Wikipedia CERN: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol

Of the 249 citations in the Wikipedia article CERN, 134 carry the sentence that cites them, 74 carry it in part, 19 do not carry it and 22 cannot be checked, and page 50 of the CERN Annual Report 2019, which the article cites for 25 member states, lists 23 member states as of December 31, 2019, the History of CERN of 1987, which the article cites for the statement that 12 countries ratified the convention on September 29, 1954, dates the deposits of the twelve ratifications from December 30, 1953 to February 24, 1955 and gives September 29, 1954 to France and the Federal Republic of Germany, and the figure of 1515 million Swiss francs that the article gives as the budget of 2026 stands in the cited budget document as the cash outflow of 2026.

Preamble: I audit the Wikipedia article CERN footnote by footnote, opening the source that each footnote cites and reading it against the sentence that cites it. This page is the companion of Disagreement 68 in the standing index of the series, Disagreements of Published Claims | Network, Not Protocol, and the article lines cited on this page are the numbered lines of Exhibit A of Wikipedia Describes CERN: Disagreements | Network, Not Protocol. The method and the five grades are the same as on Wikipedia Robert Cailliau: Reference Audit | Network, Not Protocol.

Opinion Rules: You are visiting my record, and I am the subject matter expert on it. If you are a subject matter expert too, I want to hear from you: bring your document and I will answer it on the record. If you are not, you are welcome here to read and to learn. The documented-challenge terms of marknichols.com and the condition on opinion are stated at F40 of The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, and they govern this page.

Conditional on the Governing Definitions: Every finding on this page is conditional on the Governing Definitions D1 through D13 of marknichols.com, which are reproduced in full in the Definitions Addendum at the bottom of this page.

0.0 This section records the article this page audits, the method of the audit, and the grades it assigns.

0.1 The article audited on this page is CERN of the English Wikipedia, the article on the European Organization for Nuclear Research, in the revision of November 8, 2026 that Exhibit A of Disagreement 68 reproduces. Wikipedia's revision history, read through Wikipedia's own public interface on November 15, 2026, records that revision as revision 1384478899, saved at 12:16 UTC on November 8, 2026 by the account Spartaz with the edit summary "Removing link(s) because [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of streets at CERN]] closed as delete ([[WP:XFDC#4.0.16|XFDcloser]])". The history records no later revision as of November 15, 2026.

0.2 Revision 1384478899 carries 229 numbered footnotes in one list and six notes, numbered 1 through 6, in a second list. The footnotes are cited 249 times: 246 times in the body of the article and three times in two of the notes. Note 2, which stands at line 197, cites footnotes 113 and 114, and note 4, which stands at line 210, cites footnote 117. Notes 1, 3, 5 and 6 cite no footnote. Eighteen footnotes, numbers 14, 16, 17, 23, 55, 104, 106, 110, 112, 116, 123, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131 and 147, are each cited at two lines, and footnote 148 is cited at three lines. This page read the list of footnotes, the links of each footnote and the position of each citation in revision 1384478899 through Wikipedia's own public interface, and matched every citation to its line of Exhibit A, of whose 431 lines 175 carry at least one citation. The caption of the first map at line 240 carries one further marker, the letter a, which leads to no note and to no footnote in the revision.

0.3 This page audited the footnotes on November 15, 2026. It opened each source at the archived copy that the footnote names, or, where the footnote names none, at an archived copy of the address that the footnote gives, and the unit that grades the footnote gives the date of the copy that was read. Where this page found no readable copy in the Wayback Machine, or found a copy that is cut off, it read the live page or the live file, and the unit says so. Where the cited page is the record of a report or of a paper, this page read the file of the report or of the paper, or the part of the file that the unit names, and where it did not read the file the unit says so. Where the cited paper sits behind a publisher's paywall, this page read an open copy at the site of the publisher, of an author or of a repository where it found one, and otherwise the abstract. Where the abstract of a paper, or the publisher's description of a book, itself carries what the citation is graded on, this page in several units read no further, and each of those units says what was read. Where a footnote cites a book, this page read the cited pages from their images in the preview of Google Books, or, where the footnote cites no page, searched the book there and read the pages that the search returned. Where Google Books shows no page of a book, this page read the snippets of text that its search of the book returns, and the unit says so. Where the claim sits in a scanned document, this page read the scan by optical character recognition and checked the words that it quotes against the image. Of the 229 footnotes, 169 were read in full, or retrieved in full and searched; 53 were read in part, at the cited pages of a book or of a report, at a preview or at snippets of a book, at an abstract or at the page of a publisher; and 7 could not be read. The unit that grades each footnote states which of the three applies.

0.4 Each citation receives one of five grades. Supported means that the source carries the sentence in its own words. Partial means that the source carries part of the sentence and not the rest. Not supported means that the source was read and does not carry the sentence. Uncheckable means that the citation cannot be followed to a readable source. Unread means that the source was not read for this page, and no citation of this article is graded Unread. A citation is graded against the sentence or the clause that it follows, and where a footnote stands after a name inside a list, as at line 115, line 370 and line 395, it is graded against what the line says of the thing named. A fuller name for a thing that the source identifies does not make a grade Partial, and a date, a figure, a person, an attribution or a description that the source does not carry does. Where a footnote cites pages of a book or of a report and those pages were read, the citation is graded on those pages. Where only the abstract of a source, a preview or snippets of it, or a part of it that the footnote does not name, could be read, the citation is graded Supported when that part itself carries the sentence and Uncheckable when it does not, and the unit states what the part carries; where the part that was read states the fact itself in another way than the sentence does, the citation is graded on that part. Where a source is older than the fact that the sentence reports, or speaks of that fact as a thing to come, the source cannot carry the fact, and the citation is graded Partial when the source carries the rest of the sentence or the plan and Not supported when it carries nothing of the sentence; a source that this page could not open at all stays Uncheckable, and the unit states its date. Where the cited page presents a video or a broadcast, this page read the text of the page and did not play the recording, and the citation is graded Supported when the text carries the sentence and Uncheckable when it does not.

0.5 The sources are quoted on this page in short fragments, and the rest of what each source says is stated in the words of this page. The sentences of the article are for the most part restated in the words of this page, and their text stands in Exhibit A of Disagreement 68. Where a site asked this page for a sign-in or a payment, or stopped it at a check for automated visitors, this page stopped there and did not go around the barrier, and the unit says so. Four footnotes cite articles of publishers whose sites this page does not open under the rules of its tools: footnote 79 cites The New York Times, footnote 221 cites Wired, and footnotes 210 and 211 cite copies of an article of The New York Times and of an article of Wired News that stand as files on a site of CERN, and their units say so.

1.0 Each of the 229 footnotes of the article is graded at each sentence that cites it.

1.1 Footnote 1 cites James Gillies, CERN and the Higgs Boson: The Global Quest for the Building Blocks of Reality (Icon Books, 2018), with no page. This page searched the book in the preview of Google Books and read the opening pages of its fourth chapter from their page images. The chapter, which is headed "A NEW LABORATORY IS BORN", opens on the day that it writes as 29 September 1954, and it says that on that day France and Germany deposited their instruments of ratification of the convention of CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, "formally bringing the European Organization for Nuclear Research into existence". Line 5, the entry of the infobox that dates the formation of the organization to September 29, 1954, is carried by those words, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.2 Footnote 2 cites "Professor Costas Fountas elected as next President of the CERN Council", a press release of CERN of September 30, 2024, read in full in the copy archived on May 23, 2025 that the footnote names. The release says that the CERN Council "elected Professor Costas Fountas as its 25th President, for a period of one year, renewable twice, with a mandate starting on 1 January 2025". Line 9, the entry of the infobox, names Costas Fountas as the President of the Council in the revision of November 2026 that this page audits. The release carries the election of the person whom the entry names and a mandate of one year from January 1, 2025. A release of September 2024 cannot carry the holding of the office in 2026, which rests on a renewal of the mandate, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.3 Footnote 3 cites Davide Castelvecchi, "New CERN chief pledges to forge ahead with $17-billion supercollider", Nature, November 7, 2024, and gives a digital object identifier (DOI) and no archived copy. This page read the article in full in the copy of the publisher's page archived on November 14, 2024. The article says "British particle physicist Mark Thomson has been named as the next leader of CERN", and it says "Thomson will take up the director-general post when Gianotti’s second consecutive five-year term ends at the end of 2025." Line 10, the entry of the infobox, names Mark Thomson as the Director-General in the revision of November 2026 that this page audits. The article carries the naming of the person whom the entry names and the time at which he was to take the office. An article of November 2024 speaks of his holding of the office as a thing to come and cannot carry that he holds it, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.4 Footnote 4 cites "Final Budget of the Organization for the seventy-second financial year 2026", a document of CERN of 47 pages, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on January 29, 2026 that the footnote names and searched. Line 11, the entry of the infobox, gives the budget for 2026 as 1515 million Swiss francs. The document prints the figure 1 515 once, in its Figure 15, the estimated statement of cash flow for 2025 and 2026, where it is the cash outflow of 2026 in millions of Swiss francs. Its Figure 3 gives the expenses of the final budget of 2026 as 1 526.3 million Swiss francs, and its Figure 2 gives the revenues as 1 444.5 million. The document carries the figure of the line as an outflow of cash and not as the amount of the budget, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.5 Footnote 5 cites "Governance", page 50 of the CERN Annual Report 2019, which CERN published in 2020, and names a copy of the record of the report at the CERN Document Server archived on January 20, 2022, which this page read. The copy of the file of the report archived on April 7, 2023 is cut off in the Wayback Machine after its first three megabytes, and this page read page 50 in the copy of the file archived on January 20, 2022. Page 50 is headed "CERN COUNCIL" and "Composition as of 31 December 2019", and under the heading "MEMBER STATES" it lists 23 states, from Austria to the United Kingdom. It lists Cyprus and Slovenia apart, as associate member states in the pre-stage to membership. Line 15 says that CERN comprises 25 member states. The cited page counts 23 member states at the end of 2019. A report on 2019 cannot carry the count of 25, which CERN reached on June 21, 2025, when Slovenia became its 25th member state, as unit 1.71 records, so the citation is graded Not supported.

1.6 Two footnotes cite line 16, which says that Israel, admitted in 2013, is the only full member geographically out of Europe. Footnote 6 cites "CERN to admit Israel as first new member state since 1999 – CERN Courier", January 22, 2014, read in full in the copy archived on June 19, 2018 that the footnote names. The article says that, following a resolution that the CERN Council adopted on December 12, "CERN is set to admit Israel as the organization’s 21st member state", and that the membership takes effect on the date on which Israel notifies the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) that it has ratified the convention. The article carries the decision of December 2013 and says nothing of geography, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 7 cites "CERN accepts Israel as full member", The Times of Israel, December 12, 2013, read in full in the copy archived on November 12, 2022 that the footnote names. The article says "Israel was admitted Thursday as a full member of CERN" and calls Israel the center's 21st official member and "its first non European associate". The article carries the admission of 2013 and the first place of Israel among members outside Europe, and an article of 2013 cannot carry that Israel is the only such member in 2026, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.7 Footnote 8 cites "Intergovernmental Organizations", a page of the United Nations, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 17, 2025 that the footnote names and searched. The page lists "European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)" among the intergovernmental organizations "having received a standing invitation to participate as Observers in the sessions and the work of the General Assembly". The citation at line 17, which calls CERN an official observer of the General Assembly of the United Nations, is graded Supported.

1.8 Footnote 9 cites "CERN in figures", page 53 of the CERN Annual Report 2024, and links a file at the CERN Document Server without an archived copy. The index of the Wayback Machine lists five copies of that address, and none of them is a file of the report: four are pages that the server returned as errors, of which this page read the copy of November 18, 2025, which says "Requested file does not seem to exist." and names the main file of the record as 2024_AR.pdf, and the fifth, archived on October 8, 2026, is a check for automated visitors. This page therefore read pages 12 and 53 of the report in the main file of the same record, in the copy archived on December 8, 2025. Page 53, which is headed "CERN IN FIGURES", gives the staff as "Total: 2704 people" and says that the infrastructure and services of CERN "were used by a large scientific community of 12 406 users". Line 18 says that in 2024 the laboratory had 2,704 scientific, technical and administrative staff members and hosted about 12,406 users from institutions in more than 80 countries. The cited page carries the two figures and does not carry the countries, which stand on page 12 of the report in the words "in more than 80 countries", so the citation is graded Partial.

1.9 Footnote 10 cites "Discovery machines", pages 20 to 29 of the CERN Annual report 2016, and links two records of the CERN Document Server without archived copies. This page read the two records in the copies archived on April 6, 2022 and November 15, 2017, and read pages 20 through 31 of the report in the file of the report archived on May 16, 2019. Page 27 says "In 2016, more than 49 petabytes of LHC data were recorded at the CERN Data Centre", where LHC stands for the Large Hadron Collider. The citation at line 19, which says that in 2016 CERN generated 49 petabytes of data, is graded Supported.

1.10 Footnote 11 cites "The Large Hadron Collider", a page of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on October 14, 2023 that the footnote names. The page says "The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is the world’s largest and most powerful particle accelerator." Line 21 says that CERN is the site of the Large Hadron Collider, which it calls the world's largest and highest-energy particle collider, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.11 Two footnotes cite line 24, which says "CERN is also the birthplace of the World Wide Web." Footnote 12 cites Stephanie Sammartino McPherson, Tim Berners-Lee: Inventor of the World Wide Web (Twenty-First Century Books, 2009), with no page, at the Internet Archive, which marks its copy of the book access-restricted for lending. This page searched the book in its preview at Google Books and read pages 20, 44, 45 and 80 from their images. The search returns no page for the word birthplace. Page 45 says that at CERN "Tim sat down and began working out the code for the World Wide Web", and page 80 says of CERN "The institute had given him the time, space, and freedom to create the World Wide Web." The book places at CERN the making of what it calls the World Wide Web, which is the statement of the line in other words, and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 13 cites James Gillies and Robert Cailliau, How the Web was Born: The Story of the World Wide Web (Oxford University Press, 2000), with no page. This page read the back cover of the book and its page 268 from their images at Google Books and searched the book there. The back cover says "the Web was born at CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, in" Geneva, and the citation is graded Supported. Section 7.0 of Disagreement 68 records line 24 as supported on other documents, and section 8.0 of that page notes that the line cites a book of which Robert Cailliau, whom line 58 of the article names as a colleague of Tim Berners-Lee, is an author.

1.12 Two footnotes stand at line 25, which says that the convention establishing CERN was ratified on 29 September 1954 by 12 countries in Western Europe. Footnote 14 follows the words "The convention establishing CERN" and cites the text of the "Convention for the Establishment of a European Organization for Nuclear Research | CERN Council", which this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on February 18, 2021 that the footnote names and searched. The page prints the convention "as amended on 17 January 1971", and the citation of the convention itself is graded Supported. The page also says that the convention "entered into force on 29 September, 1954". Footnote 15 stands at the end of the line and cites Armin Hermann, Lanfranco Belloni and John Krige, History of CERN (North-Holland, 1987), with no page, and its only link leads to the record of the book in a library catalog. Google Books shows no page of the first volume of the book, and its search of the volume returns snippets of text, which this page read for the ratifications. Page 232 of the volume carries a table headed "Dates of deposit of instruments of ratification of the Convention at UNESCO House in Paris". The table, which page 334 repeats in the text, dates the twelve deposits from 30 December 1953 to 24 February 1955, the date that it gives to Italy, and it gives 29 September 1954 to France and to the Federal Republic of Germany, 4 October 1954 to Norway and 9 February 1955 to Yugoslavia. Page 412 says that France and the Federal Republic deposited their instruments on the same day, on 29 September 1954, "allowing CERN finally to come into being". The book carries the ratification of the convention by the twelve states and September 29, 1954 as the day of the ratifications of two of them, and it dates the other ten ratifications to other days, from December 1953 to February 1955, so the citation is graded Partial. The book of James Gillies that footnote 1 cites, on the pages that unit 1.1 names, says that Britain ratified first, at the end of 1953, that Switzerland, Denmark, the Netherlands, Greece, Sweden and Belgium followed between February and July 1954, and that France and Germany followed on September 29, 1954, which makes nine states by that day, and it says "The process concluded with Norway ratifying in October 1954, and Yugoslavia and Italy following in February 1955." The text of the convention at footnote 14 says that the convention "shall enter into force when seven States have ratified, or acceded to, these instruments", on two conditions, that the total of their contributions "amounts to not less than seventy-five per cent" on the scale that is annexed to the Financial Protocol, and that Switzerland is among the seven.

1.13 Footnotes 16 and 17 are each cited at line 27 and at line 28. Footnote 16 cites page 5 of John Krige, From the Provisional Organization to the Permanent CERN, May 1952 – September 1954: A survey of developments, a report of the Study Team for CERN History of 1985, and links the report at Google Books with a search for the word oern. Google Books shows the report in snippets. This page read, from their images, the snippet of page 5 that the link returns and the snippets of pages 3, 7, 11 and 13 that searches for the words Copenhagen and Bohr return, and it read the snippets of text that searches of the report return for pages 2, 3, 5, 11, 12 and 13. The passage of page 5 says that at its second session, which page 13 dates to June 1952, the Council "decided henceforth to call itself the 'European Council for Nuclear Research'", and it says "Organization would have been better than Council, but the acronym CERN, which was derived from the French initials of the Council's name, was obviously preferable to 'OERN'." The passage ends with a remark on the letter C, and a new section of the report begins after it. The passage speaks of the name that the provisional council took in 1952. It does not carry the work of the council at the University of Copenhagen under Niels Bohr or its move to Geneva, of which line 27 speaks, or the keeping of the acronym after the provisional council was dissolved and the change of the name in 1954, of which line 28 speaks. The part of page 5 that stands above the passage could not be read, and the two citations of footnote 16 are graded Uncheckable. The snippets of other pages of the report bear on line 27. Page 3 says that "the group leaders would remain at their home stations", and it lists the stations as "Amaldi in Rome, Bakker in Amsterdam, Bohr in Copenhagen, Dahl in Bergen, and Kowarski in Paris". Page 11 says of the Theory group, which page 12 counts among four study groups, "Bohr was the nominal director until September 1954". Footnote 17 cites S. A. ff. Dakin, "Conflict between title and initials of the Organization", November 2, 1954, a file of three pages at the CERN Document Server, and names a copy of the file at another archive. This page read the file in full, from its page images, at the address that the footnote gives, in the copy that the Wayback Machine archived on April 6, 2023. The file holds a memorandum from Dakin to the Director General and the draft of a letter from the Director General to the heads of the delegations of the member states. Line 27 says that in its early years the council worked at the University of Copenhagen under the direction of Niels Bohr before it moved to its present site near Geneva. The file says nothing of Copenhagen, of Niels Bohr or of a move, so the citation at line 27 is graded Not supported. Line 28 says that the acronym was retained for the new laboratory after the provisional council was dissolved, although the name changed in 1954 to the name that the line gives in French and in English. The draft letter says that the European Council for Nuclear Research, having become the European Organization for Nuclear Research, "should no longer properly be using the initials C.E.R.N.", and that "it would be a great mistake to alter the initials", and it ends "I do not wish to make any recommendation". The memorandum says "I see no reason why the European Organization for Nuclear Research should not be nicknamed CERN", and it adds of Lew Kowarski "I know that Kowarski feels strongly that it is so silly as to be intolerable". The file carries the change of the name and the conflict of the initials with it as a question that was open on November 2, 1954. It does not carry the retention of the acronym as a thing decided, the dissolution of the provisional council or the French name, so the citation at line 28 is graded Partial.

1.14 Two footnotes stand at line 29. The first part of the line says that, according to Lew Kowarski, whom it calls a former director of CERN, the abbreviation could have become the awkward OERN when the name was changed, and footnote 18 follows it. Footnote 18 cites Gordon Fraser, The Quantum Exodus: Jewish Fugitives, the Atomic Bomb, and the Holocaust (Oxford University Press, 2012), and links page 229 of the book at Google Books, which this page read from its image. The page says "The acronym was retained despite the official name" being changed, and it says "CERN slips off the tongue more easily than OERN." The page carries the awkward initials, and it does not name Lew Kowarski or assign the remark to him, so the citation is graded Partial. The sentence of the book carries a note numbered 10, whose text is not on the page that the footnote links. The second part of the line says that Werner Heisenberg said that this could "still be CERN even if the name is [not]", and footnote 19 follows it. Footnote 19 cites "Lew Kowarski – Session VI", the transcript of an interview of the oral history collection of the American Institute of Physics, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on February 14, 2021 that the footnote names and searched. Kowarski says in the interview "Well, the initials would be OERN." He reports that Heisenberg proposed to change the name of the organization and added "and that we retain the initials CERN". The transcript carries the remark of Kowarski and the proposal of Heisenberg. The words that the line prints in quotation marks do not stand in the transcript, which does not contain the words still be CERN, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.15 Footnote 20 cites "People and things: Felix Bloch", CERN Courier, volume 23 (1983), and names a copy of the record of the notice at the CERN Document Server archived on August 4, 2017, which this page read. This page retrieved the file of that record in full from the copy archived on September 29, 2019 and searched its text. The notice, which reports the death of Felix Bloch, says "in 1954 Professor Bloch became CERN's first Director-General". Line 31 says that Edoardo Amaldi was the general secretary of CERN at its early stages, when operations were still provisional, and that the first Director-General, in 1954, was Felix Bloch. The notice carries the second half of the line, and the name of Edoardo Amaldi does not occur in the file, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.16 Footnote 21 stands at line 32, the caption of a map, which reads "The 12 founding member states of CERN in 1954". It cites a page of CERN that it titles "CERN.ch", read in full in the copy archived on November 16, 2010 that the footnote names. The page is the entry for 1954 of a history of CERN, and it says that the convention "was gradually ratified by the 12 founding Member States", which it names. The citation is graded Supported. Line 34 says that the convention was gradually ratified by the 12 founding Member States, which it names, and it cites footnote 22, 6th Session of the European Council for Nuclear Research, 29–30 Jun 1953: Minutes. This page read the record of the minutes at the CERN Document Server in the copy archived on August 3, 2020 that the footnote names, and read the file of the minutes, 32 scanned pages, by optical character recognition in the copy archived on April 7, 2023. The minutes are dated at Rome on December 15, 1953, and they record a session whose object was "to adopt the text of the Convention". Their sixth annex reports that at a conference in Paris on July 1, 1953 "the fully accredited representatives of" nine states, Belgium, France, the German Federal Republic, Greece, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden, the United Kingdom and Yugoslavia, "signed the Convention", and that the representatives of Denmark, Norway and Switzerland stated "that they hoped to be able to sign the Convention fairly soon". A note on the same page says "Switzerland signed the Convention on the 17th of July, 1953." The minutes name the twelve states of the line as the states of the convention, and minutes of a session of June 1953 do not carry the ratification of the convention, so the citation is graded Partial. The words of line 34, from "was gradually ratified" to "and Yugoslavia", stand word for word on the page of CERN that footnote 21 cites at line 32.

1.17 Footnote 23 is cited at line 37 and at line 38, the first two entries of the article's list of achievements in particle physics. It cites Roger Cashmore, Luciano Maiani and Jean-Pierre Revol (eds.), Prestigious Discoveries at CERN (Springer, 2003), with no page, and the article itself marks the footnote with its tag "[page needed]". The chapters of the book stand behind the publisher's paywall. This page read in full the publisher's page of the book in the copy archived on June 1, 2024, the publisher's page of the third chapter, by Dieter Haidt, in the copy archived on June 17, 2018, and the publisher's page of the fourth chapter, by Pierre Darriulat, in the copy archived on June 14, 2018. The page of the book gives the subtitle of the book as "1973 Neutral Currents 1983 W & Z Bosons". Line 37 dates to 1973 the discovery of neutral currents in the Gargamelle bubble chamber. The page of the third chapter, "The discovery of neutral currents", prints the abstract of the chapter, which speaks of "the discovery of Weak Neutral Currents", and its list of references, whose first entry is the paper on an observation "in the Gargamelle neutrino experiment" that it dates 1973, and whose tenth entry is titled "Gargamelle and the discovery of neutral currents", and the keywords of the page include the words "Bubble Chamber". The parts of the book that this page read carry the sentence, and the citation at line 37 is graded Supported. Line 38 dates to 1983 the discovery of the W and Z bosons in the UA1 and UA2 experiments. The page of the book says "The discoveries of neutral currents and of the W and Z bosons marked a watershed in the history of CERN." The page of the fourth chapter, "The discovery of the W & Z, a personal recollection", prints under the heading Abstract the opening words of the chapter, which begin "It is such a pleasure to be back at CERN after four years of absence", and a list of references whose first four entries are papers that it dates 1983. The parts that this page read carry the year and the discovery, the names UA1 and UA2 do not occur in them, the chapter itself could not be read, and the citation at line 38 is graded Uncheckable.

1.18 Footnote 24 cites Salvatore Mele, "The Measurement of the Number of Light Neutrino Species at LEP", a chapter of 60 Years of CERN Experiments and Discoveries (World Scientific, 2015), pages 89 to 106. The chapter is published with open access, and this page read its file of 18 pages in full in the copy archived on May 5, 2021. LEP is the Large Electron-Positron Collider. The chapter says "In 1989, within the first few weeks of data taking at LEP, the ALEPH, DELPHI, L3 and OPAL collaborations reported the number of light neutrino species to be around three." It also says that the accelerator operated "at and around the Z-boson resonance from its commissioning in 1989 through 1995". The citation at line 39, which dates to 1989 the determination of the number of light neutrino families at the collider operating on the Z boson peak, is graded Supported.

1.19 Two footnotes cite line 40, which dates to 1995 the first creation of antihydrogen atoms in the PS210 experiment. Footnote 25 cites Frank Close, Antimatter (Oxford University Press, 2018), pages 93 to 96, which this page read from their images at Google Books. Page 93 says "Before 1995 it is possible that not even one atom of antimatter" had ever existed, and it says that everything changed that year "when a team at CERN made the first handful of" antihydrogen atoms, at the Low Energy Antiproton Ring (LEAR). The cited pages do not print the name PS210, which is a fuller name for the team that the book identifies, and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 26 cites G. Baur and others, "Production of antihydrogen", Physics Letters B, volume 368, 1996, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode, the bibliographic code of the Astrophysics Data System, and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on May 12, 2021. This page then retrieved in full and searched the text of the paper as it was submitted for publication on December 22, 1995, a file of 17 pages at the CERN Document Server, in the copy archived on July 22, 2018, and it read from their images the pages that it quotes. The paper says "A method has been used by the PS210 collaboration at LEAR", says of antihydrogen that "so far it has never been observed before", and gives the time of its measurement as "the total running period in September/October 1995". It says "The production of 11 antihydrogen atoms is reported". The paper carries the experiment, the first production and the year, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.20 Two footnotes stand at line 41, after the words that give the years 1995 to 2005 to the precision measurement of the Z lineshape, and the rest of the line, which says that the measurement was based predominantly on data that LEP collected on the Z resonance from 1990 to 1995, follows them. Footnote 27 cites the report of the ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL and SLD collaborations and of three working groups, "Precision electroweak measurements on the Z resonance", Physics Reports, May 2006, and links the paper at arXiv, where this page retrieved its file of 302 pages in full from the copy archived on November 15, 2025 and searched it. The report is dated 7 September 2005, its second chapter is headed "The Z Lineshape and the Leptonic Forward-Backward Asymmetries", and it places the end of the taking of data around the Z resonance in the autumn of 1995. The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 28 cites Alain Blondel, Chiara Mariotti, Marco Pieri and Pippa Wells, "LEP's electroweak leap", CERN Courier, September 11, 2019, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on April 11, 2023 that the footnote names and searched. The article says "LEP continued to carry out Z-lineshape scans until 1991, and repeated them in 1993 and 1995." It also says "the final Z-pole results were published a full 11 years later". The article carries the precision measurement of the lineshape, and it does not print the years 2005 or 2006 and gives the measurement no period of 1995 to 2005, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.21 Footnote 29 cites V. Fanti and others, "A new measurement of direct CP violation in two pion decays of the neutral kaon", Physics Letters B, October 1999, the paper of the NA48 collaboration, and links it at arXiv, where this page read its file of 18 pages in full in the copy archived on January 4, 2026. The paper says that the "first evidence for direct CP violation was published in 1988", and it says that its own result "confirms that direct CP violation occurs in neutral kaon decays." Line 42 dates to 1999 the discovery of direct CP violation, a violation of the combined symmetry of charge conjugation and parity, in the NA48 experiment. The paper carries the year, the experiment and the measurement, and it calls its result a new measurement that confirms an effect for which evidence was published in 1988, and not a discovery, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.22 Footnote 30 cites "New State of Matter created at CERN", a press release of CERN of February 10, 2000, read in full in the copy archived on November 7, 2020 that the footnote names. The release says that the spokespersons of the experiments of the Heavy Ion programme "presented compelling evidence for the existence of a new state of matter", and it says that the state "features many of the characteristics of the theoretically predicted quark-gluon plasma". Line 43 says that in 2000 the Heavy Ion Programme discovered a new state of matter, quark-gluon plasma. The release carries the year, the programme and the evidence of a new state of matter, and it names the plasma as the predicted state whose characteristics the new state shares in many respects and not as the thing discovered, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.23 Two footnotes cite line 44, which dates to 2010 the isolation of 38 atoms of antihydrogen. Footnote 31 cites Eugenie Samuel Reich, "Antimatter held for questioning", Nature, November 18, 2010, and gives a DOI, a Bibcode and a PubMed identifier; this page read the article in full in the copies archived on December 17, 2012 and February 4, 2024. The article says that a collaboration at CERN "has managed, 38 times, to confine single antihydrogen atoms in a magnetic trap". Footnote 32 cites Thair Shaikh, "Scientists capture antimatter atoms in particle breakthrough", CNN, November 18, 2010, read in full in the copy archived on October 24, 2020, to which the link that the footnote names leads. The article says "The researchers created 38 antihydrogen atoms and held on to them for about a tenth of a second". The two citations are graded Supported.

1.24 Two footnotes cite line 45, which dates to 2011 the maintaining of antihydrogen for over 15 minutes. Footnote 33 cites John Matson, "Antimatter trapped for more than 15 minutes", a news article of Nature, and gives a DOI and no other link. The copy of the publisher's page archived on January 14, 2026 shows the title, the summary under the title and the date of publication, 06 June 2011, and marks the rest "This is a preview of subscription content". The summary says "Physicists have forced flighty atoms of antihydrogen to stick around". The title and the date carry the line, and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 34 cites Jonathan Amos, "Antimatter atoms are corralled even longer", BBC, June 6, 2011, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on May 27, 2018 that the footnote names and searched. The article says "Scientists have succeeded in trapping atoms of anti-hydrogen for more than 15 minutes." The citation is graded Supported.

1.25 Three footnotes cite line 46, which dates to 2012 the discovery of a boson with a mass of around 125 GeV/c2 consistent with the long-sought Higgs boson. Footnote 35 cites Lisa Randall, Higgs Discovery: The Power of Empty Space (Random House, 2012), with no page, and links the page of that edition at Google Books, which shows no page of it. Google Books offers a preview of another edition of the book, of the same year, and this page read the first three pages of its text from their images. The first of them says that on July 4, 2012 the author "learned that a new particle had been discovered at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) near Geneva", and that "the particle looks a lot like a particle called the Higgs boson". The three pages carry the discovery, the year and the likeness of the particle to the Higgs boson, and they do not give its mass. A search of that edition for 125 and for GeV returns no result, the rest of the book could not be read, and the citation is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 36 cites the paper of the ATLAS collaboration, "Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC", Physics Letters B, 2012, and footnote 37 cites the paper of the CMS collaboration, "Observation of a new boson at a mass of 125 GeV with the CMS experiment at the LHC", in the same volume. This page read the abstract of each paper at arXiv, in the copies archived on November 2, 2026 and October 29, 2026, and did not read the papers. The abstract of the first paper says "Clear evidence for the production of a neutral boson with a measured mass of 126.0", in the unit GeV, and says that the result "is compatible with the production and decay of the Standard Model Higgs boson". The abstract of the second paper reports an excess of events "at a mass near 125 GeV, signalling the production of a new particle", and it says that "the new particle is a boson". Each abstract itself carries the sentence, and the two citations are graded Supported.

1.26 Footnote 38 cites Adrian Cho, "Neutrinos Travel Faster Than Light, According to One Experiment", Science NOW, September 22, 2011, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on April 21, 2022 that the footnote names and searched. The article says "The OPERA particle detector may have spotted neutrinos traveling faster than light", and it says that the detector observes neutrinos "that are fired through the earth from the European particle physics laboratory, CERN". The citation at line 47, which says that in September 2011 CERN attracted media attention when the OPERA Collaboration reported the detection of possibly faster-than-light neutrinos, is graded Supported. Footnote 39 cites "OPERA experiment reports anomaly in flight time of neutrinos from CERN to Gran Sasso", a press release of CERN of September 2011 with its later updates, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 13, 2016 that the footnote names and searched. An update to the release names, as one of two possible faults, "the optical fibre connector that brings the external GPS signal to the OPERA master clock", and the update of June 8, 2012 says that the original measurement "can be attributed to a faulty element of the experiment’s fibre optic timing system". Line 48 says that further tests showed that the results were flawed due to an incorrectly connected synchronization cable of the Global Positioning System (GPS), and the citation is graded Supported.

1.27 Footnote 40 cites Christine Sutton, "CERN scoops up the Nobel physics prize", New Scientist, October 25, 1984, at an address of Google Books. The address returned an error page, with the code 404, on November 15, 2026, and so did four shorter forms of it. The copies of the address that the Wayback Machine archived on April 6, 2022 and on April 6, 2023 show the page of Google Books for the issue, which they name "New Scientist Oct 25, 1984", without the text of its pages, and the index of the Wayback Machine lists no copy of the image of page 10 of the issue. The catalog of the Internet Archive lists no copy of the issue of October 25, 1984 under the six searches that this page ran. The article could not be read, and the citation at line 49, which says that the Nobel Prize for Physics of 1984 was awarded to Carlo Rubbia and Simon van der Meer for the developments that resulted in the discoveries of the W and Z bosons, is graded Uncheckable.

1.28 Footnote 41 cites Ben Segal, "A short history of Internet protocols at CERN", which it dates 1995, at a page of ResearchGate, and that page answered the Wayback Machine with a notice that access is denied, in the copy archived on June 26, 2026. This page read the text of the history in full in the copy that stands on Segal's own page at CERN, archived on October 12, 2008, which dates the history April, 1995. The history treats the optional protocols TCP/IP, which it calls the Internet protocols, and it says that "the presence of the Internet protocols at CERN had already encouraged their adoption not only in many other parts of Europe". It also says "By 1990 CERN had become the largest Internet site in Europe", and that this fact "positively influenced the acceptance and spread of Internet techniques both in Europe and elsewhere". Line 54 says of the introduction of those protocols at CERN, which line 53 dates from 1984, "This played an influential role in the adoption of the TCP/IP in Europe", and the citation is graded Supported. Section 1.0 of Disagreement 68 read the shorter article by Segal that CERN published on April 9, 2014, and it makes no finding on line 54.

1.29 Two footnotes cite line 56, which says that the idea that line 55 calls the World Wide Web was based on the concept of hypertext and was designed to facilitate the sharing of information between researchers. Footnote 42 cites Tim Berners-Lee, "Information Management: A Proposal", at the site of the World Wide Web Consortium, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on April 1, 2010 that the footnote names and searched. The proposal, which is dated March 1989, May 1990, says "This proposal concerns the management of general information about accelerators and experiments at CERN." It says that it "derives a solution based on a distributed hypertext system", and it speaks of the way in which people "share information, equipment and software across groups". Footnote 43 cites "The World's First Web Site", HISTORY, August 30, 2018, read in full in the copy archived on August 19, 2023 that the footnote names. The article, by Elizabeth Nix, says that in March 1989 Berners-Lee gave the managers of CERN "a proposal for an information management system that used hypertext to link documents on different computers", and that he had observed "how tough it was to keep track of the projects and computer systems of the organization’s thousands of researchers". The sharing of information between researchers is the line's restatement of the management of information among the people of CERN that both sources describe, and the two citations are graded Supported. Section 3.0 of Disagreement 68 answers the line.

1.30 Three footnotes cite line 58, which says that a colleague, Robert Cailliau, became involved in 1990. Footnote 44 cites Gerard O'Regan, Giants of Computing: A Compendium of Select, Pivotal Pioneers (Springer, 2013), with no page. This page read the ninth chapter of the book, which is headed Tim Berners-Lee and fills pages 39 to 42, in full from the page images at Google Books, and searched the book there. The chapter does not name Robert Cailliau, a search of the book for the name Cailliau returns no page, and the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 45 cites the same author's The Innovation in Computing Companion (Springer, 2018), with no page, and the article itself marks the footnote with its tag "[page needed]". This page read pages 269 to 271 of chapter 57 of the book, which is headed World Wide Web, from the page images at Google Books, which does not show page 272, and searched the book there. The pages read do not name Robert Cailliau, a search of the book for the name Cailliau returns no page, and the citation is graded Not supported. The two books of the one author give two years for what each calls the invention of the World Wide Web. Page 39 of the book of 2013 says "His solution to this problem was the invention of the World Wide Web in 1990." Page 270 of the book of 2018 says "His solution was his invention of the World Wide Web in 1989." Footnote 46 cites a page of CERN that it titles "CERN.ch", read in full in the copy archived on November 16, 2010 that the footnote names. The page, which is headed "How the web began", says that the first proposal was made at CERN by Tim Berners-Lee in 1989 "and further refined by him and Robert Cailliau in 1990". The citation is graded Supported. Section 7.0 of Disagreement 68 records line 58 as supported by the finding aid of the CERN Archives.

1.31 Footnote 47 cites "Robert Cailliau", a page of the awards site of the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM), read in full in the copy archived on November 2, 2021 that the footnote names. The page lists the "ACM Software System Award (1995)", names the system as "World-Wide Web", gives the award to "Tim Berners-Lee, Robert Cailliau" and prints the citation of the award, which begins "For developing a network-oriented hypermedia system". Line 59 says that in 1995 Berners-Lee and Cailliau were jointly honoured by the Association for Computing Machinery for their contributions to the development of the World Wide Web, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.32 Footnote 48 cites "The World Wide Web project", a page of the World Wide Web Consortium, read in full in the copy archived on January 31, 2010 that the footnote names. The page stands on the site of the Consortium in a directory named History, under an address that carries the number 19921103, and it says "The WorldWideWeb (W3) is a wide-area hypermedia information retrieval initiative aiming to give universal access to a large universe of documents." Line 60 says that a copy of the first webpage, created by Berners-Lee, is still published on the website of the World Wide Web Consortium as a historical document. The cited page is such a copy and stands where the line says. The page does not say that it is a copy of the first webpage, that Berners-Lee created it or that it is kept as a historical document, and it links to the news of the project for November, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.33 Footnote 49 cites "30 years of the web: a short history of the invention that changed the world", a page of the British Council, read in full in the copy archived on March 7, 2026 that the footnote names. The page says that Berners-Lee and others worked to ensure "that CERN would make the underlying code available on a royalty-free basis, forever", and it adds "This decision was announced in April 1993". Line 62 says that on 30 April 1993 CERN announced that the World Wide Web would be free to anyone. The page carries the month and the year and the release of the underlying code free of royalties. It does not carry the day, and it speaks of the code and not of the World Wide Web application design as a whole, so the citation is graded Partial. Section 5.0 of Disagreement 68 answers the line.

1.34 Two footnotes cite line 63, which says that the Web became the dominant way through which most users interact with the Internet. Footnote 50 cites a paper of 1997 by Ari-Pekka Hameri and Markus Nordberg, "From Experience: Linking Available Resources and Technologies to Create a Solution for Document Sharing The Early Years of the WWW", in a scanned file of 40 pages at the CERN Document Server, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on October 28, 2023 that the footnote names and searched. The abstract of the paper limits it to "what happened at CERN between 1980 and 1992". The paper does not say that the Web became the dominant way in which most users interact with the Internet, and the words dominant and most users do not occur in its text, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 51 cites Andrew Oram, "Open, Simple, Generative: Why the Web is the Dominant Internet Application", an article on the site of the Linux Professional Institute dated August 17, 2021, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on October 27, 2023 that the footnote names and searched. The title of the article calls the Web the dominant application of the Internet, and the citation is graded Supported. The word dominant stands in the title of the article and nowhere else in its text, and the words most users are the words of the line. The footnotes print the names of the first authors of the two works as "Ari-Pekka, Hameri" and "Andrew, Oram".

1.35 Footnote 52 cites "Engineering at CERN", a page of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on February 16, 2022 that the footnote names. The page says "CERN employs ten times more engineers and technicians than research physicists." Line 66 says the same of the year 2022, and the citation is graded Supported. The page prints no date, and 2022 is the year of the copy that the footnote names. Page 53 of the CERN Annual Report 2024, which footnote 9 cites at line 18, counts among the staff of that year 88 research physicists, 1278 engineers and applied scientists and 818 technicians.

1.36 Footnote 53 cites "CERN Scientific Committees | CERN Scientific Information Service (SIS)", whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on August 25, 2023 that the footnote names and searched. The page says that a proposal for an experiment "is submitted to the appropriate CERN Scientific Committee", and that the proposals and recommendations of the committees were passed on to the Nuclear Physics Research Committee from 1960 to 1976 "and to the Research Board from 1976 to today for the final decisions concerning the experimental programme". Line 84 says that before an experiment is able to use the network of accelerators, it must be approved by the various Scientific Committees of CERN. The page carries the review of each proposal by a scientific committee, and it gives the final decision to the Research Board and not to the committees, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.37 Footnote 54 cites "CERN Website – LINAC", read in full in the copy archived on October 27, 2013 that the footnote names. The page, which is headed "CERN Hadron Linacs", names "The 4.2 MeV/u Heavy Ion Linac (Linac 3)" and says that "the lead beam was regularly injected into LEAR/LEIR for cooling experiments". Line 87 says that the linear accelerator of line 86 provides heavy ions at 4.2 MeV/Da for injection into the Low Energy Ion Ring (LEIR), and the citation is graded Supported. The page writes the unit of mass as u, and the line writes it as Da.

1.38 Two footnotes cite line 89, which says that the Low Energy Ion Ring was commissioned in 2005, after having been reconfigured from the previous Low Energy Antiproton Ring (LEAR). Footnote 55 cites Michel Chanel, "LEIR: the low energy ion ring at CERN", Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A, 2004, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract and the opening lines of its sections on the publisher's page in the copy archived on April 21, 2022. This page then retrieved in full and read the text of the paper as a report of CERN of September 2003, an invited paper of the workshop on beam cooling of May 2003. The file of the report, of ten pages, stands at the CERN Document Server under a record that gives the reference of the article in the journal, and this page read the file in the copy archived on October 20, 2023 and read from their images the two pages that it quotes. The abstract of the report says that "the conversion of the old Low Energy Antiproton Ring (LEAR) into the Low Energy Ion Ring (LEIR) is a major issue", and its section on planning says "The preliminary planning shows that LEIR commissioning can be done at the beginning of 2005 with lead ions". A paper of 2003, published in 2004, carries the conversion as a thing to be done and the plan of the commissioning, and it cannot carry the commissioning itself, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 56 cites K. Hübner, Fifty years of research at CERN, from past to future: The Accelerators (CERN, 2006), and names a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on May 3, 2021, which this page read. This page retrieved the file of the report, of 26 pages, in full from the copy archived on July 4, 2022 and searched it. The report says of the ring "It is nothing but LEAR", modified "to become a buffer accumulation ring for ions". The report carries the reconfiguration, and it gives no date of commissioning and does not print the year 2005, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.39 Footnote 57 cites "LHC Run 3: the final countdown", CERN Courier, February 18, 2022, read in full in the copy archived on April 28, 2025 that the footnote names. The article says of Linac4 that the accelerator "now replaces the long-serving Linac2 as the source of all proton beams for CERN experiments". The citation at line 93, which says that Linac4 serves as the source of all proton beams for CERN experiments, is graded Supported.

1.40 Footnote 58 cites K. Hanke, "Past and present operation of the CERN PS Booster", International Journal of Modern Physics A, 2013, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on February 11, 2023. The abstract says that the paper reviews 40 years of operation of the Proton Synchrotron Booster, "from the commissioning in the early 1970s until today's operation as injector for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC)". Line 94 says that the booster increases the energy of particles generated by the proton linear accelerator before they are transferred to the other accelerators. The abstract does not say what the booster does to the beam of the linear accelerator, the article itself could not be read, and the citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.41 Footnote 59 cites Günther Plass, "The CERN Proton Synchrotron: 50 Years of Reliable Operation and Continued Development", a chapter of From the PS to the LHC - 50 Years of Nobel Memories in High-Energy Physics (Springer, 2012), pages 29 to 47, and gives a DOI and no other link. The chapter stands behind the publisher's paywall, and the abstract on the publisher's page, in the copy archived on August 20, 2025, says only "This contribution, a personal recollection by the author, is part of a special issue". The citation at line 95, which says that the 28 GeV Proton Synchrotron (PS) was built during 1954 to 1959 and still operates as a feeder to the more powerful Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) and to many of the experiments of CERN, is graded Uncheckable.

1.42 Three footnotes cite line 99, which says that since 2008 the Super Proton Synchrotron has been used to inject protons and heavy ions into the Large Hadron Collider. Footnote 60 cites V. Hatton, "Operational history of the SPS collider 1981-1990", in the record of the 1991 IEEE Particle Accelerator Conference, pages 2952 to 2954, and gives a DOI and no other link. This page read the paper in full, in its file of three pages at the Joint Accelerator Conferences Website (JACoW), in the copy archived on November 26, 2017, and it read the three pages from their images. The paper is headed "Operational History of the SPS Collider 1981 - 1990", and it does not mention the Large Hadron Collider or heavy ions, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 61 cites Peter Watkins, Story of the W and Z (Cambridge University Press, 1986), with no page. Google Books shows the book in snippets only, and its search of the book returns no page for LHC, for the words Large Hadron Collider or for 2008, so the citation is graded Not supported. A paper of 1991 and a book of 1986 cannot carry a use that began in 2008. Footnote 62 cites Oliver Brüning and Stephen Myers (eds.), Challenges and Goals for Accelerators in the XXI Century (World Scientific, 2015), with no page. This page read in full the two chapters of the book that footnotes 98 and 99 cite, which the publisher offers with open access, read pages 165, 450 and 499 of the book from their images at Google Books, and searched the book there. Page 165, in the chapter by Rudiger Schmidt, says "Today, the SPS operates as final injector of high-intensity proton beams and ion beams for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC)". The parts that this page read carry the use and give it no first year, a search of the book for the words since 2008 returns no page, the rest of the book was not read, and the citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.43 Footnote 63 cites Maria J. G. Borge and Björn Jonson, "ISOLDE past, present and future", Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics, 2017. The article is published with open access, and this page retrieved its text in full from the publisher's page in the copy archived on September 29, 2026 and searched it. The article says "The first experiments were performed in 1967" and "Since 1992 the ISOLDE Radioactive Beam Facility is linked to an external proton beam from the PS Booster." Line 102 says that the facility was first commissioned in 1967 and was rebuilt with major upgrades in 1974 and 1992. The article carries 1967 and 1992. It names "the ISOLDE 2 upgrade" without a date, and the year 1974 does not occur in it, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.44 Footnote 64 cites page 1749 of the Proceedings Of The 28th International Conference On High Energy Physics (In 2 Volumes) (World Scientific, 1997), edited by Zygmunt Ajduk and Andrzej Kajetan Wroblewski, which this page read from its image at Google Books. The page is the first page of a paper by J. P. Riunaud, for the AD Feasibility Study Team, headed "AN ANTIPROTON DECELERATOR IN THE CERN PS COMPLEX". Its abstract describes a scheme studied "mainly to carry out studies on antihydrogen", in which the "present Antiproton Collector (AC) converted into a cooler and decelerator (Antiproton Decelerator, AD)" provides antiprotons at a momentum of 100 MeV/c. Line 103 says that the Antiproton Decelerator reduces the velocity of antiprotons to about 10% of the speed of light for research of antimatter. The page carries the decelerator and its purpose as a scheme under study, a page printed in 1997 cannot carry the working of a machine that was then a proposal, and the page does not print the fraction of the speed of light, so the citation is graded Partial. By the arithmetic of this page, a momentum of 100 MeV/c is, for a particle of the mass of the antiproton, a velocity of about 10.6 percent of the speed of light. Footnote 65 cites W. Bartmann and others, "Past, present and future low energy antiproton facilities at CERN", International Journal of Modern Physics: Conference Series, 2014, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article is published with open access. This page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on February 10, 2023, and, since the index of the Wayback Machine lists no copy of the file of the article, it read that file of six pages in full at the publisher's site on November 15, 2026. The abstract says that "the Antiproton Decelerator (AD) was constructed (adaptation of the existing Antiproton Collector, AC)", and the second section of the article speaks of the proposal "to convert the existing AC, one of the rings of the antiproton accumulation complex, into the AD". Line 104 says that the AD machine was reconfigured from the previous Antiproton Collector (AC) machine. The article carries the sentence, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.45 Two footnotes cite line 106, which calls the AWAKE experiment a proof-of-principle plasma wakefield accelerator. Footnote 66 cites E. Adli and others, "Acceleration of electrons in the plasma wakefield of a proton bunch", Nature, 2018, the paper of the AWAKE collaboration, whose full text this page retrieved from the copy of PubMed Central archived on January 2, 2026 and searched. The paper reports the acceleration of electrons "at the AWAKE experiment, in a demonstration of proton-driven plasma wakefield acceleration", and it ends "In summary, we have demonstrated proton-driven plasma wakefield acceleration." The words proof-of-principle do not stand in the paper, the demonstration that it reports carries them, and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 67 cites E. Gschwendtner and others, "AWAKE, The Advanced Proton Driven Plasma Wakefield Acceleration Experiment at CERN", Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A, 2016. This page read the abstract of the paper at arXiv, in the copy archived on February 1, 2026, and did not read the paper. The abstract says "It is a proof-of-principle R&D experiment at CERN and the world's first proton driven plasma wakefield acceleration experiment." The abstract itself carries the sentence, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.46 Two footnotes cite line 107, which names the CERN Linear Electron Accelerator for Research (CLEAR) as a facility for research and development on accelerators. Footnote 68 cites Kyrre Sjobak and others, "Status of the CLEAR Electron Beam User Facility at CERN", a paper of four pages in the proceedings of the 10th International Particle Accelerator Conference of 2019, read in full in the copy of its file archived on January 17, 2025. The paper says "The CERN Linear Electron Accelerator for Research (CLEAR) has now finished its second year of operation, providing a testbed for new accelerator technologies and a versatile radiation source." The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 69 cites D. Gamba and others, "The CLEAR user facility at CERN", Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A, November 2018. This page read the abstract of the article on the publisher's page in the copy archived on February 2, 2022, and did not read the article. The abstract says "The primary focus for CLEAR is general accelerator R&D and component studies for existing and possible future accelerator applications." The abstract itself carries the sentence, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.47 Footnote 70 cites T. Binoth, C. Buttar, P. J. Clark and E. W. N. Glover (eds.), LHC Physics (CRC Press, 2012), with no page. Google Books shows a limited preview of the book. Its search of the book for the word worldwide returns pages 374 and 375, which treat the computing grid of the collider, and its search for the word cooperation returns no page. This page found no page of the book that carries the sentence of line 109, which calls the Large Hadron Collider a large-scale, worldwide scientific cooperation project, the book as a whole was not read, and the citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.48 Eight footnotes stand inside line 115, one after each of the names of eight experiments, and the line says that the eight experiments are located along the collider and that each of them studies particle collisions from a different aspect and with different technologies. Each of the eight citations is graded on whether its source carries that the experiment whose name it follows is an experiment at the Large Hadron Collider. Footnote 71 follows the name CMS and cites The CMS Collaboration, "The CMS experiment at the CERN LHC", Journal of Instrumentation, 2008. This page retrieved the publisher's page of the paper in full from the copy archived on April 11, 2016 and searched it, and the later copies of that page are checks for automated visitors. The abstract says "The Compact Muon Solenoid (CMS) detector is described. The detector operates at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN." Footnote 72 follows the name ATLAS and cites The ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS: A 25-Year Insider Story of the LHC Experiment (World Scientific, 2019). This page read the publisher's description of the book in the copy archived on February 11, 2023 and did not read the book. The description says "This book is written by the ATLAS Collaboration at CERN's Large Hadron Collider (LHC)". Footnote 73 follows the name LHCb and cites I. Belyaev, G. Carboni, N. Harnew, C. Matteuzzi and F. Teubert, "The history of LHCb", The European Physical Journal H, December 2021, an article published with open access, whose text this page retrieved in full from the publisher's page in the copy archived on July 29, 2023 and searched. The abstract says "In this paper we describe the history of the LHCb experiment over the last three decades". Footnote 74 follows the name MoEDAL and cites "MoEDAL becomes the LHC's magnificent seventh", CERN Courier, May 5, 2010, read in full in the copy archived on September 27, 2023 that the footnote names. The article says "On 2 December 2009 the CERN Research Board approved the LHC’s seventh experiment: the Monopole and Exotics Detector At the LHC (MoEDAL)." Footnote 75 follows the name TOTEM and cites The TOTEM Collaboration, "The TOTEM Experiment at the CERN Large Hadron Collider", Journal of Instrumentation, 2008, whose abstract this page read on the publisher's page in the copy archived on October 9, 2019. The abstract says that the experiment will measure the total cross-section of proton collisions "and study elastic and diffractive scattering at the LHC". Footnote 76 follows the name LHCf and cites The LHCf Collaboration, "The LHCf detector at the CERN Large Hadron Collider", Journal of Instrumentation, 2008, whose abstract this page read on the publisher's page in the copy archived on April 8, 2023. The abstract says "LHCf is an experiment dedicated to the measurement of neutral particles emitted in the very forward region of LHC collisions." Footnote 78 follows the name ALICE and cites C. Fabjan and J. Schukraft, "The story of ALICE: Building the dedicated heavy ion detector at LHC", a paper at arXiv, whose abstract this page read in the copy archived on October 31, 2026. The abstract calls ALICE "the dedicated heavy ion experiment at the CERN LHC accelerator". The seven citations are graded Supported. Footnote 77 follows the name FASER and cites Jonathan L. Feng, Iftah Galon, Felix Kling and Sebastian Trojanowski, "ForwArd Search ExpeRiment at the LHC", Physical Review D, 2018, whose abstract this page read at arXiv in the copy archived on November 12, 2026. The abstract says "We propose a new experiment, ForwArd Search ExpeRiment, or FASER, which would be placed downstream of the ATLAS or CMS interaction point". The paper carries the proposal of the experiment, and a proposal cannot carry that the experiment is located along the collider, so the citation is graded Partial. The article that footnote 74 cites counts MoEDAL as the seventh experiment of the collider, and the line names eight.

1.49 Footnote 79 cites Dennis Overbye, "Let the Proton Smashing Begin. (The Rap Is Already Written.)", The New York Times, July 29, 2008. This page does not open the site of The New York Times or archived copies of it under the rules of its tools, and the citation at line 121, which says that in August 2008 the initial particle beams were injected into the Large Hadron Collider, is graded Uncheckable. The footnote dates the article July 29, 2008, which is before the month that the line names. Footnote 80 stands inside line 122, after the words that say that the first beam was circulated through the entire collider on 10 September 2008, and the rest of the line, on the failure of a magnet connection and the stop for repairs on 19 September 2008, follows the footnote. Footnote 80 cites "LHC First Beam", a page of the press office of CERN, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 13, 2016 that the footnote names and searched. The page says "On 10 September 2008, scientists circulated for the first time a beam in the Large Hadron Collider." The citation is graded Supported.

1.50 Footnote 81 cites Adrian Cho, "Higgs Boson Makes Its Debut After Decades-Long Search", Science, July 13, 2012, and gives a DOI, a Bibcode and a PubMed identifier. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read the summary of it on the publisher's page in the copies archived on April 17, 2017 and November 3, 2022. The summary says "Last week's announcement that physicists at the European particle physics laboratory, CERN, had discovered the Higgs boson could mark the end of the road for particle physics." Line 129 says that in July 2012 CERN scientists announced the discovery of a new sub-atomic particle that was later confirmed to be the Higgs boson. The summary carries the announcement of July 2012, and an article of July 13, 2012 cannot carry a later confirmation, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 82 cites "New results indicate that particle discovered at CERN is a Higgs boson", a press release of CERN dated 14 March 2013, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 2, 2017 that the footnote names and searched. The release says of the two collaborations that "they find that the new particle is looking more and more like a Higgs boson". Line 130 says that in March 2013 CERN announced that the measurements performed on the newly found particle allowed it to conclude that it was a Higgs boson, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.51 Two footnotes cite line 133, which says that the first ramp to the record-breaking energy of 6.5 TeV was performed on 10 April 2015. Footnote 83 cites Cian O'Luanaigh, "First successful beam at record energy of 6.5 TeV", an update of CERN read in full in the copy archived on October 29, 2015 that the footnote names. The update was posted on 10 Apr 2015, and it says "Last night the Operations team for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) successfully circulated a beam at 6.5 teraelectronvolts (TeV)". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 84 cites the same author's "Proton beams are back in the LHC", an update read in full in the copy archived on October 29, 2015 that the footnote names. The update was posted on 5 Apr 2015, five days before the day that the line names. It says of the beams of that day "These beams circulated at their injection energy of 450 GeV." It names 6.5 TeV per beam as the energy at which the collider was to operate. The update carries the energy to come and not the ramp of April 10, 2015, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.52 Footnote 85 cites "LHC smashes targets for 2016 run", an article of November 1, 2016 by Frédérick Bordry, the Director for Accelerators and Technology of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on June 23, 2018 that the footnote names. The article says that at the beginning of the year "we set ourselves the target of reaching the machine’s peak design luminosity", and that "by the end of the run we were regularly operating at 30 % above that". Line 134 says that in 2016 the design collision rate was exceeded for the first time. The article carries the year and the exceeding of the design luminosity, and it does not say that the design luminosity was exceeded for the first time, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.53 Two footnotes cite line 135, which says that a second two-year period of shutdown began at the end of 2018. Footnote 86 cites Anaïs Schaeffer, "LS2 Report: Review of a rather unusual year", an article of CERN of December 14, 2020, read in full in the copy archived on December 17, 2020 that the footnote names. The article speaks of "the upgrade work being carried out during Long Shutdown 2 (LS2)", says of one facility that it had not run "since it was shut down in November 2018", and says "Run 3 of the LHC will start in early 2022." The article carries the second long shutdown and its beginning about the end of 2018. It does not call the shutdown a period of two years, and it places the next run in early 2022, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 87 cites Michelangelo Mangano, "LHC at 10: the physics legacy", CERN Courier, March 9, 2020, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on March 25, 2020 that the footnote names and searched. The article reviews the results in physics of the first two runs of the collider, and the word shutdown does not occur in it, so the citation is graded Not supported.

1.54 Two footnotes stand at line 136. Footnote 88 follows the words that date the final run to June 14, 2026, and cites "Final collisions, new horizons", an article of CERN by Corinne Pralavorio, read in full in the copy archived on June 30, 2026 that the footnote names. The article says "In the early hours of Sunday, 14 June, the experiments at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) had their last hurrah." The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 89 stands at the end of the line, which says that the accelerator was switched off to begin Long Shutdown 3, and cites "CERN bids farewell to the LHC and enters Long Shutdown 3", read in full in the copy archived on June 30, 2026 that the footnote names. The page says "Following its final physics run, the accelerator has been switched off to begin CERN’s Long Shutdown 3 (LS3)". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 90 cites "HiLumi LHC", a page of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on June 30, 2026 that the footnote names. The page says "The HiLumi LHC, which should be operational in mid-2030", and it places the installation of the new equipment "during a four-year shutdown of the accelerators starting in mid-2026". Line 137 says that the programme will focus on maintenance and upgrades in preparation for the High Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC), which the line says is scheduled to be operational by the mid-2030s. The page carries the preparation, and it names the middle of the year 2030 where the line names the middle of the decade of the 2030s, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.55 Footnote 91 cites "CERN Yellow Reports: Monographs, Vol. 10 (2020): High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC): Technical design report". This page read the page of the issue in full in the copy archived on December 24, 2024 that the footnote names, and read the first chapter of the report, by O. Brüning and L. Rossi, 16 pages, in full in the copy of its file archived on March 1, 2026. It did not read the other chapters. The page of the issue says "To sustain and extend its discovery potential, the LHC will need a major upgrade in the 2020s." The first chapter says of the goal of the upgrade "This integrated luminosity is about ten times the predicted luminosity reach of the LHC in its initial configuration." It places the installation of the main hardware of the upgrade in the third long shutdown, which its list of milestones sets in the years 2025 to 2027. Line 139 says that the project should see the accelerator upgraded by 2026 to an order of magnitude higher luminosity. The parts of the report that this page read carry the tenfold luminosity, and neither of them says that the upgrade is to be complete by 2026, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.56 Footnote 92 cites the "Linac4 design report", edited by Maurizio Vretenar, in the series CERN Yellow Reports: Monographs, September 18, 2020. This page read the page of the issue, which carries the abstract of the report, in full in the copy archived on December 5, 2020 that the footnote names, and did not read the report. The abstract says that Linac4 will be connected to the Proton Synchrotron Booster during a long shutdown, "after which it will replace the 50 MeV Linac2 as source of protons for the LHC". Line 141 says that the LINAC 2 linear accelerator injector was decommissioned and replaced by a new injector accelerator, the LINAC4. The abstract carries the replacement as a plan, in the future tense, and it does not speak of the decommissioning of Linac 2, so the citation is graded Partial. The article of CERN Courier that footnote 57 cites at line 93 reports the replacement as done.

1.57 Footnote 93 cites H. Haseroth and seven other authors, History, developments and recent performance of the CERN linac 1, a report of CERN of 1992, and names a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on April 6, 2022, which this page read. This page read the file of the report, four scanned pages, by optical character recognition in the copy archived on April 7, 2023. The abstract says "Early June 1992, the original CERN 50 MeV proton linac accelerated its last beam after nearly 33 years of loyal service." It says that the machine was "commissioned in 1959 as an injector for the 26 GeV Proton Synchrotron". The citation at line 143, which says of the original linear accelerator of line 142 that it operated from 1959 to 1992, is graded Supported. Footnote 94 cites "The tale of a billion-trillion protons", CERN Courier, November 30, 2018, read in full in the copy archived on November 17, 2019 that the footnote names. The article says "Linac2 has delivered all of the protons for the CERN accelerator complex since 1978." It also says "On 12 November, Linac2 was switched off and will now be decommissioned". The citation at line 146, which says of the second linear accelerator that it operated from 1978 to 2018, is graded Supported.

1.58 Two footnotes cite line 148, which says of the Synchro-Cyclotron of line 147 that it was made into a public exhibition in 2012 and 2013. Footnote 95 cites Georges Charpak, "The landscape of experimental areas, from the CERN synchro-cyclotron to present accelerators", Physics Reports, April 1993, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The publisher's page, in the copy archived on April 10, 2023, shows the title of the paper and no abstract, and this page did not read the paper. A paper of April 1993 cannot carry an exhibition of 2012 and 2013, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 96 cites "The Synchrocyclotron prepares for visitors", an article of CERN by Antonella Del Rosso dated 14 December, 2012, read in full in the copy archived on November 2, 2019 that the footnote names. The article says "Now a public exhibition will breathe new life into the hall." It also says "the SC will be open to visitors by September 2013 in time for the CERN Open Day". The article of December 2012 carries the preparation of the exhibition and the plan to open it in 2013, and it cannot carry the exhibition as made, so the citation is graded Partial. The same article says that the hall has been used as a storage room "since the accelerator was shut down in 1990", where line 147, which carries no footnote, says that the accelerator was shut down in 1991.

1.59 Two footnotes cite line 149, which calls the Intersecting Storage Rings (ISR) an early collider built from 1966 to 1971 and operated until 1984. Footnote 97 cites Kurt Hübner, "The CERN intersecting storage rings (ISR)", The European Physical Journal H, 2012, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on July 29, 2023. The abstract says of the machine "It came into operation at the beginning of 1971 and was decommissioned as a collider in 1983." The abstract gives no years of construction and gives 1983 where the line gives 1984, the article itself could not be read, and the citation is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 98 cites Stephen Myers, "The CERN Intersecting Storage Rings", a chapter of Challenges and Goals for Accelerators in the XXI Century (World Scientific, 2016), pages 135 to 151. The chapter is published with open access, and this page read its file of 17 pages in full in the copy archived on April 8, 2023. The chapter says "The ISR was constructed during the period 1966 to 1970 and was operated from 1971 to 1983 for physics experiments", and it says "It was decommissioned in 1984." The chapter carries the collider and the year 1966. It ends the construction in 1970 and the operation for physics in 1983, and it gives 1984 as the year of decommissioning, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.60 Footnote 99 cites Rudiger Schmidt, "The CERN SPS proton–antiproton collider", a chapter of Challenges and Goals for Accelerators in the XXI Century (World Scientific, 2016), pages 153 to 167. The chapter is published with open access, and this page read its file of 15 pages in full in the copy archived on April 8, 2023. The chapter says "During 1981 to 1990, the CERN SPS was operated as a" proton-antiproton collider, and it says that the machine restarted in 1987 after an upgrade and that 1990 was the last year of its operation as a collider. Line 150 says that the Super Proton-Antiproton Synchrotron operated from 1981 to 1991. The chapter carries the collider and the year 1981 and gives 1990 as the last year, so the citation is graded Partial. The paper of V. Hatton that footnote 60 cites at line 99 carries the years 1981 to 1990 in its title.

1.61 Two footnotes cite line 152, which says that the Large Electron-Positron Collider operated from 1989 to 2000 and was the largest machine of its kind, housed in a circular tunnel 27 kilometres long that now houses the Large Hadron Collider. Footnote 100 cites Herwig Schopper, LEP - the Lord of the Collider Rings at CERN 1980-2000 (Springer, 2009), with no page. This page read the publisher's description of the book in the copy archived on April 6, 2023 and did not read the book. The description says that the collider was housed "by a 4 m diameter tunnel of 27 km circumference", that it "was not only the largest but also one of the most sophisticated scientific research instruments ever created by Man", that it "was built during the years 1983 - 1989, was operational until 2000", and that it was dismantled, "enabling the tunnel to be reused for building the next generation machine, the much more powerful Large Hadron Collider (LHC)". The description itself carries the sentence, and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 101 cites Emilio Picasso, "A few memories from the days at LEP", The European Physical Journal H, 2012, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and the abstract on the publisher's page, in the copy archived on July 29, 2023, says only "This contribution, a personal recollection by the author, is part of a special issue". The citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.62 Two footnotes stand at line 153. Footnote 102 follows the name of the LEP Pre-Injector (LPI) accelerator complex and cites S. Battisti and others, "Progress report on the LEP Pre-injector", in the proceedings of the 1989 IEEE Particle Accelerator Conference, pages 1815 to 1817, and gives a DOI and no other link. This page read the file of the paper at the Joint Accelerator Conferences Website, three pages, in full in the copy archived on April 19, 2022. The paper bears the title that the footnote gives, which names the complex, and the citation of the name of the complex is graded Supported. Footnote 103 stands at the end of the line, which says that the complex consisted of a linear accelerator called the LEP Injector Linac (LIL), itself made of two linear accelerators called LIL V and LIL W, and of a circular accelerator called the Electron Positron Accumulator (EPA). It cites S. Battisti and others, The design of the LEP electron positron accumulator (EPA), and names a copy of the record of the paper at the CERN Document Server archived on July 29, 2020, which this page read. This page read the file of the paper in full in the copy archived on the same day. The paper says that the accumulator gathers the pulses of electrons and positrons from the linac, and that "it thus acts as a buffer between the fast cycling linac (100 Hz) and the slow cycling PS and SPS". The paper carries the Electron Positron Accumulator and a linac that feeds it. It does not print the names LEP Injector Linac, LIL V or LIL W, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.63 Footnote 104 is cited at line 155 and at line 166. It cites Roberto Corsini, "Final Results from the Clic Test Facility (CTF3)", a paper of six pages in the proceedings of the 8th International Particle Accelerator Conference of 2017, read in full in the copy of its file archived on June 5, 2024. Line 155 says that the LEP Pre-Injector was operational from 1987 to 2001 and that, after the shutdown of LEP and the completion of the experiments that it fed, the facility was adapted to be used for the CLIC Test Facility 3 (CTF3), the third test facility of the Compact Linear Collider (CLIC). The paper does not name the LEP Pre-Injector and prints neither 1987 nor 2001. It says only that one of its injectors uses accelerating structures "recuperated from the LEP Injector Linac (LIL)", so the citation at line 155 is graded Not supported. Line 166 says that the test facility was in operation from 2001 to 2016. The paper says "CTF3 was installed and commissioned in stages" from 2003, it says "Beam commissioning started in June 2003.", and it says that the facility "completed its experimental program in December 2016 as planned, and stopped operation". The paper carries the end of the operation in 2016 and gives 2003, and not 2001, for its beginning, so the citation at line 166 is graded Partial.

1.64 Footnote 105 cites D. Möhl, LEAR, history and early achievements, a report of CERN of 1999, and names a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on April 6, 2022, which this page read. This page retrieved the file of the report, of 17 pages, in full from the copy archived on October 28, 2025 and searched it. The report says of a feature of the ring "This turned out to be a decisive advantage for the observation in 1995 of the" antihydrogen created in flight. Line 157 says that the Low Energy Antiproton Ring (LEAR) assembled the first pieces of true antimatter, in 1995, consisting of nine atoms of antihydrogen. The report carries the observation of antihydrogen at the ring in 1995. It gives no count of the atoms and does not call them the first pieces of true antimatter, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 55, the article of Michel Chanel graded at unit 1.38, is cited again at line 159, which says that the apparatus of the ring was reconfigured into the Low Energy Ion Ring. The paper, whose text is of September 2003, presents the conversion as one of the modifications that were to be made to the accelerators, with the commissioning of the ring planned for the beginning of 2005, and it cannot carry the conversion as done, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.65 Footnote 106 is cited at line 162 and inside line 164, each time for the statement that the Antiproton Accumulator (AA) and the Antiproton Collector (AC) worked in tandem and formed the Antiproton Accumulation Complex (AAC). It cites H. Koziol and D. Möhl, "The CERN antiproton collider programme: accelerators and accumulation", Physics Reports, 2004, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on April 21, 2022. This page then retrieved in full and searched the text of the paper as it was submitted for publication in November 2004, a report of CERN of 17 pages, in the copy of its file at the CERN Document Server archived on July 26, 2018. The paper says that "the Antiproton Collector (AC) [12] was built around the AA in 1986", and it adds "From 1987 on, it boosted the accumulation rate, eventually by an order of magnitude." It says that the Low-Energy Antiproton Ring "continued to take beam from the AC/AA until end 1996", and the title of a parameter list among its references names "the Antiproton Accumulator Complex (AAC)". The paper carries the working of the two rings together from 1987 and the complex that they formed, and the two citations are graded Supported. The paper prints the name of the complex with the word Accumulator, where the two lines print the word Accumulation, and the article of W. Bartmann and others that footnote 65 cites at line 104 speaks, in lowercase letters, of "the antiproton accumulation complex". The paper also says "In 1997, the AA was dismantled and the AC converted into the Antiproton Decelerator (AD)". Line 160 and line 163 give 1997 as the year in which the operations of the two machines ended, and line 158 gives 1996 as the year in which the Low Energy Antiproton Ring was closed. Footnotes 107 and 108 stand inside line 163, after the name of the Antiproton Collector, and the rest of the line, on the years of its building, the end of its operation in 1997 and its conversion into the Antiproton Decelerator, follows them. Footnote 107 cites Bruno Autin, "The CERN antiproton collector", in a report of CERN of 1984, with a DOI. This page read the record of the paper at the CERN Document Server, which carries that DOI, in the copy archived on February 11, 2023, and it read the file of that record, a scan of 18 pages, in full by optical character recognition in the copy archived on April 7, 2023. The paper is a lecture of October 1983 in a text dated January 1985, and its abstract begins "The Antiproton Collector is a new ring of much larger acceptance than the present accumulator." It says that "the collector surrounds the AA" and that "physics beams are foreseen in 1987". Footnote 108 cites Edmund J N Wilson, "Design study of an antiproton collector for the antiproton accumulator (ACOL)", a report of CERN of 1983, and names a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on April 6, 2022, which this page read; the file of that record is a scan of 61 pages, which this page did not read. The paper of footnote 107 and the title of the record of footnote 108 carry the name of the machine, which is all that the words before the two footnotes say, and the two citations are graded Supported.

1.66 Footnote 109 cites Pallab Ghosh, "Cern plans for even larger hadron collider", January 15, 2019, an article of BBC News read in full in the copy archived on January 17, 2019 that the footnote names. The article says "Cern has published its ideas for a £20bn successor to the Large Hadron Collider, given the working name of Future Circular Collider (FCC)." Line 168 says that CERN, with groups worldwide, is investigating two main concepts for future accelerators, a linear electron-positron collider with a new acceleration concept, which it calls CLIC, and a larger version of the Large Hadron Collider, which it calls the Future Circular Collider. The article carries the second concept, and it does not name CLIC or a linear collider, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.67 Two footnotes stand at line 194, and footnote 110 is cited again at line 220. Line 194 begins with the words "Of the 24 members" and says that Israel joined CERN as a full member in January 2014, where footnote 110 stands, becoming the first, and currently only, non-geographically European full member, where footnote 111 stands. Footnote 110 cites "Israel", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on July 14, 2014 that the footnote names. The page says "Israel became CERN's 21st Member State on 6 January 2014." The citation at line 194 is graded Supported, and the citation at line 220, the row of the table of member states that gives 6 January 2014 as the date of the membership of Israel, is graded Supported. Footnote 111 cites an article of Haaretz of November 11, 2013, which it titles "Israel may become first non-European member of nuclear research group CERN – Diplomacy and Defense Israel News", read in full in the copy archived on November 12, 2013 to which the footnote links. The article says "Israel will need a unanimous vote to become the first non-European member of the organization based just outside Geneva." An article of November 11, 2013 carries the prospect of the first membership outside Europe and cannot carry that Israel is currently the only such member, so the citation is graded Partial. The footnote prints the author of the article as "Rahman, Fazlur.", and the article names Ariel David as its author.

1.68 Footnote 112 is cited at line 195 and at line 238. It cites "Member States' Contributions – 2026", December 10, 2025, at a record of the CERN Document Server, which this page read in the copy archived on January 29, 2026 that the footnote names. The record is that of the "Final budget of the Organization for the seventy-second financial year 2026", the document whose file footnote 4 cites at line 11, and this page retrieved that file of 47 pages in full and searched it. Line 195 says that the budget contributions of member states are computed based on their Net National Income at factor cost. The table of contributions of the document, its Figure 4, sets beside each state its "Net National Income at factor cost" for the years 2021 to 2023 and its "2026 Full Theoretical Contribution" in percent, and the citation at line 195 is graded Supported. Line 238, the last row of the table of member states in the article, gives the total of the contributions of members, candidates and associates as 1,276.47 million Swiss francs. The second part of Figure 4 gives the grand total of the contributions for 2026 as 1 276 469 700 Swiss francs, and the citation at line 238 is graded Supported. Footnote 134 stands beside it at line 238 and cites "2021 Annual Contributions to CERN budget", a page of CERN read in full in the copy archived on February 19, 2021 that the footnote names. The page gives the scale of contributions for 2021, with a total for the member states of 1 168 922 250 Swiss francs at the prices of 2021. A page of 2021 on the contributions for 2021 cannot carry the total for 2026, so the citation is graded Not supported.

1.69 Two of the six notes of the article cite footnotes. Note 2 stands at line 197, the heading "Founding Members" of the table of member states, and says "12 founding members drafted the Convention for the Establishment of a European Organization for Nuclear Research which entered into force on 29 September 1954." It cites footnotes 113 and 114. Footnote 113 cites the ESA Convention, sixth edition, of the European Space Agency, September 2005, and names a copy at another archive. This page retrieved the file in full, 98 pages, from the address that the footnote gives, in the copy that the Wayback Machine archived on June 21, 2009, and searched it; the copies of that address archived on January 5, 2016, on November 18, 2022 and on October 9, 2026 are error pages. The document is the convention "for the establishment of a European Space Agency". It does not name CERN or the European Organization for Nuclear Research and does not print the year 1954, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 114 cites "Convention for the Establishment of a European Organization for Nuclear Research", a page of the site of the CERN Council, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on July 1, 2012 that the footnote names and searched. The page says that the convention "entered into force on 29 September 1954". It prints the convention without the names of the states that signed it and does not say who drafted it, so the citation is graded Partial. Note 4 stands at line 210, the heading "Acceded Members", and says "Acceded members become CERN member states by ratifying the CERN convention." It cites footnote 117, "CERN Member States", a page of the site of the CERN Council read in full in the copy archived on July 1, 2012 that the footnote names. The page is a table headed "Dates of Accession". It does not say how a state accedes and does not contain the word ratification, so the citation is graded Not supported. The table of the page gives 11 March 1999 as the date of the accession of Bulgaria, where line 219 of the article, which carries no footnote, gives 11 June 1999.

1.70 Footnotes 115 and 116 stand at line 209, the row of the table of member states that gives 29 September 1954 as the date of the status of Yugoslavia as a founding member. Footnote 115 cites "Member States", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on October 27, 2015 that the footnote names. The page says that the convention was signed in 1953 by twelve founding states, which it names, ending with "the United Kingdom and Yugoslavia, and entered into force on September 29, 1954". Footnote 116 cites a page of the timelines of CERN with the same title, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on July 4, 2018 that the footnote names and searched. The page has an entry headed "Twelve founding members" under the date 29 September 1954. The two citations are graded Supported. Footnote 116 is cited again at line 212, the row that gives 1 January 1983 as the date of the status of Spain, beside footnote 118. The page of the timelines has an entry headed "Spain rejoins" under the date 1 January 1983, and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 118 cites "Spain", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on November 25, 2015 that the footnote names. The page says "The return to CERN as a Member State in 1983 marked the renaissance of high-energy physics in Spain." The page carries the year and not the day, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.71 Four footnotes stand in four rows of the table of member states, each after the date of the membership of a state. Footnote 119 stands at line 221, which gives 17 July 2016 for Romania, and cites "CERN welcomes Romania as its twenty-second Member State | Media and Press Relations", whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on August 21, 2016 that the footnote names and searched. The release is dated 18 July 2016 and says "Romania yesterday became the twenty-second Member State of CERN". Footnote 120 stands at line 222, which gives 24 March 2019 for Serbia, and cites "Serbia joins CERN as its 23rd Member State", read in full in the copy archived on March 27, 2019 that the footnote names. The release is dated 24 March, 2019 and says "Today, CERN welcomes Serbia as its 23rd Member State". Footnote 121 stands at line 223, which gives 30 August 2024 for Estonia, and cites "CERN welcomes Estonia as its 24th Member State", read in full in the copy archived on October 10, 2024 that the footnote names. The release is dated 30 August 2024 and says "Today, CERN is welcoming Estonia as its 24th Member State". Footnote 122 stands at line 224, which gives 21 June 2025 for Slovenia, and cites "CERN welcomes Slovenia as its 25th Member State", read in full in the copy archived on June 23, 2025 that the footnote names. The release says "On 21 June 2025, Slovenia became a Member State of CERN". The four citations are graded Supported.

1.72 Four footnotes stand in the rows of the table of member states that give the dates of four associate members, and footnotes 123 and 126 are cited again at lines that unit 1.75 grades. Footnote 123 stands at line 226, which gives 1 April 2016 for Cyprus, and cites "Cyprus", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on June 15, 2016 that the footnote names. The page says "Since 1 April 2016, the Republic of Cyprus is an Associate Member in the pre-stage to Membership of CERN". Footnote 124 stands at line 228, which gives 6 May 2015 for Turkey, and cites "Turkey", a page of the same office, read in full in the copy archived on September 14, 2015 that the footnote names. The page says "Turkey became an Associate Member State on 6 May 2015." Footnote 125 stands at line 229, which gives 31 July 2015 for Pakistan, and cites "Pakistan", a page of the same office, read in full in the copy archived on November 21, 2016 that the footnote names. The page says "Pakistan became an Associate Member State on 31 July 2015." Footnote 126 stands at line 230, which gives 5 October 2016 for Ukraine, and cites "Ukraine becomes an associate member of CERN", October 5, 2016, read in full in the copy archived on February 22, 2021 that the footnote names. The page says "On 5 October 2016, Ukraine became an associate member State of CERN". The four citations are graded Supported.

1.73 Seven footnotes stand in the rows of the table of member states that give the dates of seven more associate members, and footnotes 127 through 131 are cited again at lines that unit 1.75, unit 1.76 and unit 1.77 grade. Footnote 127 stands at line 231, which gives 16 January 2017 for India, and cites "India becomes Associate Member State of CERN", an update of CERN posted on 16 Jan 2017, read in full in the copy archived on November 23, 2017 that the footnote names. The update says "Today, India became an Associate Member of CERN." Footnote 128 stands at line 232, which gives 8 January 2018 for Lithuania, and cites Harriet Kim Jarlett, "Lithuania becomes Associate Member State of CERN", an update posted on 8 Jan 2018, read in full in the copy archived on March 14, 2018 that the footnote names. The update says "Today, the Republic of Lithuania became an Associate Member State of CERN." Footnote 129 stands at line 233, which gives 10 October 2019 for Croatia, and cites "Croatia | International Relations", read in full in the copy archived on December 12, 2019 that the footnote names. The page says that Croatia "became an Associate Member State on 10 October 2019". Footnote 130 stands at line 234, which gives 2 August 2021 for Latvia, and cites "Latvia becomes Associate Member State of CERN", read in full in the copy archived on November 5, 2022 that the footnote names. The article is dated 2 August, 2021 and says "Today, the Republic of Latvia became an Associate Member State of CERN". Footnote 131 stands at line 235, which gives 13 March 2024 for Brazil, and cites "Brazil becomes Associate Member State of CERN", read in full in the copy archived on March 22, 2024 that the footnote names. The article says "The starting date of Brazil’s status as an Associate Member State is 13 March 2024." Footnote 132 stands at line 236, which gives 22 October 2025 for Ireland, and cites "Ireland becomes an Associate Member State of CERN", read in full in the copy archived on October 22, 2025 that the footnote names. The article says "The starting date of Ireland’s status as an Associate Member State is 22 October 2025." Footnote 133 stands at line 237, which gives 2 April 2026 for Chile, and cites "Chile becomes an Associate Member State of CERN", April 2, 2026, without an archived copy, and this page read the article in full in the copy of its address archived on April 2, 2026. The article says "Effective 2 April 2026, Chile has become an Associate Member State of CERN." The seven citations are graded Supported.

1.74 Footnote 135 stands inside line 242, after the words that say that Turkey signed an association agreement on 12 May 2014, and the rest of the line, on the associate membership of 6 May 2015, follows it. It cites "Turkey to become Associate Member State of CERN", an update of CERN of May 12, 2014. The copy archived on October 29, 2015 that the footnote names holds only the menu of the page, and this page read the update in full in the copy archived on December 1, 2014. The update was posted on 12 May 2014 and says that the Director-General of CERN and a minister of Turkey "today signed an agreement admitting Turkey to CERN Associate Membership". The citation is graded Supported. Three footnotes stand at line 243. Footnote 136 follows the words that say that Pakistan signed an association agreement on 19 December 2014, and cites "Pakistan Becomes the First Associate CERN Member from Asia", a press release of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Pakistan that the footnote dates 20 June 2014. The copy archived on June 26, 2018 that the footnote names shows, at the address of the footnote, a different release, on a summit conference, dated "Islamabad 15 April 2016". The copy of the same address archived on December 15, 2014 shows the release that the footnote titles, which this page read in full. That release is dated "Islamabad 20 June 2014" and says that the council of CERN "in its meeting held on 19 June 2014 accepted Pakistan’s application for Associate Membership of CERN". A release of June 20, 2014 reports the acceptance of the application and cannot carry a signing of December 19, 2014, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnotes 137 and 138 stand at the end of the line, which says that Pakistan became an associate member on 31 July 2015. Footnote 137 cites "Pakistan becomes Associate Member State of CERN", an update of CERN read in full in the copy archived on October 22, 2015 that the footnote names. The update was posted on 31 Jul 2015 and says "Today, the Islamic Republic of Pakistan became an Associate Member of CERN." It adds that this follows notification "that Pakistan has ratified an agreement signed in December". Footnote 138 cites "Pakistan officially becomes an associate member of CERN – The Express Tribune", read in full in the copy archived on August 1, 2015 that the footnote names. The article, which the newspaper published on August 1, 2015, says that "Pakistan on Friday became an associate member of the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)", and the Friday before August 1, 2015 was July 31, 2015. The two citations are graded Supported.

1.75 Four citations stand at line 244, line 246, line 247 and line 248. Footnote 123, the page on Cyprus graded at unit 1.72, is cited again at line 244, which says that Cyprus signed an association agreement on 5 October 2012 and became an associate member in the pre-stage to membership on 1 April 2016. The page carries the second date, and it does not carry the signing of an agreement or print the year 2012, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 126, the page on Ukraine graded at unit 1.72, is cited again at line 246, which says of the agreement of line 245 that it was ratified on 5 October 2016. The page says that Ukraine became an associate member on that day "after the ratification by its Parliament of the agreement". The page gives the date to the membership and places the ratification before it without a date, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 139 cites "India to become Associate Member State of CERN", a press release of CERN, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 3, 2018 that the footnote names and searched. The release is dated 21 November 2016 and says that on that day Sekhar Basu and the Director-General of CERN "signed an Agreement admitting India to CERN as an Associate Member". The citation at line 247, which says that India signed an association agreement on 21 November 2016, is graded Supported. Footnote 127, the update on India graded at unit 1.73, is cited again at line 248, which says that the agreement was ratified on 16 January 2017. The update says that India became an associate member on that day, following notification "that the Government of India has completed its internal approval procedures in respect of the agreement, signed in November 2016". The update gives the date to the membership and gives no date to a ratification, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.76 Five citations stand at line 249, line 250, line 252 and line 254. Footnote 140 cites "Slovenia to enter the Associate Member State family of CERN", a press release of CERN, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 3, 2018 that the footnote names and searched. The release is dated 16 December 2016 and says that the Council "voted unanimously to admit the Republic of Slovenia to Associate Membership in the pre-stage to Membership of CERN". The citation at line 249, which says that Slovenia was approved for admission as an associate member state in the pre-stage to membership on 16 December 2016, is graded Supported. Footnote 141 cites "Slovenia becomes an Associate Member in the pre-stage to Membership at CERN", whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 3, 2018 that the footnote names and searched. The page is dated 4 July 2017 and says "Today, the Republic of Slovenia becomes an Associate Member in the pre-stage to Membership at CERN." It adds that this follows notification "that the Republic of Slovenia has completed its internal approval procedures". Line 250 says that the agreement was ratified on 4 July 2017. The page gives the date to the membership and gives no date to a ratification, so the citation is graded Partial. Line 252 says that the association agreement of Lithuania was signed on 27 June 2017 and ratified on 8 January 2018, and it cites footnotes 142 and 128. Footnote 142 cites "Lithuania has become associate member of CERN", a release of the Office of the President of the Republic of Lithuania, read in full in the copy archived on May 10, 2019 that the footnote names. The release is dated "Friday, 16 June, Vilnius" and reports that the Council of CERN "has taken a decision in favor of Lithuania’s associate membership in the organization". A release of June 16, 2017 cannot carry a signing of June 27, 2017 or a ratification of January 8, 2018, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 128, the update on Lithuania graded at unit 1.73, says that the country "completed its internal approval procedures, as required for the entry into force of the Agreement, signed in June 2017". The update carries the signing in June 2017 without the day and the membership of January 8, 2018, and it gives no date to a ratification, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 129, the page on Croatia graded at unit 1.73, is cited again at line 254, which says that the agreement was ratified on 10 October 2019. The page says "Croatia signed the agreement of Associate Membership on 28 February 2019 and became an Associate Member State on 10 October 2019." The page gives October 10, 2019 to the membership and not to a ratification, so the citation is graded Partial. The same sentence of the page gives February 28, 2019 as the day on which Croatia signed the agreement, where line 253, which carries no footnote, says that Croatia was approved for admission on that day.

1.77 Four citations stand at line 255, line 256, line 257 and line 258. Footnote 143 cites "Latvia to join CERN as an Associate Member State", a press release of CERN dated 14 April, 2021, read in full in the copy archived on December 5, 2021 that the footnote names. The release says "Representatives of CERN and of the Republic of Latvia signed an Agreement today admitting Latvia as a CERN Associate Member State". The citation at line 255, which says that Latvia and CERN signed an associate membership agreement on 14 April 2021, is graded Supported. Footnote 130, the article on Latvia graded at unit 1.73, is cited again at line 256, which says that Latvia was formally admitted as an associate member on 2 August 2021. The article of that day says that Latvia became an associate member state "following official notification that the country has completed its internal approval procedures", and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 131, the article on Brazil graded at unit 1.73, is cited again at line 257, which says that Brazil became the first associate member of the Americas on 13 March 2024, after signing the associate membership agreement in March 2022. The article says "Brazil has become the first Associate Member State of CERN in the Americas", and it speaks of "the agreement signed in March 2022". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 144 cites Fabiola Gianotti, "News from the March 2025 CERN Council Session", April 4, 2025, read in full in the copy archived on April 7, 2025 that the footnote names. The article says "The Council approved the admission of Chile and Ireland as new Associate Member States". The citation at line 258, which says that Chile and Ireland were approved as new associate member states in March 2025, is graded Supported.

1.78 Footnote 145 cites "Observers", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on November 23, 2015 that the footnote names. Line 261 says "Three countries have observer status:" and the three lines after it name Japan, Russia and the United States. The page says that the status of observer is "currently held by India, Japan, Russia and the United States", with three organizations, and it says "Japan, Russia and the United States have a special Observer status". The page of 2015 names four countries as holders of the status of observer and three as holders of the special status, so the citation is graded Partial. India, the fourth country of the page, became an associate member state on January 16, 2017, as unit 1.73 records.

1.79 Footnotes 146 and 147 stand at three entries of the article's lists of observers and of states with agreements, each after a parenthesis that reads "(suspended as of March 2022)", and each citation is graded on that parenthesis. Footnote 146 stands at line 263, the entry for Russia in the list of countries with observer status, and cites "CERN Council responds to Russian invasion of Ukraine", an article of CERN of March 8, 2022, read in full in the copy archived on March 13, 2022 that the footnote names. The article says that the Council decided that "the Observer status of the Russian Federation is suspended until further notice", and the citation is graded Supported. Footnote 147 cites "CERN Council takes further measures in response to the invasion of Ukraine", an article of CERN of March 25, 2022, read in full in the copy archived on May 3, 2024 that the footnote names. It stands at line 268, the entry for the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR) in the list of organizations that are observers. The article says that the Council decided "that the Observer status of JINR at the Council is suspended", and the citation at line 268 is graded Supported. Footnote 147 stands again at line 277, the entry for Belarus in the list of states with co-operation agreements, which gives the date 28 June 1994. The article says that the member states decided to suspend the participation of the scientists of CERN in the scientific committees of institutions in Russia and Belarus, and that the Council would decide on the suspension of the international cooperation agreements "at its Session in June 2022". The article carries measures of March 2022 that concern Belarus, and it does not say that the agreement with Belarus or the involvement of Belarus was suspended in March 2022, so the citation at line 277 is graded Partial.

1.80 Footnote 148 is cited at line 269, at line 313 and at line 344, and footnotes 149 and 155 cite one and the same page. Footnote 148 cites "Member states", a page of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on October 3, 2017 that the footnote names. Footnotes 149 and 155 cite "Associate & Non-Member State Relations | International Relations", read in full in the copy archived on August 28, 2023 that both footnotes name. Line 269 says that non-member states, with the dates of their co-operation agreements, are currently involved in the programmes of CERN, and the 43 lines after it, line 270 through line 312, name 43 states with a date for each. The page of footnote 148 says "Non-member states with co-operation agreements with CERN include" and names 37 states without dates, among which are 32 of the 43 states of the article. The page of footnote 149 holds one list, headed "Non-Member States, Territories and Regions Collaborating with CERN", of 60 names without dates, among which are 42 of the 43 states of the article, all but Bosnia and Herzegovina. Each page carries the involvement of most of the states and neither carries a date of an agreement, so the two citations at line 269 are graded Partial. Line 313 says that CERN also has scientific contacts with other countries and regions, and the 21 lines after it, line 314 through line 334, name them. The page of footnote 148 says "CERN also has scientific contacts with" and names 18 countries and territories, among which are nine of the 21 names of the article. The sentence of line 313 is carried, and the citation is graded Supported. The page of footnote 155 has no class of scientific contacts, and its one list holds 16 of the 21 names of the article, all but Luxemburg, Mauritius, Sudan, Tanzania and Zambia, so the citation is graded Partial. The article names Morocco in both of its lists, at line 296 and at line 325. Line 344 says that JINR is currently suspended, due to the resolution of the CERN Council of 25 March 2022, and cites footnote 148. A copy of October 2017 cannot carry a resolution of March 2022, and the page of footnote 148 does not name JINR, so the citation is graded Not supported. The sentence stands on the page that footnotes 149 and 155 cite, which says "The Observer status of JINR is suspended in accordance with the CERN Council Resolution of 25 March 2022."

1.81 Five footnotes stand at three entries of the list of states with co-operation agreements. Footnote 150 stands at line 279, which gives 16 February 2021 for Bosnia and Herzegovina, and cites "CERN lays foundations for collaboration with Bosnia and Herzegovina through International Cooperation Agreement", an article of CERN by Thomas Hortala of February 22, 2021, read in full in the copy archived on August 28, 2023 that the footnote names. The article says that the two parties signed an agreement "concerning scientific and technical cooperation in high-energy physics on Tuesday, 16 February". The citation is graded Supported. Two footnotes stand at line 289, the entry for Jordan. Footnote 151 follows the date 12 June 2003 and cites "Jordan", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on July 1, 2012 that the footnote names. The page says "Relations with Jordan were initiated through a Memorandum of Understanding", which it says was "signed on June 12, 2003", and the citation is graded Supported. The date is that of the memorandum and not that of a co-operation agreement, as the words of the line after the footnote say. Footnote 152 stands at the end of the line and cites "SESAME", a page of the same office on the laboratory Synchrotron-light for Experimental Science and Applications in the Middle East (SESAME), read in full in the copy archived on July 1, 2012 that the footnote names. The page says "CERN signed in 2003 a MoU with Jordan and SESAME, in preparation of a cooperation agreement signed in 2004", which are the words of the line, and the citation is graded Supported. Two footnotes stand at line 292, which gives 10 January 2008 for Malta. Footnote 153 cites "Prime Minister of Malta visits CERN", an article of the CERN Bulletin read in full in the copy archived on May 24, 2014 that the footnote names. The article says that the Prime Minister of Malta "visited CERN and met Director-General, Robert Aymar, on 10 January", and that the two "signed a cooperation agreement". Footnote 154 cites "Malta signs agreement with CERN", an article of the Times of Malta of January 11, 2008, read in full in the copy archived on May 23, 2014 that the footnote names. The article says that the Prime Minister "was at CERN to sign a five-year memorandum of understanding with the research institute", on the day before its publication. The two citations are graded Supported.

1.82 Footnote 156 cites Fernando Quevedo, "The Importance of International Research Institutions for Science Diplomacy", Science & Diplomacy, July 2013, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on May 3, 2021 that the footnote names and searched. The article says "CERN illustrates the importance of science and international research institutions in uniting nations to pursue a single noble goal." The citation at line 335, which says that international research institutions, such as CERN, can aid in science diplomacy, is graded Supported. Footnote 157 cites "ESO and CERN Sign Cooperation Agreement", an announcement of the European Southern Observatory (ESO) of December 18, 2015, read in full in the copy archived on December 22, 2015 that the footnote names. The announcement says that the two organizations "have signed a cooperation agreement". The citation at line 336, which says that ESO and CERN have a cooperation agreement, is graded Supported.

1.83 Footnote 158 cites "The CERN Experimental Programme: Greybook", at an address of the database that ends in a list of countries. The copy archived on November 2, 2021 that the footnote names and the copy archived on September 29, 2022 are empty pages of an application, and the live page, which this page opened on November 15, 2026, showed the menu of the database and no list. The citation at line 337, which says that a large number of institutes around the world are associated to CERN through current collaboration agreements and historical links, is graded Uncheckable.

1.84 Three footnotes stand at three entries of the article's list of associated organizations, each of which the article calls an organization based on the CERN model. Footnote 159 stands at line 339, the entry for the European Molecular Biology Laboratory, and cites "EMBL History – EMBL", read in full in the copy archived on April 13, 2014 that the footnote names. The page says of the founders of the laboratory "Their goal was to create a CERN-like supranational research centre". Footnote 160 stands at line 340, the entry for the European Space Research Organisation, and cites pages 58 and 59 of Roger-M. Bonnet and Vittorio Manno, International Cooperation in Space: The Example of the European Space Agency (Harvard University Press, 1994), which this page read from their images at Google Books. Page 58 says of that organization, which it calls ESRO, that its "organization was derived from the example of CERN". Footnote 161 stands at line 341, the entry for the European Southern Observatory, and cites page 8 of Adriaan Blaauw, ESO's Early History: The European Southern Observatory from Concept to Reality (ESO, 1991), with a copy of the page of the observatory that offers the book, archived on January 14, 2023, which this page read. This page read page 8 from its page image in the file of the book at the site of the observatory, a file of 43,857,432 bytes, in the copy archived on November 3, 2021; the copy of that file archived on January 25, 2025 is cut off after its first megabyte. Page 8 says of the draft of the convention of the observatory "The new draft was largely adapted from the CERN Convention." It says that the constitution, the finances and the personnel rules of the observatory became very similar to those of CERN "through this early adaptation of the CERN model". The three citations are graded Supported.

1.85 Four footnotes stand at line 342, line 343 and line 345. Footnote 162 stands inside line 342, after the words that say that the European Southern Observatory and CERN share a pension fund, and cites "Home | CERN Pension Fund", read in full in the copy archived on June 15, 2025 that the footnote names. The page says that a member of the fund is a member of the personnel of CERN "or a member of the ESO personnel admitted to the Fund in accordance with the CERN/ESO Agreement". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 163 stands inside line 343, after the words that call JINR an observer to the CERN Council, and cites "JINR | International Relations", read in full in the copy archived on November 2, 2021 that the footnote names. The page says "JINR has the status of Observer in the CERN Council since 2014." The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 164 stands at the end of line 343, which says that CERN is represented in the JINR Council, and cites "Governing and Advisory Bodies of JINR", a page of the institute, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 2, 2021 that the footnote names and searched. The page says that "The JINR Scientific Council consists of" scientists of the member states and researchers from other countries and organizations, among which it names "the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)". The citation is graded Supported. The body in which the page places CERN is the Scientific Council of the institute, and the page names the Committee of Plenipotentiaries as the supreme body of the institute. Footnote 165 cites "Members and observers of SESAME | SESAME | Synchrotron-light for Experimental Science and Applications in the Middle East", read in full in the copy archived on February 1, 2020 that the footnote names. The page lists "the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)" among the observers of the year 2017. The citation at line 345, which says that CERN is an observer to the SESAME Council, is graded Supported.

1.86 Footnote 166 cites "UNESCO | International Relations", a page of the International Relations office of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on November 2, 2021 that the footnote names. The menu of the page lists UNESCO under the heading Observers, with the European Union, Japan, JINR, Russia and the United States of America. The text of the page does not use the word observer, and it says "UNESCO played an important role in setting up CERN." The citation at line 346, which calls UNESCO an observer to the CERN Council, is graded Supported.

1.87 Four footnotes cite the first two sentences of the article's section on the top-level domain .cern. Line 355 says that .cern is a top-level domain for CERN. Footnote 167 cites ".cern – ICANNWiki", read in full in the copy archived on June 24, 2023 that the footnote names. The page says ".cern is a Brand TLD delegated in ICANN's New gTLD Program." Footnote 168 cites "About .cern", the home page of the registry of the domain, read in full in the copy archived on June 13, 2023 that the footnote names. The page says "The .cern top-level domain is a closed domain for the exclusive use of CERN and its affiliates." The two citations are graded Supported. Line 356 says that the domain was registered on 13 August 2014. Footnote 169 cites ".cern Domain Delegation Data", the record of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) for the domain, read in full in the copy archived on September 4, 2019 that the footnote names. The record says "Registration date 2014-08-13." The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 170 cites ".cern registration policy", a page of the registry, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on November 1, 2019 that the footnote names and searched. The policy sets the rules for the registration of names under the domain. It gives no date for the registration of the domain itself, and the year 2014 does not occur in it, so the citation is graded Not supported. The page of ICANNWiki at footnote 167 dates the delegation of the domain to the root zone to 16 August, 2014.

1.88 Two footnotes cite line 357, which says that on 20 October 2015 CERN moved its main website to home.cern. Footnote 171 cites E. Alvarez and others, "First experience with the new .cern Top Level Domain", Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2017, a paper published with open access, which this page read in full, in its file of eight pages, in the copy archived on October 19, 2022. The paper says that "on 20 October 2015 at 2PM (GMT+1) CERN moved its main Website to http://home.cern". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 172 cites "Birthplace of the World Wide Web CERN Launches home.cern", an article of CircleID by Tony Kirsch of January 11, 2016, read in full in the copy archived on September 24, 2023 that the footnote names. The article says that CERN was "launching its new .brand domain name www.home.cern in recent weeks". The article carries the move and does not carry its date, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.89 Four footnotes stand at line 361. Footnote 173 follows the name of the librarian Luisella Goldschmidt-Clermont and cites "Luisella Goldschmidt-Clermont (1925 – 2013)", CERN Bulletin, December 3, 2013, at an address of the repository of CERN of which the index of the Wayback Machine lists no copy, and this page read the record in full on the live site on November 15, 2026. The obituary says that "she started work in the Scientific Information Service at CERN in 1954", and it says "She was behind the initiative to organise the exchange of article preprints between research centres". The citation is graded Supported. Three footnotes stand at the end of the line, which says that the librarian played an important role in transforming the existing culture of personal sharing of research results into a more institutional approach, and that she thereby laid the groundwork for what has only later been called open science. Footnote 174 cites Phillip H. Roth, "How libraries classified physics preprints before arXiv and set the stage for distinguishing insiders from outsiders", Nature Reviews Physics, March 27, 2026, and links the text at arXiv, where this page read its file of four pages in full in the copy archived on August 18, 2026. The text speaks of an "innovative librarian at CERN" and says that "the CERN library created the first formal preprint exchange system". It carries the change from private circulation to a system of the library, and the words open science do not occur in it, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 175 cites the same author's "Formalizing Informal Communication: An Archaeology of the Early Pre-Web Preprint Infrastructure at CERN", Minerva, April 1, 2026, an article published with open access, whose text this page retrieved in full from the publisher's page in the copy archived on April 2, 2026 and searched. The article says that credit for the pioneering work of registering, categorizing and announcing preprints "needs to be given to Luisella Goldschmidt-Clermont, who was a librarian at CERN". The words open science occur in the article only in the title of a work in its list of references, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 176 cites "Tuesdays 10 o'clock at the CERN library", a post of the site Preprint Culture of September 9, 2024, without an archived copy. The index of the Wayback Machine lists no copy of the post, and this page read it in full on the live site on November 15, 2026. The post says "In the late 1950s, the librarian Luisella Goldschmidt-Clermont ventured on a daring mission", and it says that "important groundwork for the current culture of “open science” was laid in the 1960s". The citation is graded Supported.

1.90 Footnote 14, the text of the convention graded at unit 1.12, is cited again at line 362, which says that CERN has developed policies and official documents that enable and promote open science, starting with its founding convention of 1953, which indicated that all its results are to be published or made generally available. Article II of the convention says that "the results of its experimental and theoretical work shall be published or otherwise made generally available", and the page dates the convention 1st July, 1953. The citation is graded Supported.

1.91 Two footnotes stand inside line 363. Footnote 177 follows the words that say that CERN published its open access policy in 2014, and cites Open Access Policy for CERN Publications, a report that the footnote dates 2021, with a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on August 4, 2017, which this page read. This page read the file of the policy, of one page, in full in the copy archived on November 27, 2018. The file is headed with two dates, that of its first issue by the Director-General, October 16, 2014, and that of its amendment, April 27, 2017. The record says "CERN authors are expected to publish all their results Gold Open Access." The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 178 follows the words that say that an open data policy was endorsed by the four main collaborations of the Large Hadron Collider, and cites CERN Open Data Policy for the LHC Experiments (CERN, 2020), with a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on January 26, 2021, which this page read. This page read the file of the policy, of two pages, in full in the copy archived on October 2, 2022. The record says "This document defines the Open Data policy for the large LHC experiments (ALICE, ATLAS, CMS and LHCb)." It adds "The policy has been endorsed by the collaboration boards of these experiments". The citation is graded Supported.

1.92 Four footnotes cite line 365, which says that, before the open data policy, guidelines for the preservation of data, for access to them and for their reuse were implemented by each collaboration individually through its own policies, which are updated when necessary. The four footnotes cite the records of four policies at the CERN Open Data Portal, each of which this page read in full in the copy that its footnote names. Footnote 179 cites the ALICE Collaboration, ALICE data preservation strategy, in the copy archived on May 12, 2021. The record says "This document contains the ALICE data preservation strategy and policy." Footnote 180 cites the ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS Data Access Policy, in the copy archived on May 3, 2021. The record says that the first version of the policy "was endorsed by the ATLAS Collaboration Board in June 2014" and that a revised version "was endorsed in February 2021". Footnote 181 cites the CMS Collaboration, CMS data preservation, re-use and open access policy, in the copy archived on May 12, 2021. The record says "The policy has been approved by the CMS Collaboration Board in March 2012." Footnote 182 cites the LHCb Collaboration, LHCb External Data Access Policy, in the copy archived on May 3, 2021. The record says "This was adopted at the Collaboration Board meeting on 27th Feb 2013." and adds "The policy was later revised in February 2020 (version 2)." The four citations are graded Supported. The four footnotes date the four policies 2014, where the records date the policy of CMS to March 2012 and the policy of LHCb to February 2013.

1.93 Footnote 183 cites the European Strategy Group, 2020 Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (CERN Council, 2020), with a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on May 3, 2021, which this page read. This page retrieved the file of the document in full from the copy archived on January 20, 2022 and searched it. The record says "The European Strategy for Particle Physics is the cornerstone of Europe’s decision-making process for the long-term future of the field." It adds that the strategy is "Mandated by the CERN Council". Line 366 says that the strategy was last updated in 2020 and quotes from it a sentence on open science. The document prints that sentence in these words: "The particle physics community should work with the relevant authorities to help shape the emerging consensus on Open Science to be adopted for publicly-funded research, and should then implement a policy of Open Science for the field." The citation is graded Supported. The quotation of the line prints the words "open science" in lowercase letters in both places, where the document prints them with capital letters.

1.94 Two footnotes cite line 369, which says that in 2018 the partnership SCOAP3, the Sponsoring Consortium for Open Access Publishing in Particle Physics, represented more than 3,000 libraries from 44 countries and 3 intergovernmental organizations, which worked to convert research articles in high-energy physics across 11 leading journals to open access. Footnote 184 cites page 9 of F. Loizides and a second editor, Positioning and Power in Academic Publishing: Players, Agents and Agendas: Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Electronic Publishing (IOS Press, 2016), with a copy of the publisher's page of the book archived on May 3, 2021, which this page read. The page lists, at pages 9 to 15 of the book, a paper by Angelika Kutz on SCOAP3, and it prints the abstract of the paper, which says "SCOAP3 is a global partnership which converts high-quality subscription journals in the field of High-Energy Physics to Open Access". This page did not read the paper. A paper of 2016 carries the partnership and cannot carry its figures for 2018, so the citation is graded Partial. The footnote prints the name of the second editor as "Smidt, B.", and the publisher's page prints it as Birgit Schmidt. Footnote 185 cites Alexander Kohls and Salvatore Mele, "Converting the Literature of a Scientific Field to Open Access through Global Collaboration: The Experience of SCOAP3 in Particle Physics", Publications, April 9, 2018, an article published with open access, whose text this page retrieved in full from the publisher's page in the copy archived on February 2, 2026 and searched. The article says "At the time of writing, SCOAP3 consists of more than 3000 libraries from 43 countries", it counts three intergovernmental organisations among the participants, and it says "A total of 8 journals are covered in this period". The article carries the libraries and the organizations. It gives 43 countries where the line gives 44, and it does not print the figure of 11 journals, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.95 Five footnotes stand inside line 370, line 371 and line 372, each after the name of a service, and each citation is graded on the naming of that service as a service of CERN or of its community. Footnote 186 follows the name of the CERN Open Data portal and cites J. Cowton and others, "Open Data and Data Analysis Preservation Services for LHC Experiments", Journal of Physics: Conference Series, December 23, 2015, whose abstract this page read on the publisher's page in the copy archived on February 3, 2026. The abstract says that a service of open data "was launched for the benefit of the general public". Footnote 187 follows the name of the CERN Document Server and cites Martin Vesely, Thomas Baron, Jean-Yves Le Meur and Tibor Simko, "CERN document server: Document management system for grey literature in a networked environment", Publishing Research Quarterly, 2004. This page read the part of the article that the publisher's page prints, in the copy archived on February 11, 2023, which says "We then presented the CERN Document Server Software suite that is a free software package". Footnote 188 follows the name HEPData and cites Eamonn Maguire, Lukas Heinrich and Graeme Watt, "HEPData: a repository for high energy physics data", Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2017, whose abstract this page read at arXiv in the copy archived on November 11, 2026. The abstract says that the database "has been built up over the past four decades as a unique open-access repository for scattering data from experimental particle physics papers". Footnote 189 follows the name CERN Analysis Preservation at line 371 and cites Pamfilos Fokianos and others, "CERN Analysis Preservation and Reuse Framework: FAIR research data services for LHC experiments", EPJ Web of Conferences, 2020, whose abstract page this page read in the copy archived on January 2, 2026. Footnote 190 follows the name REANA (Reusable Analyses) at line 372 and cites Tibor Šimko and others, "REANA: A System for Reusable Research Data Analyses", EPJ Web of Conferences, 2019, whose abstract page this page read in the copy archived on January 21, 2022. The titles of the last two papers carry the names of the two services, which is all that the words before the two footnotes say. The five citations are graded Supported. This page read the abstract or a part of each of the five papers and did not read the papers.

1.96 Footnote 191 cites "Open Science", a page of the European Commission, read in full in the copy archived on January 20, 2021 that the footnote names. The page sets out the policy of the Commission on open science, and it says "FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Re-usable data) and open data sharing should become the default for the results of EU-funded scientific research." Line 373 says that all the services of CERN are built using open source software and strive towards compliance with principles such as the FAIR principles, the FORCE11 guidelines and Plan S, while taking into account relevant activities carried out by the European Commission. The page carries activities of the Commission. It does not name CERN, the services of CERN, FORCE11 or Plan S, and it carries no statement of the line about those services, so the citation is graded Not supported. Footnote 192 cites "Microcosm to close permanently on 18 September", an announcement of CERN of August 30, 2022, read in full in the copy archived on March 9, 2023 that the footnote names. The announcement says that the exhibition Microcosm "will close permanently on 18 September, in preparation for the installation of the exhibitions in Science Gateway". Line 376 says that the museum closed permanently on 18 September 2022, in preparation for the installation of the exhibitions in the CERN Science Gateway. The announcement of August 30, 2022 carries the closing as a thing to come, on the date and for the reason that the line gives, and it cannot carry the closing as done, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.97 Footnote 193 cites "CERN inaugurates Science Gateway, its new outreach centre for science education", a press release of CERN dated 7 October 2023, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on March 19, 2024 that the footnote names and searched. The release says "Designed by world-renowned Renzo Piano Building Workshop, the new facility is open to visitors from around the world", and it says "CERN Science Gateway will be open to the public as of tomorrow, 8 October 2023." Line 377 says that the CERN Science Gateway, constructed by the Renzo Piano building workshop, was opened in October 2023. The release carries the opening in October 2023, and it says that the workshop designed the building and not that it constructed it, so the citation is graded Partial. The footnote dates the release 22 February 2024.

1.98 Footnote 194 stands inside line 379, after the words "Three permanent hands-on exhibitions", and cites "Exhibitions | visit.cern", read in full in the copy archived on November 25, 2025 that the footnote names. The page names three exhibitions, "Discover CERN Our Universe Quantum World", and it promises "hands-on experiments, real scientific objects, immersive environments and interactivity". The page carries the three exhibitions and their hands-on character, and the word permanent does not occur on it, so the citation is graded Partial. Two footnotes cite line 380, which says that the exhibition Discover CERN hosts a fully functioning 2 MeV proton accelerator named Experimental Linac for Surface Analysis (ELISA). Footnote 195 cites "Science Gateway's mini accelerator is now taking data", an article of CERN by Naomi Dinmore of November 22, 2024, read in full in the copy archived on January 6, 2026 that the footnote names. The article says that "the proton accelerator ELISA (Experimental Linac for Surface Analysis) is now being used for archaeological research at Science Gateway", and that "it works by accelerating a beam of protons to 2 MeV". Footnote 196 cites Eleonora Pasino and others, "ELISA: a compact linear accelerator for societal applications", a paper of the International Particle Accelerator Conference of 2024, with a copy of its record at the CERN Document Server archived on January 10, 2026, which this page read. This page read the file of the paper, of four pages, in full in the copy archived on February 22, 2026. The paper says that ELISA "is a linear proton accelerator installed in the Science Gateway exhibition at CERN since October 2023", and it speaks of a "structure for the acceleration of protons to 2MeV". The two citations are graded Supported. Footnote 195 gives its article the date 24 November 2024, and the article prints the date 22 November, 2024.

1.99 Three footnotes cite three more entries of the article's list of the spaces of the CERN Science Gateway. Footnote 197 cites "Exploring the Unknown – arts.cern", read in full in the copy archived on November 13, 2025 that the footnote names. The page gives the dates of the exhibition as 07.10.23 and 07.10.26 and its venue as "CERN Science Gateway, Geneva, Switzerland". The citation at line 382, which says that a part of the exhibition Our Universe hosts an art exhibition that is on display from October 2023 to October 2026, is graded Supported. Footnote 198 cites "CERN Science Gateway - Venue rental (private events)", a brochure of CERN of January 2025 in a file of 16 pages, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on January 9, 2026 that the footnote names and searched. The brochure describes the "SCIENCE GATEWAY AUDITORIUM" as a space "for up to 800 guests depending on the layout and selected activities", and its seventh page prints "Up to 800 seats". The citation at line 384, which names an auditorium with up to 800 seats, is graded Supported. Footnote 199 cites "Lab workshops | visit.cern", read in full in the copy archived on November 18, 2025 that the footnote names. The page says "Our lab workshops allow visitors of all ages and abilities to get hands on with science and technology." It also says "you can book a lab workshop for your group of school students". Line 385 names 2 Education Labs that host hands-on workshops for school groups and walk-in visitors. The page carries the workshops for both kinds of visitor and does not give the number of the labs, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.100 Two footnotes cite line 389, which says that CERN launched its Cultural Policy for engaging with the arts in 2011. Footnote 200 cites "CERN launches Cultural Policy", a press release of CERN dated 4 August 2011, read in full in the copy archived on April 6, 2023 that the footnote names. The release says that on that day CERN "launches its cultural policy for engaging with the arts". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 201 cites pages 168 to 188 of Camilla Røstvik, At the Edge of their Universe: Artists, Scientists and Outsiders at CERN, a doctoral thesis of The University of Manchester of 2016, with a copy of the record of the thesis archived on April 6, 2023, which this page read. This page read the cited pages in the text of the file of the thesis, of 282 pages, in the copy archived on July 9, 2023. Page 175 speaks of the "first cultural policy for engaging with the arts", and page 172 speaks of "the type of SciArt residency that started at CERN in 2011". The cited pages carry the policy and date the residencies to 2011, and they give no date for the launch of the policy, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.101 Footnote 202 cites the CERN Courier, volume 12, number 9, of 1972, under the title "Front cover: One of the visitors, James Lee Byars, who brought some colour into the CERN corridors during the summer", with a copy of the record of the issue at the CERN Document Server archived on April 6, 2023, which this page read. The file of the issue, in the copy archived on April 7, 2023, has 27,339,951 bytes, and this page retrieved its first 8,000,000 bytes, which hold the cover, the page of contents and 15 further pages. The page of contents prints the caption of the cover, which reads "Cover photograph : One of the visitors who brought some colour into the CERN corridors during the summer." The caption names no one. The name James Lee Byars stands in the title that the footnote gives to the photograph, and it does not occur in the record of the issue or in the pages that this page read. Line 394 says that in 1972 James Lee Byars was the first artist to visit the laboratory and the only one, so far, to feature on the cover of the CERN Courier. The issue carries a visitor of the summer of 1972 on its cover. It does not carry his name or call him the first artist to visit, and an issue of 1972 cannot carry that he is the only one so far, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.102 Five footnotes stand inside line 395, one after each of the names of five artists, and the line says that the five are among the artists who came to CERN in the years after 1972. Each citation is graded on whether its source carries that the artist whose name it follows came to CERN. Footnote 203 follows the name of Mariko Mori and cites "Art and sub-atomic particles to collide at CERN", a report of Reuters at TODAY.com of August 4, 2011, read in full in the copy archived on April 6, 2023 that the footnote names. The report quotes the artist and says "said Mori after a recent visit to the center on the borders of France and Switzerland". Footnote 204 follows the name of Gianni Motti and cites a page of Artsy for a work of the artist, read in full in the copy archived on April 6, 2023 that the footnote names. The page presents the work, a color photograph, whose title carries the words "looking for the anti-Motti" and is followed by the words "CERN, Genève, 2005", and it says nothing more of a visit. This page takes a work that the page places at CERN in 2005 as carrying that the artist came to CERN. Footnote 207 follows the name of Anselm Kiefer and cites "Anselm Kiefer Meets Science At Cern's Monumental Hadron Collider", Artlyst, January 5, 2015, read in full in the copy archived on April 6, 2023 that the footnote names. The article says that "the artist has recently visited Cern, Europe’s particle physics centre near Geneva". The three citations are graded Supported. Footnote 205 follows the name of Cerith Wyn Evans and cites the artist's book Cerith Wyn Evans: the what if? ... scenario (after LG) (Sternberg Press, 2013), with no page, and its only link leads to the record of the book in a library catalog. Google Books holds a record of the book that shows no page of it, and its search of the book returns no result for the commonest words, so the text of the book is not searchable there. This page could read nothing of the book, and the citation is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 206 follows the name of John Berger and cites Jerry White, "John Berger of the Haute-Savoie", Film Quarterly, 2017, and gives a DOI and a link to a library of journals. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and the publisher's page, in the copy archived on February 22, 2026, shows the title and a note on the author and no abstract. The part of the page that this page could read does not name CERN, and the citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.103 Two footnotes cite line 401, which says that the programmes of Arts at CERN comprise Collide, a residency programme organised with a city, Connect, a programme of residencies in collaboration with Pro Helvetia, and Guest Artists, a short stay for artists. Footnote 208 cites Ariane Koek, "In/visible: the inside story of the making of Arts at CERN", Interdisciplinary Science Reviews, October 2, 2017, and gives a DOI and a Bibcode and no other link. The article stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on April 7, 2023. The abstract calls the article "a personal account of the setting up and first five years of CERN's first institutionalized arts programme". Footnote 209 cites Mónica Bello, "Field Experiences: Fundamental Science and Research in the Arts", a chapter of On Art and Science (Springer, 2019), pages 203 to 221, and gives a DOI and no other link. The chapter stands behind the publisher's paywall, and this page read its abstract on the publisher's page in the copy archived on April 6, 2023. The abstract begins "Over recent years various scientific institutions have nurtured novel models of dialog and cooperation between scientists and artists". Neither abstract names Collide, Connect, Guest Artists or Pro Helvetia, neither work could be read, and the two citations are graded Uncheckable.

1.104 Two footnotes cite line 405, which says of the band of line 404 that its name was chosen so as to have the same initials as the LHC. Footnote 210 cites Malcolm W. Brown, "Physicists Discover Another Unifying Force: Doo-Wop", The New York Times, December 29, 1998, and footnote 211 cites Heather McCabe, "Grrl Geeks Rock Out", Wired News, February 10, 1999. Each footnote links a file that holds a copy of the article on a site of CERN and names a copy of that file at another archive. This page does not open the sites of The New York Times and of Wired under the rules of its tools, it treated the two files as copies of the articles of those publishers, and it did not open them. The two citations are graded Uncheckable.

1.105 Two footnotes cite line 406, which says that the science journalist Katherine McAlpine made a rap video called "Large Hadron Rap" about the Large Hadron Collider with some of the staff of the facility. Footnote 212 cites the page of the video at YouTube, dated July 28, 2008, whose text this page read in full in the copy archived on November 14, 2010 that the footnote names; this page did not play the video. The text of the page names the account that posted the video as alpinekat, describes the video with the words "Rappin' about CERN's Large Hadron Collider!" and says "The rapper has a day job (we agree this is a good thing) as a science writer." The text does not say who appears in the video, the video itself was not played, and the citation is graded Uncheckable. Footnote 213 cites a page that it titles "National Geographic", and its link leads to the home page of the site of that magazine, which this page read in full in the copy archived on March 26, 2012 that the footnote names. The home page does not mention the rap, the Large Hadron Collider, CERN or the name McAlpine, so the citation is graded Not supported.

1.106 Footnote 214 cites "John Titor", a page of the Time Travel Institute, whose text this page retrieved in full from the copy archived on December 17, 2023 that the footnote names and searched. The page speaks of posts "from an individual claiming to be a time traveler from the year 2036", and it says "The pseudonym John Titor wasn’t adopted until January 2001". Line 408 says that John Titor, a self-proclaimed time traveler, alleged that CERN would invent time travel in 2001. The page carries the man who called himself a time traveler, and it does not name CERN, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 215 cites a page of the official site of the television anime STEINS;GATE, in Japanese, read in full in the copy archived on February 23, 2026 that the footnote names. The page summarizes the fifteenth episode of the series, and it prints the words "SERNがタイムマシンの力で世界を支配していること", which this page translates as the statement that SERN rules the world by the power of the time machine. Line 409 says that CERN is depicted in the visual novel and anime series as SERN, a shadowy organization that has been researching time travel in order to restructure and control the world. The page carries the organization SERN and its rule of the world through a time machine. It does not say that SERN depicts CERN, and it says nothing of the visual novel, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.107 Two footnotes cite line 411, which says that a number of conspiracy theories feature CERN and accuse it of partaking in occult rituals and in secret experiments that involve opening portals into Hell or other dimensions, shifting the world into an alternative timeline and causing earthquakes. Footnote 216 cites "Fake human sacrifice filmed at Cern, with pranking scientists suspected", The Guardian, August 17, 2016, without an archived copy, and this page read the article in full in the copy archived on October 17, 2026. The article says that CERN opened an investigation into "a video filmed at night on its Geneva campus depicting a mock ritual human sacrifice". The article reports the staging of an occult rite as a prank, and it does not speak of conspiracy theories, of portals, of timelines or of earthquakes, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 217 cites Diana Brown, "Why Conspiracy Theorists Are Obsessed With CERN", HowStuffWorks, February 13, 2018, read in full in the copy archived on February 19, 2023 that the footnote names. The article says "Other theories accuse CERN of causing earthquakes by sending plasma from Switzerland to Italy at high speeds, opening portals into hell or other dimensions, and shifting the world into an alternate timeline." The article carries the theories of earthquakes, portals and timelines, and it does not speak of occult rituals, so the citation is graded Partial.

1.108 Footnote 218 cites "Angels and Demons – the science behind the story", a site of CERN, read in full in the copy archived on July 24, 2017 that the footnote names. The page speaks of the film of Ron Howard, and it says "When Langdon finds evidence that the Illuminati have stolen antimatter from a secret laboratory at CERN". Line 412 says that in the mystery-thriller novel of Dan Brown of 2000 and in the film of the same name of 2009 a canister of antimatter is stolen from CERN. The page carries the theft in the film, and it does not name Dan Brown, the novel or the year 2000, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 219 cites a page that it titles "Southparkstudios.com", the page of South Park Studios for the episode Pinewood Derby, the sixth of the thirteenth season, dated 04/15/2009, whose text this page read in full in the copy archived on October 28, 2020 that the footnote names; this page did not play the episode. The text of the page says "Randy has a plan that will assure Stan a first place trophy in this year's Pinewood Derby." Line 414 says that Randy Marsh breaks into a collider in Switzerland and steals a magnet for the racer of his son, and it prints two phrases in quotation marks. The text of the page carries neither the theft nor the two phrases, which can only stand in the episode itself, and the citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.109 Footnote 220 cites Rebecca Boyle, "Large Hadron Collider Unleashes Rampaging Zombies", an article of Popular Science posted on 10.31.2012, read in full in the copy archived on November 21, 2012 that the footnote names. The article calls the film a trailer "filmed on-site at the LHC by physics students". Line 416 says that the student film Decay of 2012, which centres on the idea of the Large Hadron Collider transforming people into zombies, was filmed on location in the maintenance tunnels of CERN. The article carries the film, its makers and its filming at the collider, and it does not speak of maintenance tunnels, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 221 stands inside line 418, after the words that say that CERN forms part of the back story of the augmented reality game Ingress, and cites Michael Andersen, "Google's Ingress Takes Mobile Gaming to the Streets", Wired. This page does not open the site of Wired or archived copies of it under the rules of its tools, and the citation is graded Uncheckable.

1.110 Three footnotes cite line 419, line 421 and line 422. Footnote 222 cites "Musician Howie Day records love song to physics | CERN", an article of CERN of June 23, 2017, read in full in the copy archived on November 27, 2018 that the footnote names. The article says "Sarah Charley, US communications manager for the LHC experiments, had come up with the idea for the original parody video." It names the three graduate students of the line and their universities as her helpers. Line 419 dates the parody video to 2015. The article carries the makers of the video and gives the video no date, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 223 cites "Howie Day records love song to physics", an article of the magazine Symmetry by Ali Sundermier dated 06/23/17, read in full in the copy archived on November 27, 2018 that the footnote names. The article says that the musician planned a visit to CERN and spoke of "booking time in his studio to re-record the song". Line 421 says that Day re-recorded the song with the new lyrics and released a new version in February 2017 with a video created during his visit to CERN. The article carries the new recording and the video, and it does not give February 2017 as the date of a release, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 224 cites "The art lightshow inspired by Cern", the page of a clip of the BBC programme Click, whose text this page read in full in the copy archived on April 28, 2022 that the footnote names; this page did not play the clip. The text of the page says "Ryoji Ikeda spent time as a resident artist at Cern", names the work as "Ryoji Ikeda's Supersymmetry" and gives the date of the release of the clip as 19 May 2015. The text of the page carries the sentence of line 422, which says that in 2015 Ryoji Ikeda created an art installation called Supersymmetry based on his experience as a resident artist at CERN, and the citation is graded Supported.

1.111 Three footnotes cite line 426, which says of the television series of line 425 that various accelerators and facilities of CERN are referenced during the show, including ATLAS, CMS, the Antiproton Decelerator and the FCC, the Future Circular Collider. Footnote 225 cites "Parallels", CERN Courier, September 6, 2022, read in full in the copy archived on August 28, 2023 that the footnote names. The review speaks of "mentions of ATLAS, CMS and the Antiproton Decelerator" and of a reference to an "FCC scheduled for operations in October 2025". The citation is graded Supported. Footnote 226 cites "French Fantasy Sci-Fi Series 'Parallels' Official Trailer from Disney | FirstShowing.net", March 14, 2022, read in full in the copy archived on August 28, 2023 that the footnote names. The article says "This is actually set around the Large Hadron Collider at CERN, located right on the French-Swiss border." Footnote 227 cites the page of the series at IMDb, read in full in the copy archived on June 18, 2023 that the footnote names. The page speaks of four friends "whose lives are turned upside down by an experiment of the LHC, the world's biggest particle collider". The two pages carry the collider and do not name ATLAS, CMS, the Antiproton Decelerator or the FCC, so the two citations are graded Partial.

1.112 Footnote 228 cites "Faces and Places (page 3)", CERN Courier, July 28, 2004, read in full in the copy archived on June 6, 2018 that the footnote names. The item says "The statue is a gift from CERN's Indian collaborators to celebrate CERN's long association with India". Line 428 says that the statue, symbolizing Shiva's cosmic dance of creation and destruction, was presented by the Indian government to celebrate the research center's long association with India. The item carries the gift and its occasion. It names the collaborators of CERN in India, and not the Indian government, as the giver, and it does not speak of the cosmic dance, so the citation is graded Partial. Footnote 229 cites "Shiva's Cosmic Dance at CERN | Fritjof Capra", a page of the site of Fritjof Capra, read in full in the copy archived on September 24, 2022 that the footnote names. The page prints the text of the plaque that stands beside the statue, which ends "The metaphor of the cosmic dance thus unifies ancient mythology, religious art and modern physics." The citation at line 431, which prints that sentence, is graded Supported. The same page says "The statue, symbolizing Shiva’s cosmic dance of creation and destruction, was given to CERN by the Indian government to celebrate the research center’s long association with India." Line 428 prints those words with the word presented in the place of the words given to CERN, and it cites footnote 228 and not footnote 229.

2.0 The sources that the article cites count nine ratifications of the convention by the day for which the article counts twelve, 23 member states on the page that is cited for 25, and a cash outflow where the article prints a budget, and 23 of the 249 citations rest on sources that are older than the facts for which they are cited.

2.1 Line 25 says that the convention establishing CERN was ratified on 29 September 1954 by 12 countries in Western Europe, and the table of member states gives that day to each of the twelve founding members, at line 198 through line 209. The History of CERN by Armin Hermann, Lanfranco Belloni and John Krige (North-Holland, 1987), which footnote 15 cites at the end of line 25, carries on its page 232 a table of the dates on which the instruments of ratification of the convention were deposited, which this page read in the snippets of text that the search of Google Books returns, as unit 1.12 records. The table dates nine of the twelve deposits from 30 December 1953 to 29 September 1954, the day that it gives to France and to the Federal Republic of Germany, and it gives 4 October 1954 to Norway, 9 February 1955 to Yugoslavia and 24 February 1955 to Italy. The book of James Gillies of 2018, which footnote 1 cites at line 5 for the day of the formation, counts the same nine ratifications by that day. Of the year 1953 it says "By the end of the year, only Britain had ratified", it names Switzerland, Denmark, the Netherlands, Greece, Sweden and Belgium as the states that followed between February and July 1954, and it says that when France and Germany followed on 29 September 1954 "all the conditions for bringing the new organisation into existence had been fulfilled". It then says "The process concluded with Norway ratifying in October 1954, and Yugoslavia and Italy following in February 1955." The text of the convention, which footnote 14 cites at line 25, says that the convention "shall enter into force when seven States have ratified, or acceded to, these instruments", on two conditions, that the total of their contributions "amounts to not less than seventy-five per cent" on the scale that is annexed to the Financial Protocol, and that Switzerland is among the seven, and the page that prints the text says that the convention "entered into force on 29 September, 1954". The page of CERN that footnote 21 cites at line 32 says that the convention was gradually ratified by the twelve founding states and that on 29 September 1954, "following ratification by France and Germany, the European Organization for Nuclear Research officially came into being". By these four sources, September 29, 1954 is the day on which the convention entered into force, upon the eighth and the ninth of the twelve ratifications, and Norway, Yugoslavia and Italy ratified after that day. Unit 1.1 and unit 1.12 grade the citations.

2.2 Three lines of the article print words that stand on a page other than the page that they cite. Line 34 prints, from the words "was gradually ratified" to the words "and Yugoslavia", the sentence of the page of CERN that footnote 21 cites at line 32, and it cites footnote 22, the minutes of a session of June 1953, which do not carry the ratification, as unit 1.16 records. Line 428 prints, with one change of words, the sentence of the page of Fritjof Capra that footnote 229 cites at line 431, and it cites footnote 228, an item of the CERN Courier that names another giver of the statue, as unit 1.112 records. Line 344 prints the substance of a sentence that stands on the page that footnotes 149 and 155 cite, and it cites footnote 148, a copy of October 2017 that cannot carry a resolution of March 2022, as unit 1.80 records.

2.3 The article counts the member states in two ways, and three of its counts differ from the sources that are cited for them. Line 7, an entry of the infobox, counts "Full members (25)", and line 15 says that CERN comprises 25 member states, while line 194 begins with the words "Of the 24 members". Line 15 cites page 50 of the annual report of CERN for 2019, which lists 23 member states as of December 31, 2019, as unit 1.5 records. The press release of September 30, 2024 at footnote 2 speaks of a council "composed of delegates of all its twenty-four Member States", the press release at footnote 121 dates the membership of Estonia, the 24th member state, to August 30, 2024, and the press release at footnote 122 dates the membership of Slovenia, the 25th, to June 21, 2025, as unit 1.71 records. Line 115 begins with the words "Eight experiments", and the article of the CERN Courier at footnote 74, which the line cites, calls one of the eight the seventh experiment of the collider, as unit 1.48 records. Line 261 says "Three countries have observer status", and the page at footnote 145 names four countries as holders of that status, as unit 1.78 records.

2.4 Three figures or pairs of figures of the article differ from the sources that are cited for them, and a fourth figure stands on a page of its source other than the page that is cited. Line 11 gives the budget of 2026 as 1515 million Swiss francs, and the budget document at footnote 4 prints that figure as the cash outflow of 2026 and gives the expenses of the final budget as 1 526.3 million and the revenues as 1 444.5 million, as unit 1.4 records. Line 66 says that CERN employs "ten times more engineers and technicians than research physicists", in the words of the page at footnote 52, and the annual report of CERN for 2024, which the article cites at footnote 9, counts 88 research physicists, 1278 engineers and applied scientists and 818 technicians, as unit 1.35 records, which by the arithmetic of this page is 23.8 engineers, applied scientists and technicians for each research physicist. Line 369 gives the partnership SCOAP3 44 countries and 11 journals in 2018, and the article of April 2018 at footnote 185 gives 43 countries and 8 journals, as unit 1.94 records. Line 18 gives users from more than 80 countries and cites page 53 of the annual report for 2024, and the countries stand on page 12 of that report, as unit 1.8 records.

2.5 The dates that the article gives to four machines, and one count of atoms, differ from the sources that are cited for them or for the lines beside them. Line 147, which carries no footnote, says that the Synchro-Cyclotron "was shut down in 1991", and the article of CERN at footnote 96, cited at line 148, says that the hall has been used for storage "since the accelerator was shut down in 1990". Line 149 says that the Intersecting Storage Rings were built from 1966 to 1971 and operated until 1984, and the chapter of Stephen Myers at footnote 98 gives 1966 to 1970 for the construction, 1971 to 1983 for the operation for physics and 1984 for the decommissioning, while the abstract of Kurt Hübner at footnote 97 gives 1983 for the decommissioning as a collider, as unit 1.59 records. Line 150 says that the Super Proton-Antiproton Synchrotron operated from 1981 to 1991, and the chapter of Rudiger Schmidt at footnote 99 and the title of the paper of V. Hatton at footnote 60 give 1981 to 1990, as unit 1.60 records. Line 166 says that the CLIC Test Facility 3 was in operation from 2001 to 2016, and the paper of Roberto Corsini at footnote 104 dates the commissioning of the facility in stages from 2003 and the beginning of the commissioning with beam to June 2003, as unit 1.63 records. Line 157 counts nine atoms of antihydrogen in 1995. The report at footnote 105 gives no count, and the book of Frank Close that the article cites at footnote 25 speaks of "the production of nine anti-atoms". The paper of the experiment itself, which footnote 26 cites at line 40 and which this page read in the text that was submitted for publication on December 22, 1995, says "The production of 11 antihydrogen atoms is reported", counts among the eleven a possible background of two signals with an uncertainty of one, and concludes that eleven atoms were observed. The number nine stands in the paper as the number of atoms that the experiment was expected to observe, in the words "which would result in the observation of nine", and the paper calls that number an upper limit.

2.6 Three lines of the article state plans or periods that differ from the sources cited for them. Line 137 says that the High Luminosity Large Hadron Collider is scheduled to be operational "by the mid-2030s", and the page of CERN at footnote 90 says that it "should be operational in mid-2030". Line 139 says that the upgrade should be complete "by 2026", and the first chapter of the design report at footnote 91 sets the installation of the main hardware in the third long shutdown, in the years 2025 to 2027, as unit 1.55 records, while line 136 of the article itself dates the beginning of that shutdown after the final run of June 14, 2026, and the page at footnote 90 places the installation "during a four-year shutdown of the accelerators starting in mid-2026". Line 135 calls the second long shutdown a period of two years that began at the end of 2018, and the article of CERN at footnote 86, of December 2020, says "Run 3 of the LHC will start in early 2022."

2.7 Twenty-three of the 249 citations rest on sources that are older than the facts for which they are cited, or that speak of those facts as things to come, and they are graded under the rule of unit 0.4. Two entries of the infobox, at line 9 and line 10, cite announcements of 2024 for the holders of two offices in 2026. Line 15 cites a report on 2019 for a count of member states that was reached in 2025. Line 16 and line 194 cite articles of 2013 for the statement that Israel is the only full member outside Europe. Line 89 and line 159 cite an article of 2004, whose text is of September 2003, for a commissioning of 2005 and for a conversion that the article presents as a thing to be done. Line 99 cites a paper of 1991 and a book of 1986 for a use that began in 2008. Line 103 cites a page printed in 1997 for a machine that was then a proposal, and line 115 cites a proposal for an experiment as installed. Line 129 cites an article of July 13, 2012 for a later confirmation, and line 133 cites an update of April 5, 2015 for a ramp of April 10, 2015. Line 141, line 148 and line 376 cite texts that speak of a replacement, of an exhibition and of a closing in the future tense, and line 148 also cites a paper of 1993 for an exhibition of 2012 and 2013. Line 238 cites a page of 2021 for a total of 2026. Line 243 cites a release of June 20, 2014 for a signing of December 19, 2014, and line 252 cites a release of June 16, 2017 for a signing of June 27, 2017. Line 344 cites a copy of October 2017 for a resolution of March 2022, line 369 cites a paper of 2016 for figures of 2018, and line 394 cites an issue of 1972 for the statement that an artist is the only one so far to appear on the cover of a magazine.

2.8 Ten sources say something other than the sentence that cites them. The page of the scientific committees at footnote 53, cited at line 84 for the approval of experiments by the committees, gives the final decisions to the Research Board. The press release at footnote 30, cited at line 43 for the discovery of quark-gluon plasma, reports evidence of a new state of matter with many of the characteristics of the predicted plasma. The paper of the NA48 collaboration at footnote 29, cited at line 42 for a discovery of 1999, calls its result a new measurement and dates the first evidence to 1988. The press release at footnote 193, cited at line 377 for a building constructed by the Renzo Piano building workshop, says that the workshop designed the building. The item of the CERN Courier at footnote 228, cited at line 428 for a gift of the Indian government, names the Indian collaborators of CERN as the givers. The article of CERN at footnote 147, cited at line 277 for a suspension of Belarus as of March 2022, defers the decision on the cooperation agreements to a session of June 2022. The document of the European Space Agency at footnote 113, cited in note 2 for the convention of CERN, is the convention of that agency and does not name CERN. The page at footnote 213, cited at line 406 for a rap video, is the home page of National Geographic and does not mention the video. The two books at footnotes 44 and 45, cited at line 58 for the involvement of Robert Cailliau, do not name him on the pages that this page read or in the searches that it ran. The units that grade these citations quote each source.

2.9 Five lines of the article give, as the date on which an association agreement was ratified, the date that the cited source gives for the beginning of the associate membership. Line 246 does so for Ukraine, line 248 for India, line 250 for Slovenia, line 252 for Lithuania and line 254 for Croatia. Each of the five sources says that the state became an associate member on the day that the line names, after a ratification or after the completion of its internal procedures of approval, and none of them dates a ratification, as unit 1.75 and unit 1.76 record. Line 253, which carries no footnote, says that Croatia was "approved for admission" on 28 February 2019, and the page at footnote 129 gives that day as the day on which Croatia signed the agreement. Line 244 dates the signing of the agreement of Cyprus to 5 October 2012 and cites a page on which the year 2012 does not occur.

2.10 Disagreement 68 answers the lines of the article on the network of CERN and on the World Wide Web application design, line 23 and line 53 through line 65, and the sources that the article cites at those lines bear on its sections as follows. Line 24, which calls CERN the birthplace of the World Wide Web, cites the book of Stephanie Sammartino McPherson of 2009, of which this page read four pages in the preview of Google Books and whose page 80 says of CERN "The institute had given him the time, space, and freedom to create the World Wide Web", and the book of James Gillies and Robert Cailliau of 2000, whose back cover says that the Web was born at CERN, as unit 1.11 records. Line 54 cites the history that Ben Segal wrote in April 1995, which says that the presence of the optional protocols TCP/IP at CERN encouraged their adoption in other parts of Europe, as unit 1.28 records, where section 1.0 of Disagreement 68, which read the shorter article by Segal that CERN published in 2014, makes no finding on the line. Line 55, which carries no footnote, gives 1989 as the year of what it calls the invention of the World Wide Web, and section 2.0 of Disagreement 68 records a finding on that date. The two books of Gerard O'Regan that the article cites at line 58 give 1990 and 1989 for it, and the page of CERN at footnote 46 dates the first proposal of Tim Berners-Lee to 1989 and its refinement by him and Robert Cailliau to 1990, as unit 1.30 records. Line 60 cites a copy of the page of the World Wide Web Consortium that is titled "The World Wide Web project", whose address carries the number 19921103 and which links to the news of the project for November, as unit 1.32 records, and line 61, which dates the first website to 1991, carries no footnote. Line 62, which says that on 30 April 1993 CERN announced that the World Wide Web would be free to anyone, cites a page that dates the announcement to April 1993 without a day and that speaks of the underlying code, as unit 1.33 records. Line 63, which says that the Web became the dominant way through which most users interact with the Internet, cites a paper that does not carry that statement and an article whose title calls the Web the dominant application of the Internet, as unit 1.34 records. Line 52, line 53, line 57, line 64 and line 65 carry no footnote.

2.11 The article gives an account of the early years of the provisional council at line 27 and accounts of its name and of its initials at line 28 and line 29, and the sources cited for the three lines carry the following. The report of John Krige of 1985, at footnote 16, which this page read in snippets at Google Books, says on its page 5 that the acronym CERN "was obviously preferable to 'OERN'", in a passage on the name that the provisional council took at its second session, and the passage does not speak of Copenhagen, of Niels Bohr or of Geneva, for which line 27 cites the page. The snippets of pages 3, 11 and 12 of the report say that the group leaders would remain at their home stations, which page 3 lists as Rome, Amsterdam, Copenhagen, Bergen and Paris, and that Niels Bohr was the nominal director, until September 1954, of the Theory group, which the report counts among four study groups. The memorandum of S. A. ff. Dakin of November 2, 1954, at footnote 17, shows the conflict of the initials with the new name as a question that was still open on that day, and it says nothing of Copenhagen or of Niels Bohr, for which line 27 cites it. The transcript of the interview of Lew Kowarski, at footnote 19, carries his remark on the initials OERN and the proposal of Werner Heisenberg to keep the initials CERN, and it does not contain the words that line 29 prints in quotation marks as the words of Heisenberg. The page of the book of Gordon Fraser, at footnote 18, does not name Kowarski. Unit 1.13 and unit 1.14 quote the four sources. The page of CERN that footnote 21 cites at line 32 says "The provisional CERN was dissolved but the acronym remained." That sentence carries line 28, which cites footnotes 16 and 17 and not footnote 21.

2.12 The footnotes of the article carry these slips. Footnotes 50 and 51 print the first authors of two works as "Ari-Pekka, Hameri" and "Andrew, Oram". Footnote 61 prints the authors of a book as "Watkins, Peter; Watkins". Footnote 111 prints the author of an article of Haaretz as "Rahman, Fazlur.", where the article names Ariel David. Footnote 184 prints the name of an editor as "Smidt, B.", where the publisher prints Birgit Schmidt. Footnote 106 prints the title of a paper as "The CERN antiproton collider programme: accelerators and accumulation", where the publisher's page prints "The CERN antiproton collider programme: accelerators and accumulation rings". Footnotes 22 and 96 date minutes of 1953 and an article of December 14, 2012 "28 September 2023". Footnotes 88 and 89 date two articles "30 June 2026", where the articles print 15 June, 2026 and 29 June, 2026. Footnote 177 dates a policy 2021, where the policy prints the dates of 2014 and 2017 that unit 1.91 records. Footnote 193 dates a press release "22 February 2024", where the release prints 7 October, 2023, and footnote 195 dates an article "24 November 2024", where the article prints 22 November, 2024. Footnotes 179 through 182 date four policies 2014, where the records date two of them to 2012 and 2013, as unit 1.92 records. Footnote 136 names an archived copy that shows a different press release, as unit 1.74 records. Footnote 202 prints a name in the title of a photograph whose caption in the magazine names no one, as unit 1.101 records. Footnotes 23 and 45 carry Wikipedia's own tag that asks for a page number. Line 366 prints in quotation marks a sentence of the document at footnote 183 with the words open science in lowercase letters, where the document prints them with capital letters.

3.0 Of the 431 lines of Exhibit A, 256 carry no footnote, and the budget document and other sources that the article cites bear on some of them.

3.1 Of the 431 lines of Exhibit A, 175 lines carry footnotes: lines 5, 9 through 11, 15 through 19, 21, 24, 25, 27 through 29, 31, 32, 34, 37 through 49, 54, 56, 58 through 60, 62, 63, 66, 84, 87, 89, 93 through 95, 99, 102 through 104, 106, 107, 109, 115, 121, 122, 129, 130, 133 through 137, 139, 141, 143, 146, 148 through 150, 152, 153, 155, 157, 159, 162 through 164, 166, 168, 194, 195, 197, 209, 210, 212, 220 through 224, 226, 228 through 238, 242 through 244, 246 through 250, 252, 254 through 258, 261, 263, 268, 269, 277, 279, 289, 292, 313, 335 through 337, 339 through 346, 355 through 357, 361 through 363, 365, 366, 369 through 373, 376, 377, 379, 380, 382, 384, 385, 389, 394, 395, 401, 405, 406, 408, 409, 411, 412, 414, 416, 418, 419, 421, 422, 426, 428 and 431. The other 256 lines carry none. None of the lines carries Wikipedia's tag that asks for a citation. The notice at line 169, which stands over the section of the article on the sites of CERN, reads "This section does not cite any sources." and is dated December 2023, and the 20 lines of that section, line 170 through line 189, carry no footnote. Among the other lines without a footnote are the opening description of CERN at line 13 and line 14, the statement on its network at line 23, the lines on the World Wide Web application design that unit 2.10 names, the lines on the Nobel Prizes of 1992 and 2013 at line 50 and line 51, and the amounts and fractions of the table of member states.

3.2 The rows of the table of member states at line 198 through line 237 give, for each state, a contribution for 2026 in millions of Swiss francs and a fraction of the contributions of the member states, and the amounts and the fractions carry no footnote. This page compared the 35 rows that carry an amount for a state named in the budget document with the second part of Figure 4 of that document, which footnotes 4 and 112 cite, and which gives the contribution of each member state in Swiss francs and in percent and the contribution of each associate member state in Swiss francs. The 35 amounts agree with the document to the two decimals that the table prints. This page compared the fractions of the 25 member states with the percentages that the document prints, and the fractions of the ten associate member states with the quotient of the contribution of each by the total of the contributions of the member states, 1 232 149 900 Swiss francs, which is the arithmetic of this page, and 32 of the 35 fractions agree to the two decimals that the table prints. The row of Belgium at line 198 prints 2.12%, where the document gives 2.81659% for Belgium, and 2.12% is the fraction that the row of Austria at line 211 prints, for which the document gives 2.11842%. The row of Turkey at line 228 prints 0.89%, where the contribution of 5 441 400 Swiss francs that the document gives for Türkiye is 0.44 percent of that total by the arithmetic of this page, and 0.89% is the fraction that the row of Brazil at line 235 prints. The row of Greece at line 202 prints 1.00%, where the document gives 1.00703%, which is 1.01% at two decimals. The total of the last row, at line 238, agrees with the grand total of the document, as unit 1.68 records.

3.3 Sources that the article cites at other lines bear on seven lines that carry no footnote. Line 26 says that the provisional council was "established by 12 European governments in 1952", and the page of CERN that footnote 21 cites says that "11 countries signed an agreement establishing the provisional Council", while a snippet of page 2 of the report of John Krige that footnote 16 cites says "On the 15 February 1952 delegates from eleven countries signed an" agreement constituting a council of representatives of European states. Line 33 says that at the sixth session of the council, in Paris from 29 June to 1 July 1953, the convention was signed, subject to ratification, "by 12 states". The minutes of that session, which footnote 22 cites at line 34, record that the representatives of nine states signed the convention on July 1, 1953, that the representatives of Denmark, Norway and Switzerland hoped to sign soon, and that Switzerland signed on July 17, 1953, as unit 1.16 records, and the text of the convention at footnote 14 says that it was "open for signature at Paris from 1 July to 31 December 1953". A snippet of page 334 of the History of CERN that footnote 15 cites speaks of a text "signed by nine of the twelve delegations on 1 July" in Paris and says "It now had to be ratified". Line 219 gives "11 June 1999" for the membership of Bulgaria, and the table of dates of accession that note 4 cites gives 11 March 1999, as unit 1.69 records. Line 147 dates the shutdown of the Synchro-Cyclotron to 1991, and the source of line 148 dates it to 1990, as unit 2.5 records. Line 160 says that the operations of the Antiproton Accumulator ended in 1997 and that the machine was dismantled, and the paper of H. Koziol and D. Möhl that footnote 106 cites at line 162 says that the Low-Energy Antiproton Ring "continued to take beam from the AC/AA until end 1996" and says "In 1997, the AA was dismantled and the AC converted into the Antiproton Decelerator (AD)", as unit 1.65 records. Line 253 says that Croatia was approved for admission on a day that the source of line 254 gives as the day of a signing, as unit 2.9 records. Line 53 dates the introduction of the optional protocols TCP/IP at CERN from 1984, and the history of Ben Segal that footnote 41 cites at line 54 says "In August, 1984 I wrote a proposal" for a pilot project to install and evaluate the protocols on machines at CERN, and it says that "CERN opened its first external connections to the Internet" after a change of all of its addresses to official ones in January 1989, which are the dates that section 1.0 of Disagreement 68 takes from Segal's article of 2014.

4.0 Of the 249 citations, 134 carry the sentence that cites them, 74 carry it in part, 19 do not carry it and 22 cannot be checked.

4.1 The 134 citations graded Supported are footnote 1 at line 5, footnote 8 at line 17, footnote 10 at line 19, footnote 11 at line 21, footnote 12 at line 24, footnote 13 at line 24, footnote 14 at line 25, footnote 21 at line 32, footnote 23 at line 37, footnote 24 at line 39, footnote 25 at line 40, footnote 26 at line 40, footnote 27 at line 41, footnote 31 at line 44, footnote 32 at line 44, footnote 33 at line 45, footnote 34 at line 45, footnote 36 at line 46, footnote 37 at line 46, footnote 38 at line 47, footnote 39 at line 48, footnote 41 at line 54, footnote 42 at line 56, footnote 43 at line 56, footnote 46 at line 58, footnote 47 at line 59, footnote 51 at line 63, footnote 52 at line 66, footnote 54 at line 87, footnote 57 at line 93, footnote 65 at line 104, footnote 66 at line 106, footnote 67 at line 106, footnote 68 at line 107, footnote 69 at line 107, footnote 71 at line 115, footnote 72 at line 115, footnote 73 at line 115, footnote 74 at line 115, footnote 75 at line 115, footnote 76 at line 115, footnote 78 at line 115, footnote 80 at line 122, footnote 82 at line 130, footnote 83 at line 133, footnote 88 at line 136, footnote 89 at line 136, footnote 93 at line 143, footnote 94 at line 146, footnote 100 at line 152, footnote 102 at line 153, footnote 106 at line 162, footnote 107 at line 163, footnote 108 at line 163, footnote 106 at line 164, footnote 110 at line 194, footnote 112 at line 195, footnote 115 at line 209, footnote 116 at line 209, footnote 116 at line 212, footnote 110 at line 220, footnote 119 at line 221, footnote 120 at line 222, footnote 121 at line 223, footnote 122 at line 224, footnote 123 at line 226, footnote 124 at line 228, footnote 125 at line 229, footnote 126 at line 230, footnote 127 at line 231, footnote 128 at line 232, footnote 129 at line 233, footnote 130 at line 234, footnote 131 at line 235, footnote 132 at line 236, footnote 133 at line 237, footnote 112 at line 238, footnote 135 at line 242, footnote 137 at line 243, footnote 138 at line 243, footnote 139 at line 247, footnote 140 at line 249, footnote 143 at line 255, footnote 130 at line 256, footnote 131 at line 257, footnote 144 at line 258, footnote 146 at line 263, footnote 147 at line 268, footnote 150 at line 279, footnote 151 at line 289, footnote 152 at line 289, footnote 153 at line 292, footnote 154 at line 292, footnote 148 at line 313, footnote 156 at line 335, footnote 157 at line 336, footnote 159 at line 339, footnote 160 at line 340, footnote 161 at line 341, footnote 162 at line 342, footnote 163 at line 343, footnote 164 at line 343, footnote 165 at line 345, footnote 166 at line 346, footnote 167 at line 355, footnote 168 at line 355, footnote 169 at line 356, footnote 171 at line 357, footnote 173 at line 361, footnote 176 at line 361, footnote 14 at line 362, footnote 177 at line 363, footnote 178 at line 363, footnote 179 at line 365, footnote 180 at line 365, footnote 181 at line 365, footnote 182 at line 365, footnote 183 at line 366, footnote 186 at line 370, footnote 187 at line 370, footnote 188 at line 370, footnote 189 at line 371, footnote 190 at line 372, footnote 195 at line 380, footnote 196 at line 380, footnote 197 at line 382, footnote 198 at line 384, footnote 200 at line 389, footnote 203 at line 395, footnote 204 at line 395, footnote 207 at line 395, footnote 224 at line 422, footnote 225 at line 426 and footnote 229 at line 431.

4.2 The 19 citations graded Not supported are footnote 5 at line 15, footnote 17 at line 27, footnote 44 at line 58, footnote 45 at line 58, footnote 50 at line 63, footnote 60 at line 99, footnote 61 at line 99, footnote 87 at line 135, footnote 95 at line 148, footnote 104 at line 155, footnote 113 at line 197, footnote 117 at line 210, footnote 134 at line 238, footnote 136 at line 243, footnote 142 at line 252, footnote 148 at line 344, footnote 170 at line 356, footnote 191 at line 373 and footnote 213 at line 406.

4.3 The 22 citations graded Uncheckable are footnote 16 at line 27, footnote 16 at line 28, footnote 23 at line 38, footnote 35 at line 46, footnote 40 at line 49, footnote 58 at line 94, footnote 59 at line 95, footnote 62 at line 99, footnote 70 at line 109, footnote 79 at line 121, footnote 97 at line 149, footnote 101 at line 152, footnote 158 at line 337, footnote 205 at line 395, footnote 206 at line 395, footnote 208 at line 401, footnote 209 at line 401, footnote 210 at line 405, footnote 211 at line 405, footnote 212 at line 406, footnote 219 at line 414 and footnote 221 at line 418. No citation is graded Unread.

4.4 The 74 citations graded Partial are footnote 2 at line 9, footnote 3 at line 10, footnote 4 at line 11, footnote 6 at line 16, footnote 7 at line 16, footnote 9 at line 18, footnote 15 at line 25, footnote 17 at line 28, footnote 18 at line 29, footnote 19 at line 29, footnote 20 at line 31, footnote 22 at line 34, footnote 28 at line 41, footnote 29 at line 42, footnote 30 at line 43, footnote 48 at line 60, footnote 49 at line 62, footnote 53 at line 84, footnote 55 at line 89, footnote 56 at line 89, footnote 63 at line 102, footnote 64 at line 103, footnote 77 at line 115, footnote 81 at line 129, footnote 84 at line 133, footnote 85 at line 134, footnote 86 at line 135, footnote 90 at line 137, footnote 91 at line 139, footnote 92 at line 141, footnote 96 at line 148, footnote 98 at line 149, footnote 99 at line 150, footnote 103 at line 153, footnote 105 at line 157, footnote 55 at line 159, footnote 104 at line 166, footnote 109 at line 168, footnote 111 at line 194, footnote 114 at line 197, footnote 118 at line 212, footnote 123 at line 244, footnote 126 at line 246, footnote 127 at line 248, footnote 141 at line 250, footnote 128 at line 252, footnote 129 at line 254, footnote 145 at line 261, footnote 148 at line 269, footnote 149 at line 269, footnote 147 at line 277, footnote 155 at line 313, footnote 172 at line 357, footnote 174 at line 361, footnote 175 at line 361, footnote 184 at line 369, footnote 185 at line 369, footnote 192 at line 376, footnote 193 at line 377, footnote 194 at line 379, footnote 199 at line 385, footnote 201 at line 389, footnote 202 at line 394, footnote 214 at line 408, footnote 215 at line 409, footnote 216 at line 411, footnote 217 at line 411, footnote 218 at line 412, footnote 220 at line 416, footnote 222 at line 419, footnote 223 at line 421, footnote 226 at line 426, footnote 227 at line 426 and footnote 228 at line 428, and units 1.1 through 1.112 state for each which part of the sentence its source carries.

5.0 The claims on this page are open to documented challenge on the standing terms of marknichols.com, and the terms are stated here in full.

5.1 The claims on this page are open to challenge on the same terms as every claim on marknichols.com. A challenger who holds that a claim on this page is wrong, or that the Internet is something other than the publicly joinable network of networks of the registry lineage defined at The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, states the competing claim or definition in one sentence, names the document that carries it and the document’s date, and sends both to mark@marknichols.com. A challenge submitted with its document is answered on this page, and a competing definition submitted with its document is added to this page as an exhibit with attribution to the person who submitted it; a challenge submitted without a document is an opinion and is heard as one.

5.2 The distinction the site’s definition rests on, that protocols enable interoperability and are not the Internet, is stated in the IETF’s own words, RFC 2026 and STD 1, in the Internet-Draft draft-mnichols-protocols-not-the-internet-01, posted by Mark Nichols to the IETF Datatracker on September 25, 2026 at https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-mnichols-protocols-not-the-internet/ and stated on this site at Protocols Are Not the Internet: The IETF Internet-Draft by Mark Nichols, so a challenger may also address the definition in the venue that publishes the protocol standards themselves. Any person who holds expertise in telecommunications and a competing claim or definition is invited to bring both, in writing, with the document.

6.0 The Definitions Addendum reproduces the Governing Definitions D1 through D13 of marknichols.com word for word, and every finding on this page is made under them.

6.1 Every finding on this page is made under the Governing Definitions of marknichols.com, D1 through D13, which are reproduced in this addendum word for word from The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking. A reader of this page either accepts these definitions or disputes them. A reader who disputes a definition states the competing definition in one sentence and names the dated document that carries it before opining on any finding of this page. A reader who opines on the findings without disputing a definition has read the findings under these definitions by default.

6.2 The definitions below are copied word for word from the section “These definitions are employed throughout marknichols.com” of The Governing Definitions and Controlling Facts of Telecommunications Internetworking, as that page read on November 13, 2026, and that page controls wherever a copy differs from it.

D1. The Internet (capital I). The publicly joinable network of networks of the registry lineage: the fabric whose addresses and autonomous system numbers were issued by the InterNIC and are maintained today by ARIN. A person joins it by purchasing access from any of competing commercial providers, for any lawful purpose, and a network joins it by obtaining addresses and an autonomous system number from the numbering registry and then interconnecting by agreement with any willing network, the way Digital Island joined under autonomous system AS6553, issued August 29, 1996 by the InterNIC, with the registration maintained today in ARIN’s registry. No owner grants admission, no written policy screens members or their purposes, and no government sponsorship is required, and that single property, open admission, is what separates the Internet from every gated network that existed before it. The capital-I Internet was born in 1991, when independently operated commercial networks of this lineage, PSINet, AlterNet under UUNET, and CERFnet, interconnected by their own agreement as the Commercial Internet eXchange (CIX), settlement-free and free of any purpose-screening policy, and it was born small: the gated research world stood beside it until April 30, 1995, upon the decommission of NSFNET folded into internetMCI, per orders of Congress. Neither the ARPANET intranet, which admitted members only by agency authorization, nor the NSFNET intranet, which admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education, met this definition on any day of either existence, so the capital I names an Internet network that is public, or it names nothing. Paragraphs D1.1 through D1.7 state why the ARPANET and the NSFNET are not in the lineage of the Internet, each on its document.

D1.1 A network stands in the lineage of the Internet only if it carried the trait that defines the Internet, and D1 names that trait as one property, open admission; a network that never carried open admission had no such trait to pass on, and the ARPANET and the NSFNET never carried it, so neither the ARPANET nor the NSFNET is the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet, and neither the ARPANET nor the NSFNET became the Internet.

D1.2 The ARPANET admitted members by its owner’s authorization from its procurement to its end: Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002, issued July 29, 1968 for the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense, states the network’s purpose as “making these advanced research computer systems available to users outside their own design circle,” a purpose among the owner’s research contractors, as F37 of this page records; admission ran through agency authorization, as D4 of this page records; and the ARPANET ran from 1969 to 1990, as F38 of this page records, so the ARPANET was an intranet under D2 on every day of its existence and never carried open admission.

D1.3 The NSFNET admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education, as D7 of this page records, and its backbone was terminated on April 30, 1995, when its regional networks passed principally to internetMCI and SprintLink, which, in the words of Merit Network, the operator of record, absorbed the NSFNET regionals as their customers, so the NSFNET’s member networks joined the Internet as customers on terms the NSFNET never offered, and the NSFNET itself ended and did not become the Internet.

D1.4 The trait that defines the Internet has a documented origin outside the gated networks: the release of March 25, 1991 by General Atomics, Performance Systems International, Inc., and UUNET Technologies, Inc., seated at F52 of this page, states that the three networks “are not subject to government mandated “acceptable use” restrictions on their traffic,” states that the agreement can be expanded “to include any commercial service which has no restrictions on traffic use,” and states that the exchange allows firms to communicate “without traversing the government restricted backbones, such as the NSFNET (National Science Foundation Network),” so the Internet was built by agreement among commercial networks to carry traffic around the gated backbone, and the Internet did not grow out of the gated backbone.

D1.5 The ARPANET, the NSFNET, and the Internet each performed internetworking under D3, and a shared function is not a shared lineage: RFC 2026, The Internet Standards Process, Revision 3, by Scott O. Bradner of Harvard University, published October 1996, states at its section 1.1 that “There are also many isolated interconnected networks, which are not connected to the global Internet but use the Internet Standards,” so a network that uses the same protocols as the Internet is a user of the same tools and is not thereby the Internet or its ancestor. A redwood and a palm are both called trees, and a redwood did not grow from a palm, and a palm cannot become a redwood; the gated internets of the ARPANET and the NSFNET and the capital-I Internet are both called internets, and the shared word names a shared function and not a shared tree. The shared word was applied to the gated networks in error, and this record documents the error by document and date: the Stanford University bronze dedicated July 28, 2005 casts the headline “BIRTH OF THE INTERNET” above an inscription that records protocol work, as Stanford University Is Petitioned to Retract the Headline of Its BIRTH OF THE INTERNET Plaque records; RFC 1208, A Glossary of Networking Terms, by Ole J. Jacobsen and Daniel C. Lynch of Interop, Inc., published March 1991 as a document that in its own words “does not specify an Internet standard,” calls the ARPANET the “grandfather” of today’s Internet with no document for the descent it asserts; and IEEE Milestone 94 of October 29, 2009 is titled “Birthplace of the Internet, 1969,” as F46.1 of this page records.

D1.6 The registry lineage named in D1 is a continuity of numbering administration, the assignment of network addresses and autonomous system numbers by the Network Information Center at SRI, then by the InterNIC, and today by ARIN, and the registry lineage is not a lineage of networks: the Network Information Center at SRI kept the Official Host Table of the ARPANET’s era, as D4 of this page records, and a number assigned by a registry admits no one to any network, so the continuity of the numbering places no gated network in the lineage of the Internet.

D1.7 On every page of marknichols.com, the ARPANET and the NSFNET are named earlier gated networks, networks that also performed internetworking, or intranets under D2, and no page of marknichols.com calls either network the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, the precursor, or the forerunner of the Internet, places either network in the lineage of the Internet, or states that either network became, evolved into, or grew into the Internet, under the ruling of Mark Nichols of November 7, 2026 that the ARPANET and the NSFNET belong to the history of internetworking and not to the lineage of the Internet, and that the Internet is a separate species.

D1.8 The plain statements of D1.1 through D1.7 are these. The ARPANET is not the Internet. The NSFNET is not the Internet. The ARPANET did not become the Internet. The NSFNET did not become the Internet. The ARPANET is not the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet. The NSFNET is not the grandfather, the ancestor, the parent, or the precursor of the Internet. The ARPANET was an intranet, because the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense owned the ARPANET and admitted the ARPANET’s members by permission. The NSFNET was an intranet, because the NSFNET backbone admitted members only under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education. The Internet admits anyone, and open admission is the one property that defines the Internet. Open admission came to the Internet from the commercial networks PSINet, AlterNet, and CERFnet at the Commercial Internet eXchange announced on March 25, 1991, and open admission did not come from the ARPANET or from the NSFNET. The ARPANET ended in 1990. The NSFNET backbone ended on April 30, 1995. The ARPANET, the NSFNET, and the Internet share the function of internetworking and share the word internet, and a shared function and a shared word are not a shared lineage. The Internet was born in 1991, and the Internet was not born from the ARPANET or from the NSFNET.

D2. intranet. A network, at any scale, in any geography, and under any protocol, whose members join by an owner’s permission. The word carries its own definition: intra means within, and an intranet is a network within a bounded and credentialed community, whether that community is one company’s offices or one government’s contractors spread across two continents. Scale does not convert an intranet into the Internet, geography does not, and protocol does not, because a gated network that adopts the optional protocols TCP/IP has changed its plumbing and not its admission policy; only open admission makes the Internet, and a research intranet is not the Internet. NSFNET and ARPANET are historical examples of intranets under this definition. Neither was the Internet, and neither became the Internet merely by being technically interconnected with other networks.

D3. internetworking. The technique of interconnecting distinct networks through gateways so that traffic originating on one can reach hosts on another. Internetworking among gated intranets was operating in production by 1975, when the gateway at University College London, developed and operated by Peter Kirstein’s group, of which Peter Higginson was a principal member, joined the ARPANET to the United Kingdom’s EPSS, an operation documented in the September 1975 paper of Peter L. Higginson and Andrew J. Hinchley, which recorded the working gateway while filing the Cerf and Kahn protocol as a future option rather than the operating method. Internetworking among gated intranets makes a lowercase internet, in the exact lowercase vocabulary of RFC 1983, and it never makes the capital-I Internet, because interconnecting two gated networks produces a larger gated system, not a public one. The credit for internetworking belongs to the engineers who built and operated the gateways; that credit does not extend to the birth of the Internet, which did not yet exist.

D4. ARPANET, also rendered DARPANET. The ARPA Network: one organization’s intranet, built, funded, owned, and access-controlled by the Advanced Research Projects Agency of the United States Department of Defense, later renamed DARPA, from its commissioning in 1969 until its decommissioning in 1990. Its very name is a possessive, the agency’s initials welded onto the agency’s property, and the network’s renamings followed the owner’s renamings, as only an owned network’s can. Admission was by the owner’s authorization for the owner’s purposes, the Official Host Table of the Network Information Center at SRI, the register of the era’s hosts that preceded the optional protocol DNS, listed 235 hosts in May 1982 and 562 hosts in August 1983, the two counts in RFC 1296 of January 1992 that bracket the 1983 protocol cutover, and no member of the public could join it, buy from it, or sell across it on any day of its twenty-one years. The owner stated the network’s purpose in its own procurement instrument before the network existed: Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002, issued July 29, 1968 by the Defense Supply Service-Washington of the Department of the Army for the Advanced Research Projects Agency under ARPA Order No. 1260, and signed by Thomas J. Scheblik, Deputy Director for Procurement, solicited the Interface Message Processors for the ARPA computer network, and its Statement of Work, Specifications of Interface Message Processors for the ARPA Computer Network, states that the Agency was forming the network “with the cooperation of its research contractors,” that the network’s potential lay in “making these advanced research computer systems available to users outside their own design circle,” and that the network itself was “a subject of study and experimentation,” while the Statement of Work’s nineteen pages and seven appendices contain no reference to war, to survivability, to attack, to command and control, or to any military mission. The design mission of the ARPANET was therefore resource sharing among the owner’s research contractors, stated by the owner in 1968, and the later recollections agree with the instrument: Charles Herzfeld, Director of ARPA from 1965 to 1967, stated that the ARPANET was not started to create a command and control system that would survive a nuclear attack; Vint Cerf recorded on the Internet Society’s internet-history list on September 1, 2009 that Larry Roberts confirmed the purpose of the ARPANET was resource sharing and that the nuclear resilience story came from Paul Baran’s earlier work; and the Internet Society’s own history, A Brief History of the Internet, calls that story a false rumor that arose from the unrelated RAND study. The wartime mission, command traffic surviving damaged links and destroyed nodes, belonged to the owner’s later internetting project, which Vint Cerf managed at DARPA and demonstrated by putting packet radios in Strategic Air Command aircraft, and the optional protocol TCP, specified in 1974 with military computer communication requirements as the stated primary focus of RFC 793 of September 1981, was designed for that mission and installed on this intranet by the owner’s directive in 1983. The ARPANET is not the Internet, and DARPANET is not the Internet: one organization’s intranet is not the publicly joinable network of networks. The ARPANET intranet was procured under Request for Quotations No. DAHC15 69 Q 0002 of July 29, 1968, ran from 1969, and carried its traffic for fourteen years, under the Network Control Program, an optional protocol first specified in RFC 33 of February 1970, before TCP was added to it on January 1, 1983; a protocol added to a working network fourteen years after the network was procured is an add-on to that network, not its birth.

D5. Flag day, January 1, 1983. A scheduled protocol cutover, from NCP to TCP/IP, planned within the ARPANET community for years and executed on the owner’s own plant: an intranet’s internal maintenance event, touching no member of the public because no member of the public was on the network before the cutover or after it. The protocol installed that day was commissioned by the same owner to weld its own three networks together, the terrestrial ARPANET, its mobile packet radio network, and its satellite network, crossing dissimilar media under a single owner without ever crossing an owner, so that traffic could survive battlefield destruction. The Internet’s own standards registry graded TCP “Recommended” and never “Required,” in RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997, grades that bind only systems electing to implement the standard suite, and a protocol cutover on a gated intranet is not the birth of anything. The network the protocol was cut over onto had been procured on July 29, 1968 and running since 1969, fourteen years before that day, so the cutover added a protocol to an existing intranet and created no network.

D6. The Internet protocols, the optional protocols TCP and IP. Protocols are utilities whose messages the networks carry; they are not the networks, and they are not the Internet. Under these Governing Definitions, TCP and IP are optional protocols, and paragraphs D6.1 through D6.13 state the documents on which that definition rests and the judgment of Mark Nichols that completes it.

D6.1 The Internet’s own standards registry, issued first by the Internet Activities Board and later by the Internet Architecture Board, under the title IAB Official Protocol Standards and from RFC 1500 of August 1993 under the title Internet Official Protocol Standards, assigned a status to each listed protocol in twenty-two editions, from RFC 1083 of December 1988 through RFC 2400 of September 1998.

D6.2 Every one of those twenty-two editions lists TCP, the Transmission Control Protocol of RFC 793, at the status “Recommended”, printed “Rec” from RFC 1280 of March 1992 onward, and lists IP, the Internet Protocol of RFC 791, at the status “Required”, printed “Req” from RFC 1280 onward, and not one of the twenty-two editions lists TCP at the status “Required” in any of its tables.

D6.3 RFC 1200 of April 1991, issued by the Internet Activities Board with Jon Postel as editor, and RFC 2200 of June 1997, issued by the Internet Architecture Board with Jon Postel as editor, each define the status “Required” at section 4.2.1 in the words “A system must implement the required protocols”, define the status “Recommended” at section 4.2.2 in the words “A system should implement the recommended protocols”, and define the status “Elective” at section 4.2.3 in the words “A system may or may not implement an elective protocol”, so that by the registry’s own definitions TCP is a protocol that a system should implement and is not a protocol that a system must implement.

D6.4 RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997 each open by stating that the edition “describes the state of standardization of protocols used in the Internet” as determined by its board, and each states that “Few protocols are required to be implemented in all systems” because of the variety of possible systems, gateways, terminal servers, workstations and multi-user hosts among them.

D6.5 RFC 1122, Requirements for Internet Hosts -- Communication Layers, edited by Robert Braden for the Internet Engineering Task Force in October 1989 and listed at the status “Required” in RFC 2200 of June 1997, states at its section 1.1.3 that “To communicate using the Internet system, a host must implement the layered set of protocols comprising the Internet protocol suite” and, in the next sentence, that “A host typically must implement at least one protocol from each layer”, so RFC 1122 binds a host that has chosen to communicate using the Internet system, and RFC 1122 requires of that host at least one transport protocol, not TCP.

D6.6 RFC 1122 of October 1989 states at its section 1.1.3 that “There are two primary transport layer protocols at present”, naming TCP and UDP, and that “the set of official Internet transport protocols may be expanded in the future”, states at its section 4.2.1 that “TCP is used by those applications needing reliable, connection-oriented transport service”, and states at its section 4.1.1 that “UDP is used by applications that do not require the level of service of TCP”, so RFC 1122 itself assigns TCP by the needs of the application.

D6.7 RFC 1200 of April 1991 and RFC 2200 of June 1997 each list, at section 6.3, Network-Specific Standard Protocols, the transmission of IP over each type of physical network, ARPANET, X.25, Ethernet, IEEE 802, FDDI and serial lines among them, at the status “Elective”, and each states that “it is elective to support any particular type of physical network” on which IP is transmitted.

D6.8 RFC 2500 of June 1999 prints no status for TCP or for IP, RFC 5000 of May 2008, the last edition of the registry, prints no status for TCP or for IP, and RFC 7100 of December 2013, written by Pete Resnick of Qualcomm Technologies, Inc., obsoletes RFC 5000 and requests that RFC 5000, and therefore STD 1, be moved to Historic status, so the last status that the Internet’s own standards registry ever assigned to TCP is “Recommended”, in RFC 2400 of September 1998.

D6.9 The IP that the registry listed at the status “Required” is version 4 of the Internet Protocol, RFC 791, and the Internet Engineering Task Force standardized a second and separate Internet Protocol, version 6, in RFC 8200 of July 2017, STD 86, by S. Deering and R. Hinden. RFC 6540 of April 2012, BCP 177, titled IPv6 Support Required for All IP-Capable Nodes and written by W. George of Time Warner Cable, C. Donley of CableLabs, C. Liljenstolpe of Big Switch Networks and L. Howard of Time Warner Cable, advises that “IPv6 support is no longer considered optional”, cautions that the term “IP” has become “a generic that can mean IPv4 + IPv6, IPv6-only, or IPv4-only, depending on context and application”, and states that new and updated IP networking implementations “must not require IPv4 for proper and complete function”, so the Internet Engineering Task Force itself used the word optional for an Internet Protocol until April 2012, and the IP version that the registry listed at the status “Required” is, under the Best Current Practice of April 2012, a version that no new or updated implementation may require.

D6.10 The suite’s own members prove reliability is a per-application choice, because the optional protocols UDP of RFC 768, RTP of RFC 1889 of January 1996, which RFC 3550 of July 2003 obsoletes, and QUIC of RFC 9000 all decline TCP’s services while each remains a protocol of the Internet standards track.

D6.11 TCP is an evolutionary option, not a permanent fixture: it replaced NCP on the owner’s intranet in the 1983 cutover, UDP stood beside it from 1980 for applications that declined its services, RTP went around it in 1996 for media that could not wait for retransmission, and QUIC, published in May 2021, is displacing it now by moving reliability into a new protocol carried inside UDP datagrams; the protocols rotate while the Internet persists, and a layer whose occupants rotate is by definition not the thing itself.

D6.12 It is the stated judgment of Mark Nichols that both are optional utilities: TCP optional on the registry’s own grade, and IP optional as a specific protocol, because the registry’s “Required” grade is conditional conformance language that binds only systems electing to implement the standard suite, the election being made before the grade applies, as the words “To communicate using the Internet system” of RFC 1122 and the word optional that RFC 6540 applies to IPv6 both record, and because what internetworking requires is the addressing function, the label that says where a packet should go, while IP is one implementation of that function and not the function itself.

D6.13 Hence the rebrand coinages stated at marknichols.com/internet-protocols/: TCP is better named ESFRP, the Endpoint Segment Failure Retry Protocol, and IP is better named ALP, the Address Label Protocol. The postmen are not the post office, and the protocols are not the Internet.

D7. NSFNET. The National Science Foundation’s backbone, 1986 to 1995: a federation of research intranets joined into a lowercase internet under a written Acceptable Use Policy that restricted carriage to research and education and barred commercial traffic. The dismantling is dated by the operator of record, Merit Network: the replacement architecture was awarded early in 1994, the very high speed Backbone Network Service to MCI and the Network Access Points to Sprint, MFS Datanet, and Bellcore representing Ameritech and PacBell; member networks began moving off in November 1994; the backbone was terminated on April 30, 1995; and the regional networks passed principally to the commercial carriers internetMCI and SprintLink, which, in Merit’s own words, absorbed the NSFNET regionals as their customers. The NSFNET is not the Internet: a backbone admission-screened under a written Acceptable Use Policy restricted to research and education is a gated network, and a gated network is not the publicly joinable network of networks.

D8. The World Wide Web. An application design made by many persons inside and outside CERN, announced publicly on August 6, 1991, three programs of CERN's World Wide Web software, the line-mode client, the basic server and the library of common code, released into the public domain by CERN on April 30, 1993, with NCSA Mosaic released in 1993 putting a graphical browser in front of it. A free application is not an open network: until April 30, 1995, the Web’s principal carriage was the gated research intranets beneath it, research-only carriage under the written policy, and the calendar states the dependency exactly, because CERN's three programs of Web software went public on April 30, 1993, and the gated research fabric beneath most of its hosts was absorbed into the public Internet two years later to the day, on April 30, 1995. The name World Wide Web is a label for a large body of technology in the public domain, made by many persons and bodies inside and outside CERN, as F32.4 of this page states. The World Wide Web is not the Internet: the Web is an application using the Internet platform, and the application is not the platform.

D9. The birth of the Internet, and the absorption. The capital-I Internet was born in 1991, when PSINet, AlterNet under UUNET, and CERFnet, independently operated commercial networks of the registry lineage, established the Commercial Internet eXchange, a settlement-free router interconnection with open admission and no purpose-screening policy, as recorded in the Federal Communications Commission working paper The Digital Handshake by Michael Kende and as announced by the three networks’ operators themselves, General Atomics, Performance Systems International, Inc., and UUNET Technologies, Inc., in their release of March 25, 1991, which states that “The CIX agreement provides for all customers of AlterNet, CERFnet and PSINet to exchange Internet traffic directly, regardless of which network the customer obtains service from, and at no additional cost” and that the three “are not subject to government mandated “acceptable use” restrictions on their traffic,” the release being preserved as message 441 of the com-priv archive at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and seated at F52 of this page; the agreement’s own text and its execution date are still sought, and the ruling stands on the dated announcement, the year, the parties, and the terms until a dated earlier instrument of the same lineage is produced. April 30, 1995 is not the Internet’s birthday; it is the absorption: the day the last written admission policy over the general-purpose research backbone died with the NSFNET, the regional networks passed principally to internetMCI and SprintLink, and the populations that had lived behind the gate joined the Internet that had existed without them since 1991. Being born is not the same as being built, and the Modern Internet, publicly accessible, eCommerce native, media streaming native, and QoS native, was built from 1996 to 1997 on executed documents: the Telecommunications Act signed February 8, 1996, autonomous system AS6553 issued August 29, 1996 by the InterNIC, the $300,000 Cisco Systems agreement of November 1996 to host cisco.com on Digital Island’s Tier-0 network, and production service in the first quarter of 1997, with Cisco Systems, Stanford University, and Visa International as the first customers in sequence.

D10. The Modern Internet. The Internet changed from the legacy Internet to the Modern Internet on the day its internetworking changed from best effort to deterministic, and that day is November 1, 1996, the Effective Date of the Cisco Systems Remote Data Services Agreement, signed for Digital Island, Inc. by Mark Nichols, Director, Global Networks, on November 7, 1996 and for Cisco Systems, Inc. by Hervé Goguely, Director, Global Service Management, on November 8, 1996, under which Cisco Systems became the first customer to buy a contractually guaranteed global service, a network segment exclusively its own with secure transaction services and sub-300 milliseconds round trip, on the architecture Mark Nichols hand-drew in June 1996, redrew as DIGITAL ISLAND DRAFT.1 in July 1996 and DRAFT.2 in October 1996, and registered as AS6553, issued to Digital Island, Inc. on August 29, 1996. An evolution, not a synonym. The capital-I Internet born in 1991 and made general-purpose by the absorption of April 30, 1995 was public but bare: a network anyone could join, and nothing commerce-grade could yet depend on, because open admission supplies members and does not supply performance. The Modern Internet is what that public network evolved into when global commerce was engineered onto it: the enabling of the globalization of eCommerce, of streaming media, and of Quality of Service under signed and enforceable terms, built on Digital Island’s Tier-0 network under autonomous system AS6553 with contractually enforced sub-300-millisecond round-trip performance across major markets, carrying the Merchant Transport product category coined in September 1996, on the architecture designed by Mark Nichols as co-founder and chief architect, the record standing at marknichols.com/architect-of-the-modern-internet/, marknichols.com/merchant-transport/, and marknichols.com/tier-0/. The evolution is dated by the executed record and by the customers who ran on AS6553 in sequence: Cisco Systems in November 1996, Stanford University in 1997, Visa International in the second quarter of 1997, E*TRADE under its global data distribution agreement with Digital Island dated August 1, 1997, as Digital Island’s S-1 records it, Charles Schwab in 1998, and MasterCard in March 1999; Telefónica Data formed a global IP alliance with Digital Island on April 26, 1999, Sun Microsystems and Inktomi invested in Digital Island in December 1999, Microsoft, Intel, and Compaq invested in Digital Island in June 2000, and CERNET, the China Education and Research Network, peered with Digital Island under the contract signed in Beijing on February 25, 1998 and was never a customer. The Modern Internet is therefore dated 1996 to 1997 in executed documents, and the word modern means publicly accessible, commerce-grade, streaming-capable, and QoS-governed, none of which the newborn network possessed.

D11. Usage. On every page of this site, Internet with a capital I means the publicly joinable network of the registry lineage born in 1991 and nothing else; internet in lowercase means any interconnection of networks, including gated ones; gated systems are named what they were, research intranets, whatever their date; and any page, headline, plaque, or biography that assigns the birth of the Internet to 1969, 1974, or 1983 is measured against these definitions and fails, because on each of those dates every network in the claim admitted its members by permission, and any account that assigns the birth to April 30, 1995 is measured against these definitions and fails as well, because on that date the Internet already existed and what died was the gate beside it. And on every page of this site, “Required” as a registry grade appears only in quotation marks with its condition stated in the same sentence, that it binds only systems electing to implement the standard suite, except within D6 of this page, where D6.12 states that condition once for every quotation of the registry in D6.1 through D6.11; this site’s own prose never calls any Internet protocol required, because at the level of Internet membership there are no required protocols, only elected ones, and an unconditional “required” applied to an Internet protocol is the registry’s conditional conformance label promoted into a membership law that no document states.

D11.1 Definitions govern meaning. Documents govern facts. Findings govern conclusions.

D12. Contemporary primary-source documents control over retrospective accounts, institutional narratives, biographies, media summaries, machine-generated responses, and personal recollections.

D13. Any finding in this record may be amended upon production of contemporaneous documentary evidence demonstrating a materially earlier, later, or contrary fact.