Group (IRSG), peer activities to the IETF and the IESG under the general supervision of the IAB, focus on longer-term research issues. Footnote 230 cites the same page as at sentence 407. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source reads: "The IRTF is tasked to consider long-term research problems in the Internet." The page says that the Board changed its structure to leave two task forces, this one and the Internet Engineering Task Force. The source carries the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF), its place beside the other task force under the Board and its long-term research. A search of the page for IRSG and Research Steering finds nothing: the page does not name the Internet Research Steering Group. The citation of footnote 230 at sentence 421 is graded Partial. Footnote 234 cites RFC 4440, "IAB Thoughts on the Role of the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF)", S. Floyd, V. Paxson and A. Falk, editors, March 2006, copy archived April 14, 2021 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; sections 1 and 2 read. The source reads: "The IRTF was tasked to consider long-term research problems in the Internet, and the IETF was to concentrate on short- to medium-term engineering issues related to the Internet." The RFC says that the chair of the Research Task Force is appointed by the Board and charters research groups in consultation with the Internet Research Steering Group and the Board. The citation of footnote 234 at sentence 421 is graded Supported.

1.170 Sentence 422 says that RFCs are the main documentation for the work of the IAB, the IESG, the IETF and the IRTF. Footnote 235 cites "RFCs", page of the site of the IETF, copy archived November 4, 2023 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "The RFC Series includes documents produced by the IETF, the Internet Architecture Board (IAB), the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF), and independent submitters." The source carries three of the four bodies of the sentence as producers of the documents. The page does not name the Internet Engineering Steering Group among the producers, it names independent submitters, whom the sentence leaves out, and it does not call the series the main documentation of the work of these bodies. The citation of footnote 235 at sentence 422 is graded Partial.

1.171 Sentence 425 says that the RFCs were edited by Jon Postel, the first RFC Editor. Footnote 230 cites the same page as at sentence 407. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The page names Jon Postel as the founder of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority and says of the two offices "both the RFC Editor and IANA involved the same people for many years". It does not say that Jon Postel edited the RFCs or that he was the first RFC Editor. The citation of footnote 230 at sentence 425 is graded Not supported. Footnote 236 cites RFC 4844, "The RFC Series and RFC Editor", L. Daigle, editor, July 2007, copy archived August 20, 2019 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; sections 1 and 3 read. The source reads: "Originally, there was a single person acting as editor of the RFC Series (the RFC Editor)." The source carries a first editor who was one person. The RFC does not name him: a search of it for Postel finds the name only in the list of references, as an author of RFC 2223. The citation of footnote 236 at sentence 425 is graded Partial.

1.172 Sentence 426 says that RFCs cover a wide range of information, from proposed standards, draft standards, full standards and best practices to experimental protocols, history and other informational topics. Footnote 237 cites RFC 1796, "Not All RFCs are Standards", C. Huitema, J. Postel and S. Crocker, April 1995, on the page of the RFC Editor, copy archived November 4, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The RFC says that each RFC has a status, which is "Informational, Experimental, or Standards Track (Proposed Standard, Draft Standard, Internet Standard), or Historic". The source carries six of the seven kinds that the sentence lists. The RFC of April 1995 does not name best practices. The citation of footnote 237 at sentence 426 is graded Partial.

1.173 Sentence 431 says that if the standard that an RFC describes changes, or its information becomes obsolete, the revised standard or updated information will be re-published as a new RFC that "obsoletes" the original. Footnote 230 cites the same page as at sentence 407. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source reads: “If the standard it describes changes, the standard will be re-published in another RFC that "obsoletes" the first.” Sentences 430 and 431 of the article follow two consecutive sentences of section 3.2.5 of the page, the first of them word for word. The citation of footnote 230 at sentence 431 is graded Supported. Footnote 236 cites the same RFC as at sentence 425. A search of the RFC for obsolete, supersede, republish and never revised finds no statement on the republication of an RFC. The RFC is a framework for the management of the series. The citation of footnote 236 at sentence 431 is graded Not supported.

1.174 Sentence 435 says that there are currently more than 90 chapters of the Internet Society around the world. Footnote 238 cites the home page of the Internet Society, copy archived November 13, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date, and the title that it gives is not the title of this copy), read in full. The copy names chapters of the Society, among them "Internet Society Ghana Chapter", under the label "Chapters and SIGs". The source carries chapters around the world. The copy gives no number of chapters. The citation of footnote 238 at sentence 435 is graded Partial.

1.175 Sentence 437 says that the Internet Society (ISOC) also promotes understanding and appreciation of the Internet model of open, transparent processes and consensus-based decision-making. Footnote 239 cites "ISOC's Standards Activities", page of the Internet Society, copy archived December 13, 2011 (named), read in full. The page says of the Internet Engineering Task Force, the Internet Research Task Force and the Internet Architecture Board: "These organizations are all open, transparent, and rely on a bottom-up consensus-building process to develop standards." The source carries the open and transparent process and the consensus, as a statement of the Internet Society (ISOC) about three bodies. The page does not say that the Society promotes the understanding and appreciation of an Internet model. The citation of footnote 239 at sentence 437 is graded Partial.

1.176 Sentence 441 says that these objections have led ICANN to remove itself from relationships, first with the University of Southern California in 2000, where the first marker stands, and that in September 2009 it gained autonomy from the government of the United States by the ending of its longstanding agreements, although some contractual obligations with the Department of Commerce continued. Footnote 240 cites "USC/ICANN Transition Agreement", page of the site of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), copy archived October 5, 2008 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the recitals and articles 1 and 5 read. The marker stands after the year 2000, and the citation is graded against the words before it. The agreement is one by which the University of Southern California transfers to the corporation the functions that it performed as the project of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority: "IANA relinquishes and ICANN assumes the performance of the following functions and responsibilities". The source carries a separation of those functions from the university. The agreement says nothing of objections, and it is not of 2000: its effective date is "the later of (i) January 1, 1999 at 12:01 a.m. and (ii) the date upon which Governmental Approval is received", and the date of the footnote, May 14, 2000, is the date on which the page says it was updated. The agreement keeps the corporation at the computer facility of the university for two years after the effective date. The citation of footnote 240 at sentence 441 is graded Partial. Footnote 241 cites Nate Anderson, "ICANN cuts cord to US government, gets broader oversight", Ars Technica, September 30, 2009, copy archived December 2, 2012 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The three markers stand together at the end of the sentence, and the citations are graded against the words after the marker of footnote 240. The source reads: "The many-times-amended Memorandum of Understanding between the two groups was replaced today with a new Affirmation of Commitments". The source carries the day, the end of the memorandum and the autonomy, which the article calls breaking free of the Department of Commerce. The article does not speak of contractual obligations that continued: it says "the US government still has an oversight position". Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the article calls Vinton Cerf a man "who helped invent the 'Net". The citation of footnote 241 at sentence 441 is graded Partial. Footnote 242 cites The Wall Street Journal, article of October 2, 2009: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 242 at sentence 441 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 243 cites The Wall Street Journal, a second article of October 2, 2009: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 243 at sentence 441 is graded Uncheckable.

1.177 Sentence 442 says that on October 1, 2016 ICANN ended its contract with the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) of the United States Department of Commerce, allowing oversight to pass to the global Internet community. Footnote 244 cites the announcement of ICANN of October 1, 2016, "Stewardship of IANA Functions Transitions to Global Internet Community as Contract with U.S. Government Ends", copy archived October 2, 2016 (nearest to the retrieval date October 1, 2016; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "Today, 1 October 2016, the contract between the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) and the United States Department of Commerce National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), to perform the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) functions, has officially expired." The announcement says that the contract expired, where the sentence says that the corporation ended it. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the announcement calls the day "the transition of the coordination and management of the Internet’s unique identifiers to the private-sector, a process that has been committed to and underway since 1998". The citation of footnote 244 at sentence 442 is graded Supported.

1.178 Sentence 446 says that the first meeting of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) was held in October and November 2006, with follow-up meetings annually thereafter. Footnote 245 cites Milton L. Mueller, Networks and States: The Global Politics of Internet Governance, MIT Press: the footnote cites page 67 of the edition of 2010 and links a copy at the Internet Archive that is lent only to registered borrowers and was not read; this page read pages 67, 116 and 117 of the paperback of 2013 from their images in the preview of Google Books, and searched that edition there for the first meeting of the forum. Page 67 tells of the Working Group on Internet Governance, of its report of July 2005 and of its proposal for a forum. It says nothing of a first meeting of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF), of October and November 2006 or of yearly meetings. The same edition speaks of the first meeting at page 117, where the agenda of the first "annual meeting in Athens was very dovish in nature", without a month or a year on that page. The citation of footnote 245 at sentence 446 is graded Not supported.

1.179 Sentence 447 says that since the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) the term "Internet governance" has been broadened beyond narrow technical concerns to include a wider range of Internet-related policy issues. Footnote 246 cites the same book: the footnote cites pages 79 and 80 of the edition of 2010; this page read pages 79 and 80 of the paperback of 2013 from their images in the preview of Google Books. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The last sentence of page 79 says that before the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) "Internet governance was a term strongly associated with the relatively narrow set of issues dealt with by ICANN.", and the first sentence of page 80 says that after the Summit "it is now widely interpreted to include practically any transnational policy issue associated with the Internet". The book says the narrow set of issues dealt with by ICANN, where the sentence says narrow technical concerns. The citation of footnote 246 at sentence 447 is graded Supported. Footnote 247 cites Laura DeNardis, "The Emerging Field of Internet Governance", chapter 26 of The Oxford Handbook of Internet Studies: the page of the chapter at Oxford Academic, copy archived December 1, 2025 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), shows the abstract and offers the chapter after a sign-in; the abstract was read in full, and the chapter was not read. The source reads: "Internet governance generally refers to policy and technical coordination issues related to the exchange of information over the Internet." The source carries a term that covers policy as well as technical coordination. The abstract does not name the World Summit on the Information Society, and it does not say that the term was broadened. The citation of footnote 247 at sentence 447 is graded Partial.

1.180 Sentence 448 calls Tim Berners-Lee the "inventor of the web" and says that he was becoming concerned about threats to its future and that in November 2009, at the IGF in Washington DC, he launched the World Wide Web Foundation (WWWF) "to campaign to make the web a safe and empowering tool for the good of humanity with access to all". Footnote 248 cites Pallab Ghosh, "Warning sounded on web's future", BBC News, September 15, 2008, copy archived September 16, 2008 (named), read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The report says that Tim Berners-Lee "was increasingly worried about the way the web has been used to spread disinformation" and that he spoke "prior to the unveiling of a Foundation he has co-created that aims to make the web truly worldwide". The source carries the concern, the foundation and its aim of access. A report of September 15, 2008 speaks of the unveiling as a thing to come and cannot carry a launch in November 2009 at a forum. The citation of footnote 248 at sentence 448 is graded Partial. Footnote 249 cites Janna Quitney Anderson, "Tim Berners-Lee launches 'WWW Foundation' at IGF 2009", Ars Technica, which the page marks as last updated November 16, 2009, where the footnote has November 17, 2009, copy archived April 16, 2011 (named), read in full. The source reads: "The place Berners-Lee chose to officially launch the new foundation was the Internet Governance Forum (IGF)." The report quotes him: "We want it to empower people. We want it to do the very best for humanity." The source carries the launch at the forum in November 2009 and the aim. The report places the forum not in Washington DC but in Egypt: "The smiling Berners-Lee was standing in a palms-surrounded conference center in Sharm El Sheikh, in the Sinai Desert." Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the report says "Just 40 or so years ago, in 1969, the Internet was getting off the ground as a simple connection between two computers.", and it names among those present "Robert Kahn, a co-inventor of the Internet protocol". The citation of footnote 249 at sentence 448 is graded Partial.

1.181 Sentence 449 says that in November 2019, at the IGF in Berlin, Tim Berners-Lee and the WWWF went on to launch the Contract for the Web, a campaign initiative to persuade governments, companies and citizens to commit to nine principles to stop "misuse", and it quotes a warning that begins "If we don't act now". Footnote 250 cites "Web inventor Tim Berners-Lee launches plan to stop Internet abuse", CNA, November 25, 2019, a report credited to the agency AFP, copy archived November 25, 2019 (named), read in full. The report says that Tim Berners-Lee “unveiled a "Contract for the Web" to halt "misuse" by governments, companies and individuals”, as leaders gathered in Berlin for the Internet Governance Forum, and it prints the warning that the article quotes, which ends "we are at risk of squandering" its potential for good. The source carries the month, the forum in Berlin, the contract, the word misuse and the warning. A search of the report for nine and principle finds nothing: the report does not give the number of the principles. The citation of footnote 250 at sentence 449 is graded Partial.

1.182 Sentence 458 says that on April 23, 2014 the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) was reported to be considering a new rule that would permit Internet service providers to offer content providers a faster track to send content, thus reversing its earlier net neutrality position. Footnote 251 cites The New York Times, report of Edward Wyatt of April 23, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The three markers stand together at the end of the sentence, and all three footnotes cite this publisher. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 251 at sentence 458 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 252 cites The New York Times, editorial of April 24, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 252 at sentence 458 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 253 cites The New York Times, column of David Carr of May 11, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 253 at sentence 458 is graded Uncheckable.

1.183 Sentence 459 says that a possible solution to net neutrality concerns may be municipal broadband, according to Professor Susan Crawford, a legal and technology expert at Harvard Law School. Footnote 254 cites The New York Times, article of Susan Crawford of April 28, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 254 at sentence 459 is graded Uncheckable.

1.184 Sentence 460 says that on May 15, 2014 the FCC decided to consider two options regarding Internet services: first, to permit fast and slow broadband lanes, thereby compromising net neutrality; and second, to reclassify broadband as a telecommunication service, thereby preserving net neutrality. Footnote 255 cites The New York Times, editorial of May 15, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence, and both footnotes cite this publisher. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 255 at sentence 460 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 256 cites The New York Times, report of Edward Wyatt of May 15, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 256 at sentence 460 is graded Uncheckable.

1.185 Sentence 461 says that on November 10, 2014 President Obama recommended that the FCC reclassify broadband Internet service as a telecommunications service in order to preserve net neutrality. Footnote 257 cites The New York Times, report of Edward Wyatt of November 10, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The three markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 257 at sentence 461 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 258 cites The New York Times, editorial of November 14, 2014: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 258 at sentence 461 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 259 cites Wired, article of Daniel A. Sepulveda of January 21, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The article is dated ten weeks after the recommendation that the sentence reports, and one day after the retrieval date that the footnote gives, January 20, 2015. The citation of footnote 259 at sentence 461 is graded Uncheckable.

1.186 Sentence 462 says that on January 16, 2015 Republicans presented legislation, in the form of a discussion draft of a bill of the House of Representatives, that makes concessions to net neutrality but prohibits the FCC from accomplishing the goal or enacting any further regulation affecting Internet service providers. Footnote 260 cites The New York Times, report of Jonathan Weisman of January 19, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 260 at sentence 462 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 261 cites a discussion draft of a bill of the House of Representatives, 114th Congress, 1st Session, to amend the Communications Act of 1934, a file of 7 pages stamped January 16, 2015, on the site of the Committee on Energy and Commerce, copy archived January 20, 2015 (named), read in full. The draft would bar a provider of broadband Internet access service from blocking, from throttling and from paid prioritization, and it would have the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) enforce these obligations, but the Commission "may not expand the Internet openness obligations for provision of broadband Internet access service beyond the obligations established in such subsection, whether by rulemaking or otherwise". Its title adds that broadband shall be considered an information service and that the Commission may not rely on section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 as a grant of authority. The source carries the date, the draft, the concessions and the limits on the Commission. The draft names no party and no sponsor, the place of the sponsor being blank. The news guide of the Associated Press that footnote 264 cites at sentence 463 says "Republicans have pitched an idea that would enforce basic open Internet rules". The citation of footnote 261 at sentence 462 is graded Partial.

1.187 Sentence 463 says that on January 31, 2015 the Associated Press, which the sentence names as AP News, reported that the FCC will present the notion of applying, "with some caveats", Title II (common carrier) of the Communications Act of 1934 to the Internet in a vote expected on February 26, 2015. Footnote 262 cites The New York Times, report of Steve Lohr of February 2, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The five markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 262 at sentence 463 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 263 cites The New York Times, post of Steve Lohr of February 2, 2015 on a weblog of the newspaper: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 263 at sentence 463 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 264 cites Anne Flaherty, "Just whose Internet is it? New federal rules may answer that", Associated Press, January 31, 2015, on a page of Excite News, copy archived February 1, 2015 (nearest to the retrieval date January 31, 2015; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The guide says of the proposal of the chairman, Tom Wheeler: "He has suggested it probably will apply Title II regulation to all Internet service, including wireless, but with some caveats." The source reads: "The commissioners will vote Feb. 26." The three words that the article prints in quotation marks stand in the guide. Of the five footnotes of the sentence, this is the report of the Associated Press that the sentence names. The citation of footnote 264 at sentence 463 is graded Supported. Footnote 265 cites Brian Fung, "Get ready: The FCC says it will vote on net neutrality in February", The Washington Post, January 2, 2015, copy archived January 3, 2015 (nearest to the retrieval date January 2, 2015; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The report says that the regulators "will introduce and vote on new proposed net neutrality rules in February", and that the agency is scheduled to hold its monthly meeting on February 26. The source carries the vote and its day. A report of January 2, 2015 cannot carry what the Associated Press reported on January 31, and it says of the proposal that it is still unclear what rules the chairman has in mind. The citation of footnote 265 at sentence 463 is graded Partial. Footnote 266 cites "FCC to vote next month on net neutrality rules", Associated Press, January 2, 2015, on a page of Excite News, copy archived January 3, 2015 (nearest to the retrieval date January 2, 2015; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "Details of the draft proposal weren't disclosed." The source carries a vote expected in February. A report of January 2, 2015 cannot carry the report of January 31, and it does not carry Title II with caveats or the day of the vote. The citation of footnote 266 at sentence 463 is graded Partial.

1.188 Sentence 464 says that adoption of this notion would reclassify Internet service from one of information to one of telecommunications, where the first marker stands, and, according to Tom Wheeler, chairman of the FCC, ensure net neutrality. Footnote 267 cites The New York Times, report of Steve Lohr of February 4, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The marker stands after the word telecommunications. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 267 at sentence 464 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 268 cites Wired, article of Tom Wheeler of February 4, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 268 at sentence 464 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 269 cites The New York Times, editorial of February 6, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 269 at sentence 464 is graded Uncheckable.

1.189 Sentence 465 says that the FCC is expected to enforce net neutrality in its vote, according to The New York Times. Footnote 270 cites The New York Times, report of Jonathan Weisman of February 24, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence, and both footnotes cite the newspaper that the sentence names. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 270 at sentence 465 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 271 cites The New York Times, report of Steve Lohr of February 25, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 271 at sentence 465 is graded Uncheckable.

1.190 Sentence 466 says that on February 26, 2015 the FCC ruled in favor of net neutrality by applying Title II (common carrier) of the Communications Act of 1934 and Section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 to the Internet. Footnote 272 cites Federal Communications Commission, news release of February 26, 2015, "FCC Adopts Strong, Sustainable Rules to Protect the Open Internet", a file of 5 pages, copy archived February 26, 2015 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The three markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The release says that the Order relies on "multiple sources of authority including both Title II of the Communications Act and Section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996". It records the action of February 26, 2015, with three members for it and two dissenting. The citation of footnote 272 at sentence 466 is graded Supported. Footnote 273 cites The New York Times, report of Rebecca R. Ruiz and Steve Lohr of February 26, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 273 at sentence 466 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 274 cites Anne Flaherty, "FACT CHECK: Talking heads skew 'net neutrality' debate", Associated Press, February 25, 2015, on a page of Excite News, copy archived February 26, 2015 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The source reads: "The Federal Communications Commission will vote Thursday on whether to put Internet service in the same regulatory camp as your telephone." The source carries the vote as a thing to come and Title II of the Communications Act of 1934. A report of February 25, 2015, the day before, cannot carry the ruling, and a search of it for 706 finds nothing. The citation of footnote 274 at sentence 466 is graded Partial.

1.191 Sentence 467 says that the chairman of the FCC, Tom Wheeler, commented that this is no more a plan to regulate the Internet than the First Amendment is a plan to regulate free speech, and that both stand for the same concept. Footnote 275 cites Dana Liebelson, "Net Neutrality Prevails In Historic FCC Vote", The Huffington Post, February 26, 2015, copy archived February 27, 2015 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The report quotes the chairman word for word as the article does: "This is no more a plan to regulate the Internet than the First Amendment is a plan to regulate free speech. They both stand for the same concept." The citation of footnote 275 at sentence 467 is graded Supported.

1.192 Sentence 468 says that on March 12, 2015 the FCC released the specific details of the net neutrality rules. Footnote 276 cites The New York Times, report of Rebecca R. Ruiz of March 12, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The three markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 276 at sentence 468 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 277 cites The New York Times, interactive page of Jeff Sommer of March 12, 2015: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 277 at sentence 468 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 278 cites Federal Communications Commission, Report and Order on Remand, Declaratory Ruling, and Order, FCC 15-24, in the matter of Protecting and Promoting the Open Internet, GN Docket No. 14-28, a file of 400 pages, copy archived March 13, 2015 (the retrieval date; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full, text extracted and searched; the head read. The head of the order reads "Adopted: February 26, 2015" and "Released: March 12, 2015". The file is itself the text of the rules whose release the sentence reports. The citation of footnote 278 at sentence 468 is graded Supported.

1.193 Sentence 469 says that on April 13, 2015 the FCC published the final rule on its new "Net Neutrality" regulations. Footnote 279 cites Don Reisinger, report of CNET of April 13, 2015 on the publication of the rules, copy archived April 14, 2015 (nearest to the retrieval date April 13, 2015; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source reads: "The Federal Communications Commission's rules for a free and open Internet were published Monday in the Federal Register". The report uses the words Net neutrality of the rules. The citation of footnote 279 at sentence 469 is graded Supported. Footnote 280 cites Federal Communications Commission, "Protecting and Promoting the Open Internet", rule in the Federal Register, 80 FR 19737, copy archived May 2, 2015 (the footnote gives the retrieval date April 13, 2015 and names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the head read. The head of the document reads "Publication Date: Monday, April 13, 2015" and "Action: Final rule." The source carries the day, the Commission and the final rule. A search of the page for the words net neutrality, which the article prints in quotation marks, finds nothing: the rule speaks throughout of the open Internet. The citation of footnote 280 at sentence 469 is graded Partial.

1.194 Sentence 470 says that on December 14, 2017 the FCC repealed its decision of March 12, 2015 on net neutrality rules by a vote of 3 to 2. Footnote 281 cites The New York Times, report of Cecilia Kang of December 14, 2017: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 281 at sentence 470 is graded Uncheckable.

1.195 Sentence 474 says that, although the history is undocumented, among the first systems to have a facility for electronic mail were the Q32 of the System Development Corporation (SDC) and the Compatible Time-Sharing System (CTSS) at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Footnote 282 cites The Risks Digest, volume 20, issue 25, March 20, 1999, moderated by Peter G. Neumann, item "Great moments in e-mail history", copy archived December 1, 2005 (the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the item read in full. The item is a reader's note on a magazine story, with a comment that the moderator signs with his initials. The comment names "the CTSS e-mail system written by Tom Van Vleck and Noel Morris, which I used during the early Multics days in 1965". The source carries the mail of the Compatible Time-Sharing System (CTSS) among the early systems. A search of the issue for Q32, SDC and System Development finds nothing. And where the sentence calls the history undocumented, the comment gives a paper reference for the mail of that system, a staff note that it dates before January 8, 1965. The other system of the sentence stands on the page that footnote 283 cites at sentence 476. The citation of footnote 282 at sentence 474 is graded Partial.

1.196 Sentence 476 says that an experimental inter-system transferred mail on the ARPANET shortly after its creation. Footnote 283 cites Tom Van Vleck, "The History of Electronic Mail", page of multicians.org, copy archived December 25, 2005 (nearest to the retrieval date December 23, 2005; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the sections on the two early systems and on mail on the ARPANET read. The source reads: "Larry Roberts supposedly wrote a TECO macro that would send mail messages across the prototype ARPANet in 1969". The source carries an early sending of mail across the ARPANET. The page gives it as a report for which it does not vouch, with the word supposedly, and it places a working method of mail between hosts in early 1972. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 474, the page says "I am informed that SDC's Q32 operating system had both MAIL and inter-user messages (DIAL facility) before the fall of 1965." The citation of footnote 283 at sentence 476 is graded Partial.

1.197 Sentence 477 says that in 1971 Ray Tomlinson created what was to become the standard Internet electronic mail addressing format, using the @ sign to separate mailbox names from host names. Footnote 284 cites Ray Tomlinson, "The First Network Email": the archived copy that the footnote names, of May 6, 2006, is a page of frames; the two frames of text were read in full in copies archived June 10, 2007. The source reads: "I chose to append an at sign and the host name to the user's (login) name." and "These first messages were sent in late 1971." The source carries the year, the man and the at sign between the name of the user and the name of the host. The page does not say that the form became the standard format of Internet electronic mail addresses. The page that footnote 283 cites dates his mail programs to March 1972, on the authority of a chronology of Larry Roberts, and says that his "achievement was to choose the @ sign to separate username from host name in mail addresses". The citation of footnote 284 at sentence 477 is graded Partial.

1.198 Sentence 491 says that the File Transfer Protocol (FTP) for use on the Internet was standardized in 1985 and is still in use today. Footnote 285 cites RFC 959, "File Transfer Protocol (FTP)", J. Postel and J. Reynolds, October 1985, on the page of the RFC Editor, copy archived November 5, 2026 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), retrieved in full and searched; the head and sections 1 and 2.1 read. The source reads: "This memo is the official specification of the File Transfer Protocol (FTP)." The source carries an official specification of October 1985. An RFC of 1985 cannot carry that the protocol is still in use today. And the RFC presents itself as a new edition and not as the first standard: its history begins with mechanisms proposed in 1971, has a new official specification by July 1973, and says that this edition is to correct minor errors of documentation and to add optional commands to the specification of RFC 765, which it replaces. The citation of footnote 285 at sentence 491 is graded Partial.

1.199 Sentence 493 says that in 1999 Napster became the first peer-to-peer file sharing system. Footnote 286 cites Kenneth P. Birman, Reliable Distributed Systems, Springer, 2005, page 532: the cited page is not shown in the preview of Google Books, and the copy at the Internet Archive that the footnote links is lent only to registered borrowers and was not read; pages 530 and 531 were read from their images in the preview. The cited page could not be read. By the table of contents of the book, section 25.1.1, Napster, begins on it. The two pages before it name Napster as a means of sharing music between peers, without a year and without calling it the first. The citation of footnote 286 at sentence 493 is graded Uncheckable.

1.200 Sentence 495 says that a variety of peer-to-peer file sharing programs and services with different levels of decentralization and anonymity followed, including Gnutella, eDonkey2000 and Freenet in 2000, FastTrack, Kazaa, Limewire and BitTorrent in 2001, and Poisoned in 2003. Footnote 287 cites Richard Menta, "Napster Clones Crush Napster. Take 6 out of the Top 10 Downloads on CNet", MP3 Newswire, July 20, 2001, copy archived March 4, 2016 (named), read in full. The report says of the programs that came after Napster that "these services have intentionally designed themselves to be different from Napster, avoiding a centralized server", and that "Morpheus and KaZaa use the Dutch FastTrack technology". The source carries programs that followed with another design, and two of the eight names of the sentence. The report names eDonkey2000, Freenet, BitTorrent and Poisoned nowhere, it names Gnutella and LimeWire only in a list of links to reviews, it gives no year of origin for any program, and a report of July 20, 2001 cannot carry a program of 2003. The citation of footnote 287 at sentence 495 is graded Partial.

1.201 Sentence 496 says that all of these tools are general purpose and can be used to share a wide variety of content, but that the sharing of music files, of software and, later, of movies and videos are major uses. Footnote 288 cites Solutions Research Group, release "Movie File-Sharing Booming: Study", a file of 2 pages, copy archived February 17, 2012 (named), read in full; the release prints the date January 24, 2006 and reports research of June to late September 2006, the record of the file gives January 24, 2007 as the day of its making, and the footnote dates it January 28, 2007. The source reads: "32 million Americans aged 12+ (18% of the US online population) downloaded a full-length movie at some point in the past". The release says that a majority of those who download movies, 80%, use only peer-to-peer file-sharing sites. The source carries movies as a large use of file sharing in the United States. The release says nothing of music files, of software or of the general purpose of the tools. The citation of footnote 288 at sentence 496 is graded Partial.

1.202 Sentence 498 says that lawsuits and other legal actions caused Napster in 2001, eDonkey2000 in 2005, Kazaa in 2006 and Limewire in 2010 to shut down or refocus their efforts. Footnote 289 cites Richard Menta, "RIAA Sues Music Startup Napster for $20 Billion", MP3 Newswire, December 9, 1999, copy archived June 27, 2017 (named), read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The source reads: "The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) filed suit yesterday against MP3 community software maker Napster for copyright infringment." (spelling of the page). The source carries the lawsuit against Napster. A report of December 9, 1999 cannot carry what the lawsuits caused in 2001, 2005, 2006 and 2010. The citation of footnote 289 at sentence 498 is graded Partial. Footnote 290 cites Fred von Lohmann, "What Peer-to-Peer Developers Need to Know about Copyright Law", Electronic Frontier Foundation, version 5.0 of January 2006, copy archived January 15, 2012 (named), retrieved in full and searched; the section on the cases read. The paper says that the injunction against Napster was affirmed on appeal in February 2001 and that "Napster was shut down while it worked on improving its filtering technologies". It names the makers of Kazaa among the defendants of the case MGM v. Grokster. The source carries the end of Napster through a lawsuit, with the year 2001 for the ruling on appeal, and a lawsuit against Kazaa. A search of the paper for eDonkey and LimeWire finds nothing, and a paper of January 2006 cannot carry events of 2006 and 2010. The citation of footnote 290 at sentence 498 is graded Partial.

1.203 Sentence 499 says that The Pirate Bay, founded in Sweden in 2003, continues despite a trial and an appeal in 2009 and 2010 that resulted in jail terms and large fines for several of its founders. Footnote 291 cites Nicole Kobie, "Pirate Bay trio lose appeal against jail sentences", PC Pro, November 26, 2010, copy archived April 21, 2014 (named), read in full. The source reads: "Three of The Pirate Bay's founders have lost an appeal against their prison sentences in a Swedish court." The report says that the sentences of one year were given in the year before, that the court of appeal cut them to ten, eight and four months, and that it raised the fine from 32 million to 46 million kronor. The source carries the trial, the appeal, the jail terms and the fine. The report does not say when or where the site was founded, and it does not say in words that the site continues. The citation of footnote 291 at sentence 499 is graded Partial.

1.204 Sentence 500 says that file sharing remains contentious and controversial, with charges of theft of intellectual property on the one hand and charges of censorship on the other. Footnote 292 cites "Poll: Young Say File Sharing OK", CBS News, September 18, 2003, copy archived September 19, 2003 (named), read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The report of the poll says: "37 percent agree with the recording industry’s position that online music sharing is never acceptable because it deprives musicians and music companies of their income." The source carries a divided opinion and the charge of the industry. The report says nothing of charges of censorship, and a poll of 2003 cannot carry that the matter remains contentious. The citation of footnote 292 at sentence 500 is graded Partial. Footnote 293 cites The New York Times, article of Stuart P. Green of March 29, 2012: the site of the publisher is closed to the tools of this page, and its archived copies, the copy that the footnote names among them, are not opened. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 293 at sentence 500 is graded Uncheckable.

1.205 Sentence 508 says that Google Drive served as a useful tool for university professors and students, as well as for those who are in need of cloud storage. Footnote 294 cites Michael Nolledo, "What is Google Drive? A guide to navigating Google's file storage service and collaboration tools", Business Insider, copy archived December 12, 2020 (the footnote gives the retrieval date November 16, 2020 and names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the opening and the closing section read. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The guide calls the application "a powerful cloud storage solution" that can become "an indispensable productivity tool for anyone, from students to business professionals". The source carries students and those who need cloud storage. The guide has business professionals where the sentence has University professors, and a search of it for professor and university finds the second word only in the note on its author. The citation of footnote 294 at sentence 508 is graded Partial. Footnote 295 cites Google, "Introducing Google Drive... yes, really", Official Google Blog, April 24, 2012, signed Sundar Pichai, copy archived November 19, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date November 16, 2020; the footnote names no archive): the page as displayed shows the title and the date, and the text of the post stands in the code of the page, where it was read in full. The two markers stand together at the end of the sentence. The post introduces the service as "a place where you can create, share, collaborate, and keep all of your stuff" and says "You can get started with 5GB of storage for free". The source carries storage. The post names no university, no professor and no student: its examples are a joint research project with a friend, a wedding and a budget shared with roommates. The citation of footnote 295 at sentence 508 is graded Partial.

1.206 Sentence 511 says that Dropbox now works to keep workers and files in sync and efficient. Footnote 296 cites Dropbox, page "About", copy archived November 18, 2020 (nearest to the retrieval date November 17, 2020; the footnote names no archive), a copy in traditional Chinese, read in full; the renderings into English are of this page. The page says that for the company, starting out in 2007, improving the way people work meant a way to keep files in sync, and that it now means products that reduce busywork, and it says: "Dropbox 協助人們變得條理分明、保持專注,並與他們的工作團隊保持同步。", that is, Dropbox helps people to become organized, to stay focused and to stay in sync with their teams. The source carries the sentence. The citation of footnote 296 at sentence 511 is graded Supported.

1.207 Sentence 512 says that Mega, having over 200 million users, is an encrypted storage and communication system that offers users free and paid storage, with an emphasis on privacy. Footnote 297 cites the page About of MEGA: the archived copy nearest to the retrieval date, of February 13, 2021, is a page that loads its text by a script and holds no text of its own. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 297 at sentence 512 is graded Uncheckable.

1.208 Sentence 516 says that with online piracy came a change in the media industry as a whole. Footnote 298 cites "1) History of Internet Piracy", page of an unsigned site made with Google Sites, "The Truth About Internet Piracy", copy archived October 9, 2020 (named), read in full. The source reads: "At around 2006-2007, there was a huge shift from how media was transferred". The source carries a shift, which the page ties to file sharing. The shift of the page is in how media was transferred, from the first peer-to-peer services to BitTorrent, and the page does not speak of a change in the media industry as a whole. The citation of footnote 298 at sentence 516 is graded Partial.

1.209 Sentence 517 says that total global mobile data traffic reached 588 exabytes during 2020, where the first marker stands, a 150-fold increase from 3.86 exabytes per year in 2010. Footnote 299 cites Ericsson, "Mobile data traffic outlook", a page of the data and forecasts of the Ericsson Mobility Report; the footnote gives no address and no date, and the page was found by a web search for its title; copies archived October 28, 2021 and March 31, 2021, both read in full. The marker stands inside the sentence and governs its first half. The copy of October 2021 says that total global mobile data traffic, without fixed wireless access, "reached 49EB per month at the end of 2020". The copy of March 2021 has it "estimated to reach around 51EB per month by the end of 2020". The source carries the traffic of 2020 as a rate per month. The figure of 588 exabytes during 2020 is on neither copy: it is twelve times the 49 exabytes per month that the page gives for the end of the year. The citation of footnote 299 at sentence 517 is graded Partial. Footnote 300 cites Statista, "Global mobile traffic per year from 2010 to 2020 (in EB)"; the footnote gives no address and no date, and the page was found by a web search for its title; copy archived January 26, 2022, read in full: the page shows its table and keeps the details of its source and its downloads for registered users. The marker stands at the end of the sentence and governs its second half. The table of the page reads 3.86 for 2010, 45.25 for 2015 and 127.82 for 2020, the last two marked as forecasts, and the page, published January 3, 2011, names the UMTS Forum as its source: "The worldwide mobile traffic is projected to amount to 127.82 Exabyte per year in 2020." The source carries 3.86 exabytes for 2010. The 150-fold increase is not on the page: it is the 588 exabytes of the first half of the sentence divided by 3.86, and the forecast of the page itself for 2020 is about 33 times its figure for 2010. The citation of footnote 300 at sentence 517 is graded Partial.

1.210 Sentence 518 says that, most recently, smartphones accounted for 95 percent of this mobile data traffic, with video accounting for 66 percent by type of data. Footnote 299 cites the same page as at sentence 517, both copies. The source reads: "Video traffic currently accounts for 66 percent of all mobile data traffic". Both copies say that smartphones generate about 95 percent of mobile data traffic. The citation of footnote 299 at sentence 518 is graded Supported.

1.211 Sentence 521 says that the most popular mobile phone application is texting, of which 2.1 trillion messages were logged in 2020. Footnote 301 cites CTIA, "2020 Annual Survey Highlights", a file of 11 pages; the footnote reads CTIA 2020 Annual Survey and gives no address; the page of the report, dated August 25, 2020, was found by a web search and read on the live site of CTIA on November 15, 2026, since the copies of it in the Wayback Machine hold no text, and the file to which the page links was read in full in the copy archived September 16, 2020, the drawn figure of its ninth page from the image of the page. The ninth page draws the figure 2.1 trillion over the caption "The number of text messages exchanged in 2019". The source carries 2.1 trillion text messages. The survey is of the wireless providers of the United States, and the figure is that of the United States for 2019, where the sentence has 2020 and names no country. The survey does not say that texting is the most popular application of the mobile telephone. The page of the highlights of the survey of the next year, read on the live site of CTIA on November 15, 2026, gives the messages of 2020 as "a total of 2.2 trillion SMS and MMS messages". The citation of footnote 301 at sentence 521 is graded Partial.

1.212 Sentence 522 says that the texting phenomenon began on December 3, 1992, when Neil Papworth sent the first text message, Merry Christmas, over a commercial cell phone network to the CEO of Vodafone. Footnote 302 cites Rose Eveleth, "The First Text Message, Sent Twenty Years Ago, Was 'Merry Christmas'", Smithsonian.com, December 5, 2012, copy archived January 26, 2015 (the footnote names no archive and no retrieval date), read in full. The source reads: "The first text was sent two decades ago, on December 3rd, by a software engineer named Neil Papworth." and "He texted the director of Vodafone, Richard Jarvis, who got the words “Merry Christmas” delivered to his Orbitel 901". The source carries the day, the year, the sender and the words. The page has the director of Vodafone, whom it names, where the sentence has the CEO of Vodafone, and it does not say that the message went over a commercial network. The citation of footnote 302 at sentence 522 is graded Partial.

1.213 Sentence 529 says that the growth of mobile phone services was initially a primarily Asian phenomenon, with Japan, South Korea and Taiwan all soon finding the majority of their Internet users accessing resources by phone rather than by personal computer (PC). Footnote 303 cites GSMA Intelligence, an analysis of July 2015 on the challenges of the use of the mobile Internet in Asia, a file of 28 pages, copy archived October 18, 2015 (named), retrieved in full and searched; pages 8 and 9, which the footnote cites, read. Page 8 says that the "highly advanced markets such as Japan, Taiwan and South Korea already show nearly, or above, 70% of the population using mobile" services of the Internet, and the figure of page 9 is of the end of 2014. The source carries the three countries as the most advanced of Asia in this use. The cited pages do not compare the telephone with the personal computer, and a search of the 28 pages finds the abbreviation PC nowhere and the word desktop once, on page 23. The pages do not say that the growth of mobile telephone services was at first chiefly Asian: page 8 says that Asia had more than half of the mobile Internet subscribers of the world in 2014. The citation of footnote 303 at sentence 529 is graded Partial.

1.214 Sentence 531 says that the European and North American use of the Internet was influenced by a large installed base of personal computers, and that the growth of mobile phone Internet access was more gradual but had reached national penetration levels of 20 to 30 percent in most Western countries. Footnote 304 cites Susmita Dasgupta, Somik V. Lall and David Wheeler, Policy Reform, Economic Growth, and the Digital Divide: An Econometric Analysis, World Bank, 2001, a paper of 24 pages in full view at Google Books: pages 1 to 3, which the footnote cites, read from the images of the pages; the rest searched there. The three pages treat the gap in the use of the Internet between rich and poor countries, and of mobile telephones they say only that their evolution "may accelerate the spread of Internet access". They say nothing of Europe or North America, of an installed base of personal computers or of a penetration of 20 to 30 percent. A search of the whole paper for personal computers and for installed base returns nothing, and its four results for penetration, on pages 7, 9, 12 and 13, concern mobile telephones in developing regions. The paper is of 2001, and the article places the matter after 2008, the year of its sentence 532. The citation of footnote 304 at sentence 531 is graded Not supported.

1.215 Sentence 533 says that in many parts of the developing world the ratio is as much as 10 mobile phone users to one PC user. Footnote 305 cites Friedhelm Hillebrand, ed., GSM and UMTS, The Creation of Global Mobile Communications, John Wiley & Sons, 2002: the footnote names no page and no address, and Google Books shows no page of the book. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 305 at sentence 533 is graded Uncheckable.

1.216 Sentence 534 says that global Internet traffic continues to grow at a rapid rate, rising 23 percent from 2020 to 2021, where the marker stands, and, after the marker, that the number of active Internet users then reached 4.66 billion people, half of the global population. Footnote 306 cites Alan Mauldin, "Global Internet Traffic and Capacity Return to Regularly Scheduled Programming", blog of TeleGeography, September 7, 2021; the footnote gives no address, and the page was found by a web search for its title; copy archived December 3, 2021, read in full. The marker stands inside the sentence, after the words from 2020 to 2021, and governs its first half. The source reads: "Average traffic growth dropped from 48% between 2019-2020 to 23% between 2020-2021". The source carries a growth of 23 percent, which is the growth of average international traffic. The post presents the figure as a slowdown, a return to normal after the surge of 2020, where the sentence has traffic growing at a rapid rate. The second half of the sentence, on 4.66 billion users, has no footnote. The citation of footnote 306 at sentence 534 is graded Partial.

1.217 Sentence 535 says that further demand for data, and the capacity to satisfy this demand, are forecast to increase to 717 terabits per second in 2021. Footnote 307 reads Cisco 2021 VNI Forecast p2 and gives no address and no exact title; the forecast of Cisco that runs to 2021 is the Cisco Visual Networking Index forecast for 2016 to 2021, of June 2017: read in full were the release of Cisco of June 8, 2017 on it, found by a web search (copy archived November 23, 2020), and page 2 of the white paper to which the release links, "Cisco Visual Networking Index: Forecast and Methodology, 2016–2021", a file of 17 pages (copy archived October 20, 2017), whose whole text was searched; whether the footnote means another document of the forecast cannot be told from it. The release says that average Internet traffic will grow 3.2-fold from 2016 to 2021, "reaching 717 Tbps by 2021". Page 2 of the white paper, its executive summary, has the growth "by a factor of 3.2" and no figure in terabits per second, and the number 717 occurs in the white paper only inside the figure 6,717 of two tables on file sharing. The source carries a forecast of 717 terabits per second for 2021, made in June 2017, as the average traffic of the Internet. Neither document speaks of a capacity of 717 terabits per second: the release sets the average against a busy hour of 4.3 petabits per second. The citation of footnote 307 at sentence 535 is graded Partial.

1.218 Sentence 536 says that this capacity stems from the optical amplification and WDM systems that are the common basis of virtually every metro, regional, national, international and submarine telecommunications network. Footnote 308 cites Klaus Grobe and Michael Eiselt, Wavelength Division Multiplexing: A Practical Engineering Guide, Wiley, 2013, page 2 cited: the preview of Google Books served no image of the page, and a search of the book there returned one line of a page that the search does not number, which was read. The line reads "common basis of all metropolitan area, regional, national, and international telecommunications networks was enabled by a number of relevant milestones" and begins after the words that name the thing so described. The source carries the list of the kinds of network. The line has all where the sentence has virtually every, it does not name submarine networks, and optical amplification is not in it. The citation of footnote 308 at sentence 536 is graded Partial.

1.219 Sentence 537 says that these optical networking systems have been installed throughout the 5 billion kilometers of fiber optic lines deployed around the world. Footnote 309 cites Corning, page "Innovations in Optical Fiber" among the product pages of Corning Optical Communications; the footnote reads Corning Glass Products/Optical Fiber and gives no address and no date, and the page was found by a web search; copies archived September 24, 2020 and August 18, 2022, the first read in full and the second searched. The source reads: "Currently more than 5 billion kilometers of optical fiber is deployed around the world". The source carries the length of the fiber. The page does not say that systems of optical amplification and of wavelength-division multiplexing (WDM) have been installed throughout it. Another page of Corning, "Leading the Way to New Discoveries", in a copy archived July 1, 2022, has "over 2 billion kilometers of optical fiber is deployed around the globe". The citation of footnote 309 at sentence 537 is graded Partial.

1.220 Sentence 540 says that the process of digitization represents a twofold challenge, both for historiography in general and, in particular, for historical communication research. Footnote 310 cites Christoph Classen, Susanne Kinnebrock and Maria Löblich, "Towards Web History: Sources, Methods, and Challenges in the Digital Age. An Introduction", Historical Social Research 37 (4), 2012, pages 97 to 101: the cited page of JSTOR stops at a check for automated visitors; the paper was read in full in the file of 7 pages of the repository of the University of Augsburg, found by a web search (copy archived November 5, 2025). The sentence of the Wikipedia article is the first sentence of the abstract of the paper and of its text, word for word: "The process of digitization represents a twofold challenge both for historiography in general and, in particular, for historical communication research." The Wikipedia article prints it without quotation marks. The citation of footnote 310 at sentence 540 is graded Supported.

1.221 Sentence 543 is the line of attribution, Doug Gale (2007), under the quotation of sentence 542, in which the period of the ARPANET is called somewhat well documented because the corporation in charge, BBN, left a physical record, and the era of the NSFNET is called an extraordinarily decentralized process whose record exists in basements and closets. Footnote 311 cites Colin Barras, "Illuminating the net's Dark Ages", BBC News, last updated August 23, 2007, copy archived March 7, 2008 (nearest to the retrieval date February 26, 2008; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The marker stands after the name and the year under the quotation of sentence 542. The page has the three parts of the quotation as words of Dr Doug Gale, president of Information Technology Associates: "it became an extraordinarily decentralised process. The record exists in people's basements, in closets." The source carries the quotation, the speaker and the year. The title that the footnote gives, An Internet Pioneer Ponders the Next Revolution, is not the title of the page, whose own title the footnote prints as the name of the work: it is the title that footnote 61 gives for an article of John Markoff in The New York Times of December 20, 1999. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the page says of the networks of the 1980s that "having a number of isolated networks speaking the same language wasn't enough. There needed to be a central backbone". The citation of footnote 311 at sentence 543 is graded Supported.

1.222 Sentence 544 says that notable works on the subject include a book by the journalists Katie Hafner and Matthew Lyon, Where Wizards Stay Up Late: The Origins Of The Internet, of 1996, and the book Inventing the Internet, of 2000, by Professor Janet Abbate. Footnote 312 cites Roy Rosenzweig, "Wizards, Bureaucrats, Warriors, and Hackers: Writing the History of the Internet", The American Historical Review 103 (5), December 1998, pages 1530 to 1552: the cited page of JSTOR stops at a check for automated visitors; the essay was retrieved in full and searched, and read at its opening and at the passages named here, in the reprint on the site rrchnm.org, found by a web search (copy archived February 27, 2026), which says that it reprints the article with permission. The essay names "Katie Hafner and Matthew Lyon’s well-written and extensively researched work of popular history", prints its title as Where the Wizards Stay Up Late: The Origins of the Internet, and dates it New York, 1996 in its third note. The source carries that book. The essay does not call its authors journalists. An essay of December 1998 cannot carry a book of 2000: it cites Janet Abbate for her dissertation, "“From Arpanet to Internet: A History of Arpa-Sponsored Computer Networks, 1966-1988,” Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. of Penn., 1994", and names no book of hers. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the essay ties the weight that the book of Katie Hafner and Matthew Lyon gives to Bolt Beranek and Newman "to the study’s origins in a suggestion from BBN, which opened its archives to Hafner and Lyon and even helped fund the project", adds in its fourth note that BBN did not exercise any control over the actual book, and says that "the Internet lacks a central founding figure". The citation of footnote 312 at sentence 544 is graded Partial.

1.223 Sentence 545 says that most scholarship and literature on the Internet lists the ARPANET as the prior network that was iterated on and studied to create it, where the first marker stands, although other early computer networks and experiments existed alongside or before the ARPANET. Footnote 313 cites Edmund Wright, ed., The Desk Encyclopedia of World History, Oxford University Press, 2006, page 311 cited: the preview of Google Books shows no page of the book, and a search of the book there returned page numbers without a line of text. The source could not be read. The citation of footnote 313 at sentence 545 is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 39 cites the same file as at sentence 75; the paragraphs headed SITA, TYMNET and CYCLADES read. The marker stands at the end of the sentence, after the marker of footnote 313, and governs its second half. The paper describes, beside the ARPANET, the network of the Societe Internationale de Telecommunications Aeronautiques, TYMNET and CYCLADES, and a local network at the National Physical Laboratory: "Also in 1969, a time sharing service bureau, Tymshare Corporation, started installing a network based on minicomputers". The source carries other early networks beside the ARPANET. The citation of footnote 39 at sentence 545 is graded Supported.

1.224 Sentence 546 says that such histories of the Internet have since been criticized as teleologies and Whig history, that is, as taking the present to be the end point toward which history has been unfolding on the basis of a single cause, and it introduces the quotation of sentences 547 and 548, which carry no marker. Footnote 314 cites Martin Campbell-Kelly and Daniel D. Garcia-Swartz, "The History of the Internet: The Missing Narratives", Journal of Information Technology 28 (1), 2013: the page of the journal, copy archived July 3, 2025, shows the abstract and the list of references and keeps the article behind its access wall; the page of the working paper of December 2, 2005 on SSRN, copy archived October 27, 2025, shows its abstract, and the Wayback Machine returned an error for the file of the working paper; both abstracts read in full. The abstract of the journal article says that the belief that the Internet grew from the ARPANET of 1969 is "incomplete at best and seriously flawed at worst" and that "the ARPANET network was one among a myriad of (commercial and non-commercial) networks". The source carries a criticism of the histories that begin with the ARPANET. The words teleology and Whig history are in neither abstract, and the quotation that follows the sentence, sentences 547 and 548, is in neither. The list of references of the journal page holds an article titled Against Whig History. The words "Whiggism and teleology" stand in the paper of footnote 315, at its third page. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the abstract says that the article lets one see "the extent to which the ARPANET network was one among many, and not a particularly large one at that". The citation of footnote 314 at sentence 546 is graded Partial.

1.225 Sentence 551 is the line of attribution, Andrew L. Russell (2012), under the quotation of sentence 550, which says that Internet history tends to be too close to its sources, that many Internet pioneers are alive, active and eager to shape the histories that describe their accomplishments, and that many museums and historians are equally eager to interview the pioneers and to publicize their stories. Footnote 315 cites Andrew L. Russell, "Histories of Networking vs. the History of the Internet", paper presented at the 2012 SIGCIS Workshop, October 7, 2012, a file of 10 pages marked Draft: September 26, 2012, at the cited address (copy archived August 3, 2026; the footnote names no archive), read in full. The marker stands after the name and the year under the quotation of sentence 550. Page 6 of the file, the page that the footnote cites, has the three sentences of the quotation, of which the first says of Internet history: "it tends to be too close to its sources". The source carries the quotation, the author and the year. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: the paper goes on to say that historians "should know better than to mistake the accounts and memories of interview subjects for the objective and honest truth", and it says at its third page that to frame the inquiry as the History of the Internet "is a category error". Of the word written without the capital, the rendering of his undergraduates, Andrew L. Russell writes that for them it means everything online and has no specific referent, "hence its reclassification from a proper to a common noun". The citation of footnote 315 at sentence 551 is graded Supported.

1.226 The caption of the figure of the message block says that the "message block", designed by Paul Baran in 1962 and refined in 1964, is the first proposal of a data packet. Footnote 22 cites Gil Press, "A Very Short History Of The Internet And The Web", Forbes, copy archived December 20, 2019 (nearest to the retrieval date January 30, 2020; the footnote names no archive), retrieved in full and searched; the entries of 1960 to 1968 read. The entry of May 1960 has Paul Baran publish a paper on reliable digital communications systems, "the first of a series of papers that proposed the design for distributed networks using packet switching". The source reads: “While Baran used the term "message blocks" for his units of communication, Davies used the term "packets."” The source carries the term. The source dates the first paper May 1960 and gives neither 1962 nor 1964 for the message block, and does not call it the first proposal of a data packet. The citation stands in the caption of a figure, which Exhibit 13.1 of Disagreement 3 does not number. The citation of footnote 22 in the caption of the figure of the message block is graded Partial. Footnote 23 cites "CSNET, Computer Science Network", page of Living Internet, copy archived February 3, 2026 (the latest copy of the address returns a refusal; the footnote names no archive and no date), read in full. The page is on the Computer Science Network of 1980 and after. It names neither Paul Baran nor a message block (the one occurrence of the word packet is "mismatched packet sizes"). The citation of footnote 23 in the caption of the figure of the message block is graded Not supported.

1.227 The caption of the first of the three maps of the article gives the Internet users of 2023 as a percentage of the population of a country and names the International Telecommunication Union as its source. Footnote 160 cites International Telecommunication Union, "Percentage of Individuals using the Internet", spreadsheet of June 2013 at the cited address, copy archived July 10, 2013 (the footnote names no archive), converted to text in full and searched. The spreadsheet gives a percentage for each country and each year from 2000 to 2012, the first row being Afghanistan. It is of June 2013 and is older than the year of the caption: it carries the measure, the countries and the Union as the source, and it cannot carry figures for 2023. The citation of footnote 160 in the caption of the first map is graded Partial.

1.228 The caption of the second map gives the fixed broadband Internet subscriptions of 2012 as a percentage of the population of a country and names the International Telecommunication Union as its source. Footnote 161 cites a dynamic report of the ICT Eye of the International Telecommunication Union: the cited address is a query form, and the Wayback Machine holds no copy of a report on fixed broadband subscriptions for 2012 at it, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 161 in the caption of the second map is graded Uncheckable.

1.229 The caption of the third map gives the mobile broadband Internet subscriptions of 2012 as a percentage of the population of a country and names the International Telecommunication Union as its source. Footnote 162 cites a dynamic report of the ICT Eye of the International Telecommunication Union, at the same address as footnote 161: the Wayback Machine holds no copy of a report on mobile broadband subscriptions for 2012 at it, and the source was not read. The citation of footnote 162 in the caption of the third map is graded Uncheckable.

1.230 The caption of a chart of the article gives the number of Internet hosts worldwide from 1969 to 2019 and names the Internet Systems Consortium as its source. Footnote 170 cites "Internet host count history", Internet Systems Consortium, copy archived May 18, 2012 (named), read in full. The page is a table of host counts from "08/1981" to "01/2012". The source carries the counts and the Consortium as their source for 1981 to 2012. The table has no row before August 1981, and the copy of May 2012 cannot carry the years to 2019. Apart from the sentence, the same source carries the following: on the matter of sentence 119, the first row of the table gives 213 hosts for August 1981, the figure that the article cites there to footnote 84. The citation of footnote 170 in the caption of the chart of hosts is graded Partial.

2.0 None of the three sources cited for the beginnings of the Internet carries that sentence whole, the sources that the article cites disagree among themselves on where the Internet began, the hearing cited for a controversy over the Act of 1992 was held before the Act, a number of sentences of the article are sentences of their sources printed without quotation marks, thirty-four of the 358 citations rest on sources that do not carry their sentences, and fifty-four cannot be checked.

2.1 Disagreement 3 disputes nine sentences of the article and the caption of a diagram, and three of the nine sentences carry footnotes. Sentence 22 says that international connections to the NSFNET, the emergence of architecture such as the Domain Name System and the adoption of TCP/IP on existing networks "marked the beginnings of the Internet", and it cites three sources, which unit 1.2 grades. The post of the Internet Hall of Fame at footnote 4 counts TCP/IP and the Domain Name System among the "milestones that led to the development of the modern Internet" and names neither the NSFNET nor international connections; the study for Ofcom at footnote 5 says of the NSFNET and of the networks joined through it "That resulting network of networks was the beginning of today’s Internet." and says nothing of the Domain Name System or of the adoption of TCP/IP as marks of a beginning; and the essay of Ian Peter at footnote 6, which sets out five theories of the origin of the Internet, never names the NSFNET or the Domain Name System, says "TCP/IP was not even added to Arpanet officially until 1983", concludes "Neither Arpanet nor TCP/IP is present in all valid theories." and quotes Bob Taylor, "The ARPAnet was not an internet. An internet is a connection between two or more computer networks." The first two citations are graded Partial and the third is graded Not supported. Section 6.0 of Disagreement 3 answers sentence 22 under the Governing Definitions, and this audit adds that none of the three sources that the article cites for the sentence carries it whole. Sentence 26 credits research at CERN by Tim Berners-Lee in 1989 and 1990 with the World Wide Web application design, and it cites one page of a book of Nick Couldry, which says that the protocols of which it speaks were "conceived first by Tim Berners-Lee in 1989, launched in 1991" and which names neither CERN nor Switzerland and no research of 1989 to 1990, as unit 1.5 records; the citation is graded Partial, and section 9.0 of Disagreement 3 answers the sentence with the proposal of November 12, 1990, which names two authors. Sentence 303 credits the invention of the World Wide Web application design to Tim Berners-Lee at CERN, as an application on the Internet, and says that it brought social and commercial uses to what was a network of networks for academic and research institutions; its three sources carry the sentence, two in whole and one in part, as unit 1.123 records, and the book of James Tobin has Tim Berners-Lee invent "a method of using the Internet". Section 10.0 of Disagreement 3 answers the sentence with the announcement of the Commercial Internet Exchange of March 25, 1991, and a source that the article itself cites at sentence 124, the report of Richard Bennett at footnote 90, says "In 1991, they formed the Commercial Internet Exchange (CIX) and connected with each other without settlement fees or payments to ANS." The other six sentences that Disagreement 3 disputes, sentences 25, 120, 162, 204, 324 and 370, carry no footnote; sentences 197 and 295, which section 7.0 of Disagreement 3 cites for the retirement of the ARPANET in 1990, carry none; and the caption of the diagram of the demonstration of November 22, 1977 carries none. The sentence of the body on that demonstration, sentence 166, cites a release of the Computer History Museum of November 1, 2007 and an article of CNET News of November 8, 2007, and unit 1.70 grades both citations Partial, because neither source names University College London; the release calls the transmission "widely regarded as the first true Internet connection" and the article of CNET News calls it "the very first true Internet connection", and this page reports both as the statements of their sources.

2.2 This audit recorded, in the sources that the article cites, statements of the source's own about where and when the Internet began, and this page reports each as the statement of its source. Twelve of the sources set the ARPANET or the NSFNET before the Internet as its origin. The release of the Computer History Museum, SRI International and BBN Technologies at footnote 2 bears in its title the words "Precursor to Today's Internet"; the introduction of the site KurzweilAI at footnote 20 says that the vision of J. C. R. Licklider "would lead to ARPANet, the precursor of the Internet in use today"; the page of Living Internet at footnote 21 says that he "inspired his successors to realize his dream by inventing the ARPANET, which led to the Internet"; the page of the RAND Corporation at footnote 26 carries the heading "Forerunner of the Internet"; the chapter of K. G. Coffman and A. M. Odlyzko at footnote 44 says of the ARPANET of four nodes of 1969 that "a case can be made that this was when the Internet was born"; the file at footnote 51 calls the ARPANET "the precursor to the Internet"; the page of Living Internet at footnote 75 calls it "the “Eve” network of what has evolved into the Internet we know and love today"; page 30 of the book at footnote 84 says "The Internet began in the 1960s with ARPANET"; the page of the University of Texas at Austin at footnote 87 asks "why is the ARPANET generally recognized as the parent of the modern Internet"; the letter of the General Accounting Office at footnote 173 calls the network of the National Science Foundation "one of the networks that became the Internet"; the opinion of the District Court at footnote 223 says that the Internet "is the outgrowth of a system known as ARPANET, a network that the military created in 1959"; and the report of Ars Technica at footnote 249 says "Just 40 or so years ago, in 1969, the Internet was getting off the ground as a simple connection between two computers." Five of the sources say otherwise. The essay of Ian Peter at footnote 6 quotes Bob Taylor, as unit 2.1 reports, and says "It therefore follows that Arpanet as a single network could hardly be described as an Internet"; the abstract of the article of Ronda Hauben at footnote 109 says of the year 1969 "That is the date marking the origins of the ARPANET (a U.S. packet switching network), but not the birth of the Internet."; Robert Kahn, in the exchange of electronic mail at footnote 30, writes of the plan to interconnect multiple heterogeneous packet networks that it "demonstrated the concept of Internetting and led to today's Internet. But, then again, thats an entirely different story."; the abstract of the article of Martin Campbell-Kelly and Daniel D. Garcia-Swartz at footnote 314 says that "the ARPANET network was one among a myriad of (commercial and non-commercial) networks"; and Andrew L. Russell, in the paper at footnote 315, says that to frame the inquiry as the History of the Internet "is a category error". The units that record these statements are units 1.1, 1.2, 1.15, 1.16, 1.18, 1.19, 1.26, 1.30, 1.46, 1.51, 1.53, 1.66, 1.118, 1.158, 1.180, 1.224 and 1.225. Each of these is the statement of the source that prints it, most of them are not the sentence for which the article cites that source, and the Governing Definitions, under which every finding on this page is made, do not place the ARPANET or the NSFNET in the lineage of the Internet.

2.3 The article dates the commercial opening of the network in several sentences, and the sources that it cites date the steps otherwise or state them in other terms. Sentence 23 dates the emergence of commercial Internet service providers in the United States and Australia to 1989, and the page of Roger Clarke at footnote 7 says of the United States that "the pilot connection of commercial services to the Internet began in 1989, although in a tightly controlled manner" and, quoting another author, "Commercial Internet access was first offered by PSI and AlterNet beginning in early 1990". Sentence 24 speaks of limited private connections by commercial entities in several American cities by late 1989 and 1990, and its one source, the essay signed Spike at footnote 8, is the account of one company of Brookline, which says "So that's how on August 13, 1992, I was running the very first official ISP." Sentence 292 calls The World the first commercial dialup provider of the United States, opened in 1989, and the home page of The World at footnote 172 says "We were the first public dialup Internet Service Provider (ISP)." and names no year. Sentence 293 says that the Scientific and Advanced-Technology Act of 1992 allowed the National Science Foundation to support access to networks that were not used exclusively for research and education, "thus permitting NSFNET to interconnect with commercial networks"; the review of the Office of Inspector General of the Foundation at footnote 174 prints a message of the Foundation to Merit of May 24, 1991, seventeen months before the Act was signed on October 23, 1992, which begins "NSF agrees that ANS may move commercial traffic in both directions across the NSF sponsored Backbone gateways". Sentence 294 says that this caused controversy in the research and education community and among the commercial network providers, and it cites the report of a hearing of the House of Representatives. The hearing was held on March 12, 1992, seven months before the Act was signed, and the report records that Rick Boucher, who offered the bill, said on June 4, 1992 that the users, the providers and the Foundation "all recommended the policy change which is enabled by this amendment", and that George E. Brown, Jr., chairman of the committee, called the bill on June 10, 1992 "a relatively short and relatively non-controversial piece of legislation". At the hearing Douglas E. Van Houweling, Member of the Board of Directors of Merit Network, Inc., testified that the commercial traffic carried on the backbone was "in the neighborhood of just 1 or 2 percent", and William L. Schrader, President and CEO of Performance Systems International, Inc., testified: "There are other commercial providers with nationwide backbones." Sentence 299 dates the end of the last restrictions on commercial traffic to April 30, 1995, the day on which it has the sponsorship of the NSFNET Backbone Service end; of its two sources, the article of Susan R. Harris and Elise Gerich at footnote 176 carries the date and says nothing of restrictions on commercial traffic, and the page of Walt Howe at footnote 177 says "All pretenses of limitations on commercial use disappeared in May 1995 when the National Science Foundation ended its sponsorship of the Internet backbone, and all traffic relied on commercial networks." and says of the early 1990s "It then became possible to route traffic across the country from one commercial site to another without passing through the government funded NSFNet Internet backbone." Two sources that the article cites at other sentences bear on the same matter: the paper of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) at footnote 124 says "In 1995 NSFNET was retired and US backbone traffic was routed via interconnected commercial networks." and says of the time of the NSFNET that "the Internet was still considered a private network because it was restricted to a defined group of users", and the draft of Elizabeth Feinler at footnote 221 says of the years 1984 to 1988 "The Internet was not yet commercial. This did not happen until after 1990". Units 1.3, 1.4, 1.78, 1.117, 1.118, 1.119, 1.120 and 1.156 record these statements. Section 3.0 of Disagreement 3 answers sentence 25, on the restrictions on commercial traffic and the end of the NSFNET backbone in 1995, which carries no footnote.

2.4 This unit sets dates and places of fourteen sentences against the sources cited for them. Sentence 83 says that elements of the network of the National Physical Laboratory became operational in early 1969, and the five sources read for sentences 81 through 83 give that start in four ways: the entry of the encyclopedia at footnote 49 has "Elements of the pilot NPL network first operated in 1969", the page of the symposium at footnote 53 has "early in 1969", the report of the BBC at footnote 50 has a network "which went live at the start of 1970", the file at footnote 51 has "operational by 1970", and the abstract of Martin Campbell-Kelly at footnote 56 has "first became operational in 1970". Sentence 100 gives the line speeds as 2.4 and 50 kilobits per second, and the cited pages of Janet Abbate give "from 9.6 to 56 kilobits per second". Sentence 169 places the adoption of TCP/IP as a standard of the Department of Defense before the change of the ARPANET in January 1983, and the page of Living Internet at footnote 118 says "In 1984, the US Department of Defense made TCP/IP the standard for all military computer networking". Sentence 237 dates the link between CERN and Cornell University to 1989, and the article of François Fluckiger at footnote 142 dates it otherwise: "In February 1990 the first transatlantic Internet link". Sentence 241 gives the first international connections to the NSFNET to INRIA and to the Centrum Wiskunde & Informatica (CWI) in 1988; the post at footnote 146 dates the link of INRIA to July 28, 1988, and the page of CWI at footnote 147, which dates its own connection to November 17, 1988, says that the institute "was the first non-American organization to gain access to the American science network NSFnet". Sentence 294 cites, for a controversy that it says the Act of 1992 caused, a hearing that was held seven months before the Act was signed, as unit 2.3 reports. Sentence 333 says that the term Web 2.0 resurfaced during the years 2002 to 2004, and its four sources bear dates from August 16, 2003 to the issue of a magazine of December 15, 2003 and January 1, 2004. Sentence 357 dates the program Future Internet Design to 2006, and the article of the Communications of the ACM at footnote 209, one of its two sources, says "In 2007, NSF started the FIND program". Sentence 371 dates the first test of a deep space network to November 2008, and the release of NASA of November 18, 2008 says "Engineers began a month-long series of DTN demonstrations in October." Sentence 372 says that the testing was scheduled to continue until March 2014, and the copy of the fact sheet that the footnote names gives "March 2009 - October 2013". Sentence 398 dates the establishment of the American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) to December 1997 and cites a release of June 24, 1997, which speaks of a change "expected to be fully implemented before March 1998". Sentence 441 dates the separation of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) from the University of Southern California to 2000, and the cited agreement gives its effective date as "the later of (i) January 1, 1999 at 12:01 a.m. and (ii) the date upon which Governmental Approval is received". Sentence 448 places the Internet Governance Forum of November 2009 in Washington DC, and the report cited at footnote 249 places it in Egypt: "The smiling Berners-Lee was standing in a palms-surrounded conference center in Sharm El Sheikh, in the Sinai Desert." Sentence 521 gives 2.1 trillion text messages for 2020, and the survey of CTIA that footnote 301 names draws that figure over the caption "The number of text messages exchanged in 2019".

2.5 This unit sets figures of five sentences against the sources cited for them. Sentence 517 says that mobile data traffic reached 588 exabytes during 2020 and that this was a 150-fold increase from 3.86 exabytes per year in 2010. The page of Ericsson, in its copy of October 2021, says that the traffic "reached 49EB per month at the end of 2020", and 588 is twelve times 49; the figure of 588 exabytes stands on neither copy of the page. The table of Statista gives 3.86 exabytes for 2010, and the 150-fold increase is 588 divided by 3.86; the forecast of that table for 2020, which Statista published on January 3, 2011, is 127.82 exabytes, about 33 times its figure for 2010. Sentence 535 gives 717 terabits per second as the forecast for 2021 of the demand for data and of the capacity to satisfy it; the release of Cisco of June 8, 2017 forecasts average Internet traffic "reaching 717 Tbps by 2021", and neither the release nor the white paper to which it links speaks of a capacity of that size. Sentence 537 gives 5 billion kilometers of fiber optic lines; the page of Corning that this page found says "Currently more than 5 billion kilometers of optical fiber is deployed around the world", and another page of Corning, in a copy of July 1, 2022, has "over 2 billion kilometers of optical fiber is deployed around the globe". Sentence 147 gives 550 hosts of UUCP for 1981 and 940 for 1984, and none of those four numbers occurs in the page cited. Sentence 29 speaks of fiber-optic networks operating at 1, 10 and 800 gigabits per second by 2019, and the article cited reports a product announced for delivery: "networking company Ciena says it will start deliveries of an 800 gigabit-per-second, single wavelength light throughput system in Q3 2019". Units 1.6, 1.63, 1.209, 1.217 and 1.219 record these figures.

2.6 A number of sentences of the article are sentences of their sources, printed without quotation marks. Sentence 540 is the first sentence of the paper of Christoph Classen, Susanne Kinnebrock and Maria Löblich that footnote 310 cites, word for word; sentence 192 is a sentence of the page of Living Internet on CSNET, word for word; sentence 264 is a sentence of the file of the Internet Society at footnote 163, word for word; and sentence 344 and the sentence before it are two consecutive sentences of the page of telephoneworld.org at footnote 204, nearly word for word. Sentence 388, with the sentence before it and the two sentences after it, is a run of four consecutive sentences of the article of The Internet Protocol Journal of December 2001 that footnote 225 cites at sentence 392 and sentence 396, and sentences 391, 392, 396, 397 and 398 follow further sentences of the same article. Sentences 407, 416 and 431, and sentences 415 and 430, which carry no footnote, follow sentences of the guide of the Internet Engineering Task Force that footnote 230 cites; sentence 378 and sentence 380 follow four consecutive sentences of RFC 1174; sentence 152 follows a sentence of the article of IEEE Spectrum at footnote 107, with institutions in the place of countries; sentence 106 follows two sentences of the page of Living Internet at footnote 75; sentence 251 follows a sentence of the page of the Internet Hall of Fame at footnote 152, and sentence 253 has the words of the post at footnote 153, which is not cited there; the second half of sentence 299 follows the wording of the page of Walt Howe; and the wording of sentences 54, 57, 68 and 71 follows two pages that the article cites at other sentences, the page of Living Internet at footnote 21 and the page of the RAND Corporation at footnote 26. Three quotations of the article and one quotation of a footnote differ from the sources cited for them. The quotation at sentence 104, which the article introduces as words of Leonard Kleinrock, reproduces a passage of the page of Gregory R. Gromov with its omission marks, and that page gives a newspaper as its source, "Sacramento Bee, May 1, 1996, p.D1", while the article of Leo Beranek that is cited beside it does not have the words. The quotation of Darcy DiNucci after sentence 332 passes over four sentences of the magazine without a mark of omission and ends with the words microwave oven, where the magazine prints no word oven. The words that sentence 302 prints in quotation marks leave out the word but of the page. And the quotation that footnote 1 prints reads computer scientists where the page of the book reads "computer experts". Units 1.1, 1.14, 1.15, 1.16, 1.18, 1.44, 1.46, 1.65, 1.76, 1.102, 1.109, 1.120, 1.122, 1.132, 1.137, 1.154, 1.159, 1.160, 1.162, 1.166, 1.167, 1.173 and 1.220 record these.

2.7 Thirty-four citations are graded Not supported, and unit 4.2 lists them. In four of them the footnote leads to a document on another subject. Footnote 117, cited at sentence 167 and at sentence 318, leads to a table of links to reports on the routing table of the Border Gateway Protocol. Footnote 132, cited at sentence 220, gives the number of RFC 1871, which is a memo on a procedure of the Internet Engineering Task Force, under a title that belongs to RFC 1817. Footnote 23, cited at the caption of the figure of the message block, is a page on the Computer Science Network of 1980 and after, which names neither Paul Baran nor a message block. In others the source states the matter differently. Three of the four sources cited before the quotation at sentence 332 for the first appearance of the term Web 2.0 in an article of Darcy DiNucci of January 1999 do not name her: the essay of Paul Graham dates his own first hearing of the term to 2004, and the articles of Tim O'Reilly and of HowStuffWorks give the term another origin. The page of the report of Bolt Beranek and Newman that sentence 100 cites is its section on the network of the National Physical Laboratory, and the two figures of the sentence stand five pages on. The cited part of the article at sentence 281 is a timeline that carries the sentence before it and nothing of a filter. The words that sentence 207 prints in quotation marks are a reworking of a sentence of the cited book that defines the term quantum electronics. In the rest, the source was read or searched and carries nothing of the statement, and the units say what was searched for.

2.8 Fifty-four citations are graded Uncheckable, and unit 4.3 lists them. Thirty-three of them are closed by the rule of unit 0.5 on the publishers whose sites this page does not open: the 32 citations of the thirty-one footnotes that cite The New York Times, Wired, The Wall Street Journal and The Economist, and the citation of footnote 220. All thirteen sentences of the section on net neutrality, sentences 458 through 470, carry footnotes, and 21 of their 31 citations are among the thirty-three. Of the other twenty-one citations graded Uncheckable, nine cite books of which the preview of Google Books shows no page, or not the cited page, or not the page on which the statement would stand: footnote 29 at sentences 68 and 69, and footnotes 47, 84, 127, 201, 286, 305 and 313. Six cite papers and chapters of which no text could be read, or of which only an abstract, a record or a list of section titles could be read and that part carries nothing of the sentence: footnotes 11, 85, 88, 100, 188 and 208. The remaining six are a recording that was not played, at footnote 55; a talk of which a web search returned no transcript, at footnote 199; an address that now shows a parking page, at footnote 165; a page that loads its text by a script, at footnote 297; and two reports behind a query form, at footnotes 161 and 162.

2.9 Fourteen footnotes describe, date or quote their sources otherwise than the sources themselves read, and the units record each case. Footnote 311 gives the report of BBC News under the title that footnote 61 gives for an article of The New York Times. Footnote 132 gives RFC 1871 under the title of RFC 1817. Footnote 111 prints the title of RFC 675 with the word Protocol where the document has Program. Footnote 66 prints the first name of Janet Abbate as Jane. Footnote 173 names the Government Accountability Office where the letter prints the name General Accounting Office, and footnote 174 calls the amended law the appropriations act where the review calls it the NSF Act. Footnote 8 gives as the date of the essay the date that the essay gives for an event, August 13, 1992. Footnote 240 gives as the date of the agreement the date on which the page says that it was updated, May 14, 2000. Footnotes 214 and 215 date the advisory and the release of NASA two days and one day later than the documents date themselves, footnote 249 dates the report of Ars Technica one day later than the page does, and footnote 190 dates the page of Webopedia one year earlier than the copy read. Footnote 259 cites, for a recommendation of November 10, 2014, an article of January 21, 2015 with a retrieval date of January 20, 2015. And the quotation that footnote 1 prints differs from the page of the book in two places, as unit 2.6 reports for the first of them. Units 1.1, 1.4, 1.42, 1.68, 1.87, 1.118, 1.130, 1.149, 1.150, 1.176, 1.180, 1.185 and 1.221 record these.

3.0 Of the 551 sentences of Exhibit 13.1, 326 carry no footnote, and among them stand six of the nine sentences that Disagreement 3 disputes, all eight sentences of the section on the politicization of the Internet, and twenty sentences whose statements stand in sources that the article cites at other sentences.

3.1 Of the 551 sentences of Exhibit 13.1, 225 carry footnotes: sentences 2, 22 through 24, 26, 29, 30, 32, 46 through 48, 50, 52, 54, 57, 59, 65, 67 through 69, 71, 74 through 88, 90, 91, 93, 95, 97, 100, 102, 104 through 106, 108, 115, 117 through 119, 121 through 126, 128, 129, 133, 134, 139, 147, 151, 152, 157 through 159, 164, 166, 167, 169, 171, 172, 179, 192, 194, 200, 201, 203, 205, 207, 209 through 211, 216, 220, 221, 227 through 231, 233, 234, 237, 240, 241, 245, 246, 250 through 254, 256, 257, 261, 264, 272, 275, 277, 278, 281, 283, 291 through 294, 299, 301 through 304, 312, 313, 316 through 320, 332, 333, 335, 339, 340, 344, 352 through 358, 360 through 363, 366, 371, 372, 374, 376, 378, 381, 384 through 386, 388, 392, 395, 396, 398, 400, 401, 407, 416, 420 through 422, 425, 426, 431, 435, 437, 441, 442, 446 through 449, 458 through 470, 474, 476, 477, 491, 493, 495, 496, 498 through 500, 508, 511, 512, 516 through 518, 521, 522, 529, 531, 533 through 537, 540, 543 through 546 and 551. The other 326 sentences carry none. Counted by the sections of the exhibit, footnotes stand at 8 of the 32 sentences of the opening section, sentences 1 through 32; at 14 of the 42 sentences of the section Foundations, sentences 33 through 74; at 41 of the 75 sentences of the section on the networks that the article says led to the Internet, sentences 75 through 149; at 52 of the 136 sentences of the section on the years 1973 to 1989, sentences 150 through 285; at 16 of the 35 sentences of the section on the years 1989 to 2004, sentences 286 through 320; at 21 of the 54 sentences of the section on the years from 2004, sentences 321 through 374; at 29 of the 75 sentences of the section on Internet governance, sentences 375 through 449; at none of the 8 sentences of the section on the politicization of the Internet, sentences 450 through 457; at all 13 sentences of the section on net neutrality, sentences 458 through 470; at 13 of the 43 sentences of the section on use and culture, sentences 471 through 513; at 1 of the 3 sentences of the section on online piracy, sentences 514 through 516; at 7 of the 17 sentences of the section on mobile telephone data traffic, sentences 517 through 533; at 4 of the 5 sentences of the section on growth in demand, sentences 534 through 538; and at 6 of the 13 sentences of the section on historiography, sentences 539 through 551. Six of the nine sentences that Disagreement 3 disputes carry no footnote: sentence 25, sentence 120, sentence 162, sentence 204, sentence 324 and sentence 370. The article itself tags three sentences without footnotes, sentences 140, 232 and 346, with the words citation needed.

3.2 Exhibit 13.1 leaves out the captions of the article under its own heading, and five captions of revision 1370792739 carry markers, which units 1.226 through 1.230 grade: the caption of the figure of the message block carries the markers of footnotes 22 and 23, the captions of the three maps carry the markers of footnotes 160, 161 and 162, and the caption of the chart of hosts carries the marker of footnote 170.

3.3 In reading the sources that the article cites, this audit found that they carry or bear on twenty sentences that carry no footnote. Sentence 99 says that Larry Roberts incorporated the packet switching concepts of Donald Davies into the design of the ARPANET, and the page of the encyclopedia that footnote 68 cites at sentence 102 says that "the NPL Data Network effort appears to have had little fundamental impact on the design of ARPANET", as unit 1.43 records. Sentence 107, on Steve Crocker and the Network Working Group, has its statement in the document that footnote 76 cites at sentence 108, as unit 1.47 records. Sentences 112, 113 and 114, on the reception of packet switching by the communication professionals, are the statements of three sentences of the chapter of Lawrence Roberts that footnote 77 cites at sentence 115, as unit 1.48 records. Sentences 131 and 132, on the International Packet Switched Service, have their statements on the page that footnote 98 cites at sentence 133, which does not carry sentence 133 itself, as unit 1.60 records. Sentence 255, on the network of South Korea of 1982, has its statement on the page of the book that footnote 158 cites at sentence 256, and sentence 280, on the first connection of China in 1994, has its statement in the timeline that footnote 168 cites at sentence 281, as unit 1.106 and unit 1.114 record. Sentence 343 and the sentence after it are two consecutive sentences of the page that footnote 204 cites, as unit 1.137 records. Sentence 375 has its statement in section 2.4 of RFC 1958, which footnote 218 cites at sentence 376: "nobody owns the Internet, there is no centralized control, and nobody can turn it off". Sentence 380 follows three sentences of RFC 1174, which footnote 219 cites at sentence 378. Sentences 387, 389, 390, 391 and 397 follow sentences of the article of The Internet Protocol Journal that footnote 225 cites at sentences 392 and 396, as units 1.159, 1.160 and 1.162 record. Sentence 394, on the awards of the National Science Foundation of 1993, has its statement in the release that footnote 226 cites at sentence 395. And sentences 415 and 430 follow sentences of the guide that footnote 230 cites at sentences 416 and 431, as unit 1.167 and unit 1.173 record.

4.0 Of the 358 citations, 81 carry the sentence that cites them, 189 carry it in part, 34 do not carry it and 54 cannot be checked.

4.1 The 81 citations graded Supported are footnote 2 at sentence 2, footnote 3 at sentence 2, footnote 21 at sentence 59, footnote 26 at sentence 67, footnote 37 at sentence 71, footnote 40 at sentence 75, footnote 41 at sentence 76, footnote 48 at sentence 81, footnote 51 at sentence 82, footnote 53 at sentence 83, footnote 54 at sentence 83, footnote 39 at sentence 84, footnote 56 at sentence 85, footnote 57 at sentence 86, footnote 56 at sentence 88, footnote 60 at sentence 90, footnote 62 at sentence 95, footnote 72 at sentence 104, footnote 73 at sentence 105, footnote 75 at sentence 106, footnote 76 at sentence 108, footnote 77 at sentence 115, footnote 78 at sentence 115, footnote 79 at sentence 117, footnote 81 at sentence 118, footnote 86 at sentence 122, footnote 90 at sentence 124, footnote 91 at sentence 125, footnote 104 at sentence 151, footnote 105 at sentence 151, footnote 106 at sentence 152, footnote 91 at sentence 158, footnote 111 at sentence 159, footnote 120 at sentence 171, footnote 122 at sentence 179, footnote 23 at sentence 192, footnote 126 at sentence 203, footnote 135 at sentence 228, footnote 136 at sentence 228, footnote 80 at sentence 234, footnote 141 at sentence 234, footnote 23 at sentence 240, footnote 147 at sentence 241, footnote 148 at sentence 245, footnote 149 at sentence 246, footnote 107 at sentence 253, footnote 154 at sentence 253, footnote 163 at sentence 264, footnote 169 at sentence 283, footnote 171 at sentence 291, footnote 180 at sentence 303, footnote 182 at sentence 303, footnote 184 at sentence 312, footnote 204 at sentence 344, footnote 206 at sentence 353, footnote 209 at sentence 356, footnote 217 at sentence 374, footnote 219 at sentence 378, footnote 221 at sentence 384, footnote 225 at sentence 392, footnote 226 at sentence 395, footnote 225 at sentence 396, footnote 230 at sentence 407, footnote 230 at sentence 416, footnote 232 at sentence 420, footnote 233 at sentence 420, footnote 234 at sentence 421, footnote 230 at sentence 431, footnote 244 at sentence 442, footnote 246 at sentence 447, footnote 264 at sentence 463, footnote 272 at sentence 466, footnote 275 at sentence 467, footnote 278 at sentence 468, footnote 279 at sentence 469, footnote 296 at sentence 511, footnote 299 at sentence 518, footnote 310 at sentence 540, footnote 311 at sentence 543, footnote 39 at sentence 545 and footnote 315 at sentence 551.

4.2 The 34 citations graded Not supported are footnote 6 at sentence 22, footnote 17 at sentence 50, footnote 27 at sentence 68, footnote 28 at sentence 68, footnote 32 at sentence 69, footnote 38 at sentence 74, footnote 67 at sentence 100, footnote 68 at sentence 102, footnote 70 at sentence 104, footnote 98 at sentence 133, footnote 103 at sentence 147, footnote 2 at sentence 157, footnote 109 at sentence 157, footnote 117 at sentence 167, footnote 128 at sentence 207, footnote 131 at sentence 216, footnote 132 at sentence 220, footnote 134 at sentence 227, footnote 144 at sentence 237, footnote 158 at sentence 256, footnote 168 at sentence 281, footnote 187 at sentence 313, footnote 117 at sentence 318, footnote 189 at sentence 320, footnote 191 at sentence 332, footnote 192 at sentence 332, footnote 193 at sentence 332, footnote 200 at sentence 339, footnote 218 at sentence 376, footnote 230 at sentence 425, footnote 236 at sentence 431, footnote 245 at sentence 446, footnote 304 at sentence 531 and footnote 23 in the caption of the figure of the message block.

4.3 The 54 citations graded Uncheckable are footnote 11 at sentence 30, footnote 12 at sentence 32, footnote 29 at sentence 68, footnote 29 at sentence 69, footnote 33 at sentence 69, footnote 47 at sentence 80, footnote 55 at sentence 83, footnote 61 at sentence 91, footnote 61 at sentence 93, footnote 84 at sentence 119, footnote 85 at sentence 121, footnote 88 at sentence 123, footnote 93 at sentence 125, footnote 100 at sentence 134, footnote 110 at sentence 158, footnote 127 at sentence 205, footnote 165 at sentence 275, footnote 188 at sentence 316, footnote 199 at sentence 335, footnote 201 at sentence 340, footnote 202 at sentence 344, footnote 203 at sentence 344, footnote 208 at sentence 355, footnote 220 at sentence 381, footnote 242 at sentence 441, footnote 243 at sentence 441, footnote 251 at sentence 458, footnote 252 at sentence 458, footnote 253 at sentence 458, footnote 254 at sentence 459, footnote 255 at sentence 460, footnote 256 at sentence 460, footnote 257 at sentence 461, footnote 258 at sentence 461, footnote 259 at sentence 461, footnote 260 at sentence 462, footnote 262 at sentence 463, footnote 263 at sentence 463, footnote 267 at sentence 464, footnote 268 at sentence 464, footnote 269 at sentence 464, footnote 270 at sentence 465, footnote 271 at sentence 465, footnote 273 at sentence 466, footnote 276 at sentence 468, footnote 277 at sentence 468, footnote 281 at sentence 470, footnote 286 at sentence 493, footnote 293 at sentence 500, footnote 297 at sentence 512, footnote 305 at sentence 533, footnote 313 at sentence 545, footnote 161 in the caption of the second map and footnote 162 in the caption of the third map. No citation is graded Unread.

4.4 The 189 citations graded Partial are footnote 1 at sentence 2, footnote 4 at sentence 22, footnote 5 at sentence 22, footnote 7 at sentence 23, footnote 8 at sentence 24, footnote 9 at sentence 26, footnote 10 at sentence 29, footnote 13 at sentence 46, footnote 14 at sentence 46, footnote 15 at sentence 47, footnote 16 at sentence 47, footnote 14 at sentence 48, footnote 18 at sentence 52, footnote 19 at sentence 54, footnote 20 at sentence 57, footnote 24 at sentence 65, footnote 25 at sentence 67, footnote 30 at sentence 68, footnote 31 at sentence 69, footnote 34 at sentence 71, footnote 35 at sentence 71, footnote 36 at sentence 71, footnote 39 at sentence 75, footnote 42 at sentence 77, footnote 43 at sentence 77, footnote 44 at sentence 78, footnote 45 at sentence 78, footnote 46 at sentence 79, footnote 49 at sentence 81, footnote 50 at sentence 81, footnote 52 at sentence 82, footnote 49 at sentence 83, footnote 56 at sentence 83, footnote 49 at sentence 87, footnote 58 at sentence 87, footnote 59 at sentence 87, footnote 63 at sentence 97, footnote 64 at sentence 97, footnote 65 at sentence 97, footnote 66 at sentence 100, footnote 39 at sentence 102, footnote 69 at sentence 104, footnote 71 at sentence 104, footnote 74 at sentence 106, footnote 80 at sentence 117, footnote 82 at sentence 118, footnote 83 at sentence 118, footnote 87 at sentence 122, footnote 89 at sentence 124, footnote 92 at sentence 125, footnote 94 at sentence 125, footnote 95 at sentence 126, footnote 96 at sentence 126, footnote 97 at sentence 128, footnote 95 at sentence 129, footnote 96 at sentence 129, footnote 99 at sentence 134, footnote 101 at sentence 134, footnote 102 at sentence 139, footnote 107 at sentence 152, footnote 108 at sentence 152, footnote 89 at sentence 158, footnote 3 at sentence 164, footnote 112 at sentence 166, footnote 113 at sentence 166, footnote 114 at sentence 167, footnote 115 at sentence 167 (first citation), footnote 116 at sentence 167, footnote 115 at sentence 167 (second citation), footnote 118 at sentence 169, footnote 119 at sentence 169, footnote 121 at sentence 172, footnote 123 at sentence 194, footnote 124 at sentence 200, footnote 125 at sentence 201, footnote 129 at sentence 209, footnote 129 at sentence 210, footnote 130 at sentence 211, footnote 133 at sentence 221, footnote 137 at sentence 229, footnote 138 at sentence 230, footnote 139 at sentence 231, footnote 109 at sentence 233, footnote 140 at sentence 233, footnote 142 at sentence 237, footnote 143 at sentence 237, footnote 145 at sentence 241, footnote 146 at sentence 241, footnote 150 at sentence 250, footnote 151 at sentence 250, footnote 152 at sentence 251, footnote 153 at sentence 251, footnote 142 at sentence 252, footnote 155 at sentence 253, footnote 23 at sentence 254, footnote 23 at sentence 256, footnote 156 at sentence 256, footnote 157 at sentence 256, footnote 23 at sentence 257, footnote 159 at sentence 261, footnote 164 at sentence 272, footnote 166 at sentence 277, footnote 167 at sentence 278, footnote 172 at sentence 292, footnote 173 at sentence 293, footnote 174 at sentence 293, footnote 175 at sentence 294, footnote 176 at sentence 299, footnote 177 at sentence 299, footnote 178 at sentence 301, footnote 179 at sentence 302, footnote 181 at sentence 303, footnote 183 at sentence 304, footnote 185 at sentence 312, footnote 186 at sentence 312, footnote 189 at sentence 317, footnote 190 at sentence 319, footnote 194 at sentence 332, footnote 195 at sentence 333, footnote 196 at sentence 333, footnote 197 at sentence 333, footnote 198 at sentence 333, footnote 205 at sentence 352, footnote 207 at sentence 354, footnote 210 at sentence 357, footnote 209 at sentence 357, footnote 207 at sentence 358, footnote 209 at sentence 358, footnote 207 at sentence 360, footnote 209 at sentence 361, footnote 206 at sentence 361, footnote 211 at sentence 362, footnote 212 at sentence 362, footnote 213 at sentence 363, footnote 214 at sentence 366, footnote 215 at sentence 371, footnote 216 at sentence 372, footnote 219 at sentence 385, footnote 222 at sentence 386, footnote 223 at sentence 386, footnote 224 at sentence 388, footnote 227 at sentence 398, footnote 228 at sentence 400, footnote 229 at sentence 401, footnote 231 at sentence 407, footnote 230 at sentence 421, footnote 235 at sentence 422, footnote 236 at sentence 425, footnote 237 at sentence 426, footnote 238 at sentence 435, footnote 239 at sentence 437, footnote 240 at sentence 441, footnote 241 at sentence 441, footnote 247 at sentence 447, footnote 248 at sentence 448, footnote 249 at sentence 448, footnote 250 at sentence 449, footnote 261 at sentence 462, footnote 265 at sentence 463, footnote 266 at sentence 463, footnote 274 at sentence 466, footnote 280 at sentence 469, footnote 282 at sentence 474, footnote 283 at sentence 476, footnote 284 at sentence 477, footnote 285 at sentence 491, footnote 287 at sentence 495, footnote 288 at sentence 496, footnote 289 at sentence 498, footnote 290 at sentence 498, footnote 291 at sentence 499, footnote 292 at sentence 500, footnote 294 at sentence 508, footnote 295 at sentence 508, footnote 298 at sentence 516, footnote 299 at sentence 517, footnote 300 at sentence 517, footnote 301 at sentence 521, footnote 302 at sentence 522, footnote 303 at sentence 529, footnote 306 at sentence 534, footnote 307 at sentence 535, footnote 308 at sentence 536, footnote 309 at sentence 537, footnote 312 at sentence 544, footnote 314 at sentence 546, footnote 22 in the caption of the figure of the message block, footnote 160 in the caption of the first map and footnote 170 in the caption of the chart of hosts, and units 1.1 through 1.230 state for each which part of the sentence its source carries.

5.0 The claims on this page are open to documented challenge on the standing terms of marknichols.com, and the terms are stated here in full.

5.1 The claims on this page are open to challenge on the same terms as every claim on marknichols.com. A challenger who holds that a claim on this page is wrong, or that the Internet is something other than the publicly joinable network of networks of the registry lineage defined at The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, states the competing claim or definition in one sentence, names the document that carries it and the document’s date, and sends both to mark@marknichols.com. A challenge submitted with its document is answered on this page, and a competing definition submitted with its document is added to this page as an exhibit with attribution to the person who submitted it; a challenge submitted without a document is an opinion and is heard as one.

5.2 The distinction the site’s definition rests on, that protocols enable interoperability and are not the Internet, is stated in the IETF’s own words, RFC 2026 and STD 1, in the Internet-Draft draft-mnichols-protocols-not-the-internet-01, posted by Mark Nichols to the IETF Datatracker on September 25, 2026 at https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-mnichols-protocols-not-the-internet/ and stated on this site at Protocols Are Not the Internet: The IETF Internet-Draft by Mark Nichols, so a challenger may also address the definition in the venue that publishes the protocol standards themselves. Any person who holds expertise in telecommunications and a competing claim or definition is invited to bring both, in writing, with the document.

6.0 The Definitions Addendum reproduces the Governing Definitions D1 through D13 of marknichols.com word for word, and every finding on this page is made under them.

6.1 Every finding on this page is made under the Governing Definitions of marknichols.com, D1 through D13, which are reproduced in this addendum word for word from The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking. A reader of this page either accepts these definitions or disputes them. A reader who disputes a definition states the competing definition in one sentence and names the dated document that carries it before opining on any finding of this page. A reader who opines on the findings without disputing a definition has read the findings under these definitions by default.

6.2 The definitions below are copied word for word from the section “These definitions are employed throughout marknichols.com” of The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, as that page read on November 13, 2026, and that page controls wherever a copy differs from it.

D1. The Internet (capital I). The publicly joinable network of networks of the registry lineage: the fabric whose addresses and autonomous system numbers were issued by the InterNIC and are maintained today by ARIN. A person joins it by purchasing access from any of competing commercial providers, for any lawful purpose, and a network joins it by obtaining addresses and an autonomous system number from the numbering registry and then interconnecting by agreement with any willing network, the way Digital Island joined under autonomous system AS6553, issued August 29, 1996 by the InterNIC, with the registration maintained today in ARIN’s registry. No owner grants admission, no written policy screens members or their purposes, and no government sponsorship is required, and that single property, open admission, is what separates the Internet from every gated network that existed before it. The capital-I Internet was born in 1991, when independently operated commercial networks of this lineage, PSINet, AlterNet under UUNET, and CERFnet, interconnected by their own agreement as the Commercial Internet eXchange (CIX), settlement-free and free of any purpose-screening policy, and it was born small: the gated research world stood beside it until April 30, 1995, upon the decommission of NSFNET folded into internetMCI, per orders of Congress. Neither the ARPANET intranet, which admitted members only by agency authorization, nor the NSFNET intranet, which admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education, met this definition on any day of either existence, so the capital I names an Internet network that is public, or it names nothing. Paragraphs D1.1 through D1.7 state why the ARPANET and the NSFNET are not in the lineage of the Internet, each on its document.

D1.1 A network stands in the lineage of the Internet only if it carried the trait that defines the Internet, and D1 names that trait as one property, open admission; a network that never carried open admission had no such trait to pass on, and the ARPANET and the NSFNET never carried it, so neither the ARPANET nor the NSFNET is the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet, and neither the ARPANET nor the NSFNET became the Internet.

D1.2 The ARPANET admitted members by its owner’s authorization from its procurement to its end: Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002, issued July 29, 1968 for the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense, states the network’s purpose as “making these advanced research computer systems available to users outside their own design circle,” a purpose among the owner’s research contractors, as F37 of this page records; admission ran through agency authorization, as D4 of this page records; and the ARPANET ran from 1969 to 1990, as F38 of this page records, so the ARPANET was an intranet under D2 on every day of its existence and never carried open admission.

D1.3 The NSFNET admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education, as D7 of this page records, and its backbone was terminated on April 30, 1995, when its regional networks passed principally to internetMCI and SprintLink, which, in the words of Merit Network, the operator of record, absorbed the NSFNET regionals as their customers, so the NSFNET’s member networks joined the Internet as customers on terms the NSFNET never offered, and the NSFNET itself ended and did not become the Internet.

D1.4 The trait that defines the Internet has a documented origin outside the gated networks: the release of March 25, 1991 by General Atomics, Performance Systems International, Inc., and UUNET Technologies, Inc., seated at F52 of this page, states that the three networks “are not subject to government mandated “acceptable use” restrictions on their traffic,” states that the agreement can be expanded “to include any commercial service which has no restrictions on traffic use,” and states that the exchange allows firms to communicate “without traversing the government restricted backbones, such as the NSFNET (National Science Foundation Network),” so the Internet was built by agreement among commercial networks to carry traffic around the gated backbone, and the Internet did not grow out of the gated backbone.

D1.5 The ARPANET, the NSFNET, and the Internet each performed internetworking under D3, and a shared function is not a shared lineage: RFC 2026, The Internet Standards Process, Revision 3, by Scott O. Bradner of Harvard University, published October 1996, states at its section 1.1 that “There are also many isolated interconnected networks, which are not connected to the global Internet but use the Internet Standards,” so a network that uses the same protocols as the Internet is a user of the same tools and is not thereby the Internet or its ancestor. A redwood and a palm are both called trees, and a redwood did not grow from a palm, and a palm cannot become a redwood; the gated internets of the ARPANET and the NSFNET and the capital-I Internet are both called internets, and the shared word names a shared function and not a shared tree. The shared word was applied to the gated networks in error, and this record documents the error by document and date: the Stanford University bronze dedicated July 28, 2005 casts the headline “BIRTH OF THE INTERNET” above an inscription that records protocol work, as Stanford University Is Petitioned to Retract the Headline of Its BIRTH OF THE INTERNET Plaque records; RFC 1208, A Glossary of Networking Terms, by Ole J. Jacobsen and Daniel C. Lynch of Interop, Inc., published March 1991 as a document that in its own words “does not specify an Internet standard,” calls the ARPANET the “grandfather” of today’s Internet with no document for the descent it asserts; and IEEE Milestone 94 of October 29, 2009 is titled “Birthplace of the Internet, 1969,” as F46.1 of this page records.

D1.6 The registry lineage named in D1 is a continuity of numbering administration, the assignment of network addresses and autonomous system numbers by the Network Information Center at SRI, then by the InterNIC, and today by ARIN, and the registry lineage is not a lineage of networks: the Network Information Center at SRI kept the Official Host Table of the ARPANET’s era, as D4 of this page records, and a number assigned by a registry admits no one to any network, so the continuity of the numbering places no gated network in the lineage of the Internet.

D1.7 On every page of marknichols.com, the ARPANET and the NSFNET are named earlier gated networks, networks that also performed internetworking, or intranets under D2, and no page of marknichols.com calls either network the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, the precursor, or the forerunner of the Internet, places either network in the lineage of the Internet, or states that either network became, evolved into, or grew into the Internet, under the ruling of Mark Nichols of November 7, 2026 that the ARPANET and the NSFNET belong to the history of internetworking and not to the lineage of the Internet, and that the Internet is a separate species.

D1.8 The plain statements of D1.1 through D1.7 are these. The ARPANET is not the Internet. The NSFNET is not the Internet. The ARPANET did not become the Internet. The NSFNET did not become the Internet. The ARPANET is not the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet. The NSFNET is not the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet. The ARPANET was an intranet, because the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense owned the ARPANET and admitted the ARPANET’s members by permission. The NSFNET was an intranet, because the NSFNET backbone admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education. The Internet admits anyone, and open admission is the one property that defines the Internet. Open admission came to the Internet from the commercial networks PSINet, AlterNet, and CERFnet at the Commercial Internet eXchange announced on March 25, 1991, and open admission did not come from the ARPANET or from the NSFNET. The ARPANET ended in 1990. The NSFNET backbone ended on April 30, 1995. The ARPANET, the NSFNET, and the Internet share the function of internetworking and share the word internet, and a shared function and a shared word are not a shared lineage. The Internet was born in 1991, and the Internet was not born from the ARPANET or from the NSFNET.

D2. intranet. A network, at any scale, in any geography, and under any protocol, whose members join by an owner’s permission. The word carries its own definition: intra means within, and an intranet is a network within a bounded and credentialed community, whether that community is one company’s offices or one government’s contractors spread across two continents. Scale does not convert an intranet into the Internet, geography does not, and protocol does not, because a gated network that adopts the optional protocols TCP/IP has changed its plumbing and not its admission policy; only open admission makes the Internet, and a research intranet is not the Internet. NSFNET and ARPANET are historical examples of intranets under this definition. Neither was the Internet, and neither became the Internet merely by being technically interconnected with other networks.

D3. internetworking. The technique of interconnecting distinct networks through gateways so that traffic originating on one can reach hosts on another. Internetworking among gated intranets was operating in production by 1975, when the gateway at University College London, developed and operated by Peter Kirstein’s group, of which Peter Higginson was a principal member, joined the ARPANET to the United Kingdom’s EPSS, an operation documented in the September 1975 paper of Peter L. Higginson and Andrew J. Hinchley, which recorded the working gateway while filing the Cerf and Kahn protocol as a future option rather than the operating method. Internetworking among gated intranets makes a lowercase internet, in the exact lowercase vocabulary of RFC 1983, and it never makes the capital-I Internet, because interconnecting two gated networks produces a larger gated system, not a public one. The credit for internetworking belongs to the engineers who built and operated the gateways; that credit does not extend to the birth of the Internet, which did not yet exist.

D4. ARPANET, also rendered DARPANET. The ARPA Network: one organization’s intranet, built, funded, owned, and access-controlled by the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense, later renamed DARPA, from its commissioning in 1969 until its decommissioning in 1990. Its very name is a possessive, the agency’s initials welded onto the agency’s property, and the network’s renamings followed the owner’s renamings, as only an owned network’s can. Admission was by the owner’s authorization for the owner’s purposes, the Official Host Table of the Network Information Center at SRI, the register of the era’s hosts that preceded the optional protocol DNS, listed 235 hosts in May 1982 and 562 hosts in August 1983, the two counts in RFC 1296 of January 1992 that bracket the 1983 protocol cutover, and no member of the public could join it, buy from it, or sell across it on any day of its twenty-one years. The owner stated the network’s purpose in its own procurement instrument before the network existed: Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002, issued July 29, 1968 by the Defense Supply Service-Washington of the Department of the Army for the Advanced Research Projects Agency under ARPA Order No. 1260, and signed by Thomas J. Scheblik, Deputy Director for Procurement, solicited the Interface Message Processors for the ARPA computer network, and its Statement of Work, Specifications of Interface Message Processors for the ARPA Computer Network, states that the Agency was forming the network “with the cooperation of its research contractors,” that the network’s potential lay in “making these advanced research computer systems available to users outside their own design circle,” and that the network itself was “a subject of study and experimentation,” while the Statement of Work’s nineteen pages and seven appendices contain no reference to war, to survivability, to attack, to command and control, or to any military mission. The design mission of the ARPANET was therefore resource sharing among the owner’s research contractors, stated by the owner in 1968, and the later recollections agree with the instrument: Charles Herzfeld, Director of ARPA from 1965 to 1967, stated that the ARPANET was not started to create a command and control system that would survive a nuclear attack; Vint Cerf recorded on the Internet Society’s internet-history list on September 1, 2009 that Larry Roberts confirmed the purpose of the ARPANET was resource sharing and that the nuclear resilience story came from Paul Baran’s earlier work; and the Internet Society’s own history, A Brief History of the Internet, calls that story a false rumor that arose from the unrelated RAND study. The wartime mission, command traffic surviving damaged links and destroyed nodes, belonged to the owner’s later internetting project, which Vint Cerf managed at DARPA and demonstrated by putting packet radios in Strategic Air Command aircraft, and the optional protocol TCP, specified in 1974 with military computer communication requirements as the stated primary focus of RFC 793 of September 1981, was designed for that mission and installed on this intranet by the owner’s directive in 1983. The ARPANET is not the Internet, and DARPANET is not the Internet: one organization’s intranet is not the publicly joinable network of networks. The ARPANET intranet was procured under Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002 of July 29, 1968, ran from 1969, and carried its traffic for fourteen years, under the Network Control Program, an optional protocol first specified in RFC 33 of February 1970, before TCP was added to it on January 1, 1983; a protocol added to a working network fourteen years after the network was procured is an add-on to that network, not its birth.

D5. Flag day, January 1, 1983. A scheduled protocol cutover, from NCP to TCP/IP, planned within the ARPANET community for years and executed on the owner’s own plant: an intranet’s internal maintenance event, touching no member of the public because no member of the public was on the network before the cutover or after it. The protocol installed that day was commissioned by the same owner to weld its own three networks together, the terrestrial ARPANET, its mobile packet radio network, and its satellite network, crossing dissimilar media under a single owner without ever crossing an owner, so that traffic could survive battlefield destruction. The Internet’s own standards registry graded TCP “Recommended” and never “Required,” in RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997, grades that bind only systems electing to implement the standard suite, and a protocol cutover on a gated intranet is not the birth of anything. The network the protocol was cut over onto had been procured on July 29, 1968 and running since 1969, fourteen years before that day, so the cutover added a protocol to an existing intranet and created no network.

D6. The Internet protocols, the optional protocols TCP and IP. Protocols are utilities whose messages the networks carry; they are not the networks, and they are not the Internet. Under these Governing Definitions, TCP and IP are optional protocols, and paragraphs D6.1 through D6.13 state the documents on which that definition rests and the judgment of Mark Nichols that completes it.

D6.1 The Internet’s own standards registry, issued first by the Internet Activities Board and later by the Internet Architecture Board, under the title IAB Official Protocol Standards and from RFC 1500 of August 1993 under the title Internet Official Protocol Standards, assigned a status to each listed protocol in twenty-two editions, from RFC 1083 of December 1988 through RFC 2400 of September 1998.

D6.2 Every one of those twenty-two editions lists TCP, the Transmission Control Protocol of RFC 793, at the status “Recommended”, printed “Rec” from RFC 1280 of March 1992 onward, and lists IP, the Internet Protocol of RFC 791, at the status “Required”, printed “Req” from RFC 1280 onward, and not one of the twenty-two editions lists TCP at the status “Required” in any of its tables.

D6.3 RFC 1200 of April 1991, issued by the Internet Activities Board with Jon Postel as editor, and RFC 2200 of June 1997, issued by the Internet Architecture Board with Jon Postel as editor, each define the status “Required” at section 4.2.1 in the words “A system must implement the required protocols”, define the status “Recommended” at section 4.2.2 in the words “A system should implement the recommended protocols”, and define the status “Elective” at section 4.2.3 in the words “A system may or may not implement an elective protocol”, so that by the registry’s own definitions TCP is a protocol that a system should implement and is not a protocol that a system must implement.

D6.4 RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997 each open by stating that the edition “describes the state of standardization of protocols used in the Internet” as determined by its board, and each states that “Few protocols are required to be implemented in all systems” because of the variety of possible systems, gateways, terminal servers, workstations and multi-user hosts among them.

D6.5 RFC 1122, Requirements for Internet Hosts -- Communication Layers, edited by Robert Braden for the Internet Engineering Task Force in October 1989 and listed at the status “Required” in RFC 2200 of June 1997, states at its section 1.1.3 that “To communicate using the Internet system, a host must implement the layered set of protocols comprising the Internet protocol suite” and, in the next sentence, that “A host typically must implement at least one protocol from each layer”, so RFC 1122 binds a host that has chosen to communicate using the Internet system, and RFC 1122 requires of that host at least one transport protocol, not TCP.

D6.6 RFC 1122 of October 1989 states at its section 1.1.3 that “There are two primary transport layer protocols at present”, naming TCP and UDP, and that “the set of official Internet transport protocols may be expanded in the future”, states at its section 4.2.1 that “TCP is used by those applications needing reliable, connection-oriented transport service”, and states at its section 4.1.1 that “UDP is used by applications that do not require the level of service of TCP”, so RFC 1122 itself assigns TCP by the needs of the application.

D6.7 RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997 each list, at section 6.3, Network-Specific Standard Protocols, the transmission of IP over each type of physical network, ARPANET, X.25, Ethernet, IEEE 802, FDDI and serial lines among them, at the status “Elective”, and each states that “it is elective to support any particular type of physical network” on which IP is transmitted.

D6.8 RFC 2500 of June 1999 prints no status for TCP or for IP, RFC 5000 of May 2008, the last edition of the registry, prints no status for TCP or for IP, and RFC 7100 of December 2013, written by Pete Resnick of Qualcomm Technologies, Inc., obsoletes RFC 5000 and requests that RFC 5000, and therefore STD 1, be moved to Historic status, so the last status that the Internet’s own standards registry ever assigned to TCP is “Recommended”, in RFC 2400 of September 1998.

D6.9 The IP that the registry listed at the status “Required” is version 4 of the Internet Protocol, RFC 791, and the Internet Engineering Task Force standardized a second and separate Internet Protocol, version 6, in RFC 8200 of July 2017, STD 86, by S. Deering and R. Hinden. RFC 6540 of April 2012, BCP 177, titled IPv6 Support Required for All IP-Capable Nodes and written by W. George of Time Warner Cable, C. Donley of CableLabs, C. Liljenstolpe of Big Switch Networks and L. Howard of Time Warner Cable, advises that “IPv6 support is no longer considered optional”, cautions that the term “IP” has become “a generic that can mean IPv4 + IPv6, IPv6-only, or IPv4-only, depending on context and application”, and states that new and updated IP networking implementations “must not require IPv4 for proper and complete function”, so the Internet Engineering Task Force itself used the word optional for an Internet Protocol until April 2012, and the IP version that the registry listed at the status “Required” is, under the Best Current Practice of April 2012, a version that no new or updated implementation may require.

D6.10 The suite’s own members prove reliability is a per-application choice, because the optional protocols UDP of RFC 768, RTP of RFC 1889 of January 1996, which RFC 3550 of July 2003 obsoletes, and QUIC of RFC 9000 all decline TCP’s services while each remains a protocol of the Internet standards track.

D6.11 TCP is an evolutionary option, not a permanent fixture: it replaced NCP on the owner’s intranet in the 1983 cutover, UDP stood beside it from 1980 for applications that declined its services, RTP went around it in 1996 for media that could not wait for retransmission, and QUIC, published in May 2021, is displacing it now by moving reliability into a new protocol carried inside UDP datagrams; the protocols rotate while the Internet persists, and a layer whose occupants rotate is by definition not the thing itself.

D6.12 It is the stated judgment of Mark Nichols that both are optional utilities: TCP optional on the registry’s own grade, and IP optional as a specific protocol, because the registry’s “Required” grade is conditional conformance language that binds only systems electing to implement the standard suite, the election being made before the grade applies, as the words “To communicate using the Internet system” of RFC 1122 and the word optional that RFC 6540 applies to IPv6 both record, and because what internetworking requires is the addressing function, the label that says where a packet should go, while IP is one implementation of that function and not the function itself.

D6.13 Hence the rebrand coinages stated at marknichols.com/internet-protocols/: TCP is better named ESFRP, the Endpoint Segment Failure Retry Protocol, and IP is better named ALP, the Address Label Protocol. The postmen are not the post office, and the protocols are not the Internet.

D7. NSFNET. The National Science Foundation’s backbone, 1986 to 1995: a federation of research intranets joined into a lowercase internet under a written Acceptable Use Policy that restricted carriage to research and education and barred commercial traffic. The dismantling is dated by the operator of record, Merit Network: the replacement architecture was awarded early in 1994, the very high speed Backbone Network Service to MCI and the Network Access Points to Sprint, MFS Datanet, and Bellcore representing Ameritech and PacBell; member networks began moving off in November 1994; the backbone was terminated on April 30, 1995; and the regional networks passed principally to the commercial carriers internetMCI and SprintLink, which, in Merit’s own words, absorbed the NSFNET regionals as their customers. The NSFNET is not the Internet: a backbone admission-screened under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education is a gated network, and a gated network is not the publicly joinable network of networks.

D8. The World Wide Web. An application design made by many persons inside and outside CERN, announced publicly on August 6, 1991, three programs of CERN's World Wide Web software, the line-mode client, the basic server and the library of common code, released into the public domain by CERN on April 30, 1993, with NCSA Mosaic released in 1993 putting a graphical browser in front of it. A free application is not an open network: until April 30, 1995, the Web’s principal carriage was the gated research intranets beneath it, research-only carriage under the written policy, and the calendar states the dependency exactly, because CERN's three programs of Web software went public on April 30, 1993, and the gated research fabric beneath most of its hosts was absorbed into the public Internet two years later to the day, on April 30, 1995. The name World Wide Web is a label for a large body of technology in the public domain, made by many persons and bodies inside and outside CERN, as F32.4 of this page states. The World Wide Web is not the Internet: the Web is an application using the Internet platform, and the application is not the platform.

D9. The birth of the Internet, and the absorption. The capital-I Internet was born in 1991, when PSINet, AlterNet under UUNET, and CERFnet, independently operated commercial networks of the registry lineage, established the Commercial Internet eXchange, a settlement-free router interconnection with open admission and no purpose-screening policy, as recorded in the Federal Communications Commission working paper The Digital Handshake by Michael Kende and as announced by the three networks’ operators themselves, General Atomics, Performance Systems International, Inc., and UUNET Technologies, Inc., in their release of March 25, 1991, which states that “The CIX agreement provides for all customers of AlterNet, CERFnet and PSINet to exchange Internet traffic directly, regardless of which network the customer obtains service from, and at no additional cost” and that the three “are not subject to government mandated “acceptable use” restrictions on their traffic,” the release being preserved as message 441 of the com-priv archive at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and seated at F52 of this page; the agreement’s own text and its execution date are still sought, and the ruling stands on the dated announcement, the year, the parties, and the terms until a dated earlier instrument of the same lineage is produced. April 30, 1995 is not the Internet’s birthday; it is the absorption: the day the last written admission policy over the general-purpose research backbone died with the NSFNET, the regional networks passed principally to internetMCI and SprintLink, and the populations that had lived behind the gate joined the Internet that had existed without them since 1991. Being born is not the same as being built, and the Modern Internet, publicly accessible, eCommerce native, media streaming native, and QoS native, was built from 1996 to 1997 on executed documents: the Telecommunications Act signed February 8, 1996, autonomous system AS6553 issued August 29, 1996 by the InterNIC, the $300,000 Cisco Systems agreement of November 1996 to host cisco.com on Digital Island’s Tier-0 network, and production service in the first quarter of 1997, with Cisco Systems, Stanford University, and Visa International as the first customers in sequence.

D10. The Modern Internet. The Internet changed from the legacy Internet to the Modern Internet on the day its internetworking changed from best effort to deterministic, and that day is November 1, 1996, the Effective Date of the Cisco Systems Remote Data Services Agreement, signed for Digital Island, Inc. by Mark Nichols, Director, Global Networks, on November 7, 1996 and for Cisco Systems, Inc. by Hervé Goguely, Director, Global Service Management, on November 8, 1996, under which Cisco Systems became the first customer to buy a contractually guaranteed global service, a network segment exclusively its own with secure transaction services and sub-300 milliseconds round trip, on the architecture Mark Nichols hand-drew in June 1996, redrew as DIGITAL ISLAND DRAFT.1 in July 1996 and DRAFT.2 in October 1996, and registered as AS6553, issued to Digital Island, Inc. on August 29, 1996. An evolution, not a synonym. The capital-I Internet born in 1991 and made general-purpose by the absorption of April 30, 1995 was public but bare: a network anyone could join, and nothing commerce-grade could yet depend on, because open admission supplies members and does not supply performance. The Modern Internet is what that public network evolved into when global commerce was engineered onto it: the enabling of the globalization of eCommerce, of streaming media, and of Quality of Service under signed and enforceable terms, built on Digital Island’s Tier-0 network under autonomous system AS6553 with contractually enforced sub-300-millisecond round-trip performance across major markets, carrying the Merchant Transport product category coined in September 1996, on the architecture designed by Mark Nichols as co-founder and chief architect, the record standing at marknichols.com/architect-of-the-modern-internet/, marknichols.com/merchant-transport/, and marknichols.com/tier-0/. The evolution is dated by the executed record and by the customers who ran on AS6553 in sequence: Cisco Systems in November 1996, Stanford University in 1997, Visa International in the second quarter of 1997, E*TRADE under its global data distribution agreement with Digital Island dated August 1, 1997, as Digital Island’s S-1 records it, Charles Schwab in 1998, and MasterCard in March 1999; Telefónica Data formed a global IP alliance with Digital Island on April 26, 1999, Sun Microsystems and Inktomi invested in Digital Island in December 1999, Microsoft, Intel, and Compaq invested in Digital Island in June 2000, and CERNET, the China Education and Research Network, peered with Digital Island under the contract signed in Beijing on February 25, 1998 and was never a customer. The Modern Internet is therefore dated 1996 to 1997 in executed documents, and the word modern means publicly accessible, commerce-grade, streaming-capable, and QoS-governed, none of which the newborn network possessed.

D11. Usage. On every page of this site, Internet with a capital I means the publicly joinable network of the registry lineage born in 1991 and nothing else; internet in lowercase means any interconnection of networks, including gated ones; gated systems are named what they were, research intranets, whatever their date; and any page, headline, plaque, or biography that assigns the birth of the Internet to 1969, 1974, or 1983 is measured against these definitions and fails, because on each of those dates every network in the claim admitted its members by permission, and any account that assigns the birth to April 30, 1995 is measured against these definitions and fails as well, because on that date the Internet already existed and what died was the gate beside it. And on every page of this site, “Required” as a registry grade appears only in quotation marks with its condition stated in the same sentence, that it binds only systems electing to implement the standard suite, except within D6 of this page, where D6.12 states that condition once for every quotation of the registry in D6.1 through D6.11; this site’s own prose never calls any Internet protocol required, because at the level of Internet membership there are no required protocols, only elected ones, and an unconditional “required” applied to an Internet protocol is the registry’s conditional conformance label promoted into a membership law that no document states.

D11.1 Definitions govern meaning. Documents govern facts. Findings govern conclusions.

D12. Contemporary primary-source documents control over retrospective accounts, institutional narratives, biographies, media summaries, machine-generated responses, and personal recollections.

D13. Any finding in this record may be amended upon production of contemporaneous documentary evidence demonstrating a materially earlier, later, or contrary fact.